New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A lost opportunity.

Arkady

President
For decades, this nation knew it had a growing infrastructure problem. Our bridges were deteriorating, our roads were in horrible shape compared to other leading nations, and we were far behind the competition when it came to things like urban transportation and high-speed rail. But, there was at least an argument against government doing something about it. If government were to borrow money for fixing and improving infrastructure, that would crowd out private investing. With fairly high interest rates already, government borrowing would drive rates to levels where it would be hard for businesses to get much-needed capital -- and the taxpayer would end up paying back a whole lot more than the government spent, thanks to those interest payments. Plus, with fairly low unemployment rates, all that government hiring would drive up labor costs for the private sector, too, while possibly resulting in a labor shortage for private-sector work. So, you could argue that neglecting our infrastructure, back then, was justifiable on the basis of the idea that to do otherwise might have hurt the economy in other ways.

But when you think of it that way, you realize the last six years or so have been a golden opportunity -- mostly squandered. We've spent six years with the government able to borrow money at essentially negative real interest rates. There have basically been big piles of un-utilized and under-utilized capital sitting around in the private sector, which was content to wait out the slowdown, and so the government could have been using that capital without crowding out any private sector activity. Similarly, there have been millions of skilled workers with nothing to do, so that the government could have put them to work without creating labor shortages for private business.

It was a once-in-a-lifetime chance to build ourselves a vastly superior infrastructure, setting us up for generations of greatly enhanced economic growth. The last time we had such an opportunity was in the 1930s, and we seized it. We built dams, bridges, roads, levees, and harbors. We electrified rural areas. We put millions of Americans to work on that, leaving us with a legacy not only of physical improvements that made the prosperity of the 1950s and 1960s possible (and helped us win WWII), but it also left us a legacy of more skilled workers -- young people who spent years doing productive labor, learning things that would prove useful to future employers, rather than standing around in bread lines. We had an unapologetically liberal president and a liberal Congress, and the golden opportunity was not lost on them.

Sadly, this time around, we missed the chance. We let massive amounts of labor and capital sit around, untapped, for nearly all of that six-year period (other than a brief period of stimulus spending, with the ARRA, in 2009). We let those resources sit around doing nothing while infrastructure fell apart, and so even if the private sector is now, finally, picking up, and will eventually start using that labor and capital effectively again, we've set ourselves up for generations of diminished economic growth. Now, we'll wind up paying for that infrastructure maintenance at a time when interest rates are higher and labor in shorter supply, and so it will be more expensive (and more expensive, too, because we'll be buying fewer ounces of prevention and more pounds of cure, after such a long period of neglect). And the next-generation infrastructure that could have set us up to again be world-beaters (e.g., nation-wide high-speed rail or high-speed public wifi) never happened. We had a once-in-a-lifetime chance to do something really special, and we pissed it away, staring out our navels and muttering about entitlement spending. It's pathetic.
 
Do you mean to tell me that there was a worthwhile project to consider other than the Keystone Pipeline? Huh....
 
For decades, this nation knew it had a growing infrastructure problem. Our bridges were deteriorating, our roads were in horrible shape compared to other leading nations, and we were far behind the competition when it came to things like urban transportation and high-speed rail. But, there was at least an argument against government doing something about it. If government were to borrow money for fixing and improving infrastructure, that would crowd out private investing. With fairly high interest rates already, government borrowing would drive rates to levels where it would be hard for businesses to get much-needed capital -- and the taxpayer would end up paying back a whole lot more than the government spent, thanks to those interest payments. Plus, with fairly low unemployment rates, all that government hiring would drive up labor costs for the private sector, too, while possibly resulting in a labor shortage for private-sector work. So, you could argue that neglecting our infrastructure, back then, was justifiable on the basis of the idea that to do otherwise might have hurt the economy in other ways.

But when you think of it that way, you realize the last six years or so have been a golden opportunity -- mostly squandered. We've spent six years with the government able to borrow money at essentially negative real interest rates. There have basically been big piles of un-utilized and under-utilized capital sitting around in the private sector, which was content to wait out the slowdown, and so the government could have been using that capital without crowding out any private sector activity. Similarly, there have been millions of skilled workers with nothing to do, so that the government could have put them to work without creating labor shortages for private business.

It was a once-in-a-lifetime chance to build ourselves a vastly superior infrastructure, setting us up for generations of greatly enhanced economic growth. The last time we had such an opportunity was in the 1930s, and we seized it. We built dams, bridges, roads, levees, and harbors. We electrified rural areas. We put millions of Americans to work on that, leaving us with a legacy not only of physical improvements that made the prosperity of the 1950s and 1960s possible (and helped us win WWII), but it also left us a legacy of more skilled workers -- young people who spent years doing productive labor, learning things that would prove useful to future employers, rather than standing around in bread lines. We had an unapologetically liberal president and a liberal Congress, and the golden opportunity was not lost on them.

Sadly, this time around, we missed the chance. We let massive amounts of labor and capital sit around, untapped, for nearly all of that six-year period (other than a brief period of stimulus spending, with the ARRA, in 2009). We let those resources sit around doing nothing while infrastructure fell apart, and so even if the private sector is now, finally, picking up, and will eventually start using that labor and capital effectively again, we've set ourselves up for generations of diminished economic growth. Now, we'll wind up paying for that infrastructure maintenance at a time when interest rates are higher and labor in shorter supply, and so it will be more expensive (and more expensive, too, because we'll be buying fewer ounces of prevention and more pounds of cure, after such a long period of neglect). And the next-generation infrastructure that could have set us up to again be world-beaters (e.g., nation-wide high-speed rail or high-speed public wifi) never happened. We had a once-in-a-lifetime chance to do something really special, and we pissed it away, staring out our navels and muttering about entitlement spending. It's pathetic.

So then....how did government manage to piss away $6 tillion in new debt and not get anything for it?
 
We are definitely afflicted with a case of short sightedness. Generally, State governments have a devil of a time passing any kind of tax increase that is targeted towards infrastructure, but gets hammered by the public whenever a bridge collapses, or when potholes don't get repaired fast enough.

Here's a link to an infrastructure report card put out by the American Society of Civil Engineers - it's got some good data: http://www.infrastructurereportcard.org/
 
So then....how did government manage to piss away $6 tillion in new debt and not get anything for it?
We had massive revenue shortfalls. Those resulted in big deficits, even in the face of uncommonly low federal spending growth. That's what happens when tax rates are too low and tax policies tilted too much in favor of the rentier class. And, meanwhile, we continued to blow hundreds of billions of dollars per year on corporate welfare for the defense industry -- buying new weapons systems we don't need, and burning through our stock of hardware on counterproductive military missions. We also had the costs, such as supporting disabled vets, that get expanded by 12 straight years of uninterrupted war.
 
We are definitely afflicted with a case of short sightedness. Generally, State governments have a devil of a time passing any kind of tax increase that is targeted towards infrastructure, but gets hammered by the public whenever a bridge collapses, or when potholes don't get repaired fast enough.

Here's a link to an infrastructure report card put out by the American Society of Civil Engineers - it's got some good data: http://www.infrastructurereportcard.org/
We like like a nation teetering on the edge of third world status.
 
Rightwingers often point to the past and the Founders.

Well, one of THE most basic Federal expenditures going back to nearly the start of the country was for transportation.....roads and canals.

Yet today, the Neo-Anarchism/Militarism that reigns on the Right won't let them spend a dime on anything but building squadrons of fighter jets and tanks....to fight an enemy that uses truck bombs in a Kabul market square.....and for nothing else.

And that same American capitalism that they SUPPOSEDLY support....is reliant on transportation.
 
We like like a nation teetering on the edge of third world status.

Said it many times....what IS the end-game of the Far Right by their rhetoric, but us becoming Somalia ? Almost no government with everybody walking around with a machine gun over their shoulders.
 
We had massive revenue shortfalls. Those resulted in big deficits, even in the face of uncommonly low federal spending growth. That's what happens when tax rates are too low and tax policies tilted too much in favor of the rentier class. And, meanwhile, we continued to blow hundreds of billions of dollars per year on corporate welfare for the defense industry -- buying new weapons systems we don't need, and burning through our stock of hardware on counterproductive military missions. We also had the costs, such as supporting disabled vets, that get expanded by 12 straight years of uninterrupted war.
http://www.examiner.com/article/gop-debunked-obama-did-not-create-5-trillion-new-debt
 
what happened to all the "stimulus" money allocated by the federal government to state and local agencies for "shovel ready" projects?

last time i read very little of this has been spent.

please don't tell me that government ineptitude and corruption exists at all levels. this would be so disappointing.
 
what happened to all the "stimulus" money allocated by the federal government to state and local agencies for "shovel ready" projects?

last time i read very little of this has been spent.

please don't tell me that government ineptitude and corruption exists at all levels. this would be so disappointing.
I'm unaware of claims that little has been spent. In my area, we got some new roads, and such. But it was minuscule stimulus vs. what we did during the New Deal.
 
For decades, this nation knew it had a growing infrastructure problem. Our bridges were deteriorating, our roads were in horrible shape compared to other leading nations, and we were far behind the competition when it came to things like urban transportation and high-speed rail. But, there was at least an argument against government doing something about it. If government were to borrow money for fixing and improving infrastructure, that would crowd out private investing. With fairly high interest rates already, government borrowing would drive rates to levels where it would be hard for businesses to get much-needed capital -- and the taxpayer would end up paying back a whole lot more than the government spent, thanks to those interest payments. Plus, with fairly low unemployment rates, all that government hiring would drive up labor costs for the private sector, too, while possibly resulting in a labor shortage for private-sector work. So, you could argue that neglecting our infrastructure, back then, was justifiable on the basis of the idea that to do otherwise might have hurt the economy in other ways.

But when you think of it that way, you realize the last six years or so have been a golden opportunity -- mostly squandered. We've spent six years with the government able to borrow money at essentially negative real interest rates. There have basically been big piles of un-utilized and under-utilized capital sitting around in the private sector, which was content to wait out the slowdown, and so the government could have been using that capital without crowding out any private sector activity. Similarly, there have been millions of skilled workers with nothing to do, so that the government could have put them to work without creating labor shortages for private business.

It was a once-in-a-lifetime chance to build ourselves a vastly superior infrastructure, setting us up for generations of greatly enhanced economic growth. The last time we had such an opportunity was in the 1930s, and we seized it. We built dams, bridges, roads, levees, and harbors. We electrified rural areas. We put millions of Americans to work on that, leaving us with a legacy not only of physical improvements that made the prosperity of the 1950s and 1960s possible (and helped us win WWII), but it also left us a legacy of more skilled workers -- young people who spent years doing productive labor, learning things that would prove useful to future employers, rather than standing around in bread lines. We had an unapologetically liberal president and a liberal Congress, and the golden opportunity was not lost on them.

Sadly, this time around, we missed the chance. We let massive amounts of labor and capital sit around, untapped, for nearly all of that six-year period (other than a brief period of stimulus spending, with the ARRA, in 2009). We let those resources sit around doing nothing while infrastructure fell apart, and so even if the private sector is now, finally, picking up, and will eventually start using that labor and capital effectively again, we've set ourselves up for generations of diminished economic growth. Now, we'll wind up paying for that infrastructure maintenance at a time when interest rates are higher and labor in shorter supply, and so it will be more expensive (and more expensive, too, because we'll be buying fewer ounces of prevention and more pounds of cure, after such a long period of neglect). And the next-generation infrastructure that could have set us up to again be world-beaters (e.g., nation-wide high-speed rail or high-speed public wifi) never happened. We had a once-in-a-lifetime chance to do something really special, and we pissed it away, staring out our navels and muttering about entitlement spending. It's pathetic.


It does little for infrastructure, but the private sector will reap a windfall off of the rise in rates. another negative in the grand scheme of things..
 
We had massive revenue shortfalls. Those resulted in big deficits, even in the face of uncommonly low federal spending growth. That's what happens when tax rates are too low and tax policies tilted too much in favor of the rentier class. And, meanwhile, we continued to blow hundreds of billions of dollars per year on corporate welfare for the defense industry -- buying new weapons systems we don't need, and burning through our stock of hardware on counterproductive military missions. We also had the costs, such as supporting disabled vets, that get expanded by 12 straight years of uninterrupted war.

What about those shovel ready proj...uhh, okay now I remember....Obama later joked that they didn't really exist didn't he?

But you say they were everywhere? I don't get it.
 
Back
Top