New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Bowe Bergdahl

Zam-Zam

Senator
Remember him? Perhaps the administration is hoping you have forgotten all about him by now. There is precious little in the news about him, the latest seems to be this:


( KMVT-TV / KSVT-TV ) - There are new claims that the White House is stalling the results of the pentagon investigation into Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl.
Retired army Lt. Col. Tony Shaffer claims that the White House is trying to get Sgt. Bergdahl to strike a deal - in order to avoid a potentially embarrassing trial for the administration.

President Obama faced criticism for trading the Hailey native - accused by some of deserting - for five Taliban leaders being held at Guantanamo bay.
Shaffer also claims there were other options on the table that might have had quote "better success ... Without giving up five adversaries."


http://www.kmvt.com/news/latest/Plea-Deal-Suggested-For-Bowe-Bergdahl-297042241.html

Way back in January, NBC reported he was likely to be charged with desertion:

Army Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, who was held captive by enemy forces in Afghanistan for five years, will likely be charged with desertion, senior defense officials tell NBC News.

The officials point out that Bergdahl will likely face a lesser charge of desertion described in the Uniform Code of Military Justice as leaving a post to avoid duty or shirk an important assignment, based on his actions when he left a remote outpost in June 2009.

Those charges carry a maximum sentence of 5 years in prison upon conviction, but sources tell NBC News the Army is considering crediting Bergdahl for the 5 years he spent in captivity and be given the opportunity to avoid prosecution by leaving the Army with a "less than honorable discharge."


http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/bowe-bergdahl-likely-be-charged-desertion-officials-say-n294466

Sure was a shrewd deal we worked out.....
 
Bergdahl won't care how it's done as long as he can get out. I think we'll find him back in Afghanistan the first chance he gets. He was merely used to make the trade with 5 top terrorists. Once this is all over, he'll be back with his people in the ME.
 
Remember him? Perhaps the administration is hoping you have forgotten all about him by now. There is precious little in the news about him, the latest seems to be this:


( KMVT-TV / KSVT-TV ) - There are new claims that the White House is stalling the results of the pentagon investigation into Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl.
Retired army Lt. Col. Tony Shaffer claims that the White House is trying to get Sgt. Bergdahl to strike a deal - in order to avoid a potentially embarrassing trial for the administration.

President Obama faced criticism for trading the Hailey native - accused by some of deserting - for five Taliban leaders being held at Guantanamo bay.
Shaffer also claims there were other options on the table that might have had quote "better success ... Without giving up five adversaries."


http://www.kmvt.com/news/latest/Plea-Deal-Suggested-For-Bowe-Bergdahl-297042241.html

Way back in January, NBC reported he was likely to be charged with desertion:

Army Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, who was held captive by enemy forces in Afghanistan for five years, will likely be charged with desertion, senior defense officials tell NBC News.

The officials point out that Bergdahl will likely face a lesser charge of desertion described in the Uniform Code of Military Justice as leaving a post to avoid duty or shirk an important assignment, based on his actions when he left a remote outpost in June 2009.

Those charges carry a maximum sentence of 5 years in prison upon conviction, but sources tell NBC News the Army is considering crediting Bergdahl for the 5 years he spent in captivity and be given the opportunity to avoid prosecution by leaving the Army with a "less than honorable discharge."


http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/bowe-bergdahl-likely-be-charged-desertion-officials-say-n294466

Sure was a shrewd deal we worked out.....
I have a few questions on this:

1) Why is it that the Obama Administration gets everything backwards? It's like some alternate universe Bizarro World in which everything is a 180 from what is good or right. Extraordinary measures are taken to secure the release only of a deserter prisoner while honorable others elsewhere are allowed to languish in obscurity. Traditional allies are treated like garbage while BHO kowtows to historic enemies and horrible actors on the world stage, etc. Up is down, everything is reversed with these loons.

2) If Bergdahl is imprisoned by American forces, what faith will he convert to this time. Is Gumby going to flex back to Western Christianity?

3) Which language will Bergdahl forget this time? Will his dad now speak English to him? These folks have iron wills, dontchathink?


This whole thing stinks to high heaven. No reasonable person accepts what transpired here at face value. One must suspend his faculties to take this as it has been presented - which is the rule rather than the exception where uncritical, bobble head lefty is concerned. A more vigorous bunch of head-nodding sycophants I have not witnessed in my lifetime.
 
I have a few questions on this:

1) Why is it that the Obama Administration gets everything backwards? It's like some alternate universe Bizarro World in which everything is a 180 from what is good or right. Extraordinary measures are taken to secure the release only of a deserter prisoner while honorable others elsewhere are allowed to languish in obscurity. Traditional allies are treated like garbage while BHO kowtows to historic enemies and horrible actors on the world stage, etc. Up is down, everything is reversed with these loons.

2) If Bergdahl is imprisoned by American forces, what faith will he convert to this time. Is Gumby going to flex back to Western Christianity?

3) Which language will Bergdahl forget this time? Will his dad now speak English to him? These folks have iron wills, dontchathink?


This whole thing stinks to high heaven. No reasonable person accepts what transpired here at face value. One must suspend his faculties to take this as it has been presented - which is the rule rather than the exception where uncritical, bobble head lefty is concerned. A more vigorous bunch of head-nodding sycophants I have not witnessed in my lifetime.



Bowe Bergdahl is a living example of amateur hour at the White House/ "How to get played by terrorists without even trying."
 
Bowe Bergdahl is a living example of amateur hour at the White House/ "How to get played by terrorists without even trying."
I'm not so sure it isn't more collaborative than that. In a certain philosophical subset, weakness and pliability is strength, jello-conviction is sophistication, and moral malleability is heroic. Victimhood is nobility.

Strange days.
 
I'm not so sure it isn't more collaborative than that. In a certain philosophical subset, weakness and pliability is strength, jello-conviction is sophistication, and moral malleability is heroic. Victimhood is nobility.

Strange days.


You do have to wonder a bit. There's a length list of American POW/MIA's, yet we make a deal for the one guy who is likely a deserter. The administration can't be that dumb, can they? So, is something else in play here? It's a head-scratcher for sure.
 
You do have to wonder a bit. There's a length list of American POW/MIA's, yet we make a deal for the one guy who is likely a deserter. The administration can't be that dumb, can they? So, is something else in play here? It's a head-scratcher for sure.

I remember back when GWB was president and his detractors would try spinning conspiracy theories around this action of his, or that. GWB supporters tended to dismiss those detractors out of hand - as well they should have, in many cases.
 
i'm okay with this - "time served in taleban custody" - give him a dishonorable discharge and get him far, far away from the army and any weapons.

does he lose his right to vote too? i'm not saying this is essential, but it would be a bonus. no vote. no right to own a gun (person prohibited) and no pension.
 
i'm okay with this - "time served in taleban custody" - give him a dishonorable discharge and get him far, far away from the army and any weapons.

does he lose his right to vote too? i'm not saying this is essential, but it would be a bonus. no vote. no right to own a gun (person prohibited) and no pension.


People risked their lives for this guy after he "walked away". If he's convicted of desertion, he should pay the price.

Somehow, in order to spare the buffoons in charge even more embarrassment, I suspect a deal will be cut to make this thing go away as quietly as possible.
 
Dunno about that. But you don't think we should send him back?

No, I don't think we should send him back (like I said, I think he'll go there anyway if he gets the chance). But if he's found guilty of desertion, he should pay the full penalty and not be let off so easily. Men died looking for him.
 
I remember back when GWB was president and his detractors would try spinning conspiracy theories around this action of his, or that. GWB supporters tended to dismiss those detractors out of hand - as well they should have, in many cases.


I'm not putting forth any conspiracy theories, I'm trying to figure out a good reason why the President would swap five terrorists for a deserter when we have so many other POW/MIAs. Do you have one?
 
I'm not putting forth any conspiracy theories, I'm trying to figure out a good reason why the President would swap five terrorists for a deserter when we have so many other POW/MIAs. Do you have one?

Were you sympathetic to those who might demand "good reasons" for everything GWB did or didn't do? As a conservative, I wasn't one of those demanders. I'm not today, either.
 
Were you sympathetic to those who might demand "good reasons" for everything GWB did or didn't do? As a conservative, I wasn't one of those demanders. I'm not today, either.


Try starting your own thread if you're not interested in discussing this one. George Bush doesn't interest me.
 
Remember him? Perhaps the administration is hoping you have forgotten all about him by now. There is precious little in the news about him, the latest seems to be this:


( KMVT-TV / KSVT-TV ) - There are new claims that the White House is stalling the results of the pentagon investigation into Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl.
Retired army Lt. Col. Tony Shaffer claims that the White House is trying to get Sgt. Bergdahl to strike a deal - in order to avoid a potentially embarrassing trial for the administration.

President Obama faced criticism for trading the Hailey native - accused by some of deserting - for five Taliban leaders being held at Guantanamo bay.
Shaffer also claims there were other options on the table that might have had quote "better success ... Without giving up five adversaries."


http://www.kmvt.com/news/latest/Plea-Deal-Suggested-For-Bowe-Bergdahl-297042241.html

Way back in January, NBC reported he was likely to be charged with desertion:

Army Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, who was held captive by enemy forces in Afghanistan for five years, will likely be charged with desertion, senior defense officials tell NBC News.

The officials point out that Bergdahl will likely face a lesser charge of desertion described in the Uniform Code of Military Justice as leaving a post to avoid duty or shirk an important assignment, based on his actions when he left a remote outpost in June 2009.

Those charges carry a maximum sentence of 5 years in prison upon conviction, but sources tell NBC News the Army is considering crediting Bergdahl for the 5 years he spent in captivity and be given the opportunity to avoid prosecution by leaving the Army with a "less than honorable discharge."


http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/bowe-bergdahl-likely-be-charged-desertion-officials-say-n294466

Sure was a shrewd deal we worked out.....
I would consider it inappropriate for an administration to essentially pre-judge someone for a crime, without trial, and effectively sentence him to harsh, indefinite detention based on that. So, I think an administration has to start from the presumption that the person is innocent and decide whether the prisoner swap makes sense or not on that basis. One can criticize the Obama administration if one thinks that even an innocent soldier's freedom wasn't worth what we traded, but I think it's a bad road to go down to criticize the administration for not holding against Bergdahl unproven accusations in deciding whether or not he should be traded for.
 
Try starting your own thread if you're not interested in discussing this one. George Bush doesn't interest me.

I realize he doesn't, and that's awfully punk of you....as is par for your course. GWB was an American president just as is Obama. IF we're to critique any specific president, it's useful to do so within the context of ALL American presidents.

The feelings of those who think each president should be considered in his own vacuum, aren't really worth anyone's time of day. If Dems think GOPs are 100% bad and vice versa, it's interesting I suppose, but doesn't help us a whole lot going forward.
 
Back
Top