New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Conceptual question for conservatives.

Arkady

President
In your view, what would be the minimum threshold for impeachment for Trump, when it comes to the Russia contacts and subsequent investigation?

I think we're already well beyond the threshold that would have triggered impeachment support by conservatives if it was Hillary Clinton we were talking about. For example, picture if there was an FBI investigation implicating Huma Abedin and potentially Clinton herself, and Clinton had isolated the head of the FBI, pressured him to lay off Abedin, then fired him after he refused -- going so far to admit her reason for firing him was because he was looking into that matter. I think that would have thrown nearly every major Republican and all the conservatives here into the "impeach" camp.

Similarly, picture if, during the campaign, John Podesta, Bill Clinton, and Chelsea Clinton's husband had secretly met with agents of the Iranian regime, expressly for purposes of getting valuable information from the Iranian government about Donald Trump, to use against him in the campaign, and if multiple leading members of the Clinton team had lied to the FBI, and/or under oath to Congress, about their contacts with Iran. Again, I think that would have nearly all the conservatives calling for impeachment.

But, since those things aren't enough when it's a Republican, what would be? If we found out that Donald Trump, personally, met with Russian agents during the campaign for purposes of receiving information on Clinton he knew they had obtained through espionage, would that be enough? If Trump made a quid-pro-quo agreement, during the campaign, to implement certain policies once president, if Russia helped him in the election, or if Russia gave him some business favor or money for such policy promises, would that be enough? If there was clear coordination between the Trump campaign and Russian agents regarding campaign matters (e.g., Trump campaign officials advising the Russians about the kinds of information to hack and timing for leaking it through Wikileaks), would that do it for you? What if Trump lied under oath to Congress or federal investigators about his interactions with Russia during the campaign? If we found out that Russia, in fact, had dirt on Trump and Trump agreed to favor certain policies in exchange for keeping it quiet, would that be enough? If Trump fired Mueller or Rosenstein without good cause, would that be enough? If Trump was found to have committed financial crimes (e.g., failing to report money transfers that federal law required to be reported) in order to hide his Russia business dealings from officials), would that be enough?

I'm just trying to figure out where the line is for you, now, before we get there, because I have a feeling it will shift if we actually do get there.
 
There's legal precedent for this. Do some basic research and get back with an informed opinion. It seems you're just fishing on behalf of the retards at the DNC who pay your salary.
 
I'm a centrist, not a conservative (I voted for Rubio)

impeachment might follow any of the following lines:

  • some "emoluments" violation significantly more onerous than owning a hotel where paying guests happen to check in. George Washington sold crops grown from his estate, you know.
  • A Trump/Russian meeting where he provided national secrets.
  • Collection of Russian funds in exchange for future favors. Like Hillary did with the Clinton Foundation, for example
  • Clandestinely promising something to Putin after the election. Like Obama's promise to Medvedev in 2012 that he would reward them after the election. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wor...Ill-have-more-flexibility-after-election.html
  • Funding a dirty tricks/lies dossier against Hillary, like the DNC did with the Fusion materials
  • Trump evidence destruction, like Hillary did with her home brew server
  • Hacking into the DNC database to get an edge, like team Hillary illegally accessed the "sanders data" on the DNC server
is that enough for starters? I don't think you can impeach someone for inflammatory statements and writings (Lincoln would have gone down for sure); promising to secure our borders; promising to arrest and deport illegal alien lawbreakers; having an executive order overturned (Obama suffered this); etc etc.
 
Speaking for myself, I'll go with... Evidence...of any of your above.

Meanwhile, as a business man he was not prohibited from dealing with Russians. Nor as president elect, or an ordinary citizen, was he prohibited from speaking with them.

I say impeach away..upon concrete evidence
 
In your view, what would be the minimum threshold for impeachment for Trump, when it comes to the Russia contacts and subsequent investigation?

I think we're already well beyond the threshold that would have triggered impeachment support by conservatives if it was Hillary Clinton we were talking about. For example, picture if there was an FBI investigation implicating Huma Abedin and potentially Clinton herself, and Clinton had isolated the head of the FBI, pressured him to lay off Abedin, then fired him after he refused -- going so far to admit her reason for firing him was because he was looking into that matter. I think that would have thrown nearly every major Republican and all the conservatives here into the "impeach" camp.

Similarly, picture if, during the campaign, John Podesta, Bill Clinton, and Chelsea Clinton's husband had secretly met with agents of the Iranian regime, expressly for purposes of getting valuable information from the Iranian government about Donald Trump, to use against him in the campaign, and if multiple leading members of the Clinton team had lied to the FBI, and/or under oath to Congress, about their contacts with Iran. Again, I think that would have nearly all the conservatives calling for impeachment.

But, since those things aren't enough when it's a Republican, what would be? If we found out that Donald Trump, personally, met with Russian agents during the campaign for purposes of receiving information on Clinton he knew they had obtained through espionage, would that be enough? If Trump made a quid-pro-quo agreement, during the campaign, to implement certain policies once president, if Russia helped him in the election, or if Russia gave him some business favor or money for such policy promises, would that be enough? If there was clear coordination between the Trump campaign and Russian agents regarding campaign matters (e.g., Trump campaign officials advising the Russians about the kinds of information to hack and timing for leaking it through Wikileaks), would that do it for you? What if Trump lied under oath to Congress or federal investigators about his interactions with Russia during the campaign? If we found out that Russia, in fact, had dirt on Trump and Trump agreed to favor certain policies in exchange for keeping it quiet, would that be enough? If Trump fired Mueller or Rosenstein without good cause, would that be enough? If Trump was found to have committed financial crimes (e.g., failing to report money transfers that federal law required to be reported) in order to hide his Russia business dealings from officials), would that be enough?

I'm just trying to figure out where the line is for you, now, before we get there, because I have a feeling it will shift if we actually do get there.

I think that maybe verifiable evidence that Trump actually may have colluded with Russia may be a good start.
 
I think the questions asked of cons are very intrinsic to why the orange cheeto has not yet been impeached.
 
I'm a centrist, not a conservative (I voted for Rubio)

impeachment might follow any of the following lines:

  • some "emoluments" violation significantly more onerous than owning a hotel where paying guests happen to check in. George Washington sold crops grown from his estate, you know.
  • A Trump/Russian meeting where he provided national secrets.
  • Collection of Russian funds in exchange for future favors. Like Hillary did with the Clinton Foundation, for example
  • Clandestinely promising something to Putin after the election. Like Obama's promise to Medvedev in 2012 that he would reward them after the election. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wor...Ill-have-more-flexibility-after-election.html
  • Funding a dirty tricks/lies dossier against Hillary, like the DNC did with the Fusion materials
  • Trump evidence destruction, like Hillary did with her home brew server
  • Hacking into the DNC database to get an edge, like team Hillary illegally accessed the "sanders data" on the DNC server
is that enough for starters? I don't think you can impeach someone for inflammatory statements and writings (Lincoln would have gone down for sure); promising to secure our borders; promising to arrest and deport illegal alien lawbreakers; having an executive order overturned (Obama suffered this); etc etc.
Thanks for replying with details. I appreciate it. However, some comments:

What would you consider to be significantly worse than the emoluments violations already out there? For example, what if, rather than just continuing to own a hotel where foreign dignitaries stayed, he hiked the prices on the hotel well beyond the typical price hike in the area, and then actively encouraged foreign dignitaries to stay there, thus opening the door for above-market payments to serve as a way for those guests to bribe him? What about, say, signalling to China that he'd break his promise to name them a currency manipulator if they addressed unnamed other matters, then, after China broke its own law to hand Ivanka Trump a bunch of trademarks she'd long been denied in the country, he did, in fact, reverse himself on that promise -- thus trading an important diplomatic concession for IP worth millions to the Trump crime family? Would that do it?

As you know, there's no evidence that Clinton took any funds from the Russians at all, much less that there was any promise for future favors. Some Russians donated to a charity she'd set up, just as plenty of people from all over the world did, but since there was no channel for her to use any of those funds for personal enrichment, that wouldn't have been an avenue for a bribe. It wasn't at all like the Trump Foundation -- a phony charity under the exclusive control of the Trump family, which avoided independent audit and used funds for Trump family and business matters (e.g., bribing an investigator in Florida, buying sports memorabilia and art for Trump Organization properties, etc.) Instead, the Clinton Foundation had a majority of board members who weren't Clinton family members nor under Clinton financial control, and all the chief officers of the Clinton Foundation, who actually ran the Foundation, were independent from the Clinton family (which earned no money for their pro bono services to the charity). It was also independently audited by one of the big accounting firms. That's why no evidence of any self-dealing has ever emerged with regard to the Clinton Foundation (unlike the Trump Foundation). Now, that doesn't mean that some foreign country may not have wrongly thought it could pass money to the Clintons by way of the foundation. But we have no evidence the Clintons encouraged that false belief, much less that they actually misappropriated any of those funds for themselves.

In 2012, Obama was the president. To be clear if Trump now, as president, were to say something to Putin about future flexibility on some matter (e.g., telling the Russians that he may have more flexibility to remove adoption sanctions after November of this year), would you regard that as an impeachable offense? If so, you're harsher than me, because I'd consider that entirely appropriate behavior. I'm sure world leaders regularly communicate to their counterparts that internal political events impact the timeline for when they can deal with issues affecting the countries. If we treated that as impeachable, I assume very few heads of state would survive the purge. But, I suspect you don't really consider that impeachable. Rather, you just want to divert the discussion with an attack on Obama.

Similarly, if we found out that Trump paid to have an independent firm collect negative information about Clinton during the campaign, would you see that as impeachable? If so, then he definitely committed an impeachable offense, because that's standard operating procedure. Again, such a standard would result in the impeachment of just about every major politician. In fact, even if we just impeached the politicians who'd hired Fusion GPS to do similar work, that would end a lot of careers. I don't impose such a standard. I fully expect candidates to pay consultants to research their opponents in search of damaging material. I find it hilariously hypocritical that right-wingers are pretending somehow that universal behavior became a serious problem when Clinton engaged in it. To be fair, though, I don't think you actually believe there was anything wrong with it. I think you're just engaging in the usual right-wing practice of trying to derail a discussion of misbehavior by Trump by attacking the Clintons or Obama.

Regarding Clinton's server, she was legally entitled to destroy it after turning over her work emails. That's why even the partisan Republican hack who ran the FBI couldn't find anything to indict her over. So, to be clear, if we found out that Trump destroyed information that he was legally entitled to destroy (e.g., destroying a cell phone he used during the campaign, which hadn't been subpoenaed or otherwise blocked from destruction), would you want him impeached for that?

Regarding the DNC server, are you referring to the four Sanders campaign members who accessed Clinton voter lists on the DNC server, to give his campaign an inappropriate advantage?

https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/20...er-improperly-accessing-clinton-voter-n482341
 
I think that maybe verifiable evidence that Trump actually may have colluded with Russia may be a good start.
I'm not looking for mushy "a good start" rhetoric, but rather specifics about what would be beyond the line, for you. For example, if we had evidence that Trump, personally met with people he knew to be Russian agents and that during the meeting they coordinated in some way impacting the campaign (e.g., Trump advising about what kinds of things the Russians might say or information they might release that would help him get elected), would that be enough collusion?
 
In your view, what would be the minimum threshold for impeachment for Trump, when it comes to the Russia contacts and subsequent investigation?

I think we're already well beyond the threshold that would have triggered impeachment support by conservatives if it was Hillary Clinton we were talking about. For example, picture if there was an FBI investigation implicating Huma Abedin and potentially Clinton herself, and Clinton had isolated the head of the FBI, pressured him to lay off Abedin, then fired him after he refused -- going so far to admit her reason for firing him was because he was looking into that matter. I think that would have thrown nearly every major Republican and all the conservatives here into the "impeach" camp.

Similarly, picture if, during the campaign, John Podesta, Bill Clinton, and Chelsea Clinton's husband had secretly met with agents of the Iranian regime, expressly for purposes of getting valuable information from the Iranian government about Donald Trump, to use against him in the campaign, and if multiple leading members of the Clinton team had lied to the FBI, and/or under oath to Congress, about their contacts with Iran. Again, I think that would have nearly all the conservatives calling for impeachment.

But, since those things aren't enough when it's a Republican, what would be? If we found out that Donald Trump, personally, met with Russian agents during the campaign for purposes of receiving information on Clinton he knew they had obtained through espionage, would that be enough? If Trump made a quid-pro-quo agreement, during the campaign, to implement certain policies once president, if Russia helped him in the election, or if Russia gave him some business favor or money for such policy promises, would that be enough? If there was clear coordination between the Trump campaign and Russian agents regarding campaign matters (e.g., Trump campaign officials advising the Russians about the kinds of information to hack and timing for leaking it through Wikileaks), would that do it for you? What if Trump lied under oath to Congress or federal investigators about his interactions with Russia during the campaign? If we found out that Russia, in fact, had dirt on Trump and Trump agreed to favor certain policies in exchange for keeping it quiet, would that be enough? If Trump fired Mueller or Rosenstein without good cause, would that be enough? If Trump was found to have committed financial crimes (e.g., failing to report money transfers that federal law required to be reported) in order to hide his Russia business dealings from officials), would that be enough?

I'm just trying to figure out where the line is for you, now, before we get there, because I have a feeling it will shift if we actually do get there.

Firstly, Trump ran in part on trying to become friends with Russia and 10's of millions of Americans voted for that.

Lastly, Clinton has committed crimes - colluding with Russians writing fake dossiers, selling U.S. Uranium mining interests to Russians, using her position as Sec. of State to extort millions of dollars around the world. When are YOU socialist Democrats going to demand that she be locked up? What is it going to take for YOU to chant, "Lock her up?"
 
Last edited:
Firstly, Trump ran on trying to become friends with Russia and 10's of millions of Americans voted for that.

Lastly, Clinton has committed crimes colluding with Russians writing fake dossiers, buying U.S. Uranium mining interests, using her position as Sec. of State to extort millions of dollars around the world. When are YOU socialist Democrats going to demand that she be locked up? What is it going to take for YOU to chant, "Lock her up?"
Where would you draw the line, in terms of the minimum behaviors we'd need to be able to prove for you to support impeaching Trump?
 
That would be "high crimes and misdemeanors." Could you provide specific examples of the minimum behaviors you'd consider to meet that standard?

One would be summarily executing American citizens without due process. Know anyone who's done that?
 
In your view, what would be the minimum threshold for impeachment for Trump, when it comes to the Russia contacts and subsequent investigation?

I think we're already well beyond the threshold that would have triggered impeachment support by conservatives if it was Hillary Clinton we were talking about. For example, picture if there was an FBI investigation implicating Huma Abedin and potentially Clinton herself, and Clinton had isolated the head of the FBI, pressured him to lay off Abedin, then fired him after he refused -- going so far to admit her reason for firing him was because he was looking into that matter. I think that would have thrown nearly every major Republican and all the conservatives here into the "impeach" camp.

Similarly, picture if, during the campaign, John Podesta, Bill Clinton, and Chelsea Clinton's husband had secretly met with agents of the Iranian regime, expressly for purposes of getting valuable information from the Iranian government about Donald Trump, to use against him in the campaign, and if multiple leading members of the Clinton team had lied to the FBI, and/or under oath to Congress, about their contacts with Iran. Again, I think that would have nearly all the conservatives calling for impeachment.

But, since those things aren't enough when it's a Republican, what would be? If we found out that Donald Trump, personally, met with Russian agents during the campaign for purposes of receiving information on Clinton he knew they had obtained through espionage, would that be enough? If Trump made a quid-pro-quo agreement, during the campaign, to implement certain policies once president, if Russia helped him in the election, or if Russia gave him some business favor or money for such policy promises, would that be enough? If there was clear coordination between the Trump campaign and Russian agents regarding campaign matters (e.g., Trump campaign officials advising the Russians about the kinds of information to hack and timing for leaking it through Wikileaks), would that do it for you? What if Trump lied under oath to Congress or federal investigators about his interactions with Russia during the campaign? If we found out that Russia, in fact, had dirt on Trump and Trump agreed to favor certain policies in exchange for keeping it quiet, would that be enough? If Trump fired Mueller or Rosenstein without good cause, would that be enough? If Trump was found to have committed financial crimes (e.g., failing to report money transfers that federal law required to be reported) in order to hide his Russia business dealings from officials), would that be enough?

I'm just trying to figure out where the line is for you, now, before we get there, because I have a feeling it will shift if we actually do get there.


Your first paragraphs are pure projection, you have no idea what Conservatives would say. Just as if I were to hold that if all the things you project did happen, Liberals would STILL support Clinton. Purely speculative.

As to your question, there has to be PROOF that Trump colluded with Russian actors to somehow rig the election. Not that he or anyone on his staff talked to them. Not that he finds Putin admirable. Not that he is accused of having Russian hookers piss on him or that he grabbed anyone 'by the pussy'. No 'sources say...', not 'fake dossier', no bullshit.

Proof , irrefutable proof, that he colluded.

If that comes to light, I'll help you and all the other liberals hang him out to dry.
 
I think the questions asked of cons are very intrinsic to why the orange cheeto has not yet been impeached.

So Impeach
as I impeached your claim of being a gas boy when gas was 18 cent a gallon and there never was 18 cent gas in Oregon and you'd have to be close to 90 or older when it was 17 cent...............

Enjoy impeaching those that want to impeach LIES
 
That would be "high crimes and misdemeanors." Could you provide specific examples of the minimum behaviors you'd consider to meet that standard?

illegal server
signing off on selling uranium for $$$$$$$$$
bleaching emails
$87,000,000 in election donations fraud

wait........ya gal Lost

26168953_10156100587954445_6040229936335707805_n.jpg
hurry to the gym :)
 
Back
Top