New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Documented Failure, Denial

Zam-Zam

Senator
Via Forbes:



Last Friday’s report by the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) on its first estimate of 1Q2012 GDP growth produced considerable weeping, wailing, and gnashing of teeth, especially among supporters of President Obama. The BEA reported that real GDP grew at a 2.2% annual rate. This was lower than the 3.0% rate growth rate reported for 4Q2011, and much lower than would be “normal” for this point in a recovery from a severe recession.

Much has been written about the BEA report. Most pundits found it discouraging, even alarming. The term “stall speed” appeared frequently. Some analysts were encouraged by the fact that consumer spending increased over 4Q2011. Others lamented that a reduction in government spending subtracted 0.6 percentage points from 1Q2012 GDP, and called for more “stimulus” spending. However, the analysts seem to have missed the big story in the BEA numbers.

Real business nonresidential fixed investment (RBNRFI) was lower in 1Q2012 than it was in 4Q2011, falling at a 2.1% annual rate, quarter to quarter. This continued a decelerating trend. After growing at 15.7% during 3Q2011, RBNRFI slowed to a 5.2% growth rate in 4Q2011 and then fell at a 2.1% rate last quarter.

Why does this matter? It matters because RBNRFI is what actually drives the economy. Both real GDP (RGDP) and employment growth are a direct function of RBNRFI. The notion that “spending” drives the economy is the Keynesian Superstition.

Plans based upon superstition tend not to work very well. Obama’s $831 billion “stimulus” program of early 2009 failed utterly, as did Bush 43’s $152 billion stimulus program a year earlier. The economists in the grip of the Keynesian Superstition (e.g., Paul Krugman) were left sputtering that the stimulus “just wasn’t big enough”.

Because stimulus works in exactly the same way as trying to raise the level of a swimming pool by drawing a bucket of water out of the deep end and pouring it into the shallow end, no stimulus can ever be big enough. In retrospect, it’s unfortunate that Obama didn’t push through a $2 trillion stimulus. It would have been worth wasting another $1.2 trillion to finally bury this deadly superstition.




Complete text: http://www.forbes.com/sites/louiswo...ction-prospects-suffer-an-ominous-gdp-report/
 
Via Forbes:



Last Friday’s report by the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) on its first estimate of 1Q2012 GDP growth produced considerable weeping, wailing, and gnashing of teeth, especially among supporters of President Obama.


Well it is bad politically for Obama.

But from an econometric and historic perspective, its another nail in the coffin of conserviatve "supply side" and "deregulatory" economics. The reality is that because of the "Just Say No" House and 2 years of a Filibuster Veto GOP Senate, we are currently running on the Fiscal Policies of the GOP Congress/WH circa 2003.

And they are doing now what they did from 2002-2007: generating sub-par growth.
 
[/I]Well it is bad politically for Obama.

But from an econometric and historic perspective, its another nail in the coffin of conserviatve "supply side" and "deregulatory" economics. The reality is that because of the "Just Say No" House and 2 years of a Filibuster Veto GOP Senate, we are currently running on the Fiscal Policies of the GOP Congress/WH circa 2003.

And they are doing now what they did from 2002-2007: generating sub-par growth.




This is where the denial part comes in.

Step 1) We need a stimulus. That will fix the economy.

Step 2) The stimulus fails to fix anything.

Step 3) We need another stimulus, only bigger.

Repeat until you run out of other people's money.



Not unlike the addicted gamble who knows he/she will "hit it big next time, it's a sure thing", until all the money's gone.
 
This is where the denial part comes in.

Step 1) We need a stimulus. That will fix the economy.

Hmm so what has worked consistently for 120+ years is somehow "denial" and what did not work well for the previous 200 years as well as failed in 1937, 1986 and 2003 is something that is not "denial"???? please

Step 2) The stimulus fails to fix anything.
When? The initial American Recovery Act committed to creating between 2.5 and 3.5 million jobs. CBO scores it at 3 million, others score it as high as 4 million.... how is that "failing to fix anything"?

Furthermore when the stimulus expires, we see an explosion of about an additiona 30,000 jobs lost per month for an additional 9 mos.

how is that "failing to fix anything?


In fact the logic you are invoking applies actually to the policies you advocate


  • Step One - Lower taxes will mean an INCREASED rate of growht
  • Step Two - cut taxes in 1986
  • Step Three - we see a REDUCED rate of GDP growth after adjusting for inflation, population growth and the normal GDP growth rate
    = we see ZERO change in the amount of capital (as a percent of GDP) invested in Long Term Capital Gains
  • Step Four - Deny there was such a reduction
  • Step Five, - Repeat the tax cuts as an answer to a downturn in the economy in 2002
  • Step Six - Ignore that the next 5 years are spent at an annual GDP Growth rate a whopping 22% below historic averages http://www.tradingeconomics.com/united-states/gdp-growth-annual
  • Step Seven - Pretend that the ARA is a "failure" even though it meets or exceeds its goals
  • Step Eight - Ignore that the Filibusters of the GOP minority and the Just Say No House has resulted in the 2002 Fiscal Policy being brought forward as THE Fiscal policy after the end of the Stimulus
  • Step Nine - Pretend that the Stimulus is causing the slow economy - the stimulus no longer in effect - and not the FISCAL Policies which are the same ones that had a 22% underperformance rate
  • Step Ten - Claim that Those pointing out these facts are the Ones in Denial
  • Step Elevn - Repeat the Denials
  • Step Twelve - Repeat the denials


The Twelve Step Program to crash the economy.
 
Back
Top