Arkady
President
Now that we're pretty sure the election will be Clinton vs. Trump, let's move beyond the horse-race analysis and consider actual policy questions.
First: taxes. For the last seven years, most conservatives have claimed to be very concerned about deficits. Even though deficits had fallen by about 2/3, between Bush's last budget and FY 2015, and even though many top economists thought increased deficit spending was a good idea to stimulate the economy, conservatives said they were concerned that continued deficits would result in soaring interest rates and a plummeting dollar, so we had to address them immediately, even if that took triggering a crisis by not raising the debt ceiling.
Let's set aside the possibility that this was just a "kitchen sink" attack -- where Republicans were throwing any criticism they could get their hands on at Obama, regardless of whether they believed it. Let's assume they really did think deficits were a central issue that should drive public policy. What does that mean for the 2016 election?
The non-partisan tax policy center has analyzed the Clinton and Trump tax plans. Clinton has proposed some upper-class tax hikes, including increased estate and gift taxes, along with some changes in corporate taxes. Over the next decade, the changes would mean about $110 billion of extra revenue per year, average. Other things being equal, this would lower deficits by about one-fifth.
The same outfit has analyzed the Trump tax plan. Trump has proposed very large tax cuts, the vast majority of the benefit of which would flow to the very rich. Over the next decade, the net impact of the changes would lower revenues by an average of about $950 billion per year. Other things being equal, this would nearly triple the deficit.
The choice for any genuine deficit hawk is clear. But since many conservatives spent the Obama years playing at being deficit hawks, and yet still want to vote for the Republican, I suppose they'll point out that Trump's plan would only increase deficits if spending didn't drop by even more. But let's take an honest look at the historical numbers. Here's the actual percentage increase in federal outlays in each four-year presidential term since WWII (using as the baseline the FY of the last budget passed before that term):
Truman 95.96
Eisenhower 0.63
Eisenhower 27.61
Kennedy 20.98
Johnson 55.33
Nixon 33.80
Ford 66.55
Carter 65.74
Reagan 39.53
Reagan 20.86
Bush 23.23
Clinton 13.60
Clinton 16.35
Bush 32.70
Bush 42.30
Obama -1.79
In all that time, we only cut federal spending over a four-year term once (under Obama). So, let's say Trump manages to duplicate the rare accomplishment of Obama's first term and lower federal spending. Heck, let's go all out and say he's "yugely" successful and manages to cut federal spending twice as much in his four years than any other president managed in any four-year term since WWII. In other words, he cuts it 3.58%. In that case, after factoring out the growth that's otherwise projected to happen, outlays would be $928 billion lower than currently projected in his fourth year, while revenues would average $950 billion less per year. So, even with that assumption of unrealistic cost-cutting, deficits would still rise substantially: $22 billion up, versus Clinton's $110 billion down.
Now stop and think about what it would require to find $950 billion in savings in our budget. The largest area of discretionary spending is the military, and certainly hundreds of billions of savings could be found there. But even though Trump is open to military spending cuts, he's been hazy about it, other than saying 3% of GNP would be too low for defense. At best, that means he might find about $100 billion of the $950 billion he'd need there. Where would the rest come from? If you set aside the Pentagon's budget, and rule out defaulting on our Medicare, Social Security, and veterans' and other retiree benefits obligations, and rule out defaulting on our debt, how much do you have left to play with? About $1.5 trillion. To find $950 billion in that part of the budget, you'd need to cut by an average of almost 2/3. Picture trying to get by, with crumbling national infrastructure, if we had only one-third our current transportation budget. Picture our already strained lower classes having a third as much help when it comes to things like healthcare and nutrition for the children of the destitute. It's just not realistic.
So, anyone voting for Trump: is it that you've decided you were wrong about the importance of deficits, or were you only pretending you cared about them? Any serious analysis says that if Trump got his way on taxes, deficits would wind up between two or three times their present level, even allowing for much more serious cost-cutting than we've ever seen under a Republican president.
First: taxes. For the last seven years, most conservatives have claimed to be very concerned about deficits. Even though deficits had fallen by about 2/3, between Bush's last budget and FY 2015, and even though many top economists thought increased deficit spending was a good idea to stimulate the economy, conservatives said they were concerned that continued deficits would result in soaring interest rates and a plummeting dollar, so we had to address them immediately, even if that took triggering a crisis by not raising the debt ceiling.
Let's set aside the possibility that this was just a "kitchen sink" attack -- where Republicans were throwing any criticism they could get their hands on at Obama, regardless of whether they believed it. Let's assume they really did think deficits were a central issue that should drive public policy. What does that mean for the 2016 election?
The non-partisan tax policy center has analyzed the Clinton and Trump tax plans. Clinton has proposed some upper-class tax hikes, including increased estate and gift taxes, along with some changes in corporate taxes. Over the next decade, the changes would mean about $110 billion of extra revenue per year, average. Other things being equal, this would lower deficits by about one-fifth.
The same outfit has analyzed the Trump tax plan. Trump has proposed very large tax cuts, the vast majority of the benefit of which would flow to the very rich. Over the next decade, the net impact of the changes would lower revenues by an average of about $950 billion per year. Other things being equal, this would nearly triple the deficit.
The choice for any genuine deficit hawk is clear. But since many conservatives spent the Obama years playing at being deficit hawks, and yet still want to vote for the Republican, I suppose they'll point out that Trump's plan would only increase deficits if spending didn't drop by even more. But let's take an honest look at the historical numbers. Here's the actual percentage increase in federal outlays in each four-year presidential term since WWII (using as the baseline the FY of the last budget passed before that term):
Truman 95.96
Eisenhower 0.63
Eisenhower 27.61
Kennedy 20.98
Johnson 55.33
Nixon 33.80
Ford 66.55
Carter 65.74
Reagan 39.53
Reagan 20.86
Bush 23.23
Clinton 13.60
Clinton 16.35
Bush 32.70
Bush 42.30
Obama -1.79
In all that time, we only cut federal spending over a four-year term once (under Obama). So, let's say Trump manages to duplicate the rare accomplishment of Obama's first term and lower federal spending. Heck, let's go all out and say he's "yugely" successful and manages to cut federal spending twice as much in his four years than any other president managed in any four-year term since WWII. In other words, he cuts it 3.58%. In that case, after factoring out the growth that's otherwise projected to happen, outlays would be $928 billion lower than currently projected in his fourth year, while revenues would average $950 billion less per year. So, even with that assumption of unrealistic cost-cutting, deficits would still rise substantially: $22 billion up, versus Clinton's $110 billion down.
Now stop and think about what it would require to find $950 billion in savings in our budget. The largest area of discretionary spending is the military, and certainly hundreds of billions of savings could be found there. But even though Trump is open to military spending cuts, he's been hazy about it, other than saying 3% of GNP would be too low for defense. At best, that means he might find about $100 billion of the $950 billion he'd need there. Where would the rest come from? If you set aside the Pentagon's budget, and rule out defaulting on our Medicare, Social Security, and veterans' and other retiree benefits obligations, and rule out defaulting on our debt, how much do you have left to play with? About $1.5 trillion. To find $950 billion in that part of the budget, you'd need to cut by an average of almost 2/3. Picture trying to get by, with crumbling national infrastructure, if we had only one-third our current transportation budget. Picture our already strained lower classes having a third as much help when it comes to things like healthcare and nutrition for the children of the destitute. It's just not realistic.
So, anyone voting for Trump: is it that you've decided you were wrong about the importance of deficits, or were you only pretending you cared about them? Any serious analysis says that if Trump got his way on taxes, deficits would wind up between two or three times their present level, even allowing for much more serious cost-cutting than we've ever seen under a Republican president.