New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Critiqueing the moderator.

Arkady

President
I don't want to be too hard on Martha Raddatz, the moderator for the Biden/Ryan debate. Moderating that kind of debate seems like an extraordinarily tough job, and nobody's going to get through it without some mistakes. But I did want to vent about one mistake that annoyed the hell out of me at the time.

It was near the end of the debate, and Ryan had just rattled off what seemed like a fairly long answer about how his personal honesty was something he could give the country that no one else could. Then it was Biden's turn to answer the same question, and Raddatz announced she'd be keeping him to 15 seconds. Biden, taken aback said "well, he gets 40, I get 15, but that's OK. That's all right." Raddatz responded, "He didn't have 40. He didn't have 40." Listening at the time, that seemed strange to me, since my internal clock put it at a little under a minute, but maybe the fingernails-on-a-chalkboard effect of "Lyin' Ryan" bragging about his honesty made the time seem to pass more slowly. But, today, I wanted to check my subjective experience, using the Youtube recording of the full debate.

Check it out yourself:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3roG09O6T4

Ryan starts talking in response at 1:25:51 and he stops at 1:26:31. That is PRECISELY 40 seconds. At this point, I suspect Biden is a cyborg, because his internal clock appears accurate to the nearest second. For Raddatz to warn Biden that she was going to hold him to 15 seconds for the question his opponent got 40 seconds to answer was wrong, for her to then insist Biden's claim was false when it was EXACTLY true was even worse. To her credit, she didn't cut Biden off after 15 seconds, notwithstanding her pronouncement.
 
My critique:....Her question around their Catholicism and then linking it to abortion, was untoward. Neither man should've been put on the spot as to his religion and this certainly wasn't the appropriate forum for them to be expected to square the abortion question with their religion.
 
there was an issue on foreign policy where Radditz made a claim that Biden said was incorrect and she started to debate him herself.

if I have the time, I'll pull that exchange from the transcript.
 
there was an issue on foreign policy where Radditz made a claim that Biden said was incorrect and she started to debate him herself.

if I have the time, I'll pull that exchange from the transcript.
Mine was at the first when Raddatz became a Reporter questioning about the death of Stevens.She came across as a Reporter wanting answers whether the Adminstration could give them or not. She took the part of the antaganist,instead of the Moderator. Much like they do in the Press Room,anything for a scoop.
 
Yes, I actually think she was a rather poor moderator, for the reason you give, and for the reasons other posters have given in this thread, and for the reason that she was allowing both Ryan and Biden to interrupt each other all too frequently. At one point during the debate, both Ryan and Biden were talking at the same time, that went on for at least half a minute, and I couldn't understand either one. I got so disgusted that I momentarily switched to the Steelers vs Titans NFL game.

Now, this may just be a problem with me because, as an old man, I am gradually losing my hearing, and I find it very difficult if not impossible, to track two conversations simultaneously---something young people can do much better. But I found it very annoying.
 
I don't want to criticize her too much either. It's a tough job. But those who were actually holding the clock to the debate show that she interrupted and challenged Ryan more than she did Biden. And at one point she said "Can you 'guarantee' your plan will work?" That is NOT a debate question. It appeared to the objective watchers that there were two people on one side debating Ryan on the other.
 
In defense of Raddatz though....Ryan obviously diverted from the question at hand, more so than Biden did. I can see how a Ryan-partisan might feel that she was picking on him more. But, he was in need of a little more "redirection" than Biden was.

Anyway.....as we learned from we bluester's harsh critique of Leherer in the first presidential debate, the "losing side" tends to have a little harder time with the moderator, than does the winning one.
 
In defense of Raddatz though....Ryan obviously diverted from the question at hand, more so than Biden did. I can see how a Ryan-partisan might feel that she was picking on him more. But, he was in need of a little more "redirection" than Biden was.

yes, because he was the "younger person." :)
 
Yes, I actually think she was a rather poor moderator, for the reason you give, and for the reasons other posters have given in this thread, and for the reason that she was allowing both Ryan and Biden to interrupt each other all too frequently. At one point during the debate, both Ryan and Biden were talking at the same time, that went on for at least half a minute, and I couldn't understand either one. I got so disgusted that I momentarily switched to the Steelers vs Titans NFL game.

Now, this may just be a problem with me because, as an old man, I am gradually losing my hearing, and I find it very difficult if not impossible, to track two conversations simultaneously---something young people can do much better. But I found it very annoying.

Turn your closed captaining on:eek:) You will not miss a word. People have a tendency to mumble,but you can catch it all. You can even turn the sound off. I have used it to write the words of a song for people.
 
I hate to be too negative when it comes to the job she did but I'll tell you at the beginning I was aghast to think she would start the debate with that question. I immediately thought she did it to put Biden in a bad light to start with because there are still so many questions hanging over all that happened. Biden also had to go first so I was right and ready to call her off. Then she asked Ryan did he think it was correct for Romney to be asking Obama to offer an apology so at that point I thought she might be fair after all.

I didn't have a time clock but it certainly seemed that Ryan had more time and if Biden was going to get a word in, he had to jump in when he could. I know CNN had some mumbo jumbo right after the debate showing each of their times to be about even. I don't believe it though.

It's over and I think he did the better of the two and I am not just saying that because he is our VP and a Democrat, he came across passionate about what he believes in and related to the middle class like the other two never could. I told it like it was when Obama didn't stand up to Romney and I call it as I see it. Many of us Democrats did and that you would never get from some people on here if their man had a bad day or made of fool of himself on foreign trips. Well on a good day maybe one.
 
I hate to be too negative when it comes to the job she did but I'll tell you at the beginning I was aghast to think she would start the debate with that question. I immediately thought she did it to put Biden in a bad light to start with because there are still so many questions hanging over all that happened. Biden also had to go first so I was right and ready to call her off. Then she asked Ryan did he think it was correct for Romney to be asking Obama to offer an apology so at that point I thought she might be fair after all.

I didn't have a time clock but it certainly seemed that Ryan had more time and if Biden was going to get a word in, he had to jump in when he could. I know CNN had some mumbo jumbo right after the debate showing each of their times to be about even. I don't believe it though.

It's over and I think he did the better of the two and I am not just saying that because he is our VP and a Democrat, he came across passionate about what he believes in and related to the middle class like the other two never could. I told it like it was when Obama didn't stand up to Romney and I call it as I see it. Many of us Democrats did and that you would never get from some people on here if their man had a bad day or made of fool of himself on foreign trips. Well on a good day maybe one.

The only expertise Raddatz has is in Foreign affairs,but when she came out aggressive with a question like a Reporter who simply wants a sound bite, she was wrong to lead off with a situation that is really sad and should not be used for Political gain.

That is all Republicans have now because Obama owns the Foreign situation with his promised to get Bin Laden,something he told them to concentrate on his first day in office.That was accomplished,we are out of one war,on the way out of another.

This is another subject entirely but the news has come out how Religion is dropping like a stone.My opinion is,based on my own experience,as many of you know is the extreme right wing evangelicals are driving people away. I know that is my case and I am hearing more each day.A Church is supposed to teach people about faith,not shove their right wing kookery on others. Separation of Church and State is what I believe and so did the founders of this Country. Churches are destroying themselves within.
 
The only expertise Raddatz has is in Foreign affairs,but when she came out aggressive with a question like a Reporter who simply wants a sound bite, she was wrong to lead off with a situation that is really sad and should not be used for Political gain.

I would not have minded it so much if it was later into the debate, it did have to do with foreigh affairs. As I watch this unfold, it could have very well have been to put Biden at a distinct disadvantage at the beginning as I said before, and even more so put Obama in a disadvantage in the debate Tuesday. The question to Ryan about how right it was for Romney to ask for an apology could certainly have just been to soften the way she started out.

I tried to give her the benefit of the doubt at times but I don't any longer. It was a game plan that should not come from a moderator, it should come from one of the debaters. imo
 
I dont want to be hard on Raddatz...sounds like some one got their ass whooped in another debate.......

Lets put it this way:

If your going to interject and laugh your way through a debate with a grimace on your face...and then have to listen what people think...people who are not stuck in the matrix like hard core lefty...that refuse to believe that their is another world out their ...the real world...where uneployment, the debt, foreign policy is not a joke and your going to think that an extra thrity seconds was going to make a difference, you, your party, and leaders..all 237 of you, really need to get some serious help.
 
The only expertise Raddatz has is in Foreign affairs,but when she came out aggressive with a question like a Reporter who simply wants a sound bite, she was wrong to lead off with a situation that is really sad and should not be used for Political gain.


And you expect to win by dodging the real questions...keep up the good work and to Joe Biden...We say thank you.
 
My critique:....Her question around their Catholicism and then linking it to abortion, was untoward. Neither man should've been put on the spot as to his religion and this certainly wasn't the appropriate forum for them to be expected to square the abortion question with their religion.

Yes, that was a terrible question. A debate should be about policies, not about each man's religious convictions. I don't care how they square their views on abortion with their religion, I just care what their policies would be.

Even if this were an appropriate line of questioning, it would be rendered inappropriate by the way it was done in isolation. Each man takes positions that go directly against his supposed faith. But the only one forced to defend that was Biden, because of the subject asked about. Why not ask about Ryan's support of the death penalty, which is every bit as much at odds with the teachings of the Roman Catholic Church? Or his support for wars that do not satisfy the church's "just war" test? Or his rejection of the church's teachings about wealth? For some reason, Democrats are the only ones who the establishment press ever dares demand reconcile their personal beliefs with their religious doctrines.
 
I don't want to criticize her too much either. It's a tough job. But those who were actually holding the clock to the debate show that she interrupted and challenged Ryan more than she did Biden. And at one point she said "Can you 'guarantee' your plan will work?" That is NOT a debate question. It appeared to the objective watchers that there were two people on one side debating Ryan on the other.

It did not appear that way to me, and I'm an objective watcher.
 
In defense of Raddatz though....Ryan obviously diverted from the question at hand, more so than Biden did. I can see how a Ryan-partisan might feel that she was picking on him more. But, he was in need of a little more "redirection" than Biden was.

Anyway.....as we learned from we bluester's harsh critique of Leherer in the first presidential debate, the "losing side" tends to have a little harder time with the moderator, than does the winning one.

Yes. It's a standard debate trick to take a question and basically answer some other tangentially related question that you wished you'd been asked. Both candidates did that a lot, but Ryan was a lot more aggressive about it. It was mostly "well, let me answer that by telling you how Obama has failed to fix any problems since he took office." That forced the moderator either to interrupt and redirect him more often, or to let him make her questions irrelevant.

I'd also argue that Raddatz's questions, generally, favored the Republicans. She mostly let the debate dwell on the Middle East, tax cuts, and the deficit. There are lots of questions that can make Republicans squirm, but you generally won't find them in those major areas. How about climate change? Gay marriage? Immigration? Job creation (not allowing that to be diverted into a discussion of tax cutting)? Supreme Court nominees? Education?
 
In defense of Raddatz though....Ryan obviously diverted from the question at hand, more so than Biden did. I can see how a Ryan-partisan might feel that she was picking on him more. But, he was in need of a little more "redirection" than Biden was.

Anyway.....as we learned from we bluester's harsh critique of Leherer in the first presidential debate, the "losing side" tends to have a little harder time with the moderator, than does the winning one.

Also, I'd love to see moderators resist the urge to get too "newsy" in their questioning. I can see why it would be tempting to ask a ripped-from-the-headlines question (like something about the security failure in Libya), but we're picking a leader for the next four years, and within a year or two nobody but political junkies and immediate family members is going to remember a trivial-in-the-big-picture event like that, so it's silly to let it play an inordinately large role in a debate, merely because it happened to occur in the prior week or two.

With an hour or two to work with, there just isn't time to be hashing out a bunch of half-baked theories and unresolved rumors about some recent event like that. Focus on the major policy matters: big government programs, climate change, major demographic, social, and economic trends, etc. Maybe a decent rule of thumb would be "if this question would have made no sense a year ago, and will seem pointlessly trivial a year from now, it's probably not enduring enough a concern to demand some of the country's limited attention during this debate."
 
I dont want to be hard on Raddatz...sounds like some one got their ass whooped in another debate.......

Lets put it this way:

If your going to interject and laugh your way through a debate with a grimace on your face...and then have to listen what people think...people who are not stuck in the matrix like hard core lefty...that refuse to believe that their is another world out their ...the real world...where uneployment, the debt, foreign policy is not a joke and your going to think that an extra thrity seconds was going to make a difference, you, your party, and leaders..all 237 of you, really need to get some serious help.

I'm afraid if you want a response you'll need to work harder to make a point.
 
Back
Top