New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

For Deficit Hawks

Arkady

President
Now that we're pretty sure the election will be Clinton vs. Trump, let's move beyond the horse-race analysis and consider actual policy questions.

First: taxes. For the last seven years, most conservatives have claimed to be very concerned about deficits. Even though deficits had fallen by about 2/3, between Bush's last budget and FY 2015, and even though many top economists thought increased deficit spending was a good idea to stimulate the economy, conservatives said they were concerned that continued deficits would result in soaring interest rates and a plummeting dollar, so we had to address them immediately, even if that took triggering a crisis by not raising the debt ceiling.

Let's set aside the possibility that this was just a "kitchen sink" attack -- where Republicans were throwing any criticism they could get their hands on at Obama, regardless of whether they believed it. Let's assume they really did think deficits were a central issue that should drive public policy. What does that mean for the 2016 election?

The non-partisan tax policy center has analyzed the Clinton and Trump tax plans. Clinton has proposed some upper-class tax hikes, including increased estate and gift taxes, along with some changes in corporate taxes. Over the next decade, the changes would mean about $110 billion of extra revenue per year, average. Other things being equal, this would lower deficits by about one-fifth.

The same outfit has analyzed the Trump tax plan. Trump has proposed very large tax cuts, the vast majority of the benefit of which would flow to the very rich. Over the next decade, the net impact of the changes would lower revenues by an average of about $950 billion per year. Other things being equal, this would nearly triple the deficit.

The choice for any genuine deficit hawk is clear. But since many conservatives spent the Obama years playing at being deficit hawks, and yet still want to vote for the Republican, I suppose they'll point out that Trump's plan would only increase deficits if spending didn't drop by even more. But let's take an honest look at the historical numbers. Here's the actual percentage increase in federal outlays in each four-year presidential term since WWII (using as the baseline the FY of the last budget passed before that term):

Truman 95.96
Eisenhower 0.63
Eisenhower 27.61
Kennedy 20.98
Johnson 55.33
Nixon 33.80
Ford 66.55
Carter 65.74
Reagan 39.53
Reagan 20.86
Bush 23.23
Clinton 13.60
Clinton 16.35
Bush 32.70
Bush 42.30
Obama -1.79

In all that time, we only cut federal spending over a four-year term once (under Obama). So, let's say Trump manages to duplicate the rare accomplishment of Obama's first term and lower federal spending. Heck, let's go all out and say he's "yugely" successful and manages to cut federal spending twice as much in his four years than any other president managed in any four-year term since WWII. In other words, he cuts it 3.58%. In that case, after factoring out the growth that's otherwise projected to happen, outlays would be $928 billion lower than currently projected in his fourth year, while revenues would average $950 billion less per year. So, even with that assumption of unrealistic cost-cutting, deficits would still rise substantially: $22 billion up, versus Clinton's $110 billion down.

Now stop and think about what it would require to find $950 billion in savings in our budget. The largest area of discretionary spending is the military, and certainly hundreds of billions of savings could be found there. But even though Trump is open to military spending cuts, he's been hazy about it, other than saying 3% of GNP would be too low for defense. At best, that means he might find about $100 billion of the $950 billion he'd need there. Where would the rest come from? If you set aside the Pentagon's budget, and rule out defaulting on our Medicare, Social Security, and veterans' and other retiree benefits obligations, and rule out defaulting on our debt, how much do you have left to play with? About $1.5 trillion. To find $950 billion in that part of the budget, you'd need to cut by an average of almost 2/3. Picture trying to get by, with crumbling national infrastructure, if we had only one-third our current transportation budget. Picture our already strained lower classes having a third as much help when it comes to things like healthcare and nutrition for the children of the destitute. It's just not realistic.

So, anyone voting for Trump: is it that you've decided you were wrong about the importance of deficits, or were you only pretending you cared about them? Any serious analysis says that if Trump got his way on taxes, deficits would wind up between two or three times their present level, even allowing for much more serious cost-cutting than we've ever seen under a Republican president.
 
Does this "extra $110B" presume status quo spending based on FY 2016 levels, or does it merely state that the government will bring in that amount of additional dollars?

Does it factor in any budget-busting likelihoods of additional INCREASED spending to align with stated policy proposals?

In another words, are we intentionally leaving out known (as well as yet to be articulated) additional EXPENDITURES and blindly citing one increment of revenue increase in a vacuum in order to bamboozle?
 
Does this "extra $110B" presume status quo spending based on FY 2016 levels, or does it merely state that the government will bring in that amount of additional dollars?

The $110 billion simply represents the shift to the black from the revenue increase, without calculating the impact of any changes to spending. If someone wants to project changes to spending, based on actual policy proposals, I'd be interested to see that.

For now, let's just do a "back of the napkin" calculation. Presently, budget projections for FY 2018 through FY 2021 have outlays rising 23.6%. In Bill Clinton's first four years, they rose 13.6%. If we projected the same rate of change on Hillary Clinton's watch, while adding $110 billion to revenues for year four, the deficit in the last budget of her first term would be about $30 billion, compared to the present projection of a $552 billion deficit for that year.

Even though the math works out for that, my gut tells me that's overly optimistic. A Hillary Clinton presidency would face a higher share of firm spending commitments than her husband did, with the expansion of Medicare and SS from Boomers retiring. So, I'm not expecting that kind of dramatic decline in deficits. But, to be fair, I didn't expect it during Bill Clinton's presidency, and it happened all the same.

One way or the other, the gap between Clinton's +$110 billion shift in revenues and Trump's -$950 billion in revenues means a $1.06 trillion gap between the two. Even we project forward unusually high spending growth under Clinton (say growing outlays by a third in her first term, the way we did in Bush's first term), and historic spending cuts under Trump (say cutting outlays by some small percent the way we did in Obama's first term), we still come out vastly better, from a deficit-hawk perspective, under Clinton.
 
yeah - you're doing what you previously castigated others for: switching between "annual deficit" and "national debt"

(most) people are concerned about annual budget deficits because they continue to add to the national debt. when the national debt reaches 90% of GDP (according to many economists) then cost of servicing that debt becomes a real danger, and a nation finds it difficult to fund other obligations.

So any individual year's annual deficit (or surplus) is not cause for my own alarm or celebration. but the fact that the national debt is nearly doubled (from $10 trillion when Obama took office to 19.2 trillion today) is mind boggling. The debt per each of America's 100 million families is now $190,000. And the US GDP is about 18-19 trillion (growth has been anemic under Obama), so the national debt is now more than 100% of GDP - a huge warning sign

We are in the same zone as Greece, Italy, Portugal, Spain, and France, in terms of excessive debt, if that helps.

America is under performing (by a wide margin) peers such as the UK, Germany, Canada, Australia . . .

Even nations we consider 3rd world/backwards, are in much better shape regarding debt to GDP

Mexico (30%)
Indonesia (27%)
Pakistan (65%)
Philippines (45%)
Ethiopia (29%)

review the complete list here: http://www.tradingeconomics.com/country-list/government-debt-to-gdp

as interest rates inevitably rise (the fed probably won't keep printing "free money" forever - it would cause hyperinflation and market crashes) the cost of servicing our national debt will escalate dramatically.

each 100 basis point (1%) increase interest rates will add about $200 billion to our annual budget expense, further crippling our ability to spend money on schools, infrastructure, defense, social programs, etc.

there are no examples of nations which let debt and spending get out of control, which had a happy ending, Ark. You probably know that already.

So why pretend otherwise, except for the purposes of partisan support of a failed presidential administration?
 
The $110 billion simply represents the shift to the black from the revenue increase, without calculating the impact of any changes to spending. If someone wants to project changes to spending, based on actual policy proposals, I'd be interested to see that.

For now, let's just do a "back of the napkin" calculation. Presently, budget projections for FY 2018 through FY 2021 have outlays rising 23.6%. In Bill Clinton's first four years, they rose 13.6%. If we projected the same rate of change on Hillary Clinton's watch, while adding $110 billion to revenues for year four, the deficit in the last budget of her first term would be about $30 billion, compared to the present projection of a $552 billion deficit for that year.

Even though the math works out for that, my gut tells me that's overly optimistic. A Hillary Clinton presidency would face a higher share of firm spending commitments than her husband did, with the expansion of Medicare and SS from Boomers retiring. So, I'm not expecting that kind of dramatic decline in deficits. But, to be fair, I didn't expect it during Bill Clinton's presidency, and it happened all the same.

One way or the other, the gap between Clinton's +$110 billion shift in revenues and Trump's -$950 billion in revenues means a $1.06 trillion gap between the two. Even we project forward unusually high spending growth under Clinton (say growing outlays by a third in her first term, the way we did in Bush's first term), and historic spending cuts under Trump (say cutting outlays by some small percent the way we did in Obama's first term), we still come out vastly better, from a deficit-hawk perspective, under Clinton.
As a committed voter for neither of those two profound national embarrassments, my curiosity is this:

Our USA policies are on an increasingly socialistic trajectory. It's probably a safe bet that healthcare will be increasingly subsidized publicly. Likewise, the constant drumbeat for higher education subsidization is becoming deafening. It is not unreasonable to project historic increases - not just in budget year expenditure, but in structural, permanent formats. Institutionally-fixed liabilities (fixed in the sense that they are driven by permanent infrastructure. The costs will certainly not be fixed, and will rise year over year).

A voter could certainly look to the philosophic underpinnings of candidates/parties and do some educated forecasting of likely policy outcomes of one candidate versus another and associated committed expenditures year over year. Tax policy would need to be similarly "fluid" (and not in a good way).

Based on what I know of progressive ambitions as well as Republican ones, any folks who have fiscal concerns should move toward the libertarians (and that doesn't even take into consideration the individual autonomy/liberty aspects).
 
As a committed voter for neither of those two profound national embarrassments, my curiosity is this:

Our USA policies are on an increasingly socialistic trajectory. It's probably a safe bet that healthcare will be increasingly subsidized publicly. Likewise, the constant drumbeat for higher education subsidization is becoming deafening. It is not unreasonable to project historic increases - not just in budget year expenditure, but in structural, permanent formats. Institutionally-fixed liabilities (fixed in the sense that they are driven by permanent infrastructure. The costs will certainly not be fixed, and will rise year over year).

A voter could certainly look to the philosophic underpinnings of candidates/parties and do some educated forecasting of likely policy outcomes of one candidate versus another and associated committed expenditures year over year. Tax policy would need to be similarly "fluid" (and not in a good way).

Based on what I know of progressive ambitions as well as Republican ones, any folks who have fiscal concerns should move toward the libertarians (and that doesn't even take into consideration the individual autonomy/liberty aspects).
higher education is already very well subsidized.

people can attend community colleges for minimal cost - state legislatures pick up most of the tab. these same states could make the University of My Own state completely free if they wanted to as well. The reason they do not, is because taxpayers in those states won't approve of that sort of budget buster.

the notion that the federal government is going to step in and make all colleges everywhere free - without pain - and that the quality of students and graduation rates is going to be positively affected s ludicrous.

things that are given away for free are dissed and under valued by the recipients. Just visit your local public high school if you doubt this.
 
Now that we're pretty sure the election will be Clinton vs. Trump, let's move beyond the horse-race analysis and consider actual policy questions.

First: taxes. For the last seven years, most conservatives have claimed to be very concerned about deficits. Even though deficits had fallen by about 2/3, between Bush's last budget and FY 2015, and even though many top economists thought increased deficit spending was a good idea to stimulate the economy, conservatives said they were concerned that continued deficits would result in soaring interest rates and a plummeting dollar, so we had to address them immediately, even if that took triggering a crisis by not raising the debt ceiling.

Let's set aside the possibility that this was just a "kitchen sink" attack -- where Republicans were throwing any criticism they could get their hands on at Obama, regardless of whether they believed it. Let's assume they really did think deficits were a central issue that should drive public policy. What does that mean for the 2016 election?

The non-partisan tax policy center has analyzed the Clinton and Trump tax plans. Clinton has proposed some upper-class tax hikes, including increased estate and gift taxes, along with some changes in corporate taxes. Over the next decade, the changes would mean about $110 billion of extra revenue per year, average. Other things being equal, this would lower deficits by about one-fifth.

The same outfit has analyzed the Trump tax plan. Trump has proposed very large tax cuts, the vast majority of the benefit of which would flow to the very rich. Over the next decade, the net impact of the changes would lower revenues by an average of about $950 billion per year. Other things being equal, this would nearly triple the deficit.

The choice for any genuine deficit hawk is clear. But since many conservatives spent the Obama years playing at being deficit hawks, and yet still want to vote for the Republican, I suppose they'll point out that Trump's plan would only increase deficits if spending didn't drop by even more. But let's take an honest look at the historical numbers. Here's the actual percentage increase in federal outlays in each four-year presidential term since WWII (using as the baseline the FY of the last budget passed before that term):

Truman 95.96
Eisenhower 0.63
Eisenhower 27.61
Kennedy 20.98
Johnson 55.33
Nixon 33.80
Ford 66.55
Carter 65.74
Reagan 39.53
Reagan 20.86
Bush 23.23
Clinton 13.60
Clinton 16.35
Bush 32.70
Bush 42.30
Obama -1.79

In all that time, we only cut federal spending over a four-year term once (under Obama). So, let's say Trump manages to duplicate the rare accomplishment of Obama's first term and lower federal spending. Heck, let's go all out and say he's "yugely" successful and manages to cut federal spending twice as much in his four years than any other president managed in any four-year term since WWII. In other words, he cuts it 3.58%. In that case, after factoring out the growth that's otherwise projected to happen, outlays would be $928 billion lower than currently projected in his fourth year, while revenues would average $950 billion less per year. So, even with that assumption of unrealistic cost-cutting, deficits would still rise substantially: $22 billion up, versus Clinton's $110 billion down.

Now stop and think about what it would require to find $950 billion in savings in our budget. The largest area of discretionary spending is the military, and certainly hundreds of billions of savings could be found there. But even though Trump is open to military spending cuts, he's been hazy about it, other than saying 3% of GNP would be too low for defense. At best, that means he might find about $100 billion of the $950 billion he'd need there. Where would the rest come from? If you set aside the Pentagon's budget, and rule out defaulting on our Medicare, Social Security, and veterans' and other retiree benefits obligations, and rule out defaulting on our debt, how much do you have left to play with? About $1.5 trillion. To find $950 billion in that part of the budget, you'd need to cut by an average of almost 2/3. Picture trying to get by, with crumbling national infrastructure, if we had only one-third our current transportation budget. Picture our already strained lower classes having a third as much help when it comes to things like healthcare and nutrition for the children of the destitute. It's just not realistic.

So, anyone voting for Trump: is it that you've decided you were wrong about the importance of deficits, or were you only pretending you cared about them? Any serious analysis says that if Trump got his way on taxes, deficits would wind up between two or three times their present level, even allowing for much more serious cost-cutting than we've ever seen under a Republican president.


Lets start with your first assumption which is wrong

1. Deficits...no one cares about the deficit..we care about the actual debt. Obama had the largest deficit reduction...also had the largest tax increase and the largest expenses.
https://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/

2. The non partisan tax policy center..which remains nameless and not linked? How interesting

So lets cut to the chase...Obama's debt record was horrible...10 trillion of debt, which we all know is approved by the house and senate before it can be signed off on by the President....this is how Bill Clinton's Presidency looked to debt free. The only way Obama has reduced the deficits is through raising taxes.
https://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/


Using deficits is a distraction from the real truth...since Democrats have had either veto power or deficit(House Senate or Presidency) the debt has increased.

01/03/2007.......8,677,214,255,313.07

05/02/2016.......19,170,001,895,674.07

http://www.treasurydirect.gov/NP/debt/current

The debt is real...deficits are B$ll sh#t
 
The $110 billion simply represents the shift to the black from the revenue increase, without calculating the impact of any changes to spending. If someone wants to project changes to spending, based on actual policy proposals, I'd be interested to see that.

For now, let's just do a "back of the napkin" calculation. Presently, budget projections for FY 2018 through FY 2021 have outlays rising 23.6%. In Bill Clinton's first four years, they rose 13.6%. If we projected the same rate of change on Hillary Clinton's watch, while adding $110 billion to revenues for year four, the deficit in the last budget of her first term would be about $30 billion, compared to the present projection of a $552 billion deficit for that year.

Even though the math works out for that, my gut tells me that's overly optimistic. A Hillary Clinton presidency would face a higher share of firm spending commitments than her husband did, with the expansion of Medicare and SS from Boomers retiring. So, I'm not expecting that kind of dramatic decline in deficits. But, to be fair, I didn't expect it during Bill Clinton's presidency, and it happened all the same.

One way or the other, the gap between Clinton's +$110 billion shift in revenues and Trump's -$950 billion in revenues means a $1.06 trillion gap between the two. Even we project forward unusually high spending growth under Clinton (say growing outlays by a third in her first term, the way we did in Bush's first term), and historic spending cuts under Trump (say cutting outlays by some small percent the way we did in Obama's first term), we still come out vastly better, from a deficit-hawk perspective, under Clinton.

That sounds like a democratic who supports Clinton....although the last we had a Clinton Presidency and a Republican Congress to stop Clinton we had very little debt increases.
 
Our USA policies are on an increasingly socialistic trajectory.

I'd agree they're on a socialistic trajectory, though I'd argue they've been on that same overall trajectory for at least 120 years. That includes when it comes to things like healthcare (with Medicare and Medicaid, CHP, and Romneycare, before Obamacare), as well as education. The first public high school was founded (in Boston) in 1821, by 1870 there were publicly-financed elementary schools in every state, and by 1918, elementary school was compulsory in every state. Gradually, public education expanded out through high school, and then expansion of public college started, with Land Grant colleges, the GI Bill, subsidized loans, and Pell Grants. It's been a gradual socialization of education spanning well over a century, and it has served the people well. Understandably, given that success, many are eager to continue on that trajectory.

Based on what I know of progressive ambitions as well as Republican ones, any folks who have fiscal concerns should move toward the libertarians (and that doesn't even take into consideration the individual autonomy/liberty aspects).

I can sympathize with the sentiment, but as a practical matter we're a two-party system. If you're in a non-competitive state, by all means make a statement by voting for a Libertarian candidate, or a Green one, or a Socialist, or a Pirate, or whatever direction you think is best that isn't being reflected by either of the two main parties. But if you're in a competitive state, you have an opportunity to at least factor into selecting the better of the two realistic options, and the responsible thing would be to take that opportunity. As between Clinton and Trump, any realistic forecast will have deficits rising much more under Trump, so if you think deficits are a really important consideration, the choice there is clear.
 
higher education is already very well subsidized.

people can attend community colleges for minimal cost - state legislatures pick up most of the tab. these same states could make the University of My Own state completely free if they wanted to as well. The reason they do not, is because taxpayers in those states won't approve of that sort of budget buster.

the notion that the federal government is going to step in and make all colleges everywhere free - without pain - and that the quality of students and graduation rates is going to be positively affected s ludicrous.

things that are given away for free are dissed and under valued by the recipients. Just visit your local public high school if you doubt this.
Public high schools are an excellent analogy. Certainly there's some tendency to take that education for granted that wouldn't be there is students' parents were paying an arm an a leg to have them there. And I'd wager that the average quality of a high school student is down considerably from the 19th century, when mostly it was only elite students from the ruling class that was educated to that level. Yet, despite those things, I think it's clear public high schools have benefited our nation. Even if the average high-schooler is less impressive today than the average high-schooler from a century or two ago, because of public financing of those schools, it's also true that the average American is FAR better educated today than the average American from a century or two ago, for those same reasons. And that's a much more consequential factor for our society.

In the same way, if we make college free to the students, chances are the quality of the average college student will go down, but the education-level of the average American will rise, and that will be a lot more consequential. That improvement of human capital will fuel stronger economic growth and greater social improvement.
 
Great! Let's make the Eisenhower tax code the law of the land today! You get your top 90%+ top tax rate and business get all the pro business/growth deductions.

Of course that will result in business paying way less taxes, but what difference does it make? You got your 90%+ top tax rate and you can screetch how productive a 90% tax rate it and how wonderful govt is.
 
higher education is already very well subsidized.

people can attend community colleges for minimal cost - state legislatures pick up most of the tab. these same states could make the University of My Own state completely free if they wanted to as well. The reason they do not, is because taxpayers in those states won't approve of that sort of budget buster.

the notion that the federal government is going to step in and make all colleges everywhere free - without pain - and that the quality of students and graduation rates is going to be positively affected s ludicrous.

things that are given away for free are dissed and under valued by the recipients. Just visit your local public high school if you doubt this.
It's coming. So is socialized (public) medicine.

I don't disagree with you, but the sloths outnumber the productive.
 
yeah - you're doing what you previously castigated others for: switching between "annual deficit" and "national debt"

No. I don't believe so. I'm being very clear about which I'm referring to.

(most) people are concerned about annual budget deficits because they continue to add to the national debt. when the national debt reaches 90% of GDP (according to many economists) then cost of servicing that debt becomes a real danger, and a nation finds it difficult to fund other obligations.

I assume you're referring to the debunked claim that ended up being a result of an error in an Excel formula:

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/19/opinion/krugman-the-excel-depression.html

So any individual year's annual deficit (or surplus) is not cause for my own alarm or celebration.

Same here. But the deficit figures I've derived here are based on 10-year revenue change numbers. Trump's tax cuts will reduce revenues by $9.5 TRILLION dollars over the course of a decade! That's on top of what was already projected to be an unbalanced budget, where revenues would fall short of outlays by about half a trillion bucks per year.

as interest rates inevitably rise (the fed probably won't keep printing "free money" forever - it would cause hyperinflation and market crashes)

We've been hearing breathless warnings about that from the usual suspects for about eight years now. They're hard to take seriously, at this point. But, even if the cost of servicing our debt does rise dramatically, it's got quite a bit of room to rise before becoming a serious problem. As a percent of GDP, net interest currently costs us 1.3%. Even if that doubled, it would still be far less than the average cost in the Reagan/Bush era (2.9%), much less the 3.2% we had in the early 90s.
there are no examples of nations which let debt and spending get out of control, which had a happy ending, Ark. You probably know that already.

Nobody has argued for letting them get out of control. The point of this post, is that if out-of-control debt scares you, you have a clear choice. Do you want the president whose tax plan will move us $110 billion towards the black, or the one whose tax plan will move us $950 billion towards the red? A lot of people have made a lot of noise for the past seven plus years about the problems of deficits and debt, and now they have a chance to show these were real concerns and not just a convenient partisan attack. I'm sure you and I both know how it'll actually turn out, though.
 
How does a President with a -1.79 deficit rate...the lowest ever incur more debt than all other President's combined while in office?

http://www.treasurydirect.gov/NP/debt/current
It is very easy to understand. First, it's not a -1.79% deficit rate. It's a 1.79% decline in spending over the first term. Second, he was left a record deficit, so even with that deficit falling by 2/3 in just a few years, that still meant years of running up a lot of debt.
 
Great! Let's make the Eisenhower tax code the law of the land today! You get your top 90%+ top tax rate and business get all the pro business/growth deductions.

Of course that will result in business paying way less taxes, but what difference does it make? You got your 90%+ top tax rate and you can screetch how productive a 90% tax rate it and how wonderful govt is.
Do you know what percentage of federal taxes were paid by corporations in the Eisenhower years? Between 21.8% and 30.5%, depending on the year. Do you know what the percentage is now? 8.8%.
 
No. I don't believe so. I'm being very clear about which I'm referring to.



I assume you're referring to the debunked claim that ended up being a result of an error in an Excel formula:

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/19/opinion/krugman-the-excel-depression.html



Same here. But the deficit figures I've derived here are based on 10-year revenue change numbers. Trump's tax cuts will reduce revenues by $9.5 TRILLION dollars over the course of a decade! That's on top of what was already projected to be an unbalanced budget, where revenues would fall short of outlays by about half a trillion bucks per year.



We've been hearing breathless warnings about that from the usual suspects for about eight years now. They're hard to take seriously, at this point. But, even if the cost of servicing our debt does rise dramatically, it's got quite a bit of room to rise before becoming a serious problem. As a percent of GDP, net interest currently costs us 1.3%. Even if that doubled, it would still be far less than the average cost in the Reagan/Bush era (2.9%), much less the 3.2% we had in the early 90s.


Nobody has argued for letting them get out of control. The point of this post, is that if out-of-control debt scares you, you have a clear choice. Do you want the president whose tax plan will move us $110 billion towards the black, or the one whose tax plan will move us $950 billion towards the red? A lot of people have made a lot of noise for the past seven plus years about the problems of deficits and debt, and now they have a chance to show these were real concerns and not just a convenient partisan attack. I'm sure you and I both know how it'll actually turn out, though.
Again, you fail to account for the more aggressive, budget-busting, entitlement-delivering bent of the candidate or party.

You're really going all out for Hillary - that's for sure.
 
Deficits...no one cares about the deficit

Interesting. I count 120 of your posts since the last presidential election with the word "deficit" in them.

2. The non partisan tax policy center..which remains nameless and not linked? How interesting

Its name is the Tax Policy Center:

http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/

It's the go-to source for non-partisan tax policy analysis.

Anyway, if you want to focus on debt instead of deficits, that's fine. But the ultimate conclusion is the same. Barring some completely unprecedented and wildly unrealistic spending cuts, a tax plan like Trumps would run up massive amounts of additional debt -- something like $9.8 trillion of extra debt (on top of what would already have been added) in ten years. Even if you imagine some pretty big spending increases under Clinton, there's no way debt would rise anywhere near as much under her tax plan as under Trump's. So, if debt concerns you, the choice is clear.
 
Again, you fail to account for the more aggressive, budget-busting, entitlement-delivering bent of the candidate or party.

You're really going all out for Hillary - that's for sure.
No, as you'll recall, I responded specifically to that point, by analyzing what would happen to deficits if spending grew on Hillary Clinton's watch at the same pace it did on her husband's watch. If you have some other analysis that incorporates projected spending levels for each candidate, feel free to share it.
 
No, as you'll recall, I responded specifically to that point, by analyzing what would happen to deficits if spending grew on Hillary Clinton's watch at the same pace it did on her husband's watch. If you have some other analysis that incorporates projected spending levels for each candidate, feel free to share it.
Common sense, Ark. You are appealing to conservatives who are deficit hawks among other things. Suggesting that Hillary is the rational choice based on the single data point that she will raise taxes is patently silly.

Getting a bit desperate, are we?
 
Back
Top