New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

For Libertarians

Arkady

President
In the Obama years, I repeatedly took issue with Obama when it came to his approach to drug enforcement. Especially in his early years, he was arguably worse than Bush, since he not only continued the Bush-era prosecution of marijuana dispensaries in states where it was legal under state law, but he even had the Justice Department going after individual users in those states, which the Bush administration hadn't been doing. I even speculated that Romney might be a better choice on that issue, since it was conceivable he'd be less of a hard-liner on drug issues than Obama. Thankfully, in his second term Obama backed off the craziness of the drug war a bit, but I didn't hesitate to call him out when he was in the wrong.

So, what I'm wondering is whether any of the self-styled small-government, libertarian conservatives here will call out the Trump administration on that issue.

Trump nominated as attorney general a guy who not only was too racist to be confirmed as a federal judge by a Republican senate in the 80s, but a guy who is horrifyingly unhinged when it comes to the drug war. Back when he was the AG for Alabama, Sessions pushed for a bill that would have imposed a mandatory death sentence for second drug trafficking offenses. Basically, someone could be caught dealing a bit of weed, and if it was his second offense, he'd be killed by the state.

Now that he's been put in the position of our nation's top law enforcement officer, he's instructing prosecutors to push hard the toughest drug charges available -- including in cases where minor charges would trigger draconian mandatory minimum sentences, which is a reversal of Obama-era instructions. In the Obama years, if the way mandatory minimum sentences were set up would result in a disproportionate penalty for certain kinds of behaviors, prosecutors were free to use their discretion to pursue less than the highest possible charge (e.g., to avoid triggering a third-strike that might give a person life in jail for what amounted to a fairly minor offense).

In the Obama years, the incarceration rate, which had been rising rapidly for decades, finally began to decline, thanks in part to crime continuing to fall, but also thanks to backing off the policy of officials always doggedly pursuing the longest possible sentences, when it came to things like non-violent drug offenses. If we reverse that, under Sessions's leadership, don't be surprised if incarceration rates start to soar again (with the associated huge taxpayer cost).

So, will anyone on the right speak up against this administration policy, and the apparent renewed eagerness to escalate the war on Americans who use recreational drugs?
 
Can you point to specific policies Trump or Sessions have implemented that are "escalat(ing) the war on Americans"? Because, frankly, this just sounds like more bullshit from your "resistance" handlers.
 
Can you point to specific policies Trump or Sessions have implemented that are "escalat(ing) the war on Americans"? Because, frankly, this just sounds like more bullshit from your "resistance" handlers.
Indeed.

They are becoming more intense as the reality of their world becomes clearer.

I'm enjoying it.
And it is going to get better as their efforts fall on deaf ears.

SB
 
Indeed.

They are becoming more intense as the reality of their world becomes clearer.

I'm enjoying it.
And it is going to get better as their efforts fall on deaf ears.

SB
Reread. I pointed to the specific policy Sessions had changed.
 
I'm not asking for your/the DNC's opinion. I'm asking for facts. Do you have any you can link to?
I didn't give you the DNC's opinion. I gave you the facts. I assumed you'd already be aware of the new policy, which is why I didn't link to anything, since it was huge news and widely reported in every major reputable outlet. However, sometimes I forget that conservatives here don't read newspapers and instead rely on only whatever stories Breitbart and the like are focusing on. So, I'm happy to share links:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/worl...18f6849a004_story.html?utm_term=.fc34372f12cb

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/09/us/politics/jeff-sessions-sentencing-criminal-justice.html?_r=0

http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/vide...prosecutors-charge-maximum-sentences-47372041

http://reason.com/blog/2017/05/12/reversing-obama-era-policy-sessions-orde
 
I didn't give you the DNC's opinion. I gave you the facts. I assumed you'd already be aware of the new policy, which is why I didn't link to anything, since it was huge news and widely reported in every major reputable outlet. However, sometimes I forget that conservatives here don't read newspapers and instead rely on only whatever stories Breitbart and the like are focusing on. So, I'm happy to share links:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/worl...18f6849a004_story.html?utm_term=.fc34372f12cb

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/09/us/politics/jeff-sessions-sentencing-criminal-justice.html?_r=0

http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/vide...prosecutors-charge-maximum-sentences-47372041

http://reason.com/blog/2017/05/12/reversing-obama-era-policy-sessions-orde

Sessions correcting the dereliction of duty committed by Eric "Machine Gun" Holder is not "new policy". It's a return to enforcement of the laws constitutionally passed by congress. I suppose from your perspective, seeing an AG uphold the law probably seems shocking, but that's what is going on here.
 
Sessions correcting the dereliction of duty committed by Eric "Machine Gun" Holder is not "new policy"

Sure it is. In a similar sense, if we were to restore a policy of "separate but equal" bathrooms for black people in the South, that would be a new policy, too, even though it was effectively a return to the way things used to be.

Anyway, my post wasn't really seeking the comments of the mindless Trump drones, who will support whatever he does. I was looking more for what the civil libertarians thought -- especially those who took issue with Obama's civil liberty abuses. And I'm looking for the thoughts of any principled small-government conservatives.
 
In the Obama years, I repeatedly took issue with Obama when it came to his approach to drug enforcement. Especially in his early years, he was arguably worse than Bush, since he not only continued the Bush-era prosecution of marijuana dispensaries in states where it was legal under state law, but he even had the Justice Department going after individual users in those states, which the Bush administration hadn't been doing. I even speculated that Romney might be a better choice on that issue, since it was conceivable he'd be less of a hard-liner on drug issues than Obama. Thankfully, in his second term Obama backed off the craziness of the drug war a bit, but I didn't hesitate to call him out when he was in the wrong.

So, what I'm wondering is whether any of the self-styled small-government, libertarian conservatives here will call out the Trump administration on that issue.

Trump nominated as attorney general a guy who not only was too racist to be confirmed as a federal judge by a Republican senate in the 80s, but a guy who is horrifyingly unhinged when it comes to the drug war. Back when he was the AG for Alabama, Sessions pushed for a bill that would have imposed a mandatory death sentence for second drug trafficking offenses. Basically, someone could be caught dealing a bit of weed, and if it was his second offense, he'd be killed by the state.

Now that he's been put in the position of our nation's top law enforcement officer, he's instructing prosecutors to push hard the toughest drug charges available -- including in cases where minor charges would trigger draconian mandatory minimum sentences, which is a reversal of Obama-era instructions. In the Obama years, if the way mandatory minimum sentences were set up would result in a disproportionate penalty for certain kinds of behaviors, prosecutors were free to use their discretion to pursue less than the highest possible charge (e.g., to avoid triggering a third-strike that might give a person life in jail for what amounted to a fairly minor offense).

In the Obama years, the incarceration rate, which had been rising rapidly for decades, finally began to decline, thanks in part to crime continuing to fall, but also thanks to backing off the policy of officials always doggedly pursuing the longest possible sentences, when it came to things like non-violent drug offenses. If we reverse that, under Sessions's leadership, don't be surprised if incarceration rates start to soar again (with the associated huge taxpayer cost).

So, will anyone on the right speak up against this administration policy, and the apparent renewed eagerness to escalate the war on Americans who use recreational drugs?

IF ever comes a time when a minor (or anyone) gets killed by the government for smoking his second reefer, I'll be the first one to speak up. Until that happens...

My personal preference regarding drug laws would be: unless caught dealing or distributing for profit, drug users should be held free from harm by the government. If all they're doing is partaking themselves, we should not legally punish them. It shouldn't even be a crime to smoke some pot or take some pills... or use any other drugs.

If they get caught dealing or distributing for profit, that's a whole 'nother story, IMO. Lock them up and throw away the key. Getting someone else hooked on a substance that will probably kill them somewhere down the road should be punishable by law, big time. It's almost like attempted murder...

As an aside... drug abusers who OD or otherwise get sick should not be entitled to free health care. If they want to kill themselves we should let them, there's no need to keep saving them from themselves over and over again. This might sound harsh, but everyone knows that drugs are addictive and there are very few people for whom 'only one' is even possible. Everyone knows where that road will lead eventually... why take that chance in the first place? How stupid...

Babies born to drug addicted mothers would be the exception to the rule. It's not their fault. Take them away from their parents and help them the best you can.
 
IF ever comes a time when a minor (or anyone) gets killed by the government for smoking his second reefer, I'll be the first one to speak up. Until that happens...

Fortunately, not everyone sits back and waits until a disaster has already happened, before acting, the way you're indicating you would. Others saw the risk ahead of time, and successfully fought back to stop it BEFORE a minor could get killed by the government for a second minor strike.

My personal preference regarding drug laws would be: unless caught dealing or distributing for profit, drug users should be held free from harm by the government. If all they're doing is partaking themselves, we should not legally punish them. It shouldn't even be a crime to smoke some pot or take some pills... or use any other drugs.

I'd go farther and legalize. It's ridiculous to effectively force consumers to deal with the underworld for a product for which there's high demand, and where the harm falls almost entirely on the user, like that. Doing that just funds the criminal underworld, just like it did when alcohol was made illegal. It also is dangerous for the consumers, who can get caught up in gangland violence simply by purchasing the product, and who can wind up poisoned by poor quality products (toxin-laced pot, just like there used to be the risk of going blind drinking bathtub gin). Government should do what it does with alcohol and tobacco. Make it legal, tax it, regulate it, and focus criminal enforcement on keeping it out of the hands of minors. A decently priced, high-quality legal supply will starve the underworld of commerce and the taxes can fund treatment for addicts and education for potential users.

As an aside... drug abusers who OD or otherwise get sick should not be entitled to free health care

Would you say the same for those who abuse legal substances? For example, should we deny healthcare to alcoholics? How about to diabetics who are abusing sugars and starches? Everyone knows sugar is addictive, so should we just leave the fatties to their fate?
 
In the Obama years, I repeatedly took issue with Obama when it came to his approach to drug enforcement. Especially in his early years, he was arguably worse than Bush, since he not only continued the Bush-era prosecution of marijuana dispensaries in states where it was legal under state law, but he even had the Justice Department going after individual users in those states, which the Bush administration hadn't been doing. I even speculated that Romney might be a better choice on that issue, since it was conceivable he'd be less of a hard-liner on drug issues than Obama. Thankfully, in his second term Obama backed off the craziness of the drug war a bit, but I didn't hesitate to call him out when he was in the wrong.

So, what I'm wondering is whether any of the self-styled small-government, libertarian conservatives here will call out the Trump administration on that issue.

Trump nominated as attorney general a guy who not only was too racist to be confirmed as a federal judge by a Republican senate in the 80s, but a guy who is horrifyingly unhinged when it comes to the drug war. Back when he was the AG for Alabama, Sessions pushed for a bill that would have imposed a mandatory death sentence for second drug trafficking offenses. Basically, someone could be caught dealing a bit of weed, and if it was his second offense, he'd be killed by the state.

Now that he's been put in the position of our nation's top law enforcement officer, he's instructing prosecutors to push hard the toughest drug charges available -- including in cases where minor charges would trigger draconian mandatory minimum sentences, which is a reversal of Obama-era instructions. In the Obama years, if the way mandatory minimum sentences were set up would result in a disproportionate penalty for certain kinds of behaviors, prosecutors were free to use their discretion to pursue less than the highest possible charge (e.g., to avoid triggering a third-strike that might give a person life in jail for what amounted to a fairly minor offense).

In the Obama years, the incarceration rate, which had been rising rapidly for decades, finally began to decline, thanks in part to crime continuing to fall, but also thanks to backing off the policy of officials always doggedly pursuing the longest possible sentences, when it came to things like non-violent drug offenses. If we reverse that, under Sessions's leadership, don't be surprised if incarceration rates start to soar again (with the associated huge taxpayer cost).

So, will anyone on the right speak up against this administration policy, and the apparent renewed eagerness to escalate the war on Americans who use recreational drugs?

I hereby call on the Trump administration to end govt's for-profit war on drugs and end CIA drug trafficking.

Happy now?
 
In the Obama years, I repeatedly took issue with Obama when it came to his approach to drug enforcement. Especially in his early years, he was arguably worse than Bush, since he not only continued the Bush-era prosecution of marijuana dispensaries in states where it was legal under state law, but he even had the Justice Department going after individual users in those states, which the Bush administration hadn't been doing. I even speculated that Romney might be a better choice on that issue, since it was conceivable he'd be less of a hard-liner on drug issues than Obama. Thankfully, in his second term Obama backed off the craziness of the drug war a bit, but I didn't hesitate to call him out when he was in the wrong.

So, what I'm wondering is whether any of the self-styled small-government, libertarian conservatives here will call out the Trump administration on that issue.

Trump nominated as attorney general a guy who not only was too racist to be confirmed as a federal judge by a Republican senate in the 80s, but a guy who is horrifyingly unhinged when it comes to the drug war. Back when he was the AG for Alabama, Sessions pushed for a bill that would have imposed a mandatory death sentence for second drug trafficking offenses. Basically, someone could be caught dealing a bit of weed, and if it was his second offense, he'd be killed by the state.

Now that he's been put in the position of our nation's top law enforcement officer, he's instructing prosecutors to push hard the toughest drug charges available -- including in cases where minor charges would trigger draconian mandatory minimum sentences, which is a reversal of Obama-era instructions. In the Obama years, if the way mandatory minimum sentences were set up would result in a disproportionate penalty for certain kinds of behaviors, prosecutors were free to use their discretion to pursue less than the highest possible charge (e.g., to avoid triggering a third-strike that might give a person life in jail for what amounted to a fairly minor offense).

In the Obama years, the incarceration rate, which had been rising rapidly for decades, finally began to decline, thanks in part to crime continuing to fall, but also thanks to backing off the policy of officials always doggedly pursuing the longest possible sentences, when it came to things like non-violent drug offenses. If we reverse that, under Sessions's leadership, don't be surprised if incarceration rates start to soar again (with the associated huge taxpayer cost).

So, will anyone on the right speak up against this administration policy, and the apparent renewed eagerness to escalate the war on Americans who use recreational drugs?

I hereby and gladly take issue with what appears to me to be an escalation of the BS "war on drugs" by the Trump administration. I'm glad you brought it up.
 
Would you say the same for those who abuse legal substances? For example, should we deny healthcare to alcoholics? How about to diabetics who are abusing sugars and starches? Everyone knows sugar is addictive, so should we just leave the fatties to their fate?

I would have people pay for risks they take. Examples include but are not limited to:

- riding a motorcycle without a helmet
- "diseases" one makes a decision to get, including but not limited to the ones you mentioned
- sports more dangerous than soccer, football, etc., like base jumping rock climbing, etc.
 
Back
Top