Arkady
President
One of my complaints about many of my fellow liberals here is that they seem to support whatever Obama supports, no matter what that happens to be at the moment. If Obama did something, it was good-by-definition, even if it's something that Obama, himself, previously criticized (with full-throated agreement from liberals). I'm not like that. I support Obama when I think he's right, and attack him when I think he's wrong.
So, I'm issuing a challenge: do you think Obama should refuse to support/sign anything that reopens government/raises the debt ceiling, in exchange for some meaningful political ransom payment to the Republicans?
I suspect many here want it both ways. If Obama digs his heels in and refuses to compromise, I think most of us liberals will say that was the right thing to do. But I think if Obama instead gives into the extortion and gives the Republicans something of real value to get them to move, many of the exact same liberals will say that was the right thing to do. So, I'm challenging liberals here to take a position now, before they know what Obama will do, so that it's possible for them to be at odds with him if he decides the other way.
I'll start. I support Obama denying any meaningful ransom. The only exception would be a "compromise" that amounted to a functionally meaningless "face saving" offer to the GOP (e.g., agreeing to a non-binding panel investigation into x, y, and z), just to give the Republicans something to cling to, or a "compromise" that merely kicks the problem down the road by a year. If Obama sticks to that, I'll praise him, even if the result is terrible, economically (the alterative is worse). If he offers up something more substantial, or agrees to a shorter duration of kicking the can down the road (a week, a month), I'll criticize him. How about you?
So, I'm issuing a challenge: do you think Obama should refuse to support/sign anything that reopens government/raises the debt ceiling, in exchange for some meaningful political ransom payment to the Republicans?
I suspect many here want it both ways. If Obama digs his heels in and refuses to compromise, I think most of us liberals will say that was the right thing to do. But I think if Obama instead gives into the extortion and gives the Republicans something of real value to get them to move, many of the exact same liberals will say that was the right thing to do. So, I'm challenging liberals here to take a position now, before they know what Obama will do, so that it's possible for them to be at odds with him if he decides the other way.
I'll start. I support Obama denying any meaningful ransom. The only exception would be a "compromise" that amounted to a functionally meaningless "face saving" offer to the GOP (e.g., agreeing to a non-binding panel investigation into x, y, and z), just to give the Republicans something to cling to, or a "compromise" that merely kicks the problem down the road by a year. If Obama sticks to that, I'll praise him, even if the result is terrible, economically (the alterative is worse). If he offers up something more substantial, or agrees to a shorter duration of kicking the can down the road (a week, a month), I'll criticize him. How about you?