New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

About hydroxychloroquine...

Is there a survey of the medical literature saying that ventilators “are the problem”? How about a single study?
No, just a consensus of doctors who are / have been watching the ventilators make the patient's condition worse. Meanwhile the hydroxychloroquine treatment without the ventilators has been 90% successful.
 
A handful of doctors said that. I don’t know of a study that said that. And many doctors believe ventilators have saved their patients’ lives.

So why did Cuomo form a Task Force to study ventilators and invest $Millions in solar panels that failed?

Remember there were a great shortage of ventilators in NYC and then there wasn't and not needed!

If you ever wake up with a water hose down your throat you will not want to do it twice.
 
Why would travelers take hydroxy prescriptions as a prophylactic against malaria if it's that dangerous? It isn't that dangerous.

The dose makes the poison. What may be safe(r than the alternative of using no medicine) at the dosage level needed to give a person a head start should they contract malaria may not be safe at the level needed to be therapeutic against a viral infection for which the drug has an entirely different mechanism of action. Also, a safe dosage for a healthy person might not be safe for someone fighting said infection.

Ask yourself why they are so concerned these days about doctors using medicines off label when it was common "practice" at one time.

Because the common practice got many people killed.

Once safety was established, the purpose of FDA testing more so than efficacy, doctors would and could apply medicines to purposes other than originally intended.

Safety is not an either/or. It is a matter of relative risk.

Discoveries were made that way.
And demonstrated in clinical trials. Off-label use is still widespread in cases where no effective therapy is known and the consequences of doing nothing is dire, and in fact hydroxychloroquine is widely prescribed for Coronavirus patients based on a plausible proposed mechanism of action and anecdotal results. But we can hardly assess its efficacy without taking the steps the FDA requires to establish efficacy.
 
No, just a consensus of doctors who are / have been watching the ventilators make the patient's condition worse. Meanwhile the hydroxychloroquine treatment without the ventilators has been 90% successful.

“Consensus” implies unanimity, when in fact what you call a “consensus” is the opinion of a small minority. Most of those treated with hydroxychloroquine are not sick enough to need ventilators, which is why most of them recover.
 
The dose makes the poison. What may be safe(r than the alternative of using no medicine) at the dosage level needed to give a person a head start should they contract malaria may not be safe at the level needed to be therapeutic against a viral infection for which the drug has an entirely different mechanism of action. Also, a safe dosage for a healthy person might not be safe for someone fighting said infection.

The dose is 200mg that they give travelers. Same as what they give Covid patients last I heard.


Because the common practice got many people killed.
No, FDA proves safety and then doctors within those safety guidelines PRACTICE the art of medicine.

Safety is not an either/or. It is a matter of relative risk.
The whole purpose they paid you for that drug trial when you were in college was not to cover your tuition but to demonstrate drug safety. They are hardly interested in efficacy as long as it is statistically significant (and that ain't much).

And demonstrated in clinical trials. Off-label use is still widespread in cases where no effective therapy is known and the consequences of doing nothing is dire, and in fact hydroxychloroquine is widely prescribed for Coronavirus patients based on a plausible proposed mechanism of action and anecdotal results. But we can hardly assess its efficacy without taking the steps the FDA requires to establish efficacy.
This is the man who has given the best case for hydroxy and who is now being poo-poo'd by anybody hawking remdesevir. Perfect? No. But not the ass hat they now claim he is.

 
The dose is 200mg that they give travelers. Same as what they give Covid patients last I heard.



No, FDA proves safety and then doctors within those safety guidelines PRACTICE the art of medicine.


The whole purpose they paid you for that drug trial when you were in college was not to cover your tuition but to demonstrate drug safety. They are hardly interested in efficacy as long as it is statistically significant (and that ain't much).


This is the man who has given the best case for hydroxy and who is now being poo-poo'd by anybody hawking remdesevir. Perfect? No. But not the ass hat they now claim he is.

If statistically significant efficacy “isn’t much” it shouldn’t be a big hurdle for the drug pushers to clear. It is not merely the harm to patients from taking drugs that is a concern, it is also that “practice” that involves unsystematic application of drugs based on doctors’ intuition is an obstacle to developing a therapy that is truly effective. Medicine doesn’t rely on arguments from authority, it relies on reproducible evidence.
 
“Consensus” implies unanimity, when in fact what you call a “consensus” is the opinion of a small minority. Most of those treated with hydroxychloroquine are not sick enough to need ventilators, which is why most of them recover.
Consensus never has implied unanimity.

P.S. on the other post really... ALL medicines are poisons.
 
If statistically significant efficacy “isn’t much” it shouldn’t be a big hurdle for the drug pushers to clear. It is not merely the harm to patients from taking drugs that is a concern, it is also that “practice” that involves unsystematic application of drugs based on doctors’ intuition is an obstacle to developing a therapy that is truly effective. Medicine doesn’t rely on arguments from authority, it relies on reproducible evidence.

I'll put it plainly.

Drugs are tested primarily for safety. Secondarily for efficacy. Once safety is demonstrated it has been common practice to let doctors go off label if they have an articulable medical reason for doing so. That freedom has been beneficial. Currently, we are teaching our culture that somehow that has NOT been past practice and that it shouldn't be.

Democrats are imbeciles.

ALL MEDICINES ARE POISON.
 
I'll put it plainly.

Drugs are tested primarily for safety. Secondarily for efficacy. Once safety is demonstrated it has been common practice to let doctors go off label if they have an articulable medical reason for doing so. That freedom has been beneficial. Currently, we are teaching our culture that somehow that has NOT been past practice and that it shouldn't be.

Democrats are imbeciles.

ALL MEDICINES ARE POISON.
None of that shows that hydroxychloroquine is effective for the treatment of SARS-Cov-2 infection.
 
“Consensus” implies unanimity, when in fact what you call a “consensus” is the opinion of a small minority. Most of those treated with hydroxychloroquine are not sick enough to need ventilators, which is why most of them recover.
The premier doctor in Europe did one of the surveys on hydroxychloroquine, and he had 91% success rate. And he only used it on very sick people. So there is a right way and wrong way to treat this virus, the ventilators are killing 50%, while the hydroxychloroquine are saving 90%. That's the overall results.
 
The premier doctor in Europe did one of the surveys on hydroxychloroquine, and he had 91% success rate. And he only used it on very sick people. So there is a right way and wrong way to treat this virus, the ventilators are killing 50%, while the hydroxychloroquine are saving 90%. That's the overall results.
I’m gonna wait for more data instead of second-guessing the doctors.
 
You are relating what a tiny minority of doctors are saying and calling it a “consensus.”
grrrrr, I'm relaying what the best doctors on the planet are telling us; what they have learned so far in treating this disease, and they are in contact with other doctors so it does amount to a consensus.

what are you reading CNN? When are you going to wake up and realize CNN is pure propaganda.
 
The premier doctor in Europe did one of the surveys on hydroxychloroquine, and he had 91% success rate. And he only used it on very sick people. So there is a right way and wrong way to treat this virus, the ventilators are killing 50%, while the hydroxychloroquine are saving 90%. That's the overall results.

Wow, this is far from a scientific result, haha. The larger study on it so far just found it doesn’t so much. Good or bad. This drug hasn’t taken off the way you were told it would.

 
Wow, this is far from a scientific result, haha. The larger study on it so far just found it doesn’t so much. Good or bad. This drug hasn’t taken off the way you were told it would.

The drug has been 90% effective in study after study, when properly prescribed in combination with other drugs. If you set up a study to look at the drug on its own - that is called isolating the drug to determine its effectiveness - then yeah, it isn't effective on its own. But that is not the best way to use the drug. The best doctors are having tremendous success with the drug... I'm not a doctor, but that is what doctors are saying.
 
The drug has been 90% effective in study after study, when properly prescribed in combination with other drugs. If you set up a study to look at the drug on its own - that is called isolating the drug to determine its effectiveness - then yeah, it isn't effective on its own. But that is not the best way to use the drug. The best doctors are having tremendous success with the drug... I'm not a doctor, but that is what doctors are saying.
90% is rough when the death rate is 1-2%. LOL

Real studies with real parameters show it not helping or hurting. Sorry. ;)
 
90% is rough when the death rate is 1-2%. LOL

Real studies with real parameters show it not helping or hurting. Sorry. ;)
that's patently false. The drug was shown to be 90% effective by the best doctors in the field and that means in a survey of two or three hundred cases of extremely sick people fighting for their lives, the drug saved 91% in one study I read about and 93% in another study I read about and the 90% figure was someone doing a consensus of all the mini studies that were done while these people are damn busy saving lives.

And that has nothing to do with the death rate, which so far, is likely closer to .03% or.04%... which means of all the people coming into contact with the virus, that's the percentage dying from the disease.

quit reading CNN, it is pure propaganda.
 
Back
Top