Arkady
President
There are problems with comparing Cliven Bundy with the Occupy Wall Street protestors. Among the differences:
(1) The OWS protestors were only illegally on public land for a fairly short period of time, where Bundy's lawlessness has persisted for 20 years.
(2) Bundy was seeking to enrich himself by acquiring raw materials that belonged to someone else without paying for them. The OWS people were peaceably assembling to petition their government for a redress of grievances.
(3) The authorities moved fairly quickly to oust the OWS protestors, whereas the BLM has dragged its feet for many years with Bundy, before doing anything -- he stopped paying 20 years ago, and was ordered by a court not to graze his cattle there 16 years ago, and defied multiple court orders, before the BLM finally started to round up the trespassing cattle.
(4) The OWS protestors almost universally relied on passive resistance to eviction, whereas Bundy and his supporters confronted authorities with firearms.
(5) The authorities didn't back down from evicting OWS protestors -- pepper-spraying and beating those who resisted, and throwing many in jail. The BLM, by comparison, backed down, and so far nobody's been jailed.
However, putting aside those many differences, there are some key similarities. In each case, you have a dispute about whether private individuals are allowed to use public land in certain ways. In each case, the statutes, regulations, and court orders are fairly clearly on the government's side, but the other side has arguments about the Constitutionally of that law (either based on actual language in the first Amendment, for the OWS crowd, or based on fanciful ideas of ancestral rights, in the case of Bundy).
So, I'm curious whether people here took consistent or inconsistent positions on these two cases. In my own case, I'll cop to some inconsistency. I was sympathetic towards the OWS lawbreakers and not towards Bundy. However, as you can see from how I laid this out, I think there's a good case to be made to differentiate the two, to justify being more supportive of OWS and more critical of the way authorities ousted them. How about others, here?
(1) The OWS protestors were only illegally on public land for a fairly short period of time, where Bundy's lawlessness has persisted for 20 years.
(2) Bundy was seeking to enrich himself by acquiring raw materials that belonged to someone else without paying for them. The OWS people were peaceably assembling to petition their government for a redress of grievances.
(3) The authorities moved fairly quickly to oust the OWS protestors, whereas the BLM has dragged its feet for many years with Bundy, before doing anything -- he stopped paying 20 years ago, and was ordered by a court not to graze his cattle there 16 years ago, and defied multiple court orders, before the BLM finally started to round up the trespassing cattle.
(4) The OWS protestors almost universally relied on passive resistance to eviction, whereas Bundy and his supporters confronted authorities with firearms.
(5) The authorities didn't back down from evicting OWS protestors -- pepper-spraying and beating those who resisted, and throwing many in jail. The BLM, by comparison, backed down, and so far nobody's been jailed.
However, putting aside those many differences, there are some key similarities. In each case, you have a dispute about whether private individuals are allowed to use public land in certain ways. In each case, the statutes, regulations, and court orders are fairly clearly on the government's side, but the other side has arguments about the Constitutionally of that law (either based on actual language in the first Amendment, for the OWS crowd, or based on fanciful ideas of ancestral rights, in the case of Bundy).
So, I'm curious whether people here took consistent or inconsistent positions on these two cases. In my own case, I'll cop to some inconsistency. I was sympathetic towards the OWS lawbreakers and not towards Bundy. However, as you can see from how I laid this out, I think there's a good case to be made to differentiate the two, to justify being more supportive of OWS and more critical of the way authorities ousted them. How about others, here?