What would be wrong with telling a muslim candidate that he (or she) would have to swear to abide by the US constitution and all the laws (womens rights)? Would you have a problem with that? I'd have no problem with a muslim president IF they swore to never take away anyone's rights and would do what is written in the Constitution....and to never try to enforce Sharia laws. You expect Christian presidents to not force their beliefs on the nation....you have to agree to the same with a muslim.
A President swears to uphold the Constitution. It's part of the job.