New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Liberalism destroyed in just 5 sentences.

Emily

NSDAP Kanzler
They were all totalitarian regimes instead of true communist regimes.
So it has never worked.
No because it's never actually been implemented.
But the idea was to implement them. That was the goal. But it never happened; every time, they became totalitarian regimes. Over & over again.
So...
maaaybe...
there's something inherently wrong in the communist idea.
Like that it's contrary to reality, incompatible with human nature, and/or unworkable on any large scale.
 

Spamature

President
But the idea was to implement them. That was the goal. But it never happened; every time, they became totalitarian regimes. Over & over again.
So...
maaaybe...
there's something inherently wrong in the communist idea.
Like that it's contrary to reality, incompatible with human nature, and/or unworkable on any large scale.
Maybe there is something inherently wrong with it ? They say eventually Capitalism will turn into feudalism. I don't think we can devise a perfect system on a large scale because it will always be created and implemented by imperfect human beings.
 

Emily

NSDAP Kanzler
They say eventually Capitalism will turn into feudalism.
Some do, yes. My ideological compatriots say that Capitalism will inevitably turn into Communism. Looks to me that the US is right now proving both assessments correct.

I don't think we can devise a perfect system on a large scale because it will always be created and implemented by imperfect human beings.
Yes, I agree.
That said, and by your own words, every attempt to implement Communism on even a moderately large scale has always failed to implement and sustain Communism. Also, significantly, it has always brought much suffering and death in the name of Communism on the way to NOT implementing and sustaining the Communism.
 

EatTheRich

President
Ok, name a true communist country that brought about the utopia you think would result.
Communism is not a ready-made utopia. It is a concrete struggle for workers’ power that like any other struggle is messy and full of contradictions. If communism is the new baby this world is giving birth to, the Soviet Union is the first labor pang and you are the quack physician advising an abortion because it hurts.
 

Nostra

Governor
Communism is not a ready-made utopia. It is a concrete struggle for workers’ power that like any other struggle is messy and full of contradictions. If communism is the new baby this world is giving birth to, the Soviet Union is the first labor pang and you are the quack physician advising an abortion because it hurts.
Soviet citizens living under it aborted it.
 

EatTheRich

President
How many millions died under Stalin’s utopia?
Perhaps 9 million ... confirming Lenin and Trotsky who alone were against Stalin’s takeover of the Soviet Union when Stalin was supported against them by every capitalist political current.
 

Spamature

President
Some do, yes. My ideological compatriots say that Capitalism will inevitably turn into Communism. Looks to me that the US is right now proving both assessments correct.
No Capitalism serves capital, in the long run it leads to a great concentration of wealth, not a greater distribution.


Yes, I agree.
That said, and by your own words, every attempt to implement Communism on even a moderately large scale has always failed to implement and sustain Communism. Also, significantly, it has always brought much suffering and death in the name of Communism on the way to NOT implementing and sustaining the Communism.
Yes.
 
Last edited:

EatTheRich

President
Even your fellow commie butt-boys don't believe that line. Is there any commie propaganda you won't swallow whole?
Fact: the workers who stopped the Litvinov coup and overthrew Gorbachev were protesting perestroika, a precursor of the capitalist “reforms” that could be pushed through only by the unbridled terror of the Putin regime.
 

EatTheRich

President
Why do workers need a revolution under the utopia of communism?
Workers need an international revolution to make communism (which is not a utopia but an entirely real possibility) a reality. The Russian revolution which Stalin, Gorbachev, and Putin all did their best to stifle was one episode in that international revolution.
 

EatTheRich

President
Yeah, every great Government systematically executes anyone who speaks out against it.

If your utopia existed here, you wouldn’t be around.
Most of those executed for speaking out against the Soviet Union were communists executed for speaking out against the anti communist course of Stalin.
 

Emily

NSDAP Kanzler
Capitalism serves capital, in the long run it leads to a great concentration of wealth, not a greater distribution.
That's true. In saying that capitalism leads eventually to communism, we're referring to the fact -- acknowledged by both of us -- that "communism" in practice, as opposed to in theory, has always become a totalitarian system with wealth concentrated among elites and the masses destitute both economically and spiritually.

Workers need an international revolution to make communism (which is not a utopia but an entirely real possibility) a reality.
An international revolution hasn't ever worked because it defies human nature and the Natural Law that, ultimately, governs all life. National revolution by essentially homogeneous, united masses can and has worked. A nationalist socialism (note the lower case & phrasing) is realistic. It's been done -- under whatever appellation -- and it's worked, right up to the point when either war or globalism brought it down.
 
Top