New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Debate bar set high. Medocrity.

Nothing surprising....but Phil? I think Romney will actually do WELL in the Debate...erase some of the President's lead.
 
I am looking for sound bites and zingers from both of them. Yep, mediocrity. Neither of them are great debaters.
 
I tend to agree with a writer from a now forgotten website, sorry.
But his take was -- the debates could hardly be called debates. He seemed to think it would be more like two guys being interviewed for the same job.... discussing their resumes..

Let's hope they have more than this debate description to offer the undecideds on the big night...
 
you mean the lead created by skewing the polling data?

badum cha...

Oh, sorry...let me re-phrase "Mitt will do well...and in REAL polls move from being 5 points ahead of Obama to 10 to 15 points ahead of Obama!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

(is that enough exclamation marks? :) )
 
no. I would have preferrd one, maybe two more exclamation points.


Let's hope, then he can dispense with the voter id nonsense...

bading cha cha... here all week folks!
 
Phil,

I think that a lot really depends on the moderator and the format. I think that these three links provide a pretty good idea of how Lehrer might initiate and referee the interaction:

Jim Lehrer Announces First Presidential Debate Topics

The Most Trusted Moderator in America

10 Debate Questions for President Obama and Mitt Romney

Obviously, the Romney and Obama teams have game plans. They have their ground games and air attacks and trick plays. They want to score points.

And remember, one person's talking point is another person's substantive answer. One person's zinger is another person's dirty play.

With both the incumbent and challengernow poised for 'just OK'...do we have something to look forward to..or will we just have to settle for some nice soundbites and zingers and call it a day?


http://news.yahoo.com/blogs/ticket/obama-romney-good-debater-m-just-ok-020801760--election.html


http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politic...n-sets-debate-expectations-low-against-obama/
 
Good choice for moderator!! :cool:

From your link:
“Jim’s reputation is unassailable. He reeks integrity,” Tom Brokaw, the veteran “NBC Nightly News” anchor, told POLITICO. “He knows that his role there is to make this about the two canidates, not about him.”

“Jim is the best person for the job, the straightest guy in this profession, and absolutely trustworthy,” said Robert MacNeil, Lehrer’s longtime co-host on the “MacNeil/Lehrer Report.” “His idea of fairness is fiercer than anyone’s — he has an almost religious respect for being fair. He stays so far out of the political swamps that he doesn’t even vote.”
 
The Right will call Lehrer a "Communist sympathizer".....they consider a "un-biased moderator" to be Sean Hannity when he does his "Great American Panel".

:)
 
Lehrer is a good guy. But wouldn't it be so much more fun if the moderators were say Olberman and Coulter... or Hannity and Maddow..

yaargh...
 
Hannity would collapse like a wet paper bag.

What does that have to do with the cache of bring such stalwarts of journalism into the mix?
 
Hannity would collapse like a wet paper bag.

What does that have to do with the cache of bring such stalwarts of journalism into the mix?


I'm willing to admit that Hannity and Maddow are both partisans, but that's where the similarities end. Maddow is an honest intellectual and Hannity is the exact opposite.
 
I heard a clip of Rushbo last night in which he called all the moderators (Lehrer, Raditz, Crowley, and Scheiffer) "far, far left-Wing socialists." But he might as well have called them "Communist sympathizers."


The Right will call Lehrer a "Communist sympathizer".....they consider a "un-biased moderator" to be Sean Hannity when he does his "Great American Panel".

:)
 
Well if all Romney is willing to commit to is "just OK"... then he's toast.

See he actually HAS TO WIN IN A BIG WAY...
  • He knows it
  • The public knows it
  • The chattering classes know it


Obama can get away with downplaying the debates. Romney cannot... Particularly after Romney has ALREADY TOLDUS that hes spent the better part of a month prepping for this.
 
What this tells me is that the Conservatives have already written Romney off. They are already setting up for a narrative that the "left wing media" has killed their candidates, and that he basically was too much of a compromiser anyway.

Of course if Romney DOES hit it out of the park, they can claim that Romney "Showed Them"... so there's a nice safe bailout from the narrative. But what it says is that conservatives consider Romney toast at this point.
 
With both the incumbent and challengernow poised for 'just OK'...do we have something to look forward to..or will we just have to settle for some nice soundbites and zingers and call it a day?


http://news.yahoo.com/blogs/ticket/obama-romney-good-debater-m-just-ok-020801760--election.html

I'd be quite surprised if there's any actual debate. These "debates" tend to have rules that transform them into nothing but a sort of tandem press conference -- canned questions from moderators that touch on the standard beltway concerns, no direct questioning of candidates by their opponents, no real opportunity for follow-ups, etc.
 
No the rules here are quite open. 2 min opening of question with a statement by each, and then 15 minutes of moderated discussion.
 
Back
Top