New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Bad Red-state Drivers

Arkady

President
A bit off the beaten path, but I'm curious what people here make of the following:

http://www.iihs.org/iihs/topics/t/general-statistics/fatalityfacts/state-by-state-overview

If you look at deaths per 100 vehicle miles traveled, nearly all the worst states are red states (the only one in the top 15 that isn't is purple-state New Mexico), while nearly all the best are blue states (plus purple states Virginia and Ohio). For some of those, I thought maybe the issue might be the urban-rural distinction. Urban states have lots of miles driven at low speeds, where accidents aren't as likely to be deadly, and when accidents occur there's more likely to be quick, high-quality medical attention. Drive into a tree in a rural area and maybe nobody even notices until your body's cold.

But the stats don't track that theory as much as I'd expect. The two least urbanized states in the union are Maine and Vermont, and Vermont has the second-lowest rate of deadly crashes, while Maine has the fifteenth lowest. California is the most urbanized state and it's got the sixteenth lowest fatality rate. The stats seem to reflect political leanings more than urbanization. Arguably our three most liberal states, Massachusetts, Vermont, and Minnesota, have the three lowest fatality rates, even though those include one of our least urbanized states, one of our most urbanized states, and one right in the middle.

So, any theory on what's going on there? One possibility is cultural -- that something about red staters makes them more likely to be bad drivers, or more likely to drive unsafe vehicles.... maybe more ride motorcycles, putting themselves at risk, or more drive over-sized trucks, putting others at risk. Another possibility is that government spending might factor in -- if you have well-maintained roads, lots of guard-rails, etc., maybe accidents happen less often and/or are less deadly. Similarly, if a state spends on better emergency services, blue-staters might survive accidents better. Likewise, if blue states are more likely to have, or at least to enforce, seat-belt, helmet, and child safety laws, or vehicle-safety-inspection laws, that could factor in. General driver health could be another issue -- for example, states with higher obesity rates (mostly red states) would have a greater share of people not physically able to endure the trauma of an accident. General healthcare might matter, too... states with lower health insurance rates might have accident victims skimping on medical treatment more often and therefore suffering deadly complications more often, which might end up being listed as traffic fatalities.

Other ideas?
 
More open spaces -- people drive faster. Faster speeds lead to more accidents and fatalities. That's speculation, of course. Another possibility is the sparse presence of police -- people drive more carefully when they might get a ticket, but it's hard to patrol large red states with the limited number of officers.

Seat belt and child-seat laws are effectively uniform now, as are DUI laws.
 
you don't have traffic fatalities in urban, bumper to bumper commutes at 15 mph.

they happen at 65 mph+, on the interstate. at night. in the rain or snow.
 
Back
Top