New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

About that concealed carry study.

Arkady

President
I'm open-minded about the effectiveness of concealed carry. Although I'm convinced that more gun saturation in a society will tend to drive up murder rates, others things being equal, I could see concealed carry going either way. On the one hand, the knowledge that a substantial number of potential targets will be armed will deter some potential violent criminals. But, on the other hand, some number of those toting the weapons around will end up committing terrible acts of violence, themselves, that they would not have if they didn't have a gun on hand in a particular moment of weakness.

Which of the two factors is stronger? I can't say. And, unlike with some other gun issues, we don't get much guidance from studying other advanced nations, since concealed carry isn't a big thing elsewhere.

So, I hope someone does a good study on this topic. Unfortunately, the "Crime Prevention Research Center" report isn't it. It's a propaganda piece put out by a a notoriously shady long-time gun control opponent, who doesn't "show his work." It's garbage statistics pulled together by a hack to hint at the conclusion that he set out to prove from the start.

Still, at least he does the work of pulling together the percentage of people with concealed carry permits by state, which is an important data point. So, I thought I'd see what the data tell us about how that had an impact on murder rates. I dropped NY and VT, since he didn't have data for them, and NYC, which is a city and doesn't belong in the list. Then, since his graph of rising cc permits starts in 1999, I ran a quick calculation of the change of murder rate between 1999 and 2012 (the most recent year officially on record), for each state. So, for example, in Alabama the murder rate dropped from 7.9, in 1999, to 7.1, in 2012, for a decline of 0.8. I then compared the decline in the murder rate, by state, over that time, to the percentage cc permits by state.

What I discovered was that there was a negative coefficient of correlation (-0.1778). In other words, the higher the percentage of concealed carry permits in the state, the smaller the decline in the murder rate was for that state, during that period of rising concealed carry prevalence.

That is what we'd expect to see if the net impact of concealed carry was to drive up the murder rate. It's what we'd expect to see if the murder rate was dropping, overall, for reasons unrelated to concealed carry (e.g., reductions in lead poisoning), but this improvement was muted by rising concealed carry prevalence.

This is hardly a slam-dunk demonstration, of course. The coefficient of correlation is small, and there was no way from his data to figure out timing (e.g., it's possible that some high concealed-carry state that had poor murder reduction already had high concealed carry in 1999, and saw less change in concealed carry than some other state with lower total permits). But, it's at least suggestive.

If someone wants to do the same correlation check with the change in violent crime rates, that might be even more interesting, since it's possible that even as concealed carry was muting the improvement in the murder rate, it was strengthening the improvement in the violent crime rate.
 
No you aren't. How can you be when you fundamentally oppose the civil liberty of self-defense?
Do you support an individual right to keep and bear nuclear arms? If not, does this mean you oppose the civil liberty of self-defense?

Anyway, I actually am open-minded about concealed carry. The kinds of gun control I favor involve background checks, registration, licensing with training and insurance requirements, waiting periods, and limits on types of firearms, magazines, and ammunition. I've taken no stance on open-carry or concealed carry, which can both be fully compatible with the types of gun control I favor. I'm waiting to see what the data say. It's entirely possible that even though greater gun saturation within society is a significant risk factor for higher violent crime, that concealed carry is a special case which goes the other way, because of the deterrent effect on would-be criminals. I'm hoping someone credible does a study on it.
 
I'm hoping someone credible does a study on it.

You mean, someone who feeds you more favorable numbers..

let's not kid ourselves here Ark.

Meanwhile, the 2nd amendment ordeal is a catch 22 for me, I have NO IDEA what to do about it.

It was meant not only to allow citizens to defend against other citizens, but for citizens to defend against government.

The founders didn't foresee a military-industrial complex. Would they have wrote the same amendment had they known that the Government would have tanks, bombers, drones, etc. while the people would "only" be able to be allowed to have AR-15's or assault rifles?

From what I can tell, things would have been much different under the 2nd amendment.

Mind you, history is 100% on my side of the argument, as there has never been a democracy-style government that hasn't gone tyrannical.
 
You mean, someone who feeds you more favorable numbers..
The "favorable" numbers would be ones that show that concealed carry lowers the murder rate. That would be fantastic if it were true, since it would give us a way to lower that rate, which is currently an absolute travesty by first-world standards. And being able to bring about that improvement in a way that didn't require much extra government spending would be a big bonus!

If a solid study showed, in a convincing way, that concealed carry lowered the murder rate, that would be extremely favorable. But, it's either true or it isn't, and my wishful thinking won't make it one bit more true than it is. Unfortunately, for now, the only data I've got to work with shows the opposite correlation: that the murder rate fell less in states with higher shares of concealed carry. That's unfortunate, but my disappointment doesn't make it one bit less true. We have to do our honest best to interpret what the evidence tells us, rather than trying to impose our wishes on the data.
 
The "favorable" numbers would be ones that show that concealed carry lowers the murder rate. That would be fantastic if it were true, since it would give us a way to lower that rate, which is currently an absolute travesty by first-world standards. And being able to bring about that improvement in a way that didn't require much extra government spending would be a big bonus!

If a solid study showed, in a convincing way, that concealed carry lowered the murder rate, that would be extremely favorable. But, it's either true or it isn't, and my wishful thinking won't make it one bit more true than it is. Unfortunately, for now, the only data I've got to work with shows the opposite correlation: that the murder rate fell less in states with higher shares of concealed carry. That's unfortunate, but my disappointment doesn't make it one bit less true. We have to do our honest best to interpret what the evidence tells us, rather than trying to impose our wishes on the data.

Indeed, we have to be honest.

However, all of what you say could be moot in regards to the issues i was bringing up in the rest of my post.
 
10514528_883860728295448_6342488203131149034_n.jpg
 
Do you support an individual right to keep and bear nuclear arms? If not, does this mean you oppose the civil liberty of self-defense?

Anyway, I actually am open-minded about concealed carry. The kinds of gun control I favor involve background checks, registration, licensing with training and insurance requirements, waiting periods, and limits on types of firearms, magazines, and ammunition. I've taken no stance on open-carry or concealed carry, which can both be fully compatible with the types of gun control I favor. I'm waiting to see what the data say. It's entirely possible that even though greater gun saturation within society is a significant risk factor for higher violent crime, that concealed carry is a special case which goes the other way, because of the deterrent effect on would-be criminals. I'm hoping someone credible does a study on it.

NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO
Was that clear?
 
Legalizing concealed carry effectively did nothing -- that's what an honest analysis shows. The people who wanted to carry were already carrying. At most what it did was allow a few people on the margins to carry.

Criminals already carried. People facing a perceived immediate threat also already carried. Legalizing the latter didn't change anything.
 
Legalizing concealed carry effectively did nothing -- that's what an honest analysis shows. The people who wanted to carry were already carrying. At most what it did was allow a few people on the margins to carry.

Criminals already carried. People facing a perceived immediate threat also already carried. Legalizing the latter didn't change anything.
It allowed the honest person to carry concealed
 
Do you support an individual right to keep and bear nuclear arms? If not, does this mean you oppose the civil liberty of self-defense?

Anyway, I actually am open-minded about concealed carry. The kinds of gun control I favor involve background checks, registration, licensing with training and insurance requirements, waiting periods, and limits on types of firearms, magazines, and ammunition. I've taken no stance on open-carry or concealed carry, which can both be fully compatible with the types of gun control I favor. I'm waiting to see what the data say. It's entirely possible that even though greater gun saturation within society is a significant risk factor for higher violent crime, that concealed carry is a special case which goes the other way, because of the deterrent effect on would-be criminals. I'm hoping someone credible does a study on it.

The old nuclear arms ploy, you got him on the run now.
 
I'm open-minded about the effectiveness of concealed carry. Although I'm convinced that more gun saturation in a society will tend to drive up murder rates, others things being equal, I could see concealed carry going either way. On the one hand, the knowledge that a substantial number of potential targets will be armed will deter some potential violent criminals. But, on the other hand, some number of those toting the weapons around will end up committing terrible acts of violence, themselves, that they would not have if they didn't have a gun on hand in a particular moment of weakness.

Which of the two factors is stronger? I can't say. And, unlike with some other gun issues, we don't get much guidance from studying other advanced nations, since concealed carry isn't a big thing elsewhere.

So, I hope someone does a good study on this topic. Unfortunately, the "Crime Prevention Research Center" report isn't it. It's a propaganda piece put out by a a notoriously shady long-time gun control opponent, who doesn't "show his work." It's garbage statistics pulled together by a hack to hint at the conclusion that he set out to prove from the start.

Still, at least he does the work of pulling together the percentage of people with concealed carry permits by state, which is an important data point. So, I thought I'd see what the data tell us about how that had an impact on murder rates. I dropped NY and VT, since he didn't have data for them, and NYC, which is a city and doesn't belong in the list. Then, since his graph of rising cc permits starts in 1999, I ran a quick calculation of the change of murder rate between 1999 and 2012 (the most recent year officially on record), for each state. So, for example, in Alabama the murder rate dropped from 7.9, in 1999, to 7.1, in 2012, for a decline of 0.8. I then compared the decline in the murder rate, by state, over that time, to the percentage cc permits by state.

What I discovered was that there was a negative coefficient of correlation (-0.1778). In other words, the higher the percentage of concealed carry permits in the state, the smaller the decline in the murder rate was for that state, during that period of rising concealed carry prevalence.

That is what we'd expect to see if the net impact of concealed carry was to drive up the murder rate. It's what we'd expect to see if the murder rate was dropping, overall, for reasons unrelated to concealed carry (e.g., reductions in lead poisoning), but this improvement was muted by rising concealed carry prevalence.

This is hardly a slam-dunk demonstration, of course. The coefficient of correlation is small, and there was no way from his data to figure out timing (e.g., it's possible that some high concealed-carry state that had poor murder reduction already had high concealed carry in 1999, and saw less change in concealed carry than some other state with lower total permits). But, it's at least suggestive.

If someone wants to do the same correlation check with the change in violent crime rates, that might be even more interesting, since it's possible that even as concealed carry was muting the improvement in the murder rate, it was strengthening the improvement in the violent crime rate.
Lefty won't be happy until only the criminals have guns.
 
Back
Top