New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ducks one

So do you disagree with him having a religious view, or merely with him expressing it?

And I hope there are no devout Catholics reading, because if they follow the tenets of their church, even with the new pope, you just said all of them were sick and twisted.

"Moral people" may greatly disagree on what constitutes morality. Most Christians agree that homosexual behavior is immoral.
I believe the view he expressed was monstrously immoral. It was not made one bit more or less monstrous by being part of his religion.

As for Catholics, I know a lot of them, and not one of those I know personally believes homosexuality ought to be punished by eternal damnation. EVERY religious person is a la carte about his beliefs. EVERYONE decides which beliefs to adhere to and which to reject. If a person chooses to reject the teachings about giving all one's wealth to charity but to cling to the teachings about gays getting burnt in a lake of fire, that is a morally meaningful choice, and says terrible things about the person (like our rich reality star with his benighted views of gays). The Catholics I know, on the other hand, make more moral choices when filling up their tray at the buffet line of religion, regardless of which Pope is behind the counter dishing out the slop.
 
I believe the view he expressed was monstrously immoral. It was not made one bit more or less monstrous by being part of his religion.

As for Catholics, I know a lot of them, and not one of those I know personally believes homosexuality ought to be punished by eternal damnation. EVERY religious person is a la carte about his beliefs. EVERYONE decides which beliefs to adhere to and which to reject. If a person chooses to reject the teachings about giving all one's wealth to charity but to cling to the teachings about gays getting burnt in a lake of fire, that is a morally meaningful choice, and says terrible things about the person (like our rich reality star with his benighted views of gays). The Catholics I know, on the other hand, make more moral choices when filling up their tray at the buffet line of religion, regardless of which Pope is behind the counter dishing out the slop.

OK, but you're saying that only one view of this "a la carte" view of religion is a legitimate one. Church officers in most churches (and especially in Catholic ones) would disagree that the individual has any right to decide. I think it's "immoral" to make judgements about other people's moral's and find them "monstrous." OK, I don't really, but simply as an object the statement is no different than the one you're making.

So I guess I need to ask again -- which of Phil's First Amendment rights do you want to take away? His freedom of religion or his freedom of speech?
 
OK, but you're saying that only one view of this "a la carte" view of religion is a legitimate one. Church officers in most churches (and especially in Catholic ones) would disagree that the individual has any right to decide. I think it's "immoral" to make judgements about other people's moral's and find them "monstrous." OK, I don't really, but simply as an object the statement is no different than the one you're making.

So I guess I need to ask again -- which of Phil's First Amendment rights do you want to take away? His freedom of religion or his freedom of speech?
Of course church officers disagree with the idea of a la carte religion. They live off the church, and they rightly worry that if you start to pluck bricks from that edifice, the whole thing may come down around their ears. But, as a practical matter, everyone picks and chooses.

When it comes to the Bible, at least, it's not even possible NOT to pick and choose, since some sections directly contradict other sections, so you necessarily have to decide which sections to reject and which sections to embrace. People all choose, and should be held accountable for their choices. A person who chooses to believe that homosexuality deserves to be punished with eternal torture (but chooses not to believe, say, that playing football on Saturday, as Robertson did in college, profanes the Sabbath) has formed independent judgments and should be held accountable for them. He can't simply point to his religion as if it relieves him of culpability, since, in the end, his choice of religion (and his choice of which aspects of a received religion to adopt) is an independent judgment like any other.

As for you claim that it's immoral to make judgments about other people's morals, the very fact that's a self-contradiction should tell you something (as I think you know, since you say that you don't really). We all judge people for their moral decisions. I'm just saying that I don't accept that people can use religion as a special exception to that. My condemnation of Robertson is, likewise, a moral judgement, and it wouldn't be one bit less legitimate as a topic for criticism of me if I told you that I have a problem with Robertson because what he said goes against my faith. My attack on Robertson is either sound or faulty and is neither enhanced nor weakened by coming from a secular or religious place.
 
OK, but you're saying that only one view of this "a la carte" view of religion is a legitimate one. Church officers in most churches (and especially in Catholic ones) would disagree that the individual has any right to decide. I think it's "immoral" to make judgements about other people's moral's and find them "monstrous." OK, I don't really, but simply as an object the statement is no different than the one you're making.

So I guess I need to ask again -- which of Phil's First Amendment rights do you want to take away? His freedom of religion or his freedom of speech?
And, again, I've said absolutely nothing to suggest I want to take away Robertson's first amendment rights. He can use them all he wants. It's just that people who are less morally depraved than Robertson can, likewise, use their First Amendment rights to criticize his sinful views about homosexuality.
 
And, again, I've said absolutely nothing to suggest I want to take away Robertson's first amendment rights. He can use them all he wants. It's just that people who are less morally depraved than Robertson can, likewise, use their First Amendment rights to criticize his sinful views about homosexuality.

Certainly they can. They can also stop watching A&E, which has reinstated Phil Robertson. All is well within their scope.

It's funny that I find myself defending Robertston per se. I grew up in rural America and I detest Duck Dynasty as a mockery of the culture in which I was raised.
 
Of course church officers disagree with the idea of a la carte religion. They live off the church, and they rightly worry that if you start to pluck bricks from that edifice, the whole thing may come down around their ears. But, as a practical matter, everyone picks and chooses.

So you're saying most people don't believe what they believe, but Phil Robertson is wrong for actually believing what he believes? One of us is confused, and I don't think it's me.

As for you claim that it's immoral to make judgments about other people's morals, the very fact that's a self-contradiction should tell you something (as I think you know, since you say that you don't really). We all judge people for their moral decisions. I'm just saying that I don't accept that people can use religion as a special exception to that. My condemnation of Robertson is, likewise, a moral judgement, and it wouldn't be one bit less legitimate as a topic for criticism of me if I told you that I have a problem with Robertson because what he said goes against my faith. My attack on Robertson is either sound or faulty and is neither enhanced nor weakened by coming from a secular or religious place.

I think people can indeed use religion as a special exception. I'd say your attack on Robertson is faulty, flawed to the deepest end, as it essentially involves stacking one man's morality against another and then saying, "mine is better." Says who? I'm sure Robertson would say -- he actually did say -- that his is better.
 
So you're saying most people don't believe what they believe, but Phil Robertson is wrong for actually believing what he believes? One of us is confused, and I don't think it's me.
No. That was gibberish. I'm saying every religious person picks and chooses which things to include in his personal faith, generally in part from some collection of beliefs in one or more religions. Some are good people, and select morally sound values for their personal faith. Some are evil, like Robertson, and instead select depraved values.

I think people can indeed use religion as a special exception.

Fine. Then we can just say that my religion requires me to hate people like Robertson and any who would defend him. Does that make my position more palatable to you?

I'd say your attack on Robertson is faulty, flawed to the deepest end, as it essentially involves stacking one man's morality against another and then saying, "mine is better." Says who?

Says me, obviously. And when you claim that is faulty you are, likewise, stacking your morality against mine and claiming superiority for yours. Only one of us is right. I don't think it's the one defending the guy who believes never-ending, unimaginable torment is the right fate for someone who chooses to indulge in unorthodox, consensual sexual practices. That is an sadistic belief, and is a sign of a deeply diseased soul.
 
Fine. Then we can just say that my religion requires me to hate people like Robertson and any who would defend him. Does that make my position more palatable to you?

You don't need religion to be a hateful bigot who despises free speech. Lefties prove that daily...
 
You don't need religion to be a hateful bigot who despises free speech. Lefties prove that daily...
You don't need religion to be a hateful bigot... But it sure does help. I'm sure there must be atheists out there, for example, who hate gays; it's just so rare that I've honestly never heard of one. Similarly, surely somewhere in the world there must be an atheist group that hates black people as much as does the KKK or Aryan nation or the Christian identity movement; I've just never heard of them, since all the big hate groups have religious affiliations.
 
Last edited:
OK, but you're saying that only one view of this "a la carte" view of religion is a legitimate one. Church officers in most churches (and especially in Catholic ones) would disagree that the individual has any right to decide. I think it's "immoral" to make judgements about other people's moral's and find them "monstrous." OK, I don't really, but simply as an object the statement is no different than the one you're making.

So I guess I need to ask again -- which of Phil's First Amendment rights do you want to take away? His freedom of religion or his freedom of speech?
Trappy that post qualifies you for the biggest ass award, you tried to put words in arks mouth then you give ark two choices and only two when clearly ark would not choose either. You really are insufferable and obnoxious.
 
Last edited:
Trappy that post qualifies you for the biggest ass ward, you tried to put words in arks mouth then you give ark two choices and only two when clearly ark would not choose either. You really are insufferable and obnoxious.

pot calls kettle black☻
 
Trappy that post qualifies you for the biggest ass ward, you tried to put words in arks mouth then you give ark two choices and only two when clearly ark would not choose either. You really are insufferable and obnoxious.

Lol. That's the entire rhetorical arsenal of some of our more prominent lefty posters, but I've never seen you complain about that.
 
Lol. That's the entire rhetorical arsenal of some of our more prominent lefty posters, but I've never seen you complain about that.

apparently, Boar got a brain disease from his Gorebal Solar Panels.........or from eating his Carbon Footprint Offsets*
 
Lol. That's the entire rhetorical arsenal of some of our more prominent lefty posters, but I've never seen you complain about that.


Marvin,

You've never exhibited the propensity to piece together an adequate collection of thoughts to generate so much as a complete paragraph. You've never taken a clear and concise position on any issue of significance. You are nothing more than a classic ankle biter, and yet you have the audacity to discredit the debating skills of your fellow posters? You are far more absurd than any actual cartoon character.
 
apparently, Boar got a brain disease from his Gorebal Solar Panels.........or from eating his Carbon Footprint Offsets*

Yea you like sucking on the teat of pig oil and gas and being dependent on the ultra rich who rape you. And you don't complain because you've allowed yourself to be convinced that you like being raped and you like being dependent.

You are a slave, yet you do not see the bars that surround thee.
 
Yea you like sucking on the teat of pig oil and gas and being dependent on the ultra rich who rape you. And you don't complain because you've allowed yourself to be convinced that you like being raped and you like being dependent.

You are a slave, yet you do not see the bars that surround thee.

Po-Po Boar..............I heat with WOOD..........cost=much manual labor...but FREE.......have a water-stove that heats my water........electric water heater suck....you're on a CORP made computer bitching at other's for doing what you do..........go suk another [Unwelcome language removed]........live your life and let us live ours......YOu don't have the power to make us live like YOU...........Boar☻
 
Back
Top