New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A message from another earth.

Arkady

President
I had an idea for a sci-fi short story, where our Internet starts picking up stray data packets from the Internet on a parallel-dimension Earth, and vice versa. Given the unfathomable complexity of the Internet, nobody on either Earth can track down exactly how the stray data keeps making the jump, but the result is that people keep getting tweets and e-mail snippets that come in from a world similar to our own, but also fundamentally different. Maybe you get an e-mail confirming your honeymoon itinerary, when on this world you aren't even dating anyone.

Anyway, I bring this up because at times conversing with conservatives can feel as if this data leakage between worlds is already happening. We get communications that have many features recognizable from our own world, but with elements suggesting they must have come from some alternate reality that differs with ours in crucial ways. For example, on April 12, Rand Paul said "When is the last time in our country we created millions of jobs? It was under Ronald Reagan." It's hard to explain this as mere ignorance on his part, since he's a US Senator. He surely would be well aware the economy had created millions of jobs EACH YEAR, during 2011, 2012, AND 2013, and was on pace to do so again in 2014. So, he'd have known that the correct answer to "When is the last time in our country we created millions of jobs" would be "in the last year."

Nor is it easy to explain Rand Paul's comment as being a lie. Although he might have counted on most people being unaware of the last few years of creating millions of jobs (given the conservative media blackout of Obama-era economic success), surely he couldn't have expected them also to be unaware of the Clinton-era job creation record. Could he? As a reminder, between 1993 and 2000, the economy created 23.23 million jobs. That compares to just 15.96 million during the Reagan era that Paul identified as the last time we created millions of jobs. It would be a very strange lie to try out when he should have known the falsehood would be obvious even to denizens of the conservative media bubble.

So, if he wasn't ignorant and he couldn't have thought he'd get away with such a lie, maybe this was just an example of data slipping in from an alternate Earth. In that alternate reality, the last time the economy created millions of jobs was back in the Reagan era. The GOP's cult of Reagan makes a lot more sense when you consider the possibility that it is based on events that didn't actually happen on our Earth.
 
Is it truly "creating" jobs this time around? As near as anyone can tell, we have not returned to the pre-2008 baseline, so we're not much creating jobs as re-creating them, in an environment where there are too few jobs for those entering the workforce, and where many have given up and left the workforce -- and that's just looking at the numbers without doing a qualitative analysis of how man of the "new" jobs are simply $10-per-hour burger turning.
 
I had an idea for a sci-fi short story, where our Internet starts picking up stray data packets from the Internet on a parallel-dimension Earth, and vice versa. Given the unfathomable complexity of the Internet, nobody on either Earth can track down exactly how the stray data keeps making the jump, but the result is that people keep getting tweets and e-mail snippets that come in from a world similar to our own, but also fundamentally different. Maybe you get an e-mail confirming your honeymoon itinerary, when on this world you aren't even dating anyone.

Anyway, I bring this up because at times conversing with conservatives can feel as if this data leakage between worlds is already happening. We get communications that have many features recognizable from our own world, but with elements suggesting they must have come from some alternate reality that differs with ours in crucial ways. For example, on April 12, Rand Paul said "When is the last time in our country we created millions of jobs? It was under Ronald Reagan." It's hard to explain this as mere ignorance on his part, since he's a US Senator. He surely would be well aware the economy had created millions of jobs EACH YEAR, during 2011, 2012, AND 2013, and was on pace to do so again in 2014. So, he'd have known that the correct answer to "When is the last time in our country we created millions of jobs" would be "in the last year."

Nor is it easy to explain Rand Paul's comment as being a lie. Although he might have counted on most people being unaware of the last few years of creating millions of jobs (given the conservative media blackout of Obama-era economic success), surely he couldn't have expected them also to be unaware of the Clinton-era job creation record. Could he? As a reminder, between 1993 and 2000, the economy created 23.23 million jobs. That compares to just 15.96 million during the Reagan era that Paul identified as the last time we created millions of jobs. It would be a very strange lie to try out when he should have known the falsehood would be obvious even to denizens of the conservative media bubble.

So, if he wasn't ignorant and he couldn't have thought he'd get away with such a lie, maybe this was just an example of data slipping in from an alternate Earth. In that alternate reality, the last time the economy created millions of jobs was back in the Reagan era. The GOP's cult of Reagan makes a lot more sense when you consider the possibility that it is based on events that didn't actually happen on our Earth.
I know what you mean. I found one of those data packets:
 
Is it truly "creating" jobs this time around? As near as anyone can tell, we have not returned to the pre-2008 baseline, so we're not much creating jobs as re-creating them, in an environment where there are too few jobs for those entering the workforce, and where many have given up and left the workforce -- and that's just looking at the numbers without doing a qualitative analysis of how man of the "new" jobs are simply $10-per-hour burger turning.
Add to that, Barry isn't creating jobs nearly as quickly as the number of people coming into the workforce, which is why the work force participation rate is so awful.
 
Add to that, Barry isn't creating jobs nearly as quickly as the number of people coming into the workforce, which is why the work force participation rate is so awful.

I'm still waiting for someone to link me to a well thought out treatise suggesting that higher workforce participation rates are necessarily better than lower ones. I suppose I can see why some might simply assume this to be a no-brainer. BUT, it's nowhere nearly as simple as that. Here's a good question to ponder...What's "better", a family in which both parents earn $30k, or one in which just one parent works, and earns $60k?
 
I'm still waiting for someone to link me to a well thought out treatise suggesting that higher workforce participation rates are necessarily better than lower ones. I suppose I can see why some might simply assume this to be a no-brainer. BUT, it's nowhere nearly as simple as that. Here's a good question to ponder...What's "better", a family in which both parents earn $30k, or one in which just one parent works, and earns $60k?
you should be more generous, fair, towards stupid dumb cons, don't kill them that perfectly with an obvious simple questions
 
I'm still waiting for someone to link me to a well thought out treatise suggesting that higher workforce participation rates are necessarily better than lower ones. I suppose I can see why some might simply assume this to be a no-brainer. BUT, it's nowhere nearly as simple as that. Here's a good question to ponder...What's "better", a family in which both parents earn $30k, or one in which just one parent works, and earns $60k?
If those were the options, It would be an interesting discussion. However, household income has also gone down and commodity inflation is increasing the cost of everything.
 
I had an idea for a sci-fi short story, where our Internet starts picking up stray data packets from the Internet on a parallel-dimension Earth, and vice versa. Given the unfathomable complexity of the Internet, nobody on either Earth can track down exactly how the stray data keeps making the jump, but the result is that people keep getting tweets and e-mail snippets that come in from a world similar to our own, but also fundamentally different. Maybe you get an e-mail confirming your honeymoon itinerary, when on this world you aren't even dating anyone.

Anyway, I bring this up because at times conversing with conservatives can feel as if this data leakage between worlds is already happening. We get communications that have many features recognizable from our own world, but with elements suggesting they must have come from some alternate reality that differs with ours in crucial ways. For example, on April 12, Rand Paul said "When is the last time in our country we created millions of jobs? It was under Ronald Reagan." It's hard to explain this as mere ignorance on his part, since he's a US Senator. He surely would be well aware the economy had created millions of jobs EACH YEAR, during 2011, 2012, AND 2013, and was on pace to do so again in 2014. So, he'd have known that the correct answer to "When is the last time in our country we created millions of jobs" would be "in the last year."

Nor is it easy to explain Rand Paul's comment as being a lie. Although he might have counted on most people being unaware of the last few years of creating millions of jobs (given the conservative media blackout of Obama-era economic success), surely he couldn't have expected them also to be unaware of the Clinton-era job creation record. Could he? As a reminder, between 1993 and 2000, the economy created 23.23 million jobs. That compares to just 15.96 million during the Reagan era that Paul identified as the last time we created millions of jobs. It would be a very strange lie to try out when he should have known the falsehood would be obvious even to denizens of the conservative media bubble.

So, if he wasn't ignorant and he couldn't have thought he'd get away with such a lie, maybe this was just an example of data slipping in from an alternate Earth. In that alternate reality, the last time the economy created millions of jobs was back in the Reagan era. The GOP's cult of Reagan makes a lot more sense when you consider the possibility that it is based on events that didn't actually happen on our Earth.

I admire your audacity in plagiarizing both your thread title and your premise from a movie (one which I happen to like), but you could have gotten your (usual) point across without it. Why bother with the intellectual property theft?

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1549572/
 
Is it truly "creating" jobs this time around? As near as anyone can tell, we have not returned to the pre-2008 baseline

Pre-2008, there were 138,350,000 jobs (December 2007). Today, there are 139,435,000 jobs (September 2014). We have over a million more jobs than the "baseline" you suggest.

See BLS data:
Series Id: CES0000000001

But, even if you redefine "job creation" so that it only counts net job creation over some prior cherry-picked baseline, it still doesn't get us around Rand Paul's truly bizarre attempt to argue that the Reagan era was the last time we created millions of jobs. Does he just assume your average conservative if so ignorant that even the famously productive Clinton-era job creation machine would be unknown to them?
 
I admire your audacity in plagiarizing both your thread title and your premise from a movie (one which I happen to like), but you could have gotten your (usual) point across without it. Why bother with the intellectual property theft?

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1549572/
I haven't seen it. Does it involve data coming in from another world's Internet? Or is it merely a matter of the idea of an alternate Earth. If so, that notion goes way, way back in sci-fi. For example, the "Adventures of Bulukiy" describes a protagonist learning of alternate worlds. That's probably a thousand years old. Star Trek and many others played with similar plots of alternate Earths, and Sliders was an entire series based on the idea.
 
Last edited:
Darn close, which casts extreme doubt on your claim.

Now I'm wondering what else you've written that isn't yours...
So, your saying it doesn't involve messages coming through from some parallel-dimension Earth Internet (the plot point I'd offered)? So, are we back to just the idea of there being alternate Earths? If so, I'll fully admit to having been familiar with that trope. It's been around at least a thousand years, and was explored exhaustively in Sliders. It's such a common theme that it gets played with in comedy -- for example, both South Park and Community have episodes where alternative-earth versions of the characters have goatees (an allusion to an alternative-earth episode of Star Trek where Spock had one).

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/MirrorUniverse
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/AlternateUniverse

My story would be different since the extremely limited nature of their interaction would make it impossible to communicate effectively between the two, much less to travel between the two. The data "leakage" would be unpredictable and impossible to replicate, so each world would get random insights into the other, but not be able to send messages through any means short of having a message completely take over the Internet until it eventually leaked through a crack.
 
So, your saying it doesn't involve messages coming through from some parallel-dimension Earth (the plot point I'd offered)? So, are we back to just the idea of there being alternate Earths? If so, I'll fully admit to having been familiar with that trope. It's been around at least a thousand years, and was explored exhaustively in Sliders. It's such a common theme that it gets played with in comedy -- for example, both South Park and Community have episodes where alternative-earth versions of the characters have goatees (an allusion to an alternative-earth episode of Star Trek where Spock had one).

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/MirrorUniverse
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/AlternateUniverse

My story would be different since the extremely limited nature of their interaction would make it impossible to communicate effectively between the two, much less to travel between the two. The data "leakage" would be unpredictable and impossible to replicate, so each world would get random insights into the other, but not be able to send messages through any means short of having a message completely take over the Internet until it eventually leaked through a crack.

Stop wasting time, you got busted plagiarizing (and it isn't the first time). Your thread title was the giveaway. Accept it and move on...
 
Stop wasting time, you got busted plagiarizing (and it isn't the first time). Your thread title was the giveaway. Accept it and move on...
No, Marvin, you've just been caught being an imbecile... again. No worries. There isn't a person on this site you would expect anything different from you.
 
No, Marvin, you've just been caught being an imbecile... again. No worries. There isn't a person on this site you would expect anything different from you.

That's as good an admission of guilt as any I would expect from you. Your fallback to personal insults when you've been caught out is very reliable.

I hope you were slicker than this getting through law school...
 
No, Marvin, you've just been caught being an imbecile... again. No worries. There isn't a person on this site you would expect anything different from you.

You are stretching.

"A message from another Earth" contains standard English language words that include the title of a movie, plus 150% more words. Possible, but likely that it is coincidence. "Scientists: We're 'very close' to finding another Earth" Did CNN plagiarize their title?

As far as being darn close, please detail the movie plot where internet data packets leak between the two alternate Universes.
 
That's as good an admission of guilt as any I would expect from you. Your fallback to personal insults when you've been caught out is very reliable.

I hope you were slicker than this getting through law school...
I just don't have much of a knack for suffering fools. If you need your feelings coddled, you won't get that from me.
 
You are stretching.

"A message from another Earth" contains standard English language words that include the title of a movie, plus 150% more words. Possible, but likely that it is coincidence. "Scientists: We're 'very close' to finding another Earth" Did CNN plagiarize their title?

As far as being darn close, please detail the movie plot where internet data packets leak between the two alternate Universes.
The funny thing is that when I penned the title, my thought wasn't of that movie (which I wasn't aware existed), but rather of a TV show I watched in the 1980s, as a kid, called "Otherworld." I almost wrote "A message from an Otherearth" as a kind of obscure reference to it, but thought it just looked like I'd made a typo with a migrating space.

Anyone else remember that one? It's on Youtube. Not as good as I remember, to say the least:


It involves a family falling through a rift to an alternate earth, where much is the same but there are plot-driving differences. For example, pop music never existed there, so in one episode the kids in the family became hugely successful musicians by playing well-known pop tunes from our world that the Otherworlders have never heard -- something similar pops up in "Back to the Future" with Marty McFly playing Johnny B. Goode, and in Hot Tub Time Machine, with a time traveler wowing the crowd with hip hop.
 
Back
Top