New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

For liberals only.

Arkady

President
One of my complaints about many of my fellow liberals here is that they seem to support whatever Obama supports, no matter what that happens to be at the moment. If Obama did something, it was good-by-definition, even if it's something that Obama, himself, previously criticized (with full-throated agreement from liberals). I'm not like that. I support Obama when I think he's right, and attack him when I think he's wrong.

So, I'm issuing a challenge: do you think Obama should refuse to support/sign anything that reopens government/raises the debt ceiling, in exchange for some meaningful political ransom payment to the Republicans?

I suspect many here want it both ways. If Obama digs his heels in and refuses to compromise, I think most of us liberals will say that was the right thing to do. But I think if Obama instead gives into the extortion and gives the Republicans something of real value to get them to move, many of the exact same liberals will say that was the right thing to do. So, I'm challenging liberals here to take a position now, before they know what Obama will do, so that it's possible for them to be at odds with him if he decides the other way.

I'll start. I support Obama denying any meaningful ransom. The only exception would be a "compromise" that amounted to a functionally meaningless "face saving" offer to the GOP (e.g., agreeing to a non-binding panel investigation into x, y, and z), just to give the Republicans something to cling to, or a "compromise" that merely kicks the problem down the road by a year. If Obama sticks to that, I'll praise him, even if the result is terrible, economically (the alterative is worse). If he offers up something more substantial, or agrees to a shorter duration of kicking the can down the road (a week, a month), I'll criticize him. How about you?
 
One of my complaints about many of my fellow liberals here is that they seem to support whatever Obama supports, no matter what that happens to be at the moment. If Obama did something, it was good-by-definition, even if it's something that Obama, himself, previously criticized (with full-throated agreement from liberals). I'm not like that. I support Obama when I think he's right, and attack him when I think he's wrong.

So, I'm issuing a challenge: do you think Obama should refuse to support/sign anything that reopens government/raises the debt ceiling, in exchange for some meaningful political ransom payment to the Republicans?

I suspect many here want it both ways. If Obama digs his heels in and refuses to compromise, I think most of us liberals will say that was the right thing to do. But I think if Obama instead gives into the extortion and gives the Republicans something of real value to get them to move, many of the exact same liberals will say that was the right thing to do. So, I'm challenging liberals here to take a position now, before they know what Obama will do, so that it's possible for them to be at odds with him if he decides the other way.

I'll start. I support Obama denying any meaningful ransom. The only exception would be a "compromise" that amounted to a functionally meaningless "face saving" offer to the GOP (e.g., agreeing to a non-binding panel investigation into x, y, and z), just to give the Republicans something to cling to, or a "compromise" that merely kicks the problem down the road by a year. If Obama sticks to that, I'll praise him, even if the result is terrible, economically (the alterative is worse). If he offers up something more substantial, or agrees to a shorter duration of kicking the can down the road (a week, a month), I'll criticize him. How about you?

I'm pretty much with you Ark.. give them a token face-saver or two but nothing substantial. And whatever it is, CANNOT leave the debt ceiling hanging for another clusterfuk in just a few weeks from now. We simply can't allow these a-holes go govern like that or it will be never-ending.
 
I think he can agree to "talks" about entitlement reform....there are ideas that can be compromised (raising the cap AND raising the age eligibility).

But no quid pro quo. The GOP is in a death spiral....28% favorables, guys like Mike Lee at 51% unfavorable back home in Red-Red-RED Utah?

They hold the weak hand....let them maybe "save face" a little...but no guarantees.
 
This is a time to stand on principle. This issue is larger than partisan politics. The House Republicans are engaged in economic warfare against their own nation because they are afraid of the political repercussions of opposing their fringe, right-wing base.

I don't support any meaningful "compromise" to end this standoff.
 
Amusing that the only replies so far are from two of the biggest DNC hacks on the board. LOL! Never seen a post from either of these two that disagrees with Obama. Ever.
 
Hell no. He made that mistake once before.

He should offer NO concessions under the GOP's threats of extortion, other than a pledge to discuss anything after the GOP pulls its gun from the nation's head.
 
Hell no. He made that mistake once before.

He should offer NO concessions under the GOP's threats of extortion, other than a pledge to discuss anything after the GOP pulls its gun from the nation's head.


Really, buggy? "gun to the nation's head"? THAT the best way you could think of to describe this situation?

Let me try to help you out. I worry about how silly you insist on making yourself look in the eyes of normal folks.........

Lets look closely at what it is we are dealing with here, just to begin with I mean, ok?

Well we have republicans saying they will fund EVERYTHING in our government except ONE bill. We also have Democrats saying they want EVERYTHING funded.

Republicans say they will fund nothing if this one bill is included. Democrats say this bill WILL be included or they will accept the funding of nothing else.

So, Americans can have everything that the government ever had funded except this 1 new bill, republican option.
Or, Americans can have nothing that the government ever had funded including this 1 new bill, dim option.

Seems to ME that the republicans are more like holding a rubber band to the head of the nation and the Democrats who are holding the gun.
 
Amusing that the only replies so far are from two of the biggest DNC hacks on the board. LOL! Never seen a post from either of these two that disagrees with Obama. Ever.

I'm not very good about remembering which people said what. Without faces to go with the names, people tend to blur together for me. So I don't know if they're DNC hacks or not. But, the advantage of this post is that it calls for people to make their stand public now, before the course of events is known. I've set myself up to have to criticize Obama in three possible directions:

(1) If he causes a crisis by refusing even a meaningless face-saving gesture, like agreeing to form a non-binding commission to look into a proposal.

(2) If he offers up something of real value to the Republicans in exchange for avoiding the crisis (e.g., changing to chained-CPI for S.S.)

(3) If he just kicks the can a few weeks down the road, merely lengthening the crisis.

Although this thread is meant for liberals, I'd love to see conservatives step up and offer similar challenges for their own. Are there things that they'd attack the Republicans for? Are there things they'd praise Obama for? I think there are plenty of conservatives who think that anything Obama does is, by definition, the wrong thing. For example, when Obama offered up health care reform that was a conservative's wet dream (Heritage Foundation-designed, Mitt Romney-approved, for-profit-corporation-favoring), it instantly became a horrible thing in their eyes, merely because it was Obama who proposed it.
 
Really, buggy? "gun to the nation's head"? THAT the best way you could think of to describe this situation?

Let me try to help you out. I worry about how silly you insist on making yourself look in the eyes of normal folks.........

Lets look closely at what it is we are dealing with here, just to begin with I mean, ok?

Well we have republicans saying they will fund EVERYTHING in our government except ONE bill. We also have Democrats saying they want EVERYTHING funded.

Republicans say they will fund nothing if this one bill is included. Democrats say this bill WILL be included or they will accept the funding of nothing else.

So, Americans can have everything that the government ever had funded except this 1 new bill, republican option.
Or, Americans can have nothing that the government ever had funded including this 1 new bill, dim option.

Seems to ME that the republicans are more like holding a rubber band to the head of the nation and the Democrats who are holding the gun.

Sophistry is [Unwelcome language removed] hilarious! Honestly picture the shoe on the other foot for a minute. Picture if the Democrats were the ones saying they'd keep the government shut down unless, say, Republicans voted for a law banning hand guns, and the Republicans were willing to reopen the government with no conditions, but weren't willing to ban handguns to get that done. In that situation, a sophist could say that the Democrats were being more reasonable, since they were only requesting a single item from the ultra-liberal wish list, whereas the Republicans were insisting that ever single item from the wish list not be granted, and so the Republicans were the unreasonable ones. But we'd laugh at such a moron. What else are idiots good for?
 
For example, when Obama offered up health care reform that was a conservative's wet dream (Heritage Foundation-designed, Mitt Romney-approved, for-profit-corporation-favoring), it instantly became a horrible thing in their eyes, merely because it was Obama who proposed it.

This is the kind of liberal dishonesty that makes them the most amusing. The Heritage Foundation never endorsed a take over of healthcare, and there were a few house members, about 25, who thought a mandate was a good idea. Mitt Romney created a STATE system, much like Badgercare in Wisconsin. No one on the right endorsed taking over healthcare on a national level.

Liberals are working so hard to absolve themselves of the clusterfuck that they themselves tied us too like an anchor. "It's all the republicans fault that we took over the nation's healthcare". How pathetic can you get?
 
Really, buggy? "gun to the nation's head"? THAT the best way you could think of to describe this situation?

Let me try to help you out. I worry about how silly you insist on making yourself look in the eyes of normal folks.........

Lets look closely at what it is we are dealing with here, just to begin with I mean, ok?

Well we have republicans saying they will fund EVERYTHING in our government except ONE bill. We also have Democrats saying they want EVERYTHING funded.

Republicans say they will fund nothing if this one bill is included. Democrats say this bill WILL be included or they will accept the funding of nothing else.

So, Americans can have everything that the government ever had funded except this 1 new bill, republican option.
Or, Americans can have nothing that the government ever had funded including this 1 new bill, dim option.

Seems to ME that the republicans are more like holding a rubber band to the head of the nation and the Democrats who are holding the gun.

Again, you're drifting off onto the Pugs' We didn't want the shutdown" Big Lie.

Address what I said here about that, if you wish to address that topic...

https://www.politicaljack.com/threa...-about-the-shutdown-and-default-threat.59669/
 
This is the kind of liberal dishonesty that makes them the most amusing. The Heritage Foundation never endorsed a take over of healthcare, and there were a few house members, about 25, who thought a mandate was a good idea. Mitt Romney created a STATE system, much like Badgercare in Wisconsin. No one on the right endorsed taking over healthcare on a national level.

Liberals are working so hard to absolve themselves of the clusterfuck that they themselves tied us too like an anchor. "It's all the republicans fault that we took over the nation's healthcare". How pathetic can you get?

1. Calling the Heritage Foundation Plan elements a "takeover" does not change the fact that the central elements of Obamacare and the Heritage plan are the same. That includes the insurance mandate and the subsidies - the two things Pugs now bitch about the most.

2. About 25 GOP senators supported it, not House members.

3. Noting the obvious - that Romneycare was his state law, does not mean that the central elements of Romneycare and Obamacare are not nearly identical. They are.
 
I'm not very good about remembering which people said what. Without faces to go with the names, people tend to blur together for me. So I don't know if they're DNC hacks or not. But, the advantage of this post is that it calls for people to make their stand public now, before the course of events is known. I've set myself up to have to criticize Obama in three possible directions:

(1) If he causes a crisis by refusing even a meaningless face-saving gesture, like agreeing to form a non-binding commission to look into a proposal.

(2) If he offers up something of real value to the Republicans in exchange for avoiding the crisis (e.g., changing to chained-CPI for S.S.)

(3) If he just kicks the can a few weeks down the road, merely lengthening the crisis.

Although this thread is meant for liberals, I'd love to see conservatives step up and offer similar challenges for their own. Are there things that they'd attack the Republicans for? Are there things they'd praise Obama for? I think there are plenty of conservatives who think that anything Obama does is, by definition, the wrong thing. For example, when Obama offered up health care reform that was a conservative's wet dream (Heritage Foundation-designed, Mitt Romney-approved, for-profit-corporation-favoring), it instantly became a horrible thing in their eyes, merely because it was Obama who proposed it.

As a conservative, I think it's quite easy to criticize Republicans. They have few conservatives among their ranks. Whom would you like me to savage? Boehner? McConnell? McCain? Does this scathing review need to be sourced specifically in navigation of this shutdown...because there all sorts of legitimate reasons to lambast these guys.

Perhaps it's because the GOP doesn't hold the presidency and the president is the party leader/standard-bearer, but I don't see conservative hero-worship and absolution afforded to their guys the way I see it with lefty folks and President Obama. In any case, the vast majority here are far too busy attacking the other guy to break formation.
 
One of my complaints about many of my fellow liberals here is that they seem to support whatever Obama supports, no matter what that happens to be at the moment. If Obama did something, it was good-by-definition, even if it's something that Obama, himself, previously criticized (with full-throated agreement from liberals). I'm not like that. I support Obama when I think he's right, and attack him when I think he's wrong.

So, I'm issuing a challenge: do you think Obama should refuse to support/sign anything that reopens government/raises the debt ceiling, in exchange for some meaningful political ransom payment to the Republicans?

I suspect many here want it both ways. If Obama digs his heels in and refuses to compromise, I think most of us liberals will say that was the right thing to do. But I think if Obama instead gives into the extortion and gives the Republicans something of real value to get them to move, many of the exact same liberals will say that was the right thing to do. So, I'm challenging liberals here to take a position now, before they know what Obama will do, so that it's possible for them to be at odds with him if he decides the other way.

I'll start. I support Obama denying any meaningful ransom. The only exception would be a "compromise" that amounted to a functionally meaningless "face saving" offer to the GOP (e.g., agreeing to a non-binding panel investigation into x, y, and z), just to give the Republicans something to cling to, or a "compromise" that merely kicks the problem down the road by a year. If Obama sticks to that, I'll praise him, even if the result is terrible, economically (the alterative is worse). If he offers up something more substantial, or agrees to a shorter duration of kicking the can down the road (a week, a month), I'll criticize him. How about you?


First and foremost for me is that no tangible concessions be given before a debt ceiling extension and a continuing resolution is passed. Doing so would set an awful precedent, and all but guarantee that this scenario would played out over and over again, crippling our system of government.

Personally, what I'd really like to see is the debt limit eliminated altogether. It's a crutch used by both parties that prevents honest bargaining during budget negotiatons. At the moment, I'd be OK with a clean short term extension just as a pressure release mechanism.

If and / or when we ever get into budget negotiations, I'd insist on a raising of the social security cap for any increase in the retirement are or implementation of the chained CPI. Any fix to social security that consists only of cuts is not acceptable.

Likewise with spending cuts. If Republicans are serious about deficit reduction, they're going to have accept tax increases to go along with spending cuts with the majority of those cuts coming to our bloated defense budget. Spending cuts without tax increases are not acceptable.

To summarize, it's kind of hard to predict what I'd approve / disapprove of without knowing all the details ( where the devil does indeed dwell), but what I've laid out are some of my broad guidelines.
 
The top-premise around the hypocrisy of some libruls, is lame. First of all, it seems to presume some sort of "moral equivalence" between all presidents. Unless I take the exact same issue with this president as I did with a prior one, I'm a hypocrite. That's like saying that IF I advise Manning to stay in the pocket, I have to advise that Kaepernick do the same, lest I be accused of being a hypocrite.

Second, the top-premise self-righteously assumes that it's the final arbiter of all equivalence. Pres. Bush cruise missled someone. If I took issue with that, I must also take issue with Obama's droning someone....or I'm a hypocrite.

Third, it demonstrates some rather remarkable tunnel vision and navel contemplativeness. I voted for President Obama. I've been pleased with the job he's done so far. He's the only president we have for the next 3+ years. I want him to be successful. And, per the reality of our democratic majoritarian politic, I concede my personal feelings to the whole now and again. And SURE....his political opposition MAY be inclined to countering him, even as they may've taken a different tack with one of their own. And SURE...some of his otherwise-advocates MAY be inclined to take issue with him as they see fit, and presumably per their perspective of the whole. All THREE of these "types" play their essential role in our politic. So as good as it may feel for some of us to call another a hypocrite, it's really just redundant, self-absorbtive.......hypocrisy.
 
I'm pretty much with you Ark.. give them a token face-saver or two but nothing substantial. And whatever it is, CANNOT leave the debt ceiling hanging for another clusterfuk in just a few weeks from now. We simply can't allow these a-holes go govern like that or it will be never-ending.

I'm sorry, but this basically means that both you and Arkady are saying that Republicans do not merit the opportunity to bargain in good faith about the policies of the United States of America. You want them, and their ideas, excluded from serious consideration.
 
I'm sorry, but this basically means that both you and Arkady are saying that Republicans do not merit the opportunity to bargain in good faith about the policies of the United States of America. You want them, and their ideas, excluded from serious consideration.

No trap, that's completely ridiculous. We've shown willingness to have discussions and compromise. With your Teawad contingency ... please face it - it's THEIR way or the highway. We will simply not allow you to use the debt ceiling as a hostage for their laundry list of demands having learned that lesson the first time around.
 
I'm sorry, but this basically means that both you and Arkady are saying that Republicans do not merit the opportunity to bargain in good faith about the policies of the United States of America. You want them, and their ideas, excluded from serious consideration.


Horseshit.

Republicans can bargain in good faith during the conference committee on the budget, per the regular order of business. Their ideas are no more excluded than Senate Democrats will be.

Why are Republicans blocking the conference committee if they're so eager to negotiate?
 
One of my complaints about many of my fellow liberals here is that they seem to support whatever Obama supports, no matter what that happens to be at the moment. If Obama did something, it was good-by-definition, even if it's something that Obama, himself, previously criticized (with full-throated agreement from liberals). I'm not like that. I support Obama when I think he's right, and attack him when I think he's wrong.

So, I'm issuing a challenge: do you think Obama should refuse to support/sign anything that reopens government/raises the debt ceiling, in exchange for some meaningful political ransom payment to the Republicans?

I suspect many here want it both ways. If Obama digs his heels in and refuses to compromise, I think most of us liberals will say that was the right thing to do. But I think if Obama instead gives into the extortion and gives the Republicans something of real value to get them to move, many of the exact same liberals will say that was the right thing to do. So, I'm challenging liberals here to take a position now, before they know what Obama will do, so that it's possible for them to be at odds with him if he decides the other way.

I'll start. I support Obama denying any meaningful ransom. The only exception would be a "compromise" that amounted to a functionally meaningless "face saving" offer to the GOP (e.g., agreeing to a non-binding panel investigation into x, y, and z), just to give the Republicans something to cling to, or a "compromise" that merely kicks the problem down the road by a year. If Obama sticks to that, I'll praise him, even if the result is terrible, economically (the alterative is worse). If he offers up something more substantial, or agrees to a shorter duration of kicking the can down the road (a week, a month), I'll criticize him. How about you?

...first, casting a generalization noting that liberals will support Obama no matter what is not accurate, especially if you look back no further that Syria.

...next - it is my opinion that Obama not cave in to this absurd 6-week nonsense for several reasons:
  1. It accomplishes little in-terms of stabilizing the markets/economy. If anything it makes this worse (could this be the republican plan?)
  2. It leaves the government unfunded and exposed to more piecemeal (expensive) budgeting, and
  3. Opens up an entirely new way of legislating. Any small number of ideologists can bring the entire Nation to its knees on a "whim".
If Obama agrees to the current g0p proposal as I understand it - I am done with him.
 
The top-premise around the hypocrisy of some libruls, is lame. First of all, it seems to presume some sort of "moral equivalence" between all presidents. Unless I take the exact same issue with this president as I did with a prior one, I'm a hypocrite. That's like saying that IF I advise Manning to stay in the pocket, I have to advise that Kaepernick do the same, lest I be accused of being a hypocrite.

Second, the top-premise self-righteously assumes that it's the final arbiter of all equivalence. Pres. Bush cruise missled someone. If I took issue with that, I must also take issue with Obama's droning someone....or I'm a hypocrite.

Third, it demonstrates some rather remarkable tunnel vision and navel contemplativeness. I voted for President Obama. I've been pleased with the job he's done so far. He's the only president we have for the next 3+ years. I want him to be successful. And, per the reality of our democratic majoritarian politic, I concede my personal feelings to the whole now and again. And SURE....his political opposition MAY be inclined to countering him, even as they may've taken a different tack with one of their own. And SURE...some of his otherwise-advocates MAY be inclined to take issue with him as they see fit, and presumably per their perspective of the whole. All THREE of these "types" play their essential role in our politic. So as good as it may feel for some of us to call another a hypocrite, it's really just redundant, self-absorbtive.......hypocrisy.

In truth, everyone is missing a very real factor here. This sort of internet forum is adversarial and contentious. Sides stick together. Many fear breaking ranks. Several folks post openly here that they refuse to offer any daylight to contrasting viewpoints because - to paraphrase - it gives ammo to the enemy.

We cannot ignore the Romper Room aspect. ;-)
 
Back
Top