New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A Darwinian thought...

Bernard_Fokke

Captain Fokke
Supporting Member
Nature as it were is set up to insure the survival of the fittest correct?

Please understand I'm not against the help system at all, just putting a thought out there for conjecture.

Now we humans come along and populate the planet and some survive better than others then someone decides that that isn't "Fair" and the safety net is created, call it what you will, the dole, welfare, social assistance, orphans fund and so on and it is developed into a science over many years.

Looking at this I can't help but wonder if the good intent has in some ways reversed the evolutionary process in that there are generations of humans that depend on this social assistance to survive and can't fend for themselves, ie too lazy, stupid call it what you want to survive on their own.

So as a species humans have developed through good intent mind you a system that is helping the weak and unfit to survive and weakening the species in a broad sense .
 
Nature as it were is set up to insure the survival of the fittest correct?

Please understand I'm not against the help system at all, just putting a thought out there for conjecture.

Now we humans come along and populate the planet and some survive better than others then someone decides that that isn't "Fair" and the safety net is created, call it what you will, the dole, welfare, social assistance, orphans fund and so on and it is developed into a science over many years.

Looking at this I can't help but wonder if the good intent has in some ways reversed the evolutionary process in that there are generations of humans that depend on this social assistance to survive and can't fend for themselves, ie too lazy, stupid call it what you want to survive on their own.

So as a species humans have developed through good intent mind you a system that is helping the weak and unfit to survive and weakening the species in a broad sense .

Different world in NATURE.........of course Mother Nature doesn't have taxpayers money to just give away to her critters..........so when a let's say a herd of Deer grow bigger than the land will feed.......she uses 'black tongue' disease and kill off % of herd............liberals/republicans give Food Stamps...........
 
Nature as it were is set up to insure the survival of the fittest correct?

Please understand I'm not against the help system at all, just putting a thought out there for conjecture.

Now we humans come along and populate the planet and some survive better than others then someone decides that that isn't "Fair" and the safety net is created, call it what you will, the dole, welfare, social assistance, orphans fund and so on and it is developed into a science over many years.

Looking at this I can't help but wonder if the good intent has in some ways reversed the evolutionary process in that there are generations of humans that depend on this social assistance to survive and can't fend for themselves, ie too lazy, stupid call it what you want to survive on their own.

So as a species humans have developed through good intent mind you a system that is helping the weak and unfit to survive and weakening the species in a broad sense .
Someone had a plan to keep the "unfit" from passing their genes on back in the 1930's. Is lazy, stupid, weak and unfit inherited? Smarts can be inherited but I wonder about stupid. Another way to look at it is because we are more civilized it isn't just the strongest, fastest, meanest passing their genes on but the puny weaklings who are really, really smart who thousands of years ago wouldn't have made it now do.
 
Last edited:
Nature as it were is set up to insure the survival of the fittest correct?

Please understand I'm not against the help system at all, just putting a thought out there for conjecture.

Now we humans come along and populate the planet and some survive better than others then someone decides that that isn't "Fair" and the safety net is created, call it what you will, the dole, welfare, social assistance, orphans fund and so on and it is developed into a science over many years.

Looking at this I can't help but wonder if the good intent has in some ways reversed the evolutionary process in that there are generations of humans that depend on this social assistance to survive and can't fend for themselves, ie too lazy, stupid call it what you want to survive on their own.

So as a species humans have developed through good intent mind you a system that is helping the weak and unfit to survive and weakening the species in a broad sense .


I think it has very little to do with aiding those less fortunate. I am a subscriber to the fact that evolution, or survival of the fitttess, has come to an end. Our perpetual need to live forever, with extreme amounts of health care and regeneration of our natural parts, will kill us all before anything else.

Just take a look at our natural world, we have virtually decimated it to the point that it can no longer be sustained. Then what do we do? Keep in mind the whole purpose of this decimation is economic development, and what do we have when we can no longer develop and suffer the consequences?


The human race is a pure example of Darwinian evolution, just not for the particular reason you cite.
 
Nature as it were is set up to insure the survival of the fittest correct?

Please understand I'm not against the help system at all, just putting a thought out there for conjecture.

Now we humans come along and populate the planet and some survive better than others then someone decides that that isn't "Fair" and the safety net is created, call it what you will, the dole, welfare, social assistance, orphans fund and so on and it is developed into a science over many years.

Looking at this I can't help but wonder if the good intent has in some ways reversed the evolutionary process in that there are generations of humans that depend on this social assistance to survive and can't fend for themselves, ie too lazy, stupid call it what you want to survive on their own.

So as a species humans have developed through good intent mind you a system that is helping the weak and unfit to survive and weakening the species in a broad sense .

You're talking economics not biology.
 
Nature as it were is set up to insure the survival of the fittest correct?

Please understand I'm not against the help system at all, just putting a thought out there for conjecture.

Now we humans come along and populate the planet and some survive better than others then someone decides that that isn't "Fair" and the safety net is created, call it what you will, the dole, welfare, social assistance, orphans fund and so on and it is developed into a science over many years.

Looking at this I can't help but wonder if the good intent has in some ways reversed the evolutionary process in that there are generations of humans that depend on this social assistance to survive and can't fend for themselves, ie too lazy, stupid call it what you want to survive on their own.

So as a species humans have developed through good intent mind you a system that is helping the weak and unfit to survive and weakening the species in a broad sense .

Well, the ideas of Social Darwinism have been around for quite a while now -- well over a hundred years in fact. So there's nothing new about that.

The vast majority of scientists who study evolution have rejected those ideas, however. In fact, those ideas never had all that much currency among biologists. In any case, these days science tends to embrace rather more complicated notions of "fitness." There's a lot of information out there about that if you're interested.

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
Someone had a plan to keep the "unfit" from passing their genes on back in the 1930's. Is lazy, stupid, weak and unfit inherited? Smarts can be inherited but I wonder about stupid. Another way to look at it is because we are more civilized it isn't just the strongest, fastest, meanest passing their genes on but the puny weaklings who are really, really smart who thousands of years ago wouldn't have made it now do.

If you're right in saying that there are still meek to inherit the Earth then the entire Darwinian argument is bullcrap.
 
You're talking economics not biology.
Well Mr Wahbooz I'm angling towards the biological side in that animal breeders have historically selected traits in their animals they want to make dominate.

For example lets pick chickens, specifically Cornish Rocks, bred to eat like maniacs grow fast and be ready for slaughter in about 6 weeks.

Try to keep them past 6 weeks and they die from heart attacks as their hearts can't keep up with the rapid growth this was done through selective breeding in a species. Point being here is could possibly we humans accidentally, through good intent mind you, have selected traits genetically that have developed a subspecies of human that is predisposed to being happy on the dole?

There are generations of people who have never known any different way of life, they live together in groups, marry/breed within the same class thereby doing what one might consider accidental selective breeding.

I know people are much more advanced than chickens or livestock but it's an interesting thought in that at what point do habits over generations become genetic traits rather than learned habits.
 
Well Mr Wahbooz I'm angling towards the biological side in that animal breeders have historically selected traits in their animals they want to make dominate.

For example lets pick chickens, specifically Cornish Rocks, bred to eat like maniacs grow fast and be ready for slaughter in about 6 weeks.

Try to keep them past 6 weeks and they die from heart attacks as their hearts can't keep up with the rapid growth this was done through selective breeding in a species. Point being here is could possibly we humans accidentally, through good intent mind you, have selected traits genetically that have developed a subspecies of human that is predisposed to being happy on the dole?

There are generations of people who have never known any different way of life, they live together in groups, marry/breed within the same class thereby doing what one might consider accidental selective breeding.

I know people are much more advanced than chickens or livestock but it's an interesting thought in that at what point do habits over generations become genetic traits rather than learned habits.

That could be said for both the top and the bottom of the economic spectrum. Both ends of the scale can have those who for generations have seen themselves as entitled. Perhaps they will die off at some point, because even the top part of the scale will not be equipped to survive. But I don't believe 'being on the dole' is necessarily some example of a social pariah. This society is designed to create those who do not have the equipment to compete in this economic environment. You have school districts that are ill equipped, underfunded, while other school districts can afford to spend like they have a charge card at the Treasury. The deck is stacked against some in this society.
 
That could be said for both the top and the bottom of the economic spectrum. Both ends of the scale can have those who for generations have seen themselves as entitled. Perhaps they will die off at some point, because even the top part of the scale will not be equipped to survive. But I don't believe 'being on the dole' is necessarily some example of a social pariah. This society is designed to create those who do not have the equipment to compete in this economic environment. You have school districts that are ill equipped, underfunded, while other school districts can afford to spend like they have a charge card at the Treasury. The deck is stacked against some in this society.

Never thought it was a bad thing and did not intend the post to imply a negative connotation to being on the dole more-so just speculation about the human species and the interesting things we do and why.
 
Nature as it were is set up to insure the survival of the fittest correct?

Please understand I'm not against the help system at all, just putting a thought out there for conjecture.

Now we humans come along and populate the planet and some survive better than others then someone decides that that isn't "Fair" and the safety net is created, call it what you will, the dole, welfare, social assistance, orphans fund and so on and it is developed into a science over many years.

Looking at this I can't help but wonder if the good intent has in some ways reversed the evolutionary process in that there are generations of humans that depend on this social assistance to survive and can't fend for themselves, ie too lazy, stupid call it what you want to survive on their own.

So as a species humans have developed through good intent mind you a system that is helping the weak and unfit to survive and weakening the species in a broad sense .


Except in your world of "survival of the fittest" there are no survivors.

How utterly dour and meaningless.
 
Nature as it were is set up to insure the survival of the fittest correct?

Good post, but I would like the opportunity to point out that "natural selection" aka "survival of the fittest" is not exactly evolution as we tend to think of it, it's evolving mutations of species....not new species.

Dumbo the Flying Elephant was a cartoon. Puddles to people is absurd.
 
Never thought it was a bad thing and did not intend the post to imply a negative connotation to being on the dole more-so just speculation about the human species and the interesting things we do and why.

Yes, I understand. And I see many who are 'on the dole' as nothing more than lazy, and those are the ones who most likely will not economically survive. But there are also those who are 'on the dole' who need that support because their incomes are too far below the poverty level to provide for their families. I don't see them as ill equpped to survive.

But I also see those, at what is referred to as the top, who may not survive either; depending on the next stage of the earths evolution. They've never had to struggle or fight for anything, and they are ill equipped to deal with 'survival at all cost'.
 
Back
Top