I believe the Arkady simulation is an example of a Markov process. If the state is "possession of ball" then who has the ball next depends on who currently has the ball. The Markov matrix is built into the 5.1/4.9 factors of the simulation.
I re-did the simulation using field goal percentage...
I did the simulation as you described and basically got the same results:
make-it-take-it:
player1_wins: 63760 (%63.76), player2_wins: 32558 (%32.56), ties: 3682 (%3.68)
alternate possession:
player1_wins: 61433 (%61.43), player2_wins: 31249 (%31.25), ties: 7318 (%7.32)
Seems to be fewer...
Unfortunately, I don't see how "Thread Start Time" can be set as your default, you have to manually specify for each forum. Look at this setting:
Settings => General Settings => Thread Display Options => Default Thread Age Cut Off
It might help address your concern.