New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

conservative cruelty

JuliefromOhio

President
Supporting Member
TN legislators are considering a bill that calls for a 30% reduction in Temporary Assistance for Needy Families benefits to parents whose children are not making satisfactory progress in school.

Tennessee already ties welfare to education by mandating a 20% cut in benefits if students do not meet attendance standards.

Tennessee’s welfare program is hardly robust — the maximum benefit is $185 a month and hasn’t changed since 1996.


http://thinkprogress.org/economy/20...n-that-would-tie-welfare-to-childrens-grades/

http://www.tanfprogram.com/tennessee-tanf-eligibility
 
185 lousy godamned dollars, and they STILL think it's appropriate to put the family burden on the children. These people are pathetic.
 
repub legislatures have spent much time looking for ways to beat up on the poor. drug testing welfare applicants is their latest....even though FL tried it, found out welfare applicants use of drugs was way lower than the population at large, they lost $$ and the Court stayed this scheme. however, that's not stopping other states from implementing the same nonsense. to be fair, they should drug test those given corporate welfare.

compassionate conservatism --> cruel conservatism
 
TN legislators are considering a bill that calls for a 30% reduction in Temporary Assistance for Needy Families benefits to parents whose children are not making satisfactory progress in school.

Malnutrition does not contribute to "satisfactory progress in school"...
 
so to sum up -

you're indifferent to parents (and kids) about school attendance, and believe that welfare and other benefits should come with no strings attached?

i think we've identified part of the problem with "progressive" visions for america, if that's true.
 
TN legislators are considering a bill that calls for a 30% reduction in Temporary Assistance for Needy Families benefits to parents whose children are not making satisfactory progress in school.

Tennessee already ties welfare to education by mandating a 20% cut in benefits if students do not meet attendance standards.

Tennessee’s welfare program is hardly robust — the maximum benefit is $185 a month and hasn’t changed since 1996.


http://thinkprogress.org/economy/20...n-that-would-tie-welfare-to-childrens-grades/

http://www.tanfprogram.com/tennessee-tanf-eligibility

How sad. You're just punishing struggling kids and making them struggle worse. It would be better to mandate special weekend, evening, and summer classes for children not making satisfactory progress... but that would cost extra money, so you're unlikely to see it in conservative states.
 
How sad. You're just punishing struggling kids and making them struggle worse. It would be better to mandate special weekend, evening, and summer classes for children not making satisfactory progress... but that would cost extra money, so you're unlikely to see it in conservative states.

They also should provide free breakfast and lunch for the needy kids. How can they study when they are hungry? And I'd guess part of the time they do not attend is because they are physically sick. A malnourished kid will catch anything going around. Damn, people are so disgustingly cruel.
 
so to sum up -

you're indifferent to parents (and kids) about school attendance, and believe that welfare and other benefits should come with no strings attached?

i think we've identified part of the problem with "progressive" visions for america, if that's true.

If your goal is to punish parents who don't emphasize academics, then there are ways to do that which don't cause malnutrition or other problems for children, making it even harder for them to catch up. For example, how about mandating some sort of community service for the parents? A parent who finds himself having to spend 10 hours per week cleaning up garbage along the side of roads because his kid keeps skipping classes is going to pay more attention to that in the future. You could also do things like making that part of the TANF refundable to the state after the last child turns 21. That way you're not cutting into money that's needed to support innocent kids... you're just pulling money away from the parents, years later, when the kid is no longer relying on them. A parent who understands that his neglect of his child's academics will potentially mean the government will be taking a bite out of his paycheck for many years after the kid has left home, will have a motivation to get the kid back on track.
 
They also should provide free breakfast and lunch for the needy kids. How can they study when they are hungry? And I'd guess part of the time they do not attend is because they are physically sick. A malnourished kid will catch anything going around. Damn, people are so disgustingly cruel.

Yes. I wouldn't be surprised if a significant factor in our national economic under-performance is our lousy healthcare system. In every other wealthy nation, there's universal, high-quality, affordable care for everybody.
 
so to sum up -

you're indifferent to parents (and kids) about school attendance, and believe that welfare and other benefits should come with no strings attached?

i think we've identified part of the problem with "progressive" visions for america, if that's true.

No, ASOT...to "sum up"..."You kids better get good grades or our family is going to starve."
 
If your goal is to punish parents who don't emphasize academics, then there are ways to do that which don't cause malnutrition or other problems for children, making it even harder for them to catch up. For example, how about mandating some sort of community service for the parents? A parent who finds himself having to spend 10 hours per week cleaning up garbage along the side of roads because his kid keeps skipping classes is going to pay more attention to that in the future. You could also do things like making that part of the TANF refundable to the state after the last child turns 21. That way you're not cutting into money that's needed to support innocent kids... you're just pulling money away from the parents, years later, when the kid is no longer relying on them. A parent who understands that his neglect of his child's academics will potentially mean the government will be taking a bite out of his paycheck for many years after the kid has left home, will have a motivation to get the kid back on track.

Excellent ideas. They will NEVER be considered in Tennessee.
 
hey, lib friends, you're edging close to the punitive approach that our "cruel conservatives" want.

could you imagine a non-TANF family putting up with that kind of govt intrusion?

what about their FREEDOMS???...... cons usually screech.

how about "adopt a TANF family" to be helpful. bossy conservatives could do that and practice their empathy. no situation is so simple that some rule to take $$ away from dirt poor families will remedy what are probably complicated circumstances.
 
Back
Top