New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

4 Steps To Destroy The Future

Joe Economist

Council Member
For millions of Americans Social Security is the future. It will pay for a substantial part of their retirement. Last year, the system's unfunded liability grew by roughly 2.5 trillion dollars, more than three times the amount of the revenue collected.

Originally, Social Security was not a generational wealth transfer or ponzi scheme. Social Security was designed to be funded by workers not financed by their children. Since that time, the system's finances have deteriorated to the point where the financing gap is nearly the size of our entire GDP. So what the hell happened?

How to destroy the future in four easy steps.

1. Give To Voters

The original law included automatic tax increases which would have increased the cost of Social Security to 6% of wages from its 2% base. Congress waived every increase, one of which required a Congressional override of FDR's Veto. Funding for Social Security did not reach the originally envisioned 6% until 1960. Self-employed workers would not pay 6% until the 1970s.
These tax-cuts transformed Social Security from a system paid by workers to a system financed by children.

2. Take From Non-Voters

Congress raised benefits every election year in the 1950s. Social Security Act Amendments of 1950, 1952, 1954, 1956, 1958 all increased benefits. These increased the value of existing benefits, created new benefits, or expanded coverage to more Americans. The 1950 Amendment raised benefits by 77%, 1952 (12.5%), 1954 (13%), 1956(added disability), 1958 (7%). (source)

A couple retiring in 1960 expected to collect $8 of benefits for every $1 of contribution. Basically Congress was selling dollars of benefits to voters for little more than a dime. The difference was largely passed on to future generations who had no vote in 1950.

3. Allow The Federal Reserve To Lower Interest Rates At A Cost Of $1.2 trillion of projected interest income (in 2012 alone)

In 2011, projected interest income over the life of the Trust Fund was (3.6 trillion)
In 2012, projected interest income over the life of the Trust Fund was (2.4 trillion)
Thanks Ben Bernanke.

4. Ignore The Problem

Social Security almost reached insolvency in 1983. At that time, Social Security had more than 40 years of promises embedded in a system that did not have a penny to pay them. The solution to these problems in 1983? Repeat step 1. Repeat step 2. Prepare for step 3. The solution to these problems in 2013? Repeat step 1. Repeat step 2.
 
If Congress had not tried to use Social Security funds to pay for every social program that came along, the program would still be solvent. Failing that, the funds should have been left in the hands of the people who earned those dollars, and allowed them to be placed in a 401 program, as we are doing with 401 at this time.
 
If Congress had not tried to use Social Security funds to pay for every social program that came along, the program would still be solvent. Failing that, the funds should have been left in the hands of the people who earned those dollars, and allowed them to be placed in a 401 program, as we are doing with 401 at this time.


As it good as it may feel, the idea that Congress somehow purloined those Social Security dollars, is a red herring. Per Social Security's charter, Social Security is required to invest its surplus in US Treasuries and Congress is required to sell it those treasuries. In other words, the law requires Social Security to lend and it requires Congress to borrow.

And sure....a lot of people think there must be a better way, but none can suggest an ACTUAL better way, that would pass the most cursury economic test.
 
Last edited:
As it good as it may feel, the idea that Congress somehow purloined those Social Security dollars, is a red herring. Per Social Security's charter, Social Security is required to invest its surplus in US Treasury and Congress is required to sell it those treasuries. In other words, the law requires Social Security to lend and it requires Social Security to borrow.

And sure....a lot of people think there must be a better way, but none can suggest an ACTUAL better way, that would pass the most cursury economic test.
Yes, but the social programs I am talking about were not part of the original idea that the government would take the funds, to fund the workers retirement. And if they had loaned the money at a decent interest rate there would be more than enough money to pay the retires a good monthly stipend, and still stay solvent.
 
Yes, but the social programs I am talking about were not part of the original idea that the government would take the funds, to fund the workers retirement. And if they had loaned the money at a decent interest rate there would be more than enough money to pay the retires a good monthly stipend, and still stay solvent.


You'd be really hardpressed to cite me ANYTHING speaking to how Congress was supposed to spend those lent funds.
 
Yes, but the social programs I am talking about were not part of the original idea that the government would take the funds, to fund the workers retirement. And if they had loaned the money at a decent interest rate there would be more than enough money to pay the retires a good monthly stipend, and still stay solvent.

It is difficult to argue with your point because you do not provide any links to confirm what you are saying. I don't know what social program you think are drawing on Social Security.

I can tell you that the Social Security Administration says that Social Security funds to programs, old-age/survivors retirement and disability.

I can provide links to Congressional testimony from the head of Social Security that says in 1944 Social Security was actuarily unsound. So your statement that SS could 'still stay solvent' is not consistent with the historical record.
 
You'd be really hardpressed to cite me ANYTHING speaking to how Congress was supposed to spend those lent funds.
You are most certainly right on that, but all we can hope is that our politicians can get their act together, and get the government out of our business. We have to try to keep things going in the meantime.
 
Our nation borrowed - in the form of US Treasuries, the money to pay for the WWII and Korean War Era GI bills. Those were social programs. By the most conservative estimates, that investment repaid our nation 7x over.
 
It is difficult to argue with your point because you do not provide any links to confirm what you are saying. I don't know what social program you think are drawing on Social Security.

I can tell you that the Social Security Administration says that Social Security funds to programs, old-age/survivors retirement and disability.

I can provide links to Congressional testimony from the head of Social Security that says in 1944 Social Security was actuarily unsound. So your statement that SS could 'still stay solvent' is not consistent with the historical record.
Every one wants proof or a link to go to. I can not give you proof. Just using common sense should tell you that we can't issue checks to every hard luck story that comes along. I wish we could, but the only thing I can tell you is that if we want to do that we need to take more Social Security taxes to pay for the extra services for farmers who paid in, for a small amount of time, then drew full retirement. And children whose parent are given money to pay for their upkeep and education, and every other plan that must be paid for with Social Security funds. If you want to raise taxes for all these things, lets go for it, but don't call it Social Security.
 
Every one wants proof or a link to go to. I can not give you proof. Just using common sense should tell you that we can't issue checks to every hard luck story that comes along. I wish we could, but the only thing I can tell you is that if we want to do that we need to take more Social Security taxes to pay for the extra services for farmers who paid in, for a small amount of time, then drew full retirement. And children whose parent are given money to pay for their upkeep and education, and every other plan that must be paid for with Social Security funds. If you want to raise taxes for all these things, lets go for it, but don't call it Social Security.

I can give you proof in the form of government documents which say that SS funds go to SS beneficiaries. Total distribution are roughly 90% of the funds collected. The difference is held in the Trust Fund.

Farmers are A problem, but far from THE problem. These aren't hardluck stories. The system subsidizes short careers from any occupation, and it is fair to argue that SS Reform should adjust that subsidy.

The only children who collect do so under surivivor benefits. These are part of THE problem, but survivors benefits are part of Old-age and Survivors benefits.
 
I can give you proof in the form of government documents which say that SS funds go to SS beneficiaries. Total distribution are roughly 90% of the funds collected. The difference is held in the Trust Fund.

Farmers are A problem, but far from THE problem. These aren't hardluck stories. The system subsidizes short careers from any occupation, and it is fair to argue that SS Reform should adjust that subsidy.

The only children who collect do so under surivivor benefits. These are part of THE problem, but survivors benefits are part of Old-age and Survivors benefits.
Hi Joe, you have made some good points. My only point is that if you try to take out more money than you take in, the program will not work, and the people who paid the taxes will eventually get ripped off. Maybe not us but our children.
 
Hi Joe, you have made some good points. My only point is that if you try to take out more money than you take in, the program will not work, and the people who paid the taxes will eventually get ripped off. Maybe not us but our children.

In order for Social Security to work, workers have to contribute for themselves. That means you have to have a growing reserve.

Today, children pay for parents. The problem with this approach is that children will always pay the least amount and parents will take more than they deserve. That is how Social Security operated for about 70 years. The money hasn't be taken by Congress. It was handed to our parents.

The boomers, people born in 1946, are the first birth year to pay the full amount of their benefits. Everyone before that was a sponge to a lesser and lesser degree. Couples retiring in 1960 expected to get $8 of benefits for every $1 contributed. That difference has to be paid for by someone getting less. The problem is that boomers didn't pay for themselves, much of their contribution went to the 70 year spread of deadbeats who sponged on the system.

Yes people are going to lose, and it will be sooner than my children's generation.
 
In order for Social Security to work, workers have to contribute for themselves. That means you have to have a growing reserve.

Today, children pay for parents. The problem with this approach is that children will always pay the least amount and parents will take more than they deserve. That is how Social Security operated for about 70 years. The money hasn't be taken by Congress. It was handed to our parents.

The boomers, people born in 1946, are the first birth year to pay the full amount of their benefits. Everyone before that was a sponge to a lesser and lesser degree. Couples retiring in 1960 expected to get $8 of benefits for every $1 contributed. That difference has to be paid for by someone getting less. The problem is that boomers didn't pay for themselves, much of their contribution went to the 70 year spread of deadbeats who sponged on the system.

Yes people are going to lose, and it will be sooner than my children's generation.
How soon do you foresee that dire prediction coming true.
 
It isn't possible to guess the size of a bubble. I 'predicted' the internet bubble but was two years early. I 'predicted' the housing bubble, but was materially wrong on the size.

I don't think that people act on the possibility of the problem. We have talked about the problem for 3 decades. Today is different because we are actually seeing people retire. It is very different to talk about a possible problem, and experience an actual problem.

Today interest cost of the government is about $420 billion and the revenue is about 1.7 trillion. That means that $0.25 of every dollar paid today is going to interest expense. Interest cost could easily double.

The ACA is more of the same. Propaganda isn't enough to get young people to join. Today we have to hit them with a penalty. The problem is that we are forcing younger people into the system on unequal terms. They are suppose to subsidize older workers.

My gut tells me that we have an intergenerational battle coming where the young object to paying for both the retirees and the debt that they created as younger voters.
 
Don't forget that SS is not contractually guaranteed, which means the government does not have to pay out its benefits. That's ironic considering thru a tax we were mandated to pay into it.
 
Back
Top