New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Chasing a fair wage...

PhilFish

Administrator
Staff member
In watching the latest news regarding protests on McDonalds corporate campus...I woner about possible solutions and the notion of 'blame'

In one clip, a protesting employee states that he was promised x, y and z..

Doesnt matter the specifics, but the gist is pay, hours, bennies. agreed?

ok... so, given that this employee is displeased, to say the least... what recourse does he have. and persons in similar circumstances.. are any of what follows inappropriate actions?


> leave the current employer.

> study / pursue skills that are applicable to other industries and careers

> stay put

> work hard to learn all that there is to learn and hopefully move up in the chosen employ.

I understand the displeasure, but it escapes me how a person, responsible of his/her own actions...can readily put blame on another. in theis case, the employer. (thisis not to say the employer is in the right entirely, nor that i support maintaining min wages at current levels....)


http://news.yahoo.com/protesters-arrested-pay-fight-mcdonalds-hq-220153839--finance.html
 
In watching the latest news regarding protests on McDonalds corporate campus...I woner about possible solutions and the notion of 'blame'

In one clip, a protesting employee states that he was promised x, y and z..

Doesnt matter the specifics, but the gist is pay, hours, bennies. agreed?

ok... so, given that this employee is displeased, to say the least... what recourse does he have. and persons in similar circumstances.. are any of what follows inappropriate actions?


> leave the current employer.

> study / pursue skills that are applicable to other industries and careers

> stay put

> work hard to learn all that there is to learn and hopefully move up in the chosen employ.

I understand the displeasure, but it escapes me how a person, responsible of his/her own actions...can readily put blame on another. in theis case, the employer. (thisis not to say the employer is in the right entirely, nor that i support maintaining min wages at current levels....)


http://news.yahoo.com/protesters-arrested-pay-fight-mcdonalds-hq-220153839--finance.html
All four options you present are perfectly valid.

When you apply for a job, are offered a job, accept the job under the circumstances it is offered to you, you have no one to blame but yourself if you don't like the results.
 
In watching the latest news regarding protests on McDonalds corporate campus...I woner about possible solutions and the notion of 'blame'

In one clip, a protesting employee states that he was promised x, y and z..

Doesnt matter the specifics, but the gist is pay, hours, bennies. agreed?

ok... so, given that this employee is displeased, to say the least... what recourse does he have. and persons in similar circumstances.. are any of what follows inappropriate actions?


> leave the current employer.

> study / pursue skills that are applicable to other industries and careers

> stay put

> work hard to learn all that there is to learn and hopefully move up in the chosen employ.

I understand the displeasure, but it escapes me how a person, responsible of his/her own actions...can readily put blame on another. in theis case, the employer. (thisis not to say the employer is in the right entirely, nor that i support maintaining min wages at current levels....)


http://news.yahoo.com/protesters-arrested-pay-fight-mcdonalds-hq-220153839--finance.html

My question has always been what is a fair wage?

Let say Congress raised the minimum wage to $10.10 hr will that really help those in cities like Chicago, L.A., or New york where cost of living is so high that $10.10 hr would not lift them out of poverty!?!

As you stated the employee does have options but it seem to me the American public is getting lazier and just want Uncle Sam to give them what they want and not work for it...

So what is a fair wage?

Where I live in Texas $10 hr is liveable but in Chicago it is not...
 
My question has always been what is a fair wage?

Let say Congress raised the minimum wage to $10.10 hr will that really help those in cities like Chicago, L.A., or New york where cost of living is so high that $10.10 hr would not lift them out of poverty!?!

As you stated the employee does have options but it seem to me the American public is getting lazier and just want Uncle Sam to give them what they want and not work for it...

So what is a fair wage?

Where I live in Texas $10 hr is liveable but in Chicago it is not...


Dunno. Does every position that exists require a 'liveable' wage? or a fair wage for the work required?
 
In watching the latest news regarding protests on McDonalds corporate campus...I woner about possible solutions and the notion of 'blame'

In one clip, a protesting employee states that he was promised x, y and z..

Doesnt matter the specifics, but the gist is pay, hours, bennies. agreed?

ok... so, given that this employee is displeased, to say the least... what recourse does he have. and persons in similar circumstances.. are any of what follows inappropriate actions?


> leave the current employer.

> study / pursue skills that are applicable to other industries and careers

> stay put

> work hard to learn all that there is to learn and hopefully move up in the chosen employ.

I understand the displeasure, but it escapes me how a person, responsible of his/her own actions...can readily put blame on another. in theis case, the employer. (thisis not to say the employer is in the right entirely, nor that i support maintaining min wages at current levels....)


http://news.yahoo.com/protesters-arrested-pay-fight-mcdonalds-hq-220153839--finance.html
He has lots of options, including exposing a PR-sensitive national brand to public scorn if they don't treat their employees better. That will potentially make the senior execs think twice before screwing the workers. Or collective bargaining.
 
He has lots of options, including exposing a PR-sensitive national brand to public scorn if they don't treat their employees better. That will potentially make the senior execs think twice before screwing the workers. Or collective bargaining.


perhaps. but so far you've levied deserving of scorn, mistreatment, screwing...and the need to leverage PR.

if the position does not merit paying, lets pick an arbitrary saaay $18/hr....what options then. the position should not be relied upon for ekeing out a living wage...if it's demands not meet that in remuneration.. no?
 
All four options you present are perfectly valid.

When you apply for a job, are offered a job, accept the job under the circumstances it is offered to you, you have no one to blame but yourself if you don't like the results.


well, in whic case...what oprtions present themselves...

it think a/ talk to the employer. b/ leave the employer.

learned helplessness comes to mind....
 
Dunno. Does every position that exists require a 'liveable' wage? or a fair wage for the work required?

Don't you think it should?

Would you pay someone to work for you a wage they can not support themselves on?

Now I agree if the employee is not happy then yes they should attempt to find other employment but I also feel that employers have to be realistic and paying a decent wage that is fair and liveable would bring you better employees and less turn over...

Just my opinion and in your first post you make valid points also...
 
Don't you think it should?

Would you pay someone to work for you a wage they can not support themselves on?

Now I agree if the employee is not happy then yes they should attempt to find other employment but I also feel that employers have to be realistic and paying a decent wage that is fair and liveable would bring you better employees and less turn over...

Just my opinion and in your first post you make valid points also...


sure, but if the average wage for a given position is x....and soem decide x is insufficient to live off of. does the industry in its entirety change the wage? or the worker exercise his/her option to change positions?
 
perhaps. but so far you've levied deserving of scorn, mistreatment, screwing...and the need to leverage PR.

if the position does not merit paying, lets pick an arbitrary saaay $18/hr....what options then. the position should not be relied upon for ekeing out a living wage...if it's demands not meet that in remuneration.. no?
The protestor needs to assess his chances based on his own pain points and those of his employer. It's certainly possible to overplay one's hand, and there's only so much one can realistically hope to get out of low-skill employment.
 
if he was actually promised XY and Z - then it should be a simple matter to resolve. Call the Department of Labor, and report a violation of wages and benefits.

the fact that he has never done so, and no attorney has latched onto him to advance his claim, suggests that there is an element of BS at work here.
 
Whenever we pay a full time worker less than the minimum wage, we - the taxpayers - are subsidizing that worker. We do that by way of the EITC, Medicaid, various social service and support regimes, to name just a few.

In other words, we taxpayers are kicking in part of their paychecks, in order that McDonald's may thrive. I don't know if that's necessarily a good thing or a bad thing?....but, it is a "thing" worth thinking about. Do we really want to subsidize other people's payroll departments and paychecks? Is it in our interest to subsidize burger flipping specifically?

Reagan came up with the very good (imho) idea of the EITC - the earned income tax credit. By linking aid with work, we move our needle a tad, from socialist to free market. But, the EITC is STILL a taxpayer subsidy to private industry. I subsidize that burger flipper whether I eat at McDonald's or not.

If we want to move our needle even more in the direction of free markets, we would insist that McDonald's own market cover these costs, by raising wages, rather than continuing to foist them off on we taxpayers in general.
 
In watching the latest news regarding protests on McDonalds corporate campus...I woner about possible solutions and the notion of 'blame'

In one clip, a protesting employee states that he was promised x, y and z..

Doesnt matter the specifics, but the gist is pay, hours, bennies. agreed?

ok... so, given that this employee is displeased, to say the least... what recourse does he have. and persons in similar circumstances.. are any of what follows inappropriate actions?


> leave the current employer.

> study / pursue skills that are applicable to other industries and careers

> stay put

> work hard to learn all that there is to learn and hopefully move up in the chosen employ.

I understand the displeasure, but it escapes me how a person, responsible of his/her own actions...can readily put blame on another. in theis case, the employer. (thisis not to say the employer is in the right entirely, nor that i support maintaining min wages at current levels....)


http://news.yahoo.com/protesters-arrested-pay-fight-mcdonalds-hq-220153839--finance.html

This protest seemed like a huge waste of time. If they really want higher pay and benefits then bring in a union and call for a vote, if McDonalds interferes then raise a stink. They're wasting their time expecting the corporation to just give them something they want.

I think higher wages in general are good for all of us but how do we get there? I don't like the idea of minimum wage, it's just not something the government can mandate because there are too many variables between different areas, I think collective bargaining is a better way to get there.

Fairsheet bought up an important point, it's not just the wage that's an issue, it's the reason behind the low wage. We the people have allowed companies like McDonalds to use our money in order to establish a ceiling on wages. If I were in charge I'd keep track of the Employer IDs of every working American who needed to file for any kind of need based benefit or tax break and then when the numbers were in I'd bill the employers for every damn dime their employees claimed, plus a quarterly percentage.
 
In watching the latest news regarding protests on McDonalds corporate campus...I woner about possible solutions and the notion of 'blame'

In one clip, a protesting employee states that he was promised x, y and z..

Doesnt matter the specifics, but the gist is pay, hours, bennies. agreed?

ok... so, given that this employee is displeased, to say the least... what recourse does he have. and persons in similar circumstances.. are any of what follows inappropriate actions?


> leave the current employer.

> study / pursue skills that are applicable to other industries and careers

> stay put

> work hard to learn all that there is to learn and hopefully move up in the chosen employ.

I understand the displeasure, but it escapes me how a person, responsible of his/her own actions...can readily put blame on another. in theis case, the employer. (thisis not to say the employer is in the right entirely, nor that i support maintaining min wages at current levels....)


http://news.yahoo.com/protesters-arrested-pay-fight-mcdonalds-hq-220153839--finance.html
With jobs as scarce as they are leaving your present employer and even having better job skills that should allow you to get better work is almost impossible and the employers know this fact. Maybe if the GOP spent more time working with the Dems and the Pres to try and create new jobs instead of spending all their energy blocking everything and constantly starting new investigations investigating the same old thing, there would be more jobs for these people to aspire to.
 
In watching the latest news regarding protests on McDonalds corporate campus...I woner about possible solutions and the notion of 'blame'

In one clip, a protesting employee states that he was promised x, y and z..

Doesnt matter the specifics, but the gist is pay, hours, bennies. agreed?

ok... so, given that this employee is displeased, to say the least... what recourse does he have. and persons in similar circumstances.. are any of what follows inappropriate actions?


> leave the current employer.

> study / pursue skills that are applicable to other industries and careers

> stay put

> work hard to learn all that there is to learn and hopefully move up in the chosen employ.

I understand the displeasure, but it escapes me how a person, responsible of his/her own actions...can readily put blame on another. in theis case, the employer. (thisis not to say the employer is in the right entirely, nor that i support maintaining min wages at current levels....)


http://news.yahoo.com/protesters-arrested-pay-fight-mcdonalds-hq-220153839--finance.html


Everyone always has a choice of what they wish to seek in life. Moving on, moving up, sideways, leftways or rightways is alsways an option, for an individual. The issue is that someone still needs to fill those jobs, and there are a limited number of jobs available for those in low paying jobs to move to. Regardless of how much potential a person has, they may end up in one of those jobs.


We are in a feudalistic/ oligarchy society, capitalism left to its own devices dictates it to progress this way. Not that capitalism is a bad thing, it just needs to be kept in check by a set of "checks and balances." The issue of pay is far greater than the minimum wage, it's needless tax breaks for corporations, ceo bonus caps, R&D responsible spending, tariffs, wasted government oversight (money which could be spent on social programs if more efficient), etc.


Would it be possible to reform the system as we sit right now, politically and economically, no. We are fallible beings and we have created an environment which creates such circumstances. The minimum wage should be raised, but it will do little to no good as that already billionaire will need another billion without major and sprawling reforms.
 
In watching the latest news regarding protests on McDonalds corporate campus...I woner about possible solutions and the notion of 'blame'

In one clip, a protesting employee states that he was promised x, y and z..

Doesnt matter the specifics, but the gist is pay, hours, bennies. agreed?

ok... so, given that this employee is displeased, to say the least... what recourse does he have. and persons in similar circumstances.. are any of what follows inappropriate actions?


> leave the current employer.

> study / pursue skills that are applicable to other industries and careers

> stay put

> work hard to learn all that there is to learn and hopefully move up in the chosen employ.

I understand the displeasure, but it escapes me how a person, responsible of his/her own actions...can readily put blame on another. in theis case, the employer. (thisis not to say the employer is in the right entirely, nor that i support maintaining min wages at current levels....)


http://news.yahoo.com/protesters-arrested-pay-fight-mcdonalds-hq-220153839--finance.html


Oh come on now Phil. We all know these people are helpless slaves of big corporations. And I suspect the Koch brothers are somewhere behind this curtain at McDonalds, scheming to keep wages low.
 
Whenever we pay a full time worker less than the minimum wage, we - the taxpayers - are subsidizing that worker. We do that by way of the EITC, Medicaid, various social service and support regimes, to name just a few.

In other words, we taxpayers are kicking in part of their paychecks, in order that McDonald's may thrive. I don't know if that's necessarily a good thing or a bad thing?....but, it is a "thing" worth thinking about. Do we really want to subsidize other people's payroll departments and paychecks? Is it in our interest to subsidize burger flipping specifically?

Reagan came up with the very good (imho) idea of the EITC - the earned income tax credit. By linking aid with work, we move our needle a tad, from socialist to free market. But, the EITC is STILL a taxpayer subsidy to private industry. I subsidize that burger flipper whether I eat at McDonald's or not.

If we want to move our needle even more in the direction of free markets, we would insist that McDonald's own market cover these costs, by raising wages, rather than continuing to foist them off on we taxpayers in general.

McDonalds pays less than minimum wage???
 
This protest seemed like a huge waste of time. If they really want higher pay and benefits then bring in a union and call for a vote, if McDonalds interferes then raise a stink. They're wasting their time expecting the corporation to just give them something they want.

I think higher wages in general are good for all of us but how do we get there? I don't like the idea of minimum wage, it's just not something the government can mandate because there are too many variables between different areas, I think collective bargaining is a better way to get there.

Fairsheet bought up an important point, it's not just the wage that's an issue, it's the reason behind the low wage. We the people have allowed companies like McDonalds to use our money in order to establish a ceiling on wages. If I were in charge I'd keep track of the Employer IDs of every working American who needed to file for any kind of need based benefit or tax break and then when the numbers were in I'd bill the employers for every damn dime their employees claimed, plus a quarterly percentage.

Great. So if some clown decides to have three kids, work at McDonalds, and qualify for public assistance, that's McDonalds' fault and they should pay the price for their employees' bad judgment and decisions?
 
Don't you think it should?

Would you pay someone to work for you a wage they can not support themselves on?

Now I agree if the employee is not happy then yes they should attempt to find other employment but I also feel that employers have to be realistic and paying a decent wage that is fair and liveable would bring you better employees and less turn over...

Just my opinion and in your first post you make valid points also...

Why should minimum wage be a "livable" wage? And besides, isnt' "livable" different for a kid working after school and a moron deciding to have babies on minimum wage?
 
My question has always been what is a fair wage?

Let say Congress raised the minimum wage to $10.10 hr will that really help those in cities like Chicago, L.A., or New york where cost of living is so high that $10.10 hr would not lift them out of poverty!?!

As you stated the employee does have options but it seem to me the American public is getting lazier and just want Uncle Sam to give them what they want and not work for it...

So what is a fair wage?

Where I live in Texas $10 hr is liveable but in Chicago it is not...

Minimum wage should be left to the states just like medical insurance.
 
Back
Top