New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Bad writers.

Arkady

President
Does anyone else here read CNN.com? They're not a bad way to keep up-to-date on recent news, but their writing standards are hilariously bad. For example:

Putin recently called Trump "a brighter person, talented without a doubt." Trump returned the compliment saying: "I like him because he called me a genius. He said Trump is the real leader."​

That's not returning a compliment; its reveling in one. Trump isn't complimenting Putin, he's saying he likes Putin because Putin says stuff that strokes Trump's ego. Don't these people have editors?
 
Does anyone else here read CNN.com? They're not a bad way to keep up-to-date on recent news, but their writing standards are hilariously bad. For example:

Putin recently called Trump "a brighter person, talented without a doubt." Trump returned the compliment saying: "I like him because he called me a genius. He said Trump is the real leader."​

That's not returning a compliment; its reveling in one. Trump isn't complimenting Putin, he's saying he likes Putin because Putin says stuff that strokes Trump's ego. Don't these people have editors?
I thought you were going to complain about me.
 
journalism jobs are being outsourced to places like India, or being taken over by software programs.

financial and sports stories were the early experiments. politics is in the mix now.

if Watson can win at jeopardy, why can't it serve up news written at the 5th grade reading level?

I'm surprised you weren't aware of this trend. I encounter it more than I'd expect in the (print) WSJ, and I'm beginning to suspect that the WaPo is experimenting along the same lines.
 
journalism jobs are being outsourced to places like India, or being taken over by software programs.

financial and sports stories were the early experiments. politics is in the mix now.

if Watson can win at jeopardy, why can't it serve up news written at the 5th grade reading level?

I'm surprised you weren't aware of this trend. I encounter it more than I'd expect in the (print) WSJ, and I'm beginning to suspect that the WaPo is experimenting along the same lines.

Or is it just that young Americans can't write anything right anymore? My daughter who teaches freshman English at OU is shocked at the lack of ability those kids bring into her college course. Some don't know techniques that should have been second nature by 8th grade. And yes, they passed the screening and either came straight in or came from remedial (which did no good).
 
journalism jobs are being outsourced to places like India, or being taken over by software programs.

financial and sports stories were the early experiments. politics is in the mix now.

if Watson can win at jeopardy, why can't it serve up news written at the 5th grade reading level?

I'm surprised you weren't aware of this trend. I encounter it more than I'd expect in the (print) WSJ, and I'm beginning to suspect that the WaPo is experimenting along the same lines.
I'd bet good money that wasn't written by a computer. However, I do expect that financial pressures on the industry mean it's being written by a much worse writer today than could have found work in journalism 20 years ago, whether that's in India or the US. Plus, the turnaround time in the Internet age is measured in minutes rather than hours, as it was when it was print newspapers, which means we're reading the rough drafts. Still, that's worse than much of what you read on this forum.
 
Or is it just that young Americans can't write anything right anymore? My daughter who teaches freshman English at OU is shocked at the lack of ability those kids bring into her college course. Some don't know techniques that should have been second nature by 8th grade. And yes, they passed the screening and either came straight in or came from remedial (which did no good).
I think that's a symptom of a much larger share of people going to college now. It's no longer an elite group.
 
I think that's a symptom of a much larger share of people going to college now. It's no longer an elite group.


That's for sure. Hey, I know, let's make college "free" for everyone, no matter how stupid they are! That ought to raise the bar, right?
 
Got to thank and give all the credit to the progressive liberal Universities that are graduating these journalist.............ark

 
That's for sure. Hey, I know, let's make college "free" for everyone, no matter how stupid they are! That ought to raise the bar, right?
No, it won't raise the bar for those at that level. But it'll raise overall education. Think of it in terms of public financed high school when that was first implemented. That didn't raise the bar for those getting education at that age. It probably lowered it. Compare a 16-year-old full-time student in 1770 with one from 1970, and the latter is probably less educated, overall. But compare an AVERAGE 16-year-old in 1770 and one in 1970 and it won't even be close. The former will be very nearly illiterate and won't have any math skills beyond basic addition and subtraction. Before publicly financed high school was common, mass ignorance ruled. Only a minority of 16 year olds were even being formally educated.
 
Does anyone else here read CNN.com? They're not a bad way to keep up-to-date on recent news, but their writing standards are hilariously bad. For example:

Putin recently called Trump "a brighter person, talented without a doubt." Trump returned the compliment saying: "I like him because he called me a genius. He said Trump is the real leader."​

That's not returning a compliment; its reveling in one. Trump isn't complimenting Putin, he's saying he likes Putin because Putin says stuff that strokes Trump's ego. Don't these people have editors?

I have found that as time goes on, writing gets worse and worse. It used to be you could read any decent publication and not find a grammatical and spelling error. Ironically, now that we have auto checks for these things, writing is getting worse! I was fortunate to have been sent to Catholic school grades 1-8, where writing well was drilled into us. Now I do not claim to be an ace writer, but I'm knowledgeable enough to spot plenty of errors in wording, grammar, spelling and punctuation on a pretty regular basis. And we really can't even say it's just this group or that group. It's pretty much across the board.

It's been several months since I've read The Economist, but they have held up pretty well in that department. There's probably a few more I'm forgetting at the moment, but I know they're out there.
 
Or is it just that young Americans can't write anything right anymore? My daughter who teaches freshman English at OU is shocked at the lack of ability those kids bring into her college course. Some don't know techniques that should have been second nature by 8th grade. And yes, they passed the screening and either came straight in or came from remedial (which did no good).

And once they're in college, the focus is on "safe spaces" and shutting down non-leftist ideology. Who has time for trivial stuff like proper English? Besides, I hear that's racist anyway.
 
I have found that as time goes on, writing gets worse and worse. It used to be you could read any decent publication and not find a grammatical and spelling error. Ironically, now that we have auto checks for these things, writing is getting worse! I was fortunate to have been sent to Catholic school grades 1-8, where writing well was drilled into us. Now I do not claim to be an ace writer, but I'm knowledgeable enough to spot plenty of errors in wording, grammar, spelling and punctuation on a pretty regular basis. And we really can't even say it's just this group or that group. It's pretty much across the board.

It's been several months since I've read The Economist, but they have held up pretty well in that department. There's probably a few more I'm forgetting at the moment, but I know they're out there.
The higher end weekly magazines have held up. So have a few elite newspapers, if you don't hold their online editions against them. But the money just isn't there any more for quality anywhere else, and the pace makes it even harder. When you have to fill out a 24/7 news cycle on a budget dictated by banner ad revenues, you wind up employing novice writers and editors and paying them peanuts, while expecting them to churn out material fast. The results are hideous.
 
And once they're in college, the focus is on "safe spaces" and shutting down non-leftist ideology. Who has time for trivial stuff like proper English? Besides, I hear that's racist anyway.
Small sample size, I know, but I recently spent time on the Babson campus and the problem I saw was different.

There wasn't an academic atmosphere at all -- no sense that this was a break from the rat race to broaden the mind and to learn to think deeply. Instead, they seemed focused narrowly on the question of how it could all be monetized. Proper English wasn't taught not because of a focus on safe spaces, but rather because it just isn't viewed as important to pull in the bucks after graduation. Instead they focus on financial accounting, business buzz words, trendy new professional niches, and entrepreneurship. If you have enough English to be vaguely understood in an inter-office email, that's fine. Mostly your written communication will consist of PowerPoint sentence fragments, anyway.

I can't totally blame them. With the debt they take on to get a degree, knowledge for the sake of becoming a well rounded and polished person is a luxury they can't afford. Instead, they need to think mostly in terms of how to pay the bills. Even the PC stuff is more valuable, from that perspective, than a traditional liberal arts education, since at least it'll train them to talk the talk in middle management inclusion and diversity seminars.
 
Small sample size, I know, but I recently spent time on the Babson campus and the problem I saw was different.

There wasn't an academic atmosphere at all -- no sense that this was a break from the rat race to broaden the mind and to learn to think deeply. Instead, they seemed focused narrowly on the question of how it could all be monetized. Proper English wasn't taught not because of a focus on safe spaces, but rather because it just isn't viewed as important to pull in the bucks after graduation. Instead they focus on financial accounting, business buzz words, trendy new professional niches, and entrepreneurship. If you have enough English to be vaguely understood in an inter-office email, that's fine. Mostly your written communication will consist of PowerPoint sentence fragments, anyway.

I can't totally blame them. With the debt they take on to get a degree, knowledge for the sake of becoming a well rounded and polished person is a luxury they can't afford. Instead, they need to think mostly in terms of how to pay the bills. Even the PC stuff is more valuable, from that perspective, than a traditional liberal arts education, since at least it'll train them to talk the talk in middle management inclusion and diversity seminars.

That's an interesting perspective you got. So essentially we have institutes of higher learning abandoning (OK, that's probably a little dramatic, but you the point) excellent communication skills for one thing or another. Doing so as a prioritization secondary to the almighty dollar is probably the more generally correct answer. That said, I'll also say there's other reasons- some we probably haven't even given much thought of or consideration to.

I put minimal effort into writing well here on PJ. But you can rest assured when I'm communicating about business, I am a grammar, spelling and wording Nazi. I'm sure you are as well in your line of work. I suspect in law, you and others will stay "old school" and give serious weight changes to what people write based on their ability or inability to do so well.
 
The higher end weekly magazines have held up. So have a few elite newspapers, if you don't hold their online editions against them. But the money just isn't there any more for quality anywhere else, and the pace makes it even harder. When you have to fill out a 24/7 news cycle on a budget dictated by banner ad revenues, you wind up employing novice writers and editors and paying them peanuts, while expecting them to churn out material fast. The results are hideous.

I was going to say I recall going through a paper New York Times recently and I didn't find anything wrong. However, you raise a good point about the rapid news cycle. Now from where I'm standing, however, that means they should be extra diligent. But at least there's a somewhat logical reason for the offenses

But I am constantly annoyed by news channels- well, when I do happen to see the screens. I rarely if ever watch TV news. I don't have cable or satellite and it just doesn't interest me anyway. However, the two treadmills I get on at the gym have CNN and Fox News next to each other and I do catch a thing or two as I'm running or walking the incline. They're both serial offenders. Within the last week, one of them had a banner at the bottom talking about how Trump was "confidant" about the primary this past Tuesday. I usually listen to music, but being as anal as I am about spelling, I remember being annoyed about this banner the entire 45 minutes I spent on the treadmill.
 
I was going to say I recall going through a paper New York Times recently and I didn't find anything wrong. However, you raise a good point about the rapid news cycle. Now from where I'm standing, however, that means they should be extra diligent. But at least there's a somewhat logical reason for the offenses

But I am constantly annoyed by news channels- well, when I do happen to see the screens. I rarely if ever watch TV news. I don't have cable or satellite and it just doesn't interest me anyway. However, the two treadmills I get on at the gym have CNN and Fox News next to each other and I do catch a thing or two as I'm running or walking the incline. They're both serial offenders. Within the last week, one of them had a banner at the bottom talking about how Trump was "confidant" about the primary this past Tuesday. I usually listen to music, but being as anal as I am about spelling, I remember being annoyed about this banner the entire 45 minutes I spent on the treadmill.
Yes, the text under news broadcasts can be hilariously bad.
 
No, it won't raise the bar for those at that level. But it'll raise overall education. Think of it in terms of public financed high school when that was first implemented. That didn't raise the bar for those getting education at that age. It probably lowered it. Compare a 16-year-old full-time student in 1770 with one from 1970, and the latter is probably less educated, overall. But compare an AVERAGE 16-year-old in 1770 and one in 1970 and it won't even be close. The former will be very nearly illiterate and won't have any math skills beyond basic addition and subtraction. Before publicly financed high school was common, mass ignorance ruled. Only a minority of 16 year olds were even being formally educated.

Mass ignorance and they didn't need food stamps, unemployment to feed and provide for themselves...........yep.........mass ignorance came years later.
 
Does anyone else here read CNN.com? They're not a bad way to keep up-to-date on recent news, but their writing standards are hilariously bad. For example:

Putin recently called Trump "a brighter person, talented without a doubt." Trump returned the compliment saying: "I like him because he called me a genius. He said Trump is the real leader."​

That's not returning a compliment; its reveling in one. Trump isn't complimenting Putin, he's saying he likes Putin because Putin says stuff that strokes Trump's ego. Don't these people have editors?

I read FOXNEWS.COM when I want to keep up to date on recent news. If I wanted a bunch of liberal bullshit, I'd find Huffington. Same thing.
 
Back
Top