Arkady
President
Since it's looking increasingly likely Trump will lose (PredictWise has it at 87%, the highest the markets have put it yet), I thought I'd take a quick break from the usual partisan discussions to discuss a policy question being neglected by both sides in this campaign: the use of violence away from war zones (e.g., drone strikes, special forces actions, etc.)
I am sympathetic to the idea that the modern era of international terrorism creates issues that don't fit neatly into more traditional categories like conventional war or international crime, and so the constraints built around those concepts may make it impossible to wage an anti-terrorism war effectively. Yet, I think it's horrifyingly dangerous to vest unilateral authority in one man to kill whoever he feels like killing, any way he feels like doing it, anywhere outside our borders, in secret, with only such consultation as he feels like submitting to.
Our government ought not to deprive anyone of life without due process of law. If the traditional processes of law like declarations of war and criminal trial by jury are too cumbersome for this brave new world, then we should create new processes -- processes that allow for speed and secrecy as needed, but that include checks and balances to guard against abuse.
Here's an idea of what I'm picturing. The details can be fine-tuned, but I just want to get the concepts out there. If someone is suspected of being a terrorist, the president can secretly request an assassination warrant. That warrant would be reviewed by a court or committee able to hear secret evidence (as with the FISA court). The court or committee would need to be independent from the executive branch. Someone from the administration would act as a kind of prosecutor, and someone else would serve in the role of defense counsel. The standards would be spelled out in advance by an open, duly enacted law (setting up the procedure and the rules of evidence, and the elements of the crimes allowing for assassination). It would be a bit like a Grand Jury and a bit like a trial in absentia.
If the president gets a conviction of the suspect, part of the verdict would be public, and part private. Publicly, it would be announced that the suspect has some minimal period to turn himself in to the nearest embassy or consulate. If he does, he's guaranteed a criminal trial in a civilian court in the US. If he hasn't done so, he's thereafter fair game to kill and he goes on an official kill list so everyone in the world is on notice to avoid the person if they don't want to be collateral damage.
The private part of the conviction would be the standards around how he can be killed.... for very high-priority targets like Bin Laden, rules of engagement could be very loose -- basically, any way the military or CIA thinks he can be taken down, anywhere in the world, short of mass civilian casualties or a high probability of starting a war, is OK. For lower-priority targets, there might be tighter restrictions (e.g., no doing it in friendly countries without their cooperation, or no attacks likely to kill civilians, or something requiring that attempts at capture must be made with assassination only an option if that fails). There'd also be some rules about disclosure -- the government would be required to acknowledge those we kill, and there'd have to be reports on how many requests the president makes, for example.
Finally, there'd be something making it very clear that assassinations carried out without proper assassination warrants are illegal, and that anyone who becomes aware of them has full clearance to inform the government, press, and/or public about it. Anyone carrying out a targeted assassination of someone not on the kill list would be guilty of a crime, and "just following orders" would be no defense.
I am sympathetic to the idea that the modern era of international terrorism creates issues that don't fit neatly into more traditional categories like conventional war or international crime, and so the constraints built around those concepts may make it impossible to wage an anti-terrorism war effectively. Yet, I think it's horrifyingly dangerous to vest unilateral authority in one man to kill whoever he feels like killing, any way he feels like doing it, anywhere outside our borders, in secret, with only such consultation as he feels like submitting to.
Our government ought not to deprive anyone of life without due process of law. If the traditional processes of law like declarations of war and criminal trial by jury are too cumbersome for this brave new world, then we should create new processes -- processes that allow for speed and secrecy as needed, but that include checks and balances to guard against abuse.
Here's an idea of what I'm picturing. The details can be fine-tuned, but I just want to get the concepts out there. If someone is suspected of being a terrorist, the president can secretly request an assassination warrant. That warrant would be reviewed by a court or committee able to hear secret evidence (as with the FISA court). The court or committee would need to be independent from the executive branch. Someone from the administration would act as a kind of prosecutor, and someone else would serve in the role of defense counsel. The standards would be spelled out in advance by an open, duly enacted law (setting up the procedure and the rules of evidence, and the elements of the crimes allowing for assassination). It would be a bit like a Grand Jury and a bit like a trial in absentia.
If the president gets a conviction of the suspect, part of the verdict would be public, and part private. Publicly, it would be announced that the suspect has some minimal period to turn himself in to the nearest embassy or consulate. If he does, he's guaranteed a criminal trial in a civilian court in the US. If he hasn't done so, he's thereafter fair game to kill and he goes on an official kill list so everyone in the world is on notice to avoid the person if they don't want to be collateral damage.
The private part of the conviction would be the standards around how he can be killed.... for very high-priority targets like Bin Laden, rules of engagement could be very loose -- basically, any way the military or CIA thinks he can be taken down, anywhere in the world, short of mass civilian casualties or a high probability of starting a war, is OK. For lower-priority targets, there might be tighter restrictions (e.g., no doing it in friendly countries without their cooperation, or no attacks likely to kill civilians, or something requiring that attempts at capture must be made with assassination only an option if that fails). There'd also be some rules about disclosure -- the government would be required to acknowledge those we kill, and there'd have to be reports on how many requests the president makes, for example.
Finally, there'd be something making it very clear that assassinations carried out without proper assassination warrants are illegal, and that anyone who becomes aware of them has full clearance to inform the government, press, and/or public about it. Anyone carrying out a targeted assassination of someone not on the kill list would be guilty of a crime, and "just following orders" would be no defense.