New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Fixing Education

Arkady

President
As I've mentioned, I'm somewhat ambivalent about standardized testing as a tool for managing public education, but I ultimatley lean in favor of it. One idea I could see working well is having variable teacher pay that is based on performance relative to either prior-year performance by the same kids or, if unavailable, average performance by demographically similar kids.

So, for example, picture a situation where teacher base pay is $30,000 per year, with variable pay pegged to $20,000, which moves up or down based on improvement or worsening relative to the benchmark. So, for instance, let's say the kids in your class were, last year, on average at the 20th percentile for science for their grade level, and this year your kids also score at the 20th percentile relative to their new grade level. That's average progress, so you get $20,000 variable pay, for a total income of $50,000. But what if your kids score in the 10th percentile? Then you lose half the variable pay, and only take home $40,000. And what if they score in the 40th percentile? Then you double the variable pay, and take home $70,000.

That structure would make teaching spots in crappy neighborhoods hot commodities. Economically ambitious teachers would compete against each other for those spots (or for remdial-track spots in nicer schools), because that's where the upside is. If you can take kids who were at the 10th percentile the prior year and get them performing at the 90th percentile, you could earn the kind of income elite professionals get in other fields like law and medicine. If you were so good you could have that impact year in and year out, you could get rich. By comparison, working with kids who are already elite would have its spiritual awards, and the benefit of a more pleasant and safer school, but it wouldn't be a path for getting rich.

A program like that, that steered the hardest-working, most-talented, and most ambitious teachers into the positions where the most help was needed, would almost certainly boost our national performance:

http://www.slate.com/articles/doubl...ducation_experiment_finds_that_merit_pay.html

I suspect that something like I'm talking about would have some weird side effects, some of which would be obviously positive, and some of which might seem unseemly, but still might be positive. For example, a clearly positive effect would be a greater focus by teachers on their students who most need help. For example, if you have someone at the 10th percentile, he's potentially your big payday, because he's got so much room for upside... you'd have no incentive to neglect him or to try to get him transfered out or flunked out, because if you can instead get him to focus, he could be your ticket to a big boost in variable pay. An example of something unseemly but potentially positive would be teachers bribing students to get them to focus: for example, what if I promised half my variable pay, above the baseline, to my students. If a class of 20 kids averaging at the 20th percentile understood that moving to the 40th percentile, as a group, could earn them each $500 at the end of the year, I bet you'd get some focus -- you might even get positive peer pressure encouraging studying, since the kids would know the class slackers were costing them money. In poor neighborhoods, that kind of money could make a big difference.
 
As I've mentioned, I'm somewhat ambivalent about standardized testing as a tool for managing public education, but I ultimatley lean in favor of it. One idea I could see working well is having variable teacher pay that is based on performance relative to either prior-year performance by the same kids or, if unavailable, average performance by demographically similar kids.

So, for example, picture a situation where teacher base pay is $30,000 per year, with variable pay pegged to $20,000, which moves up or down based on improvement or worsening relative to the benchmark. So, for instance, let's say the kids in your class were, last year, on average at the 20th percentile for science for their grade level, and this year your kids also score at the 20th percentile relative to their new grade level. That's average progress, so you get $20,000 variable pay, for a total income of $50,000. But what if your kids score in the 10th percentile? Then you lose half the variable pay, and only take home $40,000. And what if they score in the 40th percentile? Then you double the variable pay, and take home $70,000.

That structure would make teaching spots in crappy neighborhoods hot commodities. Economically ambitious teachers would compete against each other for those spots (or for remdial-track spots in nicer schools), because that's where the upside is. If you can take kids who were at the 10th percentile the prior year and get them performing at the 90th percentile, you could earn the kind of income elite professionals get in other fields like law and medicine. If you were so good you could have that impact year in and year out, you could get rich. By comparison, working with kids who are already elite would have its spiritual awards, and the benefit of a more pleasant and safer school, but it wouldn't be a path for getting rich.

A program like that, that steered the hardest-working, most-talented, and most ambitious teachers into the positions where the most help was needed, would almost certainly boost our national performance:

http://www.slate.com/articles/doubl...ducation_experiment_finds_that_merit_pay.html

I suspect that something like I'm talking about would have some weird side effects, some of which would be obviously positive, and some of which might seem unseemly, but still might be positive. For example, a clearly positive effect would be a greater focus by teachers on their students who most need help. For example, if you have someone at the 10th percentile, he's potentially your big payday, because he's got so much room for upside... you'd have no incentive to neglect him or to try to get him transfered out or flunked out, because if you can instead get him to focus, he could be your ticket to a big boost in variable pay. An example of something unseemly but potentially positive would be teachers bribing students to get them to focus: for example, what if I promised half my variable pay, above the baseline, to my students. If a class of 20 kids averaging at the 20th percentile understood that moving to the 40th percentile, as a group, could earn them each $500 at the end of the year, I bet you'd get some focus -- you might even get positive peer pressure encouraging studying, since the kids would know the class slackers were costing them money. In poor neighborhoods, that kind of money could make a big difference.

Bump.
 
As I've mentioned, I'm somewhat ambivalent about standardized testing as a tool for managing public education, but I ultimatley lean in favor of it. One idea I could see working well is having variable teacher pay that is based on performance relative to either prior-year performance by the same kids or, if unavailable, average performance by demographically similar kids.

So, for example, picture a situation where teacher base pay is $30,000 per year, with variable pay pegged to $20,000, which moves up or down based on improvement or worsening relative to the benchmark. So, for instance, let's say the kids in your class were, last year, on average at the 20th percentile for science for their grade level, and this year your kids also score at the 20th percentile relative to their new grade level. That's average progress, so you get $20,000 variable pay, for a total income of $50,000. But what if your kids score in the 10th percentile? Then you lose half the variable pay, and only take home $40,000. And what if they score in the 40th percentile? Then you double the variable pay, and take home $70,000.

That structure would make teaching spots in crappy neighborhoods hot commodities. Economically ambitious teachers would compete against each other for those spots (or for remdial-track spots in nicer schools), because that's where the upside is. If you can take kids who were at the 10th percentile the prior year and get them performing at the 90th percentile, you could earn the kind of income elite professionals get in other fields like law and medicine. If you were so good you could have that impact year in and year out, you could get rich. By comparison, working with kids who are already elite would have its spiritual awards, and the benefit of a more pleasant and safer school, but it wouldn't be a path for getting rich.

A program like that, that steered the hardest-working, most-talented, and most ambitious teachers into the positions where the most help was needed, would almost certainly boost our national performance:

http://www.slate.com/articles/doubl...ducation_experiment_finds_that_merit_pay.html

I suspect that something like I'm talking about would have some weird side effects, some of which would be obviously positive, and some of which might seem unseemly, but still might be positive. For example, a clearly positive effect would be a greater focus by teachers on their students who most need help. For example, if you have someone at the 10th percentile, he's potentially your big payday, because he's got so much room for upside... you'd have no incentive to neglect him or to try to get him transfered out or flunked out, because if you can instead get him to focus, he could be your ticket to a big boost in variable pay. An example of something unseemly but potentially positive would be teachers bribing students to get them to focus: for example, what if I promised half my variable pay, above the baseline, to my students. If a class of 20 kids averaging at the 20th percentile understood that moving to the 40th percentile, as a group, could earn them each $500 at the end of the year, I bet you'd get some focus -- you might even get positive peer pressure encouraging studying, since the kids would know the class slackers were costing them money. In poor neighborhoods, that kind of money could make a big difference.

So in your world here, teachers would neglect the kids who perform well?
 
One of the best things about teaching is that teachers work in cooperation with each other. I do not like the idea of teachers competing
 
Teachers are professionals, as are doctors, laywers, nurses, and engineers. The idea that some panel of people in
fields other than those specific professions, should come up with some scoring modus and apply it to those professions, would be absolute anathema to the members of those professions.

Yet in terms of the teaching profession, everyone's a critic and they don't appear to think nothin' of it.
 
One of the best things about teaching is that teachers work in cooperation with each other. I do not like the idea of teachers competing

Of course you don't. Competition would expose the incompetents and the underperformers...can't have that, right?
 
Of course you don't. Competition would expose the incompetents and the underperformers...can't have that, right?
What makes you think teachers don't compete?
We want our kids to do better than other schools..
I love parents who believe because they went to school, they are experts. I wonder why parents of kids who do poorly blame the teacher, and the kids who do well? It's in the genes
 
What makes you think teachers don't compete?

For what are you competing? Not your jobs. The unions make sure you keep those, regardless of how poorly your students perform, or how incompetent you may be. For prestige? Laughable. For higher test scores? Again, the unions have made those irrelevant.

So, do tell, for what are you competing?
 
For what are you competing? Not your jobs. The unions make sure you keep those, regardless of how poorly your students perform, or how incompetent you may be. For prestige? Laughable. For higher test scores? Again, the unions have made those irrelevant.

So, do tell, for what are you competing?

It is quite an insult to believe that teachers don't care about raising test scores....it is a reflection on us. But there are realities like having the top class that will usually do better than a bottom class. I have had top classes soar and had bottom classes go up a few months and that was an accomplishment. Different dynamics
I think we should get rid of tenure, and raise teachers salaries so we can attract those who are the best and brightest
 
All told - from the beginning of my "learning career" to the most recent end, I imagine I've had about 80 teachers. IF I were to go back through them all and choose out the top-10, I'm certaind they'd have one thing in common. They'd all be quite different from one another. Therefore, it makes absolutely no sense to me, that lay people could come up with some sort of "one size fits all" testing regime for them.

My concern - which I've gotta say, is born out by the current names and realities - is that it's the STEM-type people who seem to be taking the lead on all this. And for them, learning is much more about some sort of "data downloading" process. That's fine for them but, we won't know what we've lost 'til its gone, if we let them take over the entire process.
 
So in your world here, teachers would neglect the kids who perform well?

I'm always amused when I see lawyers that charge at a minimum $150@hr posting and worried about folks only making $30,000...........apparently some lawyers have more time than they have clients that can afford to hire them and they write diatribes as above.√
 
Teachers are professionals, as are doctors, laywers, nurses, and engineers. The idea that some panel of people in
fields other than those specific professions, should come up with some scoring modus and apply it to those professions, would be absolute anathema to the members of those professions.

Yet in terms of the teaching profession, everyone's a critic and they don't appear to think nothin' of it.

maybe teachers should be required to carry malpractice insurance as doctors......no
 
What makes you think teachers don't compete?
We want our kids to do better than other schools..
I love parents who believe because they went to school, they are experts. I wonder why parents of kids who do poorly blame the teacher, and the kids who do well? It's in the genes

You taught inner schools and evidently had those parents that blamed YOU for kids doing poorly, or did you ever meet those kids parents. One post you claim teachers work together and in next post they compete to have better school than other teachers.........geeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeezus☻
 
It is quite an insult to believe that teachers don't care about raising test scores....it is a reflection on us. But there are realities like having the top class that will usually do better than a bottom class. I have had top classes soar and had bottom classes go up a few months and that was an accomplishment. Different dynamics
I think we should get rid of tenure, and raise teachers salaries so we can attract those who are the best and brightest

Like the White House and Congress.......it's evident $$$$$$$$$$$$ work there either.......School Administration is where the BIG $$$$$$$$$ is and wasted......
 
All told - from the beginning of my "learning career" to the most recent end, I imagine I've had about 80 teachers. IF I were to go back through them all and choose out the top-10, I'm certaind they'd have one thing in common. They'd all be quite different from one another. Therefore, it makes absolutely no sense to me, that lay people could come up with some sort of "one size fits all" testing regime for them.

My concern - which I've gotta say, is born out by the current names and realities - is that it's the STEM-type people who seem to be taking the lead on all this. And for them, learning is much more about some sort of "data downloading" process. That's fine for them but, we won't know what we've lost 'til its gone, if we let them take over the entire process.

I always tell my audiences of new teachers to find a teacher who made a difference in their lives and tell her/him...same to all of you.
I mentioned the 16 kids I had from. MY first year honoring me....it was one of the highlights of my life. Teaching is so rewarding and has enriched my life so much....just knowing you touch so many lives is one of life's rewards.
 
So in your world here, teachers would neglect the kids who perform well?
No. In my world, the best teachers would migrate to the kids who most need good teachers.

Just to give you a sense for where I'm coming from, I was essentially an auto-didact. I had a habit of skipping lots of classes, because i have a low tolerance for boredom and I learn best when I pick the topic and timing of my study myself. Law school was wonderful fo me, because 100% of the grade is based on the final exam, so you can quite literally skip every single class and yet get a good grade, and I very nearly did that for some classes (going to the first class, then the last couple before the exam, and skipping the rest). Teachers aren't terribly important to me. But the stats say they're extremely important to people generally, and that suggests to me that they're vastly more important to people who are unlike me (those who struggle academically). So, with limited talent to distribute, why not distribute it more to where it will have a bigger impact?
 
One of the best things about teaching is that teachers work in cooperation with each other. I do not like the idea of teachers competing
I can understand that, but if it was done properly, the competition would be set up in a way that wouldn't interfere with the collaboration. What you'd need to do is have the bonus pool managed at a state level, or better yet, at the national level, so that it would be possible for teachers within a school or a school district to rise without having to push down their peers.

For example, you could get a big bonus as a seventh grade history teacher even if your school's other seventh grade history teacher did even better, since you'd be judged in relation to the progress your students made relative to demographically similar seventh grade history students state-wide or nationally. That way you'd have an incentive to cooperate with other teachers for your mutual advantage, since the ability of nearby teachers to help you boost your numbers (and vice versa) would be greater than any worry that those nearby teachers would have a statistically meaningful effect in raising your overall benchmark.

That might, theoretically, still interfere with some kinds of cooperation. For example, you and other nearby teachers might have an incentive to treat some successful teaching innovations as "trade secrets," rather than sharing them generally with others in the field and thereby losing your advantage. But I suspect that wouldn't actually be a meaningful factor, given all the other advantages, in prestige and job opportunities, that would come to someone who was known as such a successful innovator as to have the ability to have a state-wide or nation-wide impact on education.
 
Teachers are professionals, as are doctors, laywers, nurses, and engineers. The idea that some panel of people in
fields other than those specific professions, should come up with some scoring modus and apply it to those professions, would be absolute anathema to the members of those professions.

Yet in terms of the teaching profession, everyone's a critic and they don't appear to think nothin' of it.

I think the standards should be set by professional educators -- teachers, professors, etc., the same way medical standards are set by medical professionals (doctors and nurses) and legal standards are set by legal professionals (lawyers and judges).
 
Back
Top