Arkady
President
For a long time now, even the climate change deniers haven't been denying the fact there's a global warming trend. The evidence has been overwhelming, such that most people recognized it decades ago, and the last vestiges of serious scientific objections have now completely vanished. Instead, the deniers have moved on to claiming that there has been a trend, but it's not because of human induced greenhouse gas emissions, but is instead due to some other unknown cause.
The thing is, if it was an unknown cause, there'd be no particular reason to think temperatures would keep on rising. In fact, absent any theoretical mechanism for ongoing warming, the normal prediction would be for temperatures to fall, just based on regression to the mean. So, those who aren't putting forward a theoretical mechanism for warming are essentially saying we have no idea whether average temperatures are going to rise or fall in the future, and they're probably more likely to fall back to the mean than to rise still farther above it. On the other hand, if human-induced greenhouse gas emissions are the cause, long-term trends are expected to be up -- they may be down in any given year or small cluster of years, based on short-term cycles and random events (solar cycles, El Nino/La Nina cycles, volcanic eruptions), but one fully expects the multi-year averages to keep creeping upward as long as human greenhouse gas contributions keep going up.
That's been true for decades now: that the climate change consensus supporters have been predicting a long-term future trend of ongoing warming, while the climate change denialists have been tacitly predicting no future trend at all, or a regression to the mean. For decade after decade, the consensus supporters have been right. Multi-year average temperatures have just kept creeping up, consistent with their predictions. The denialists have no explanation for this.
So, where would you put your money? Do you think average global temperatures from, say, 2020-2025 will be higher or lower than they've been during the last five years? If you're a denialist, you'd logically take odds on them being lower (based on regression to the mean, from what has certainly been an uncommonly warm run for the last few years). If you support the consensus position, though, you'd take odds on them being higher, since that's what all the models predict. I believe that very few of the denialists would actually make that bet with their own hard-earned money, because it's more of an exercise in propaganda for them, not a genuine scientific belief. By comparison, I think most consensus supporters would jump at that bet, because the science is on our side and we know it.
The thing is, if it was an unknown cause, there'd be no particular reason to think temperatures would keep on rising. In fact, absent any theoretical mechanism for ongoing warming, the normal prediction would be for temperatures to fall, just based on regression to the mean. So, those who aren't putting forward a theoretical mechanism for warming are essentially saying we have no idea whether average temperatures are going to rise or fall in the future, and they're probably more likely to fall back to the mean than to rise still farther above it. On the other hand, if human-induced greenhouse gas emissions are the cause, long-term trends are expected to be up -- they may be down in any given year or small cluster of years, based on short-term cycles and random events (solar cycles, El Nino/La Nina cycles, volcanic eruptions), but one fully expects the multi-year averages to keep creeping upward as long as human greenhouse gas contributions keep going up.
That's been true for decades now: that the climate change consensus supporters have been predicting a long-term future trend of ongoing warming, while the climate change denialists have been tacitly predicting no future trend at all, or a regression to the mean. For decade after decade, the consensus supporters have been right. Multi-year average temperatures have just kept creeping up, consistent with their predictions. The denialists have no explanation for this.
So, where would you put your money? Do you think average global temperatures from, say, 2020-2025 will be higher or lower than they've been during the last five years? If you're a denialist, you'd logically take odds on them being lower (based on regression to the mean, from what has certainly been an uncommonly warm run for the last few years). If you support the consensus position, though, you'd take odds on them being higher, since that's what all the models predict. I believe that very few of the denialists would actually make that bet with their own hard-earned money, because it's more of an exercise in propaganda for them, not a genuine scientific belief. By comparison, I think most consensus supporters would jump at that bet, because the science is on our side and we know it.