Arkady
President
In order to give the phony fiscal conservatives cover, Trump and the Republicans are relying on various tricks to hide the way their upper-class tax cuts and obscene military overspend will drive up deficits. Some of those tricks are new -- e.g., shamelessly counting the same savings multiple times within a budget. But the key trick is an old one -- pretending that tax cuts will result in a big boost in economic growth, such that they'll pay for themselves. That's the same trick Reagan used to justify his tax cuts --right before presiding over what was, at that point, the biggest peace-time increase in budget deficits in history. And it's the trick Bush used to justify his tax cuts -- right before turning record budget surpluses into record budget deficits in just a few short years. Trump and today's Republicans are betting on us being dumb enough to fall for the same trick a third time.
Specifically, Trump's budget projects that real GDP growth will average 3%. Ask yourself this: How often has the economy averaged 3% real growth under a Republican administration? Such growth is common under Democratic presidents. We enjoyed over 3% real GDP growth averages under FDR, Truman, Kennedy, Johnson, Carter, and Clinton. But it has happened just once during the past seven Republican administrations: during the Reagan years, when we averaged about 3.44% annualized.
Reagan-era growth wasn't particularly impressive -- in that list of 3%+ presidencies I provided, he comes out a whisker ahead of Carter (3.43%), and behind all the rest. But, still, it was decent. So, what made it possible for Reagan to succeed where all the other modern Republican presidents failed?
Well, one thing he had going for him were gigantic Fed rate cuts, which dramatically eased money supply, stimulating economic activity. When Reagan was sworn in, we were in the midst of a Fed-engineered depression, designed to kill inflation. The effective Federal Funds rate was 19.08%. In Reagan's last month in office, that same rate was 9.12. We're talking about a nearly 10-point easing of rates during his presidency. That is the only time in American history we've had that big of a rate drop over that short a period. In fact, nothing else comes close. Obviously, that's not going to be happening to bring us to 3% GDP growth in the Trump era, since the current effective federal funds rate is 0.91% -- almost no rate-cutting is possible. The only way to do the equivalent would be unorthodox money-printing exercises, rather than the use of normal Fed maneuvers. But money printing on that scale would mean huge inflation, causing other problems that would likely hurt real growth as much as the added liquidity was helping it.
The other thing Reagan had going for him were gigantic deficit increases. In FY 1981, the last Carter budget, we had a deficit of $79.968 billion. In FY 1989, Reagan's last budget year, that was up to $152.639 billion. In other words, we roughly doubled the federal budget deficit in just eight years, flooding the economy with IOU-fueled economic activity. Before Trump took office, the federal deficit was about $577 billion. So, to get similar proportional stimulus, you'd need that to rise to about $1.101 trillion. That's conceivable -- Bush led us to over a $1.4 trillion deficit, so it can be done. But, if the idea is to avoid massive deficits by way of 3% growth, then obviously you can't get to that 3% growth by way of massive deficits.
The difficulty of hitting 3% growth is all the harder for demographic reasons. In the Reagan years, the working age population was still growing pretty robustly -- rising about 1.04% per year. An expanding working-age population tends to expand the economy. Currently, that demographic is only growing 0.06% per year, and it's on track to go negative as Baby Boomers retire. If you adjusted the Reagan-era 3.44% growth by the difference between the Reagan-era population growth and what we have today, he'd be down around 2.46%. So, even with that massive deficit increase and all the Fed stimulus, even the Reagan-era would likely have missed the 3% threshold with this little population growth.
In theory we could boost the growth rate of the working-age population back to something like we had during the Reagan years. But doing so would require a MASSIVE increase in immigration -- roughly doubling the number of immigrants over the next decade. Short of that, it's hard to picture getting to an average of 3% real GDP growth. And I doubt Trump and the Republicans honestly think we'll get there. They just know that a lot of people pinned their names to phony deficit hawking rhetoric in the Obama years, and they want to help them pretend that the budget plans being pushed these days aren't going to be a fiscal catastrophe.
Specifically, Trump's budget projects that real GDP growth will average 3%. Ask yourself this: How often has the economy averaged 3% real growth under a Republican administration? Such growth is common under Democratic presidents. We enjoyed over 3% real GDP growth averages under FDR, Truman, Kennedy, Johnson, Carter, and Clinton. But it has happened just once during the past seven Republican administrations: during the Reagan years, when we averaged about 3.44% annualized.
Reagan-era growth wasn't particularly impressive -- in that list of 3%+ presidencies I provided, he comes out a whisker ahead of Carter (3.43%), and behind all the rest. But, still, it was decent. So, what made it possible for Reagan to succeed where all the other modern Republican presidents failed?
Well, one thing he had going for him were gigantic Fed rate cuts, which dramatically eased money supply, stimulating economic activity. When Reagan was sworn in, we were in the midst of a Fed-engineered depression, designed to kill inflation. The effective Federal Funds rate was 19.08%. In Reagan's last month in office, that same rate was 9.12. We're talking about a nearly 10-point easing of rates during his presidency. That is the only time in American history we've had that big of a rate drop over that short a period. In fact, nothing else comes close. Obviously, that's not going to be happening to bring us to 3% GDP growth in the Trump era, since the current effective federal funds rate is 0.91% -- almost no rate-cutting is possible. The only way to do the equivalent would be unorthodox money-printing exercises, rather than the use of normal Fed maneuvers. But money printing on that scale would mean huge inflation, causing other problems that would likely hurt real growth as much as the added liquidity was helping it.
The other thing Reagan had going for him were gigantic deficit increases. In FY 1981, the last Carter budget, we had a deficit of $79.968 billion. In FY 1989, Reagan's last budget year, that was up to $152.639 billion. In other words, we roughly doubled the federal budget deficit in just eight years, flooding the economy with IOU-fueled economic activity. Before Trump took office, the federal deficit was about $577 billion. So, to get similar proportional stimulus, you'd need that to rise to about $1.101 trillion. That's conceivable -- Bush led us to over a $1.4 trillion deficit, so it can be done. But, if the idea is to avoid massive deficits by way of 3% growth, then obviously you can't get to that 3% growth by way of massive deficits.
The difficulty of hitting 3% growth is all the harder for demographic reasons. In the Reagan years, the working age population was still growing pretty robustly -- rising about 1.04% per year. An expanding working-age population tends to expand the economy. Currently, that demographic is only growing 0.06% per year, and it's on track to go negative as Baby Boomers retire. If you adjusted the Reagan-era 3.44% growth by the difference between the Reagan-era population growth and what we have today, he'd be down around 2.46%. So, even with that massive deficit increase and all the Fed stimulus, even the Reagan-era would likely have missed the 3% threshold with this little population growth.
In theory we could boost the growth rate of the working-age population back to something like we had during the Reagan years. But doing so would require a MASSIVE increase in immigration -- roughly doubling the number of immigrants over the next decade. Short of that, it's hard to picture getting to an average of 3% real GDP growth. And I doubt Trump and the Republicans honestly think we'll get there. They just know that a lot of people pinned their names to phony deficit hawking rhetoric in the Obama years, and they want to help them pretend that the budget plans being pushed these days aren't going to be a fiscal catastrophe.