New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Discrimination against atheists.

Arkady

President
Good article here on discrimination against atheists:

http://www.salon.com/2012/08/09/4_reasons_atheists_have_to_fight_for_their_rights_salpart/

I actually think the article doesn't go far enough, since it focuses on the ways that atheists suffer de facto discrimination, rather than legal discrimination. It focuses mostly on cases where communities or even courts ignore laws or precedents in order to discriminate against atheists, where the atheists would be protected by a proper application of the law. That is, admittedly, the more severe and common variety of discrimination. But there is also legal discrimination remaining in this country. Most of it isn't particularly harmful, but it's still there.

Take the "In God We Trust" printed on our coins. As an atheist, I'm not harmed by that in any serious way. But it isn't hard to see how it enshrines a form of state theism that would be eagerly struck down by courts if it were so openly hostile to the beliefs of more politically valued groups. Picture, for example, that it said "In Jesus We Trust." That would cut out some additional groups, including Muslims but, most important politically, Jews. And so it wouldn't fly. But saying that we trust in God isn't qualitatively different from saying we trust in Jesus. In each case it's a state-sponsored statement of religious faith, with the only difference being what portions of the population would agree with it.

"In God We Trust" leaves out people the same way "In Jesus We Trust" does -- just different people. There's no intellectually consistent way to claim it's OK for the state to take a theological stance that's abhorrent to atheists but not a theological stance that's abhorrent to Jews, unless you basically admit that Jews are more worthy of respect than atheists. And that's legal discrimination. The same is true for "one nation, under God" (as opposed to "one nation, under Jesus"), and the "non-denominational prayers" used in many public settings.
 
Lissen, buster, Amercans sposed to be good God-fearin' Christains! Sez so, write their in the Constution!! We's dont want no athiests in this countrey, and no Muslems or Budists or Hindi or Zorrostrians or pagins, niether! Dont want no agnustics or Wickans or Judaistic kinda folks, niether! And people oughtta speak English, dammit!

If English was good enough fer Jesus Christ, it oughtter be good enough fer everywon!!
 
Lissen, buster, Amercans sposed to be good God-fearin' Christains! Sez so, write their in the Constution!! We's dont want no athiests in this countrey, and no Muslems or Budists or Hindi or Zorrostrians or pagins, niether! Dont want no agnustics or Wickans or Judaistic kinda folks, niether! And people oughtta speak English, dammit!

If English was good enough fer Jesus Christ, it oughtter be good enough fer everywon!!
You forgot to mention those Sikhs.
 
In God we trust... One nation under God... "divine providence"... Yes, this nation is not a theocracy, but it is founded upon worshipping God. That doesn't mean you're not free to deny God, but you have to accept this country basically is a God-fearing land. You can worship the flying spaghetti monster if you want, or you can believe in nothing at all. That's what great about this country.
 
In God we trust... One nation under God... "divine providence"... Yes, this nation is not a theocracy, but it is founded upon worshipping God. That doesn't mean you're not free to deny God, but you have to accept this country basically is a God-fearing land. You can worship the flying spaghetti monster if you want, or you can believe in nothing at all. That's what great about this country.

James Madison, Father of the Constitution: During almost fifteen centuries has the legal establishment of Christianity been on trial. What have been its fruits? More or less in all places, pride and indolence in the Clergy, ignorance and servility in the laity, in both, superstition, bigotry and persecution.
 
Lissen, buster, Amercans sposed to be good God-fearin' Christains! Sez so, write their in the Constution!! We's dont want no athiests in this countrey, and no Muslems or Budists or Hindi or Zorrostrians or pagins, niether! Dont want no agnustics or Wickans or Judaistic kinda folks, niether! And people oughtta speak English, dammit!

If English was good enough fer Jesus Christ, it oughtter be good enough fer everywon!!

Amen, brother Leroy! It's time these heatherns unnerstand that this nation was founded by Christians and we ain't gonna let no atheists tell us that our schools can't teach our children how to pray to Jesus. Them thar Muslems, Hinddoos and Pisscopalians can just go to hell!
 
James Madison, Father of the Constitution: During almost fifteen centuries has the legal establishment of Christianity been on trial. What have been its fruits? More or less in all places, pride and indolence in the Clergy, ignorance and servility in the laity, in both, superstition, bigotry and persecution.

Leroy, things haven't changed much since Madison said that.
 
Back
Top