New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

For the record:

Unfortunately, I have to agree with you...

I ask myself this: According to liberals, America's military spending is far, far too high, and our armaments are enough to beat the crap out of anyone a hundred times over.

So WHY.... WHY couldn't we win a crappy little war like Vietnam, for instance, and lost 58,000 of our guys over there in THAT shithole? And haven't won anything since, only prolonged the agony and helped spread the evil?

The one and only explanation is that "The Elites" don't WANT to WIN...
Ask yourself when was the last time a country "won" a war of that sort. The Soviet Union fought something similar for a decade in Afghanistan, and never got the outcome they were looking for. France fought in Vietnam, too, and lost. Germany, in WWII, got ground down to a pulp in Russia. In WWI, the Turkish empire got torn apart in the Middle East.

I think there are three reasons that modern superpowers can't dominate "crappy little wars" the way superpowers were used to dominating from ancient times through the mid part of the colonial era:

(1) The perfection of guerrilla fighting. Superpowers today are facing off against guerrillas who know how to negate superpower advantages. A relatively small handful of fighters with rifles and improvised explosives can deal out serious pain against much superior militaries -- hitting and melting away into the mountains, swamps, or village populations. The partisans almost never win the battles, but they wear down the opponent until it thinks it just isn't worth it. With the spread of literacy and information, partisans today can educate themselves on what tactics have worked and what tactics haven't, in a way that partisans of centuries past couldn't, so they don't stumble into ridiculous tactics the way Zulus charged repeating rifles with their hide shields, or Aztecs tried to match conquistador strength in open battle.

(2) Moral evolution. If you look at the tactics of the "successful" superpowers from the era when they dominated, they did things few modern people could stomach. For example, if saboteurs were operating in the area, they'd happily start executing known innocent people until the villagers identified who was responsible, or they'd simply wipe out the whole village -- every man, woman, and child. Conquerers would intentionally spread disease, burn crops, poison wells, and do whatever else they thought was needed to bend the locals to their will or wipe them out of existence. The Romans would leave no stone standing on another, and would sow the soil with salt. That kind of brutality puts terrorism and genocide in the superpower's arsenal, but we have evolved past that.

(3) Economics. Wars are incredibly expensive. In theory, they can be profitable for a society if it wages them as mercilessly pragmatic colonial exercises: seizing new territory and extracting as much value out of them as possible, to recoup the cost of the investment. But, again, we don't operate that way. We're not going to move into a new territory, Roman style, and enslave thousands, putting them to work in the mines for the enrichment of our own nation. We're not going to move in and start shipping all their national treasures back stateside. We're not going to set up colonies for the exclusive benefit of the home country, like Europe did throughout central Africa. But, without doing those things, a country will nearly always come out behind when it wages a war. In Iraq, for example, we will have blown about $3 trillion. Even if we shipped 10% of the value of Iraq's whole GDP back to the US every year, it would take something like 15 years for that to be a break-even economic proposition for us. When people come to realize a war is costing them far more, as taxpayers, than they'll ever hope to see in benefits, they lose their stomach for the fight.
 
Ask yourself when was the last time a country "won" a war of that sort. The Soviet Union fought something similar for a decade in Afghanistan, and never got the outcome they were looking for. France fought in Vietnam, too, and lost. Germany, in WWII, got ground down to a pulp in Russia. In WWI, the Turkish empire got torn apart in the Middle East.

I think there are three reasons that modern superpowers can't dominate "crappy little wars" the way superpowers were used to dominating from ancient times through the mid part of the colonial era:

(1) The perfection of guerrilla fighting. Superpowers today are facing off against guerrillas who know how to negate superpower advantages. A relatively small handful of fighters with rifles and improvised explosives can deal out serious pain against much superior militaries -- hitting and melting away into the mountains, swamps, or village populations. The partisans almost never win the battles, but they wear down the opponent until it thinks it just isn't worth it. With the spread of literacy and information, partisans today can educate themselves on what tactics have worked and what tactics haven't, in a way that partisans of centuries past couldn't, so they don't stumble into ridiculous tactics the way Zulus charged repeating rifles with their hide shields, or Aztecs tried to match conquistador strength in open battle.

(2) Moral evolution. If you look at the tactics of the "successful" superpowers from the era when they dominated, they did things few modern people could stomach. For example, if saboteurs were operating in the area, they'd happily start executing known innocent people until the villagers identified who was responsible, or they'd simply wipe out the whole village -- every man, woman, and child. Conquerers would intentionally spread disease, burn crops, poison wells, and do whatever else they thought was needed to bend the locals to their will or wipe them out of existence. The Romans would leave no stone standing on another, and would sow the soil with salt. That kind of brutality puts terrorism and genocide in the superpower's arsenal, but we have evolved past that.

(3) Economics. Wars are incredibly expensive. In theory, they can be profitable for a society if it wages them as mercilessly pragmatic colonial exercises: seizing new territory and extracting as much value out of them as possible, to recoup the cost of the investment. But, again, we don't operate that way. We're not going to move into a new territory, Roman style, and enslave thousands, putting them to work in the mines for the enrichment of our own nation. We're not going to move in and start shipping all their national treasures back stateside. We're not going to set up colonies for the exclusive benefit of the home country, like Europe did throughout central Africa. But, without doing those things, a country will nearly always come out behind when it wages a war. In Iraq, for example, we will have blown about $3 trillion. Even if we shipped 10% of the value of Iraq's whole GDP back to the US every year, it would take something like 15 years for that to be a break-even economic proposition for us. When people come to realize a war is costing them far more, as taxpayers, than they'll ever hope to see in benefits, they lose their stomach for the fight.

So... without writing a book about it... what's YOUR solution? Let ISIS just spread unchecked?

Yeah...now THERE'S a great idea... :rolleyes:
 
So... without writing a book about it... what's YOUR solution? Let ISIS just spread unchecked?

Yeah...now THERE'S a great idea... :rolleyes:
My solution is to deny them the opportunity to pose as the scrappy Muslim saviors standing up to the big western bully. Leave the region to sort out its own problems. If we're in the mood to address humanitarian crises abroad, focus on some that don't involve us bombing the crap out of a third-world country at the cost of countless billions of dollars. We can do far more humanitarian good, for far less money, and gain more political capital in the process, if we focus on something like malaria prevention and clean water in sub-Saharan Africa.
 
I hate war just as much as most people... in my perfect world, we'd all live in peace and harmony.

However... evil exists, and when it spreads its wings the way ISIS is doing, it MUST be eliminated before it gets too powerful and threatens sane people's way of life. ISIS must be destroyed... no mercy, no limitations, no PC correctness, and certainly no political nor financial considerations.

ALL civilized nations must act and annihilate this evil. Now. To do any less is to condone the actions of these barbarians.

Obama, Merkel, Cameron, Hollande, Gillard: Do whatever it takes to squash these MF'ers. Send in the drones, bomb the shit out of them, and, while I absolutely HATE the thought of sending in ground troops... do it RIGHT, send in 100,000, and make sure you kill every last one of these cockroaches.

Sometimes you just HAVE to take a stand. And please, this time, do it right: Forget the pussyfooting, ignore the "Rules of Engagement", and go out there to WIN, not merely to "look good".

Totally agree.

War is terrible, but sometimes it is the only thing that will stop evil.
 
I hate war just as much as most people... in my perfect world, we'd all live in peace and harmony.

However... evil exists, and when it spreads its wings the way ISIS is doing, it MUST be eliminated before it gets too powerful and threatens sane people's way of life. ISIS must be destroyed... no mercy, no limitations, no PC correctness, and certainly no political nor financial considerations.

ALL civilized nations must act and annihilate this evil. Now. To do any less is to condone the actions of these barbarians.

Obama, Merkel, Cameron, Hollande, Gillard: Do whatever it takes to squash these MF'ers. Send in the drones, bomb the shit out of them, and, while I absolutely HATE the thought of sending in ground troops... do it RIGHT, send in 100,000, and make sure you kill every last one of these cockroaches.

Sometimes you just HAVE to take a stand. And please, this time, do it right: Forget the pussyfooting, ignore the "Rules of Engagement", and go out there to WIN, not merely to "look good".

In Obama's case he'd need Congress to authorize war.

Don't really see that happening, but perhaps if you pray earnestly for war it will come about.
 
Totally agree.

War is terrible, but sometimes it is the only thing that will stop evil.
The classic case when justifying war is the US's role in WWII. The cost in blood and treasure was unimaginably high, but few believe there was any other real option left to us. A coalition of superpower aggressors were expanding across Europe, Africa, and Asia, they were working to conquer a couple of our closest allies, and they'd brought the fight to us with a major sneak attack on our homeland. But you could hardly get farther from that analogy than what's going on with ISIS in Iraq. In Iraq, it's far from certain that US involvement won't just make things worse, as it did when we kicked over the Hussein regime at a mad president's whim. And ISIS doesn't pose an existential threat to the US -- their focus is on consolidating power in the Middle East, and they're still so small and weak that it's unclear they can have any success outside the few pockets of chaos in their immediate vicinity (Iraq, Syria, and possibly Lebanon, and Jordan.)

There's more than enough money in that region for them to deal with their own problems. They don't need the US stumbling around continuing to make a mess of things. If ISIS is nasty enough to make Iraq's wealthy neighbors nervous, or to worry the Shiah powers in Iran, let them take care of it. If not, let it burn itself out. Let's not pretend some humanitarian imperative forces us to intervene. We could do far more good at far lower cost through peaceful means elsewhere, if humanitarianism actually drives us.
 
The classic case when justifying war is the US's role in WWII. The cost in blood and treasure was unimaginably high, but few believe there was any other real option left to us. A coalition of superpower aggressors were expanding across Europe, Africa, and Asia, they were working to conquer a couple of our closest allies, and they'd brought the fight to us with a major sneak attack on our homeland. But you could hardly get farther from that analogy than what's going on with ISIS in Iraq. In Iraq, it's far from certain that US involvement won't just make things worse, as it did when we kicked over the Hussein regime at a mad president's whim. And ISIS doesn't pose an existential threat to the US -- their focus is on consolidating power in the Middle East, and they're still so small and weak that it's unclear they can have any success outside the few pockets of chaos in their immediate vicinity (Iraq, Syria, and possibly Lebanon, and Jordan.)

There's more than enough money in that region for them to deal with their own problems. They don't need the US stumbling around continuing to make a mess of things. If ISIS is nasty enough to make Iraq's wealthy neighbors nervous, or to worry the Shiah powers in Iran, let them take care of it. If not, let it burn itself out. Let's not pretend some humanitarian imperative forces us to intervene. We could do far more good at far lower cost through peaceful means elsewhere, if humanitarianism actually drives us.

ISIS has declared war on the USA. Spokespersons said that they will fly their flag in DC. They have killed an American in public.

Just because we say we aren't at war with them doesn't mean we aren't at war. They have declared it.

The course of action shouldn't be the same as that we followed in WW2. And I agree that the ME should take care of its own. I supported our staying completely out of it until they declared war and killed an American. That changes things. But that said.......... our approach should be smart and cut deep......no flooding the area with boots on the ground.
 
ISIS has declared war on the USA. Spokespersons said that they will fly their flag in DC. They have killed an American in public.

Just because we say we aren't at war with them doesn't mean we aren't at war. They have declared it.

The course of action shouldn't be the same as that we followed in WW2. And I agree that the ME should take care of its own. I supported our staying completely out of it until they declared war and killed an American. That changes things. But that said.......... our approach should be smart and cut deep......no flooding the area with boots on the ground.
Could you link me to their declaration of war and the statements by their spokespersons?
 
Back
Top