A quote, oft attributed to Eleanor Roosevelt, although it likely predates her:
Great minds discuss ideas; average minds discuss events; small minds discuss people.
Most of us here, myself included, spend the lion's share of our time here discussing people and events...Issues and idea take a back seat most of the time. Problems require solutions, and it is far easier to criticize someone else's proposed solution that it is for us to come up with one of our own. Most of the time we tend to opt for the easy.
When I came across the brief article cited here, it got me thinking "What are the opposition's solutions? I know what Trump's ideas are - he's not bashful about sharing - but what are the Democrat solutions to those same problems?
So this is a bit of a challenge for anyone here who thinks they can tackle it. Something other than "so-and-so is a big poopy head".
I am interested to see if any attempt it. or just ignore it, or fall back on ad hominem.
It’s not reasonable to take the Democrats as the only possible opposition, when they share the same capitalist assumptions and goals as the Republicans and cannot but reproduce the same systemic failures that are symptomatic of capitalism’s general breakdown. Addressing many of these problems objectively requires a planned economy, state ownership of the means of production, and a state monopoly on foreign trade, to put us on the road to socialist solutions. Compare and contrast:
Debt: a requirement for capitalism since it acts as a hidden state subsidy for the finance capital that undergirds the system. Trump exacerbated this problem greatly during his first term by driving the deficits way up to finance tax cuts for the wealthy; his proposed solution now is drastically reducing social spending (eliminating social security, Medicare, and Medicaid), education spending, and infrastructure spending, which will inevitably create new problems (skyrocketing poverty and violence, reduced productivity, etc.). On the other hand, what we saw with the Democrats were sharp reductions of the deficit through spending cuts (mostly military) and the increased revenue that came from the stronger economy when Trump’s graft and incompetence were no longer choking it. But their solution didn’t solve the underlying debt problem. The socialist alternative allows for confiscatory taxation of the great estates, repudiation of the debts owed to parasitical speculators, substantial profits from state-capitalist activity, and a return to a gold standard that can force the state to be fiscally responsible.
Illegal drugs being smuggled in from Mexico: a profit-driven enterprise that, like any capitalist big business, can only be successful with de facto state support. The bipartisan lack of a solution: a militarization of the borders that makes the cartels more powerful and drives increased smuggling (as it did during his last term), more speed up and less safety regulation on the job, meaning more maimed people in need of painkillers, and war, meaning the same. The socialist alternative allows for treatment on the decisive demand side by reduction of the suffering driving addiction and by allowing for the resources to treat the underlying causes of pain leading people to self-medicate, allows workers to benefit when the state meets its border control goals instead of suffering, allows for rationalization of the border through a state monopoly on foreign trade, and creates the possibility of a Soviet Union of Mexico and the United States that eliminates the problems caused by a tightly controlled border.
Wars in Ukraine and Gaza: there is not much the U.S. can do that won’t make it worse. Trump by strengthening Russia and isolating the Palestinians helped create the conditions for war. Now he is looking for an armistice on Russia’s terms that allows a regime that cannot survive without permanent war to regroup and launch more aggressive wars in the future. The Democratic alternative was providing enough paltry aid to Ukraine to keep the two sides bleeding each other. Wrt Israel, the approach of both parties is giving Israel a blank check to double down on its aggression. A workers’ state in the U.S. would not automatically solve these problems, driven by the internal politics of Russia and Israel, but it could help by canceling the Third World debt, thus eliminating some of the economic imperatives driving the Gaza War, providing massive military aid to Ukraine and (via the PLO’s left) to the Palestinian resistance, and cutting off the spigot funding Israeli aggression. Moreover, a socialist revolution in the U.S. would realistically push the rest of the world on a path to socialism and permanent peace.
The trade deficit: this is a “solution” in search of a problem. Countries that import more real wealth (goods and services) and export more fictitious wealth (capital) become wealthier as a result, and the mercantilist fantasy to the contrary is just a pretext for protectionist favors for special-interest industries and often a cover for hoarding wealth in preparation for war. Trump no doubt will reduce the trade deficit. Which will mean more cash chasing fewer commodities, i.e., more inflation and more shortages. Democrats seem to favor the free-market approach which means volatility, dependence on undependable foreign supplies, and competition-driven unemployment. The rational solution, evidently, is state control of foreign trade as part of a planned economy, with the needs of workers the primary aim.
Preventing Iran from building nuclear weapons: short of a war to eliminate Iran as we know it, there is not much the U.S. can do. Obama did the best he could by working out a deal whereby Iran could achieve its main goal (nuclear energy and sanctions relief) by agreeing to the most intrusive inspections regime in history and verifiably decommissioning much of their nuclear weapons capability, but of course Trump spiked that program … which experts say pushed back the time it would take Iran to develop a nuclear weapon by 2-5 years … out of demagogic spite. Now Republicans and Democrats are begging Iran for a new version of Obama’s deal (but negotiating from a weaker position) while using proxy wars by Saudi Arabia, etc., to keep Iran occupied while they kick the can down the road. The socialist alternative is respecting Iran’s sovereignty while working for the revolutionary war that would make Iran the kind of country that can be trusted with nuclear weapons.
Cost of health care: this must be commodified in our society to allow for more profits to be made at workers’ expense. Trump’s plan is to greatly drive up out of pocket costs by eliminating Medicare, Medicaid, and the Affordable Care Act, while the Democrats are for technocratic band-aid fixes that don’t address the underlying problem of a privately controlled health care market. A labor party based in the unions could lead a successful fight for a state-subsidized health care system that is free to consumers of its services at point of treatment, but only if it breaks with the big-business parties to do so.