New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Does ANYONE obey the Ten Commandments?

Arkady

President
My daughter is in pre-school and recently learned to draw a star. That probably won't seem terribly controversial, but it's actually a clear violation of one of the ten commandments.

Exodus 20:4 says:

לֹֽ֣א תַֽעֲשֶׂ֨ה־לְךָ֥֣ פֶ֣֙סֶל֙ ׀ וְכָל־תְּמוּנָ֡֔ה אֲשֶׁ֤֣ר בַּשָּׁמַ֣֙יִם֙ ׀ מִמַּ֡֔עַל וַֽאֲשֶׁ֥ר֩ בָּאָ֖֨רֶץ מִתַָּ֑֜חַת

In the New International Version translation that means: "You shall not make for yourself an image in the form of anything in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the waters below." The King James version has it as "Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth." Deuteronomy 5 recounts these with only two minor textual contradictions: "Thou shalt not make thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the waters beneath the earth."

The gist of all versions is the same. You're not supposed to be creating any images of anything on earth, or above it, or in the waters below it. Creating an image of a star, as my daughter did, is clearly an example of creating an image of something in the heaven above the earth, and thus a defiance of Yahweh's clear commandment.

I know that, in the past, there have been people who actually tried to obey the commandments. Most Islamic churches, for example, are noteworthy for avoiding any art depicting any image. Rather than having pictures of angels and the prophet and other figures from the Koran, they have stylized Arabic script with verses from the book, together with abstract mosaic designs:

Examples of Islamic Art.


awww_metmuseum_org_learn_for_educators_publications_for_educat4d8baf45daaeb0141adb5f10e4dda75a.jpg

Ancient Muslim coins, likewise, stuck with text and abstraction. But, modern Muslims seem to have mostly abandoned that principle -- they still typically avoid making images for church art, but Muslims use images for all sorts of other functions, including money.

Are you aware of any "People of the Book" (Christians, Muslims, of Jews) who still attempt to follow the commandments as written?
 
My daughter is in pre-school and recently learned to draw a star. That probably won't seem terribly controversial, but it's actually a clear violation of one of the ten commandments.

Exodus 20:4 says:

לֹֽ֣א תַֽעֲשֶׂ֨ה־לְךָ֥֣ פֶ֣֙סֶל֙ ׀ וְכָל־תְּמוּנָ֡֔ה אֲשֶׁ֤֣ר בַּשָּׁמַ֣֙יִם֙ ׀ מִמַּ֡֔עַל וַֽאֲשֶׁ֥ר֩ בָּאָ֖֨רֶץ מִתַָּ֑֜חַת

In the New International Version translation that means: "You shall not make for yourself an image in the form of anything in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the waters below." The King James version has it as "Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth." Deuteronomy 5 recounts these with only two minor textual contradictions: "Thou shalt not make thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the waters beneath the earth."

The gist of all versions is the same. You're not supposed to be creating any images of anything on earth, or above it, or in the waters below it. Creating an image of a star, as my daughter did, is clearly an example of creating an image of something in the heaven above the earth, and thus a defiance of Yahweh's clear commandment.

I know that, in the past, there have been people who actually tried to obey the commandments. Most Islamic churches, for example, are noteworthy for avoiding any art depicting any image. Rather than having pictures of angels and the prophet and other figures from the Koran, they have stylized Arabic script with verses from the book, together with abstract mosaic designs:

Examples of Islamic Art.


View attachment 22994

Ancient Muslim coins, likewise, stuck with text and abstraction. But, modern Muslims seem to have mostly abandoned that principle -- they still typically avoid making images for church art, but Muslims use images for all sorts of other functions, including money.

Are you aware of any "People of the Book" (Christians, Muslims, of Jews) who still attempt to follow the commandments as written?
I think you need to incorporate the immediately following verse, "You shall not bow down to them or worship them" (from NRSV, anglicized version)to get the gist of that passage. IIRC, creating the image gave the one who made it some power over that supposed deity, although I am open to correction on that.
 
I would suggest that the better and more useful question should be, "Does anyone NOT obey the 10 Commandments*?"

Once again, the top-poster builds us a strawman, then proudly knocks down his own strawman. That's not of much use to any of us.

BUT....does it make more sense to focus on the fewer times the average person is in conflict with the 10 Commandments?...or, the many MORE times that the average person comports with the 10 Commandments? I think of this when some get to obsessing over how many past wars appear to've been rooted in one religion or another. And, perhaps their obsession is valid. But, they NEVER - and I mean never - contrast those presumably religion-rooted wars, with the number of wars that never happened and the number of people who never died, specifically BECAUSE of religion!

*To clarify as to the 10 Commandments, I use this term because I'm a Christian and it's the one I'm most familiar with. But, my gist would be the same, if we substituted just about any other religion's list of admonitions, especially since they actually are remarkably similar!
 
I think you need to incorporate the immediately following verse, "You shall not bow down to them or worship them" (from NRSV, anglicized version)to get the gist of that passage.

Exactly, but Arkady and his fellow anti-Christians read the bible the same way they read the constitution...
 
My daughter is in pre-school and recently learned to draw a star. That probably won't seem terribly controversial, but it's actually a clear violation of one of the ten commandments.

Exodus 20:4 says:

לֹֽ֣א תַֽעֲשֶׂ֨ה־לְךָ֥֣ פֶ֣֙סֶל֙ ׀ וְכָל־תְּמוּנָ֡֔ה אֲשֶׁ֤֣ר בַּשָּׁמַ֣֙יִם֙ ׀ מִמַּ֡֔עַל וַֽאֲשֶׁ֥ר֩ בָּאָ֖֨רֶץ מִתַָּ֑֜חַת

In the New International Version translation that means: "You shall not make for yourself an image in the form of anything in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the waters below." The King James version has it as "Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth." Deuteronomy 5 recounts these with only two minor textual contradictions: "Thou shalt not make thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the waters beneath the earth."

The gist of all versions is the same. You're not supposed to be creating any images of anything on earth, or above it, or in the waters below it. Creating an image of a star, as my daughter did, is clearly an example of creating an image of something in the heaven above the earth, and thus a defiance of Yahweh's clear commandment.

I know that, in the past, there have been people who actually tried to obey the commandments. Most Islamic churches, for example, are noteworthy for avoiding any art depicting any image. Rather than having pictures of angels and the prophet and other figures from the Koran, they have stylized Arabic script with verses from the book, together with abstract mosaic designs:

Examples of Islamic Art.


View attachment 22994

Ancient Muslim coins, likewise, stuck with text and abstraction. But, modern Muslims seem to have mostly abandoned that principle -- they still typically avoid making images for church art, but Muslims use images for all sorts of other functions, including money.

Are you aware of any "People of the Book" (Christians, Muslims, of Jews) who still attempt to follow the commandments as written?

That would be a big 10-4.

The big guy and I are muy simpatico

Ain't never carved me a deity

Ain't never taken the lords name in vain, and I'll be god-damned (not the big guy but all them other wanna be also rans) if you say I did

I remember the Sabbath, and keep it holey. Sometime 18, but if I'm strapped for time, I try to get at least 9.

Flowers for mum every Mother's Day, and call to say hey every Father's day

Never done murdered anybody

Never done cheated, and when I did adulterize someone else, got slapped down good by the big guy. Took it as a warning and never did it again.

Don't steal

Never beared false witness, even though I know that dirty rotten SOB stole my paper last Sunday.

Never coveted my neighbor's wife, no matter how sweet a piece of ass she is, nor have I ever covet any of his crap that he leave laying around the front yard, nor the cheesy furnishings he has in his house.

But then again, Mr. Arkady, not many are as saintly as I
 
That would be a big 10-4.

The big guy and I are muy simpatico

Ain't never carved me a deity

Ain't never taken the lords name in vain, and I'll be god-damned (not the big guy but all them other wanna be also rans) if you say I did

I remember the Sabbath, and keep it holey. Sometime 18, but if I'm strapped for time, I try to get at least 9.

Flowers for mum every Mother's Day, and call to say hey every Father's day

Never done murdered anybody

Never done cheated, and when I did adulterize someone else, got slapped down good by the big guy. Took it as a warning and never did it again.

Don't steal

Never beared false witness, even though I know that dirty rotten SOB stole my paper last Sunday.

Never coveted my neighbor's wife, no matter how sweet a piece of ass she is, nor have I ever covet any of his crap that he leave laying around the front yard, nor the cheesy furnishings he has in his house.

But then again, Mr. Arkady, not many are as saintly as I

I am so lucky I am a woman, because it says you should not covet thy neighbors WIFE so I am so busy coveting thy neighbor's husband but it's okay. I will admit I have a hard time telling the girl who was molested by her father that she must honor him. Thank goodness for the 10 Commandments because I would be out murdering people all the time and stealing
. I kind of go with one commandment,,,, be the best you can be.
 
I think you need to incorporate the immediately following verse, "You shall not bow down to them or worship them" (from NRSV, anglicized version)to get the gist of that passage. IIRC, creating the image gave the one who made it some power over that supposed deity, although I am open to correction on that.
If the only problem is bowing down to those images, then it would be phrased differently. It would say "You shall not bow down or worship an image in the form of anything in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the waters below." That's shorter and clearer and would be just as effective at preventing that bowing and worshiping. Instead, there are two grammatically independent clauses. One says not to make those things. The other says not to worship them. Thus, you're breaking the commandment if you make the image but don't worship it, and you're breaking it if you worship it, even if you didn't make it.

I fully approve of the decision by nearly everyone to toss that commandment on the rubbish heap, since obeying it would cause all sorts of problems. But it does strike me as mighty weird in a culture where so many people pretend to care about the Ten Commandments, to the point of fighting for the right to use taxpayer-financed property, schools, and courts to promote the commandments.

Another one that almost nobody follows is the one about the Sabbath. There are some ultra-orthodox Jews and a few hard-core conservative Seventh Day Adventists who take seriously the notion that it's forbidden to do any work on Saturday, but the whole rest of the culture has dispensed with it. First, most Christians have decided there's nothing special about the Sabbath at all, and that the real holy day is Sunday. Second, most are perfectly comfortable with all manner of non-sacred work and recreation on Sunday, from mowing the lawn and cooking food, to playing and watching sports. Again, I think it's great that the commandment got tossed away by most of the culture, but it's very odd that, nonetheless, so many continue to posture about the supposed importance of those commandments to them.
 
Nope...

View attachment 22995

Not even Roy Moore.
He cracks me up, since the idol he promoted was EXACTLY the kind of thing that particular commandment opposed.

I also saw something a while back where he came down in favor of high school cheerleaders displaying religious texts on signs at high school football games. The irony is that most of these games were played either Friday night or during the day on Saturday -- times that were "the Sabbath" as it was understood by the writers of the Bible (who regarded the Sabbath as sun-down Friday until sun-down Saturday). And so, the very event that those cheerleaders were at would have been seen as a serious infraction against the law of Yahweh.
 
I would suggest that the better and more useful question should be, "Does anyone NOT obey the 10 Commandments*?"

Once again, the top-poster builds us a strawman, then proudly knocks down his own strawman. That's not of much use to any of us.

BUT....does it make more sense to focus on the fewer times the average person is in conflict with the 10 Commandments?...or, the many MORE times that the average person comports with the 10 Commandments? I think of this when some get to obsessing over how many past wars appear to've been rooted in one religion or another. And, perhaps their obsession is valid. But, they NEVER - and I mean never - contrast those presumably religion-rooted wars, with the number of wars that never happened and the number of people who never died, specifically BECAUSE of religion!

*To clarify as to the 10 Commandments, I use this term because I'm a Christian and it's the one I'm most familiar with. But, my gist would be the same, if we substituted just about any other religion's list of admonitions, especially since they actually are remarkably similar!
I disobey the ten commandments on a regular basis. Don't you? Do you really keep Saturday holy -- avoiding doing any work of any sort on Saturday, and avoiding causing others to do that work? If you're an ultra-orthodox Jew or a super-conservative Seventh Day Adventist, maybe the answer is yes, but I assume it's actually no. Likewise, do you really avoid taking the lord's name in vain? If so, you're odd -- most people do it so casually that it's not even something the government censors on broadcast TV. And our whole damned capitalist system is built on coveting stuff, so that's not one that most people even make an effort to comply with.

So, if you ask "Does anyone NOT obey the 10 Commandments," then my answer is, "Yep, everyone I know doesn't obey the 10 Commandments."

As for the idea that every religion's list of admonitions is relatively similar, I disagree strongly. Religions have vastly different rules -- even diametrically opposed ones. For example, in the Bible, people are guided to kill and eat fatted calves in celebration, where as in Hinduism people are instructed not to kill cattle. In the Bible, it is forbidden to eat pigs, while some Polynesian cultures had sacred ceremonies where eating pigs was required. In some religions, marrying a cousin is forbidden, in others it is the most favored match. Some religions encourage chastity, other see it as sinful and order followers to be fruitful and multiply.
 
Last edited:
I disobey the ten commandments on a regular basis. Don't you? Do you really keep Saturday holy -- avoiding doing any work of any sort on Saturday, and avoiding causing others to do that work? If you're an ultra-orthodox Jew or a super-conservative Seventh Day Adventist, maybe the answer is yes, but I assume it's actually no. Likewise, do you really avoid taking the lord's name in vain? If so, you're odd -- most people do it so casually that it's not even something the government censors on broadcast TV. And our whole damned capitalist system is built on coveting stuff, so that's not one that most people even make an effort to comply with.

So, if you ask "Does anyone NOT obey the 10 Commandments," then my answer is, "Yep, everyone I know doesn't obey the 10 Commandments."

As for the idea that every religion's list of admonitions is relatively similar, I disagree strongly. Religions have vastly different rules -- even diametrically opposed ones. For example, in the Bible, people are guided to kill and eat fatted calves in celebration, where as in Hinduism people are instructed not to kill cattle. In the Bible, it is forbidden to eat pigs, while some Polynesian cultures had sacred ceremonies where eating pigs was required. In some religions, marrying a cousin is forbidden, in others it is the most favored match. Some religions encourage chastity, other see it as sinful and order followers to be fruitful and multiply.

As usual, your word-gamery is weak. Everyone does NOT obey the 10 Commandments and every one DOES obey the 10 Commandments. My response wasn't to suggest that your implication/question was wrong and that mine is right. It was merely to suggest that I think MY question is more useful, especially since most all "faith entities" I know of, acknowledge the fact that we're all sinners and NONE insist upon perfection for membership.
 
That would be a big 10-4.

The big guy and I are muy simpatico

Ain't never carved me a deity

Ain't never taken the lords name in vain, and I'll be god-damned (not the big guy but all them other wanna be also rans) if you say I did

I remember the Sabbath, and keep it holey. Sometime 18, but if I'm strapped for time, I try to get at least 9.

Flowers for mum every Mother's Day, and call to say hey every Father's day

Never done murdered anybody

Never done cheated, and when I did adulterize someone else, got slapped down good by the big guy. Took it as a warning and never did it again.

Don't steal

Never beared false witness, even though I know that dirty rotten SOB stole my paper last Sunday.

Never coveted my neighbor's wife, no matter how sweet a piece of ass she is, nor have I ever covet any of his crap that he leave laying around the front yard, nor the cheesy furnishings he has in his house.

But then again, Mr. Arkady, not many are as saintly as I
Hehe. Nicely done.
 
I am so lucky I am a woman, because it says you should not covet thy neighbors WIFE so I am so busy coveting thy neighbor's husband but it's okay. I will admit I have a hard time telling the girl who was molested by her father that she must honor him. Thank goodness for the 10 Commandments because I would be out murdering people all the time and stealing
. I kind of go with one commandment,,,, be the best you can be.
Sadly, you're not excused for wanting the neighbor's husband, since there's a catch-all at the end of the list, saying you're not allowed to desire "anything which is thy neighbour's".
 
As usual, your word-gamery is weak. Everyone does NOT obey the 10 Commandments and every one DOES obey the 10 Commandments. My response wasn't to suggest that your implication/question was wrong and that mine is right. It was merely to suggest that I think MY question is more useful, especially since most all "faith entities" I know of, acknowledge the fact that we're all sinners and NONE insist upon perfection for membership.
OK. In what way is your question useful? I'm not denying it is, I just haven't detected what you see useful about it.

If your argument is that there are certain basic moral principles that cross cultures and that most people at least make an effort to comply with, although they may fall short, I agree. However, those principles are not, for the most part, summed up in the Ten Commandments, which are mostly the particular taboos of one specific Bronze Age desert cult, rather than general moral principles. A reminder:

(1) One shouldn't worship any deity more than Yahweh. Obviously, that's not a general moral principle, it's something very specific to the followers of this particular deity, and would be contradicted by the vast majority of humans who have ever lived, and even the majority currently alive.

(2) Don't make or worship any likenesses. Again, that's the taboo of one religion, and would be contradicted by the vast majority of humans. Also, the commandment is patently immoral, in that Yahweh pairs it with a warning that if you transgress that taboo, he'll hold your kids, grandkids, and great-grandkids accountable for what you did, which is not morally defensible.

(3) Don't take the name of Yahweh in vain. This isn't a general moral principle, it's a taboo of a particular faith. The vast majority of people in history wouldn't think there's anything the slightest bit special about the name Yahweh. And plenty of religions exist where people not only aren't instructed not to use the gods' name in vain, but where various curses and oaths using the gods' names were encouraged.

(4) Don't work on Saturday, or cause anyone else to work on that day. Again, that's the taboo of a particular religion, not a moral principle. Most people do not consider Saturday to be a sacred day, much less one where nobody should be allowed to do any work.

(5) Honor they father an mother. OK, that one sounds a bit more like a moral rule, or at least a social rule of thumb that might generally be recognized across most religions. But then the Bible screws it up by saying to do so in order to have a long life, which again makes it not a moral rule, but more like instructions for a magic trick.

(6) Don't murder. This is a moral concept crossing most religions, though they all disagree on what it means.

(7) Don't commit adultery. Again, this is generally something that crosses most religions, though again they disagree on what it means. Even the Bible is inconsistent on it. Jesus defines adultery to include gazing with lust and remarriage following divorce.

(8) Don't steal. That's another good social rule of thumb, but most religions really only mean it in the sense of "don't take something from a member of your own tribe" -- since they allow for pillage and other taking by force (the way, for example, the Israelites stole the Promised Land from its prior owners, shortly after receiving this commandment).

(9) Don't provide false testimony. That's another fairly universal one, and, for a change, I think most people have a pretty standard understanding of what it actually means.

(10) Don't covet your neighbor's stuff. This is far from a universal moral principle. Most humans would probably say that wanting the stuff other people have is not only natural and unavoidable, but actually good for society, in that it drives achievement.

So, to summarize, commandments 1, 2, 3, 4, and 10 (half the list) aren't even related to general principles about moral or social good behavior that would be recognized across other religions. 6, 7, and 8 are things that most people would agree to in very vague terms, but where all the interesting questions are about interpretation, and vast differences will exist between one religion/culture and another (e.g., is it murder to kill in war? To kill as legal punishment?) That leaves 5 and 9 as things that are cross-cultural standards of desired social conduct, if not necessarily moral absolutes.
 
Last edited:
I think you need to incorporate the immediately following verse, "You shall not bow down to them or worship them" (from NRSV, anglicized version)to get the gist of that passage. IIRC, creating the image gave the one who made it some power over that supposed deity, although I am open to correction on that.

I think you're right, NFP. It's about worship of graven images, which was something of an issue back then!
Unfortunately, anti-Catholic Christians often twist our love for symbols into something it's not, and cite this Commandment as 'proof" that we, too, are pagans.
 
If the only problem is bowing down to those images, then it would be phrased differently. It would say "You shall not bow down or worship an image in the form of anything in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the waters below." That's shorter and clearer and would be just as effective at preventing that bowing and worshiping. Instead, there are two grammatically independent clauses. One says not to make those things. The other says not to worship them. Thus, you're breaking the commandment if you make the image but don't worship it, and you're breaking it if you worship it, even if you didn't make it.

I fully approve of the decision by nearly everyone to toss that commandment on the rubbish heap, since obeying it would cause all sorts of problems. But it does strike me as mighty weird in a culture where so many people pretend to care about the Ten Commandments, to the point of fighting for the right to use taxpayer-financed property, schools, and courts to promote the commandments.

Another one that almost nobody follows is the one about the Sabbath. There are some ultra-orthodox Jews and a few hard-core conservative Seventh Day Adventists who take seriously the notion that it's forbidden to do any work on Saturday, but the whole rest of the culture has dispensed with it. First, most Christians have decided there's nothing special about the Sabbath at all, and that the real holy day is Sunday. Second, most are perfectly comfortable with all manner of non-sacred work and recreation on Sunday, from mowing the lawn and cooking food, to playing and watching sports. Again, I think it's great that the commandment got tossed away by most of the culture, but it's very odd that, nonetheless, so many continue to posture about the supposed importance of those commandments to them.

It would be phrased differently if you wrote it. But you didn't write it. If the Commandment was intended as you describe, then drawing, sculpting,or photographing anything would be a sin. After all, everything can be categorized as being of the earth, or the heavens, or the seas.

We Catholics love artwork and symbolism. I didn't put the picture of the Blessed Mother up on my wall because I love pictures. I put it up because I love her. That's exactly why I have pictures of my kids up, too.
It really is all about intention.

But, along the lines of what you're discussing...Here's one...People who feel it's so sinful to put up a Cross or religious symbol in their own home, but then fight for the giant religious symbol to remain on public property. I think it's territorialist, like when cats spray.

Why do you feel that most Christians have decided not to keep the Sabbath holy? What is your opinion of the definition of sacred work?
 
I think you're right, NFP. It's about worship of graven images, which was something of an issue back then!
Unfortunately, anti-Catholic Christians often twist our love for symbols into something it's not, and cite this Commandment as 'proof" that we, too, are pagans.
If it's only about worshipping graven images, why isn't that what it says? Read it yourself. Exodus 20. It plainly talks about making any image as something you're not allowed by God to do. Exodus 20 also has separate rules against worshipping images, but why even talk about making images being prohibited if the intent wasn't to prohibit that other than in cases of worshiping images?

Look, don't hold it against me. I assure you, I didn't write Exodus. But it says what it says, as plainly as can be imagined. It talks about MAKING IMAGES being something that God has put off limits. It's a dumb rule, but that's what it clearly says.
 
It would be phrased differently if you wrote it. But you didn't write it. If the Commandment was intended as you describe, then drawing, sculpting,or photographing anything would be a sin. After all, everything can be categorized as being of the earth, or the heavens, or the seas.

We Catholics love artwork and symbolism. I didn't put the picture of the Blessed Mother up on my wall because I love pictures. I put it up because I love her. That's exactly why I have pictures of my kids up, too.
It really is all about intention.

But, along the lines of what you're discussing...Here's one...People who feel it's so sinful to put up a Cross or religious symbol in their own home, but then fight for the giant religious symbol to remain on public property. I think it's territorialist, like when cats spray.

Why do you feel that most Christians have decided not to keep the Sabbath holy? What is your opinion of the definition of sacred work?
Yes, drawing, sculpting, and photographing are all clearly sins, according to the Bible, other than if it can be said not to involve an image of something in heaven, on earth, or under the earth (e.g., drawing an abstract design of the sort that decorates Muslim mosques). That's why ancient Jews and Muslims didn't traffic in pictures.

I have no problem with Catholic art. The Sistine Chapel is among my favorites. But it was clearly a sin, according to Exodus and Deuteronomy, to paint it. If you think Exodus and Deuteronomy are the true revelations of God, that's a problem. If not, it's not. But you can't honestly claim those books don't say what they plainly say.

As for why nearly all Christians decided to break the commandment about not working on the Sabbath, that's easy. Early on, they decided to keep Sunday sacred instead of the Sabbath because Sunday was the sacred day for the pagans, and aligning Christian practice with that made it easier to function in the Roman world. Much later, they even decided to work on Sundays because it's inconvenient not to, and they'd lost any true faith in the Bible. When the Bible stops being something you really believe in, and just becomes a shallow cultural touchstone, or a way to bash people who aren't in your religious club, then you let fall by the wayside anything that's a little inconvenient, like a rule against working on a particular day. You ask why I define as sacred work, but I don't see the relevance of that question. The Bible says no work on the seventh day. Period.
 
Back
Top