New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Calculating Inflation

Arkady

President
Over the years, I've had a lot of debates about inflation, and I find them interesting because they don't break down on the usual partisan lines. You can guess how the knee-jerk partisans are going to argue based on what's convenient for their party at the moment, but those arguments keep reversing themselves (the right-winger who wants to insist real inflation is much higher than the official rate, right now, would have made the opposite argument a few years earlier when higher inflation would have looked bad for Bush).

I sympathize with those who have to compile the official inflation rates, because there's no easy and fair way to do it. I wonder whether most people here have really thought through the challenges. Ultimately, what you're trying to record is how far a dollar will go for a consumer. So, what you do is you come up with a basket of goods, and figure out how much it costs to buy that basket. You want the basket to represent a fairly typical collection of purchases for an average consumer -- each type of purchase in relative proportion to the other purchases he makes, so that a move in one item reflect the overall inflation rate in proportion to how hard such a move would hit a typical consumer's bottom line.

That sounds pretty easy, and if what a typical consumer bought never changed, there'd be no difficulty or controversy involved in the inflation rate. E.g., if a typical consumer in 1960, 1970, 1980, 1990, 2000, 2010 bought the same average basket of goods each month (30 gallons of gas, two dozen eggs, four gallons of milk, two pair of underwear, twenty newspapers, etc.), then you could just price them out in each year and compare. But a typical consumer's purchases change over time, so how do you account for that?

Obviously, some of that happens due to technology changes. For example, a typical consumer today is far more likely to buy a color TV than a typical consumer in 1960 (when that would have been a luxury good). For a couple hundred dollars, today, I can buy you a smart phone with more storage and processing power than a $100,000 super computer would have gotten you in 1960. How do you account for that?

It's difficult to compare products across time periods even when the fundamental technologies aren't that different. The basics of the American automobile aren't all that different -- four wheels and an internal combustion engine. Still, to what do you compare a mid-market mid-sized sedan of 2012, when you want to price it out against an equivalent product in 1972? In theory, you could just compare it to a mid-market mid-sized sedan of 1972.... but chances are your 2012 model has vastly more going for it -- airbags, anti-lock braking, traction control, a far more fuel efficient engine, more horsepower, lighter materials, stability control, high-quality sound system, power windows, power steering, power locks, maybe even things like GPS.

People also make substitutions based on pricing, and those have to be accounted for. For example, shrimp farming has turned shrimp from a luxury items just a couple decades ago to something you get in dirt-cheap appetizers at low-end family restaurants. In 1998, a pound of shrimp cost $18.80. Today it costs $7.96. The predictable result is that people will eat more shrimp. That changes the proportional composition of shrimp within the "basket of goods" that a typical consumer purchases. On the flip side, the price of beef has sky-rocketed -- especially in the last few years. Yet people are eating less beef (partly due to price and partly due to health concerns that have made chicken and fish relatively more attractive). So, again, the typical "basket of goods" has changed. You could price out what it would cost for someone to buy what was typical in 1998, but it wouldn't mean that much if that's just not what a typical consumer is buying these days. Or you could price out what it would have cost in 1998 to buy what a typical consumer buys today, but again that isn't terribly meaningful if a typical consumer wouldn't have been buying that (e.g., lots of shrimp).

Anyway, I'm not posting this to defend how the government calculates inflation, and certainly not to argue that there aren't improvements to be made. I'm just saying that a lot of the criticisms I see are just superficial ones, driven by a desire to game the numbers one way or the other for political purposes. Most people haven't even begun to grapple with how hard it is to come up with a good inflation calculation. No matter how much a person wants to calculate the "real inflation rate," and no matter how good he is about dismissing his own partisan prejudices about it, there's no simple or uncontroversial "real" number to be had. As long as technology and consumption patterns keep changing, any calculation will be fraught with judgment calls and controversies.
 
inflation is a total non-issue with real money (salt, silver, gold, etc)

but when synthetic money replaces real money; it brings in a new variable; a constantly changing value that is in total flux to the volume of throughput in any given market; making inflation a real problem for value. Synthetic money is like the blank tile in Scrabble. It can be used for everything, but it simply has no value; the value is constantly having to be calculated against the overall volume of money in a given market and the overall value of the market... and nobody actually does this, it is up to each of us to decide what price is right for us. When we had real silver and gold in our pockets; uniform in weight and purity and duly stamped, we knew what our money was worth and the value was intrinsic and rock steady. But when our nation switched up the money and we spent enough time on synthetic money, we slowly came to realize that this money is interdependent with lending attitudes that are constantly changing, that the market moves our money around and that the banks move the volume throughput around (in the markets) ... it seems the more you understand the more confused you get.

When politicians try to use the economy as a political argument, you can bet they are just tossing out simple notions and hoping the public will bite. My personal indicator for inflation is not the price of goods or even the price of oil, I just glance at the DOW Jones from time to time and it registers with me how much money is getting printed. That, to me, is inflation. The problem with this system is that it hands total control of the money to the banks and then the presidential candidates point fingers at each other and pretend that either one is making a mess of the economy or is growing the economy... when the whole manner of measuring the economy is just to measure the throughput of money in the marketplace... which doesn't measure the amount of goods, it just measures money volumes changing hands, and since the value changes based on the volume in use, it tells you nothing about whether the real economy is growing or shrinking; so the whole argument is firmly grounded in hot air. The presidents don't have any control over the economy anyway, but for the sake of running an election, they toss clouds at each other, pretending that they do anything that would affect the economy... while the banks are the ones that run the money. The irony of this whole confused state of affairs is that the presidents actually do have authority over the currency, but they never, ever use that authority, so if the politicians were to be honest about their arguments, they would point out how the other guy is too cowardly to utilize the tools at his disposal... but since they all are cowards, they never press that argument.
 
money is simply an instrument of trade used to simplify bartering. if gold or salt were used to simplify bartering, they would be no different.
 
there's a world of difference between real money and fiat money. Not a tiny sliver of difference, but a great big huge enormous difference...
 
The top-poster's discussion can ALSO be applied in spades, to the "healthcare" product. We still tend to measure the "cost" of healthcare in terms of the "visit to the doctor" unit. Yet, the difference between the actual product delivered in the context of that visit in 1960 as compared to today, is exponential and (almost) incalculable.
 
Inflation can be an issue with ANYTHING you use as money. Take gold as an example. During a gold rush, you get inflation. As more gold "currency" gets dumped into the mix, the relative price of everything else, stated in gold terms, rises. It might cost you a quarter ounce of gold just to buy a dozen eggs.

The same is true of salt -- if a new salt mine opens up, increasing the supply of salt (or if some new process is perfected for pulling it out of sea water), there is rapid inflation, in terms of how much salt it will cost you to buy a basket of goods. So, you don't eliminate the problem of inflation by going with some sort of more primitive barter-based system of money, where the unit of money has some intrinsic usefulness. All you do is set a practical cap on the likely amount of inflation (and deflation).
 
Inflation can be an issue with ANYTHING you use as money. Take gold as an example. During a gold rush, you get inflation. As more gold "currency" gets dumped into the mix, the relative price of everything else, stated in gold terms, rises. It might cost you a quarter ounce of gold just to buy a dozen eggs.

The same is true of salt -- if a new salt mine opens up, increasing the supply of salt (or if some new process is perfected for pulling it out of sea water), there is rapid inflation, in terms of how much salt it will cost you to buy a basket of goods. So, you don't eliminate the problem of inflation by going with some sort of more primitive barter-based system of money, where the unit of money has some intrinsic usefulness. All you do is set a practical cap on the likely amount of inflation (and deflation).

Your right.

Actually anything can be used as currency/ everything can be manipulated if consolidated in the hands of a few or in the hands of a criminal/lawless govt.
 
Interesting point. That's a huge part of why healthcare costs inflate so quickly -- we get all sorts of expensive advanced diagnostics and treatments that weren't even possible a few decades ago (e.g., MRIs and CAT scans and all kinds of tests and drugs that didn't exist). However, one interesting thing is how this has had a relatively small impact on lifespans and quality of life, at least later in life. Lifespans are up, but that's more based on a fall in infant and childhood mortality than on a greater life expectancy for someone who has reached old age. And yet what we're spending on the old is vastly more. That's an argument that if you really want to bring down healthcare costs, one of the things you need to do is focus on spending more money where it has a lot of impact (e.g., early in life) and less where it has less impact (e.g., late in life).
 
Agreed. We can actually see that in history, just by looking at gold prices. Gold prices were around $660/ounce 30 years ago, then around $260/ounce a little over a decade ago. If our currency had been gold-based, in that period, that would have registered as inflation -- that which had cost one ounce of gold in 1980 would have cost two and a half ounces of gold in 2000. And in the last 12 years, we would have suffered through crippling deflation. The idea that gold is some sort of stable source of real value just isn't supported by history. In the end, it's just a shiny soft yellow metal, which has value mostly because people think it has value.... no more or less intrinsically valuable than the greenback, and less stable.
 
Agreed. We can actually see that in history, just by looking at gold prices. Gold prices were around $660/ounce 30 years ago, then around $260/ounce a little over a decade ago. If our currency had been gold-based, in that period, that would have registered as inflation -- that which had cost one ounce of gold in 1980 would have cost two and a half ounces of gold in 2000. And in the last 12 years, we would have suffered through crippling deflation. The idea that gold is some sort of stable source of real value just isn't supported by history. In the end, it's just a shiny soft yellow metal, which has value mostly because people think it has value.... no more or less intrinsically valuable than the greenback, and less stable.

What would happen in your opinion if we followed the U.S Constitution which originally set the monetary value of the U.S dollar to be $20=1oz of Gold and $1 + 1oz of silver?

And instead of printing money based on debt, had to produce this..

awww.coinnews.net_wp_content_uploads_2009_01_2009_Ultra_High_R78ceeb1be0ffec8203f34a608a133e02.jpg
 
Interesting point. That's a huge part of why healthcare costs inflate so quickly -- we get all sorts of expensive advanced diagnostics and treatments that weren't even possible a few decades ago (e.g., MRIs and CAT scans and all kinds of tests and drugs that didn't exist). However, one interesting thing is how this has had a relatively small impact on lifespans and quality of life, at least later in life. Lifespans are up, but that's more based on a fall in infant and childhood mortality than on a greater life expectancy for someone who has reached old age. And yet what we're spending on the old is vastly more. That's an argument that if you really want to bring down healthcare costs, one of the things you need to do is focus on spending more money where it has a lot of impact (e.g., early in life) and less where it has less impact (e.g., late in life).

There's an especial silver lining to all that, that we're not seeming to acknowledge. It's way better that we enjoy a surplus of healthcare capability, than a deficit. As you say, we may've overshot our mark. So, we've got plenty of room to dial things back without causing any harm.
 
Days: inflation is a total non-issue with real money (salt, silver, gold, etc)

LeRoy: That's just not true, Days. Arkady has already answered you on this claim, but I am going to amplify on what he said. Silver and gold were used as money by the ancient Romans. [They didn't even have paper yet, though it had been invented in China by ~100 AD.] But the Romans suffered from a serious trade deficit with the East. (Sound familiar?) They were importing silk from China and spices from India and points further. The only things the Romans had that the Asians wanted were, you guessed it, silver and gold. So much of the silver and gold was leaving the empire that the emperors naturally became concerned about it. Some attempted to deal with the issue by passing sumptuary laws, limiting the consumption of silk (for example). That didn't work very well. As the empire started to decline, some of the later emperors started DEBASING the coinage, introducing impurities into it. That didn't fool people for very long. [As Abraham Lincoln noted, you can fool some of the people all of the time, and can fool all of the people some of the time, but you can't fool all of the people all of the time.] So what happened? Prices of ordinary goods and services started to rise, naturally. [People wanted more coins for the same goods, because the coins were worth less.] A generalized inflation set in, which lasted for a period of centuries. The Romans certainly noticed this---you bet they did!---but adopted a fatalistic attitude towards it. They did not search for an explanation; they simply figured if prices were going up, it must be the whim of the gods.

Fast forward more than a millenium. The 16th century. The Spaniards had their vast empire in the New World, and were bringing back massive quantities of silver and gold, from Mexico and Peru. That big boost to the supply of money started to circulate more generally around the wider European economy, and voila! Prices went up! In fact, they went up so consistently over the 16th century that historians have taken to calling it 'the Price Revolution of the 16th Century'. This time, though, with a different mindset, and more curiosity, people started asking WHY the inflation was happening. May have even led to the birth of modern economics.

So prices can certainly go up with commodity money. They can also go down. We had a long rather gentle deflation in the late 19th century, but it was strong enough to give birth to the Populist movement in America. That period of deflation did not end until 1896, with the discovery of gold in the Yukon.

The one thing that IS likely true with commodity money is that you could never get a hyper-inflation. That has only ever happened with paper fiat money, when a central bank is being wildly irresponsible.
 
the surplus youre so proud of has the effect of making healthcare unavailable to all your citizens.
 
Arkady: The idea that gold is some sort of stable source of real value just isn't supported by history.

LeRoy: Keynes said that gold was a "barbarous relic".

We seem to have a lot of barbarous relics around here, too.
 
In the pre-colonization America, at least in the Northeast, special shell beads were used as currency. The key is to have something where there are controls on the increase of supply, so that people have some expectation that what they have today will retain much of that value tomorrow.
 
Back
Top