New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

full zombie

The State of the Union address was not, I’m sorry to say, very interesting. True, the president offered many good ideas. But we already know that almost none of those ideas will make it past a hostile House of Representatives.


​
On the other hand, the G.O.P. reply, delivered by Senator Marco Rubio of Florida, was both interesting and revelatory. And I mean that in the worst way. For Mr. Rubio is a rising star, to such an extent that Time magazine put him on its cover, calling him “The Republican Savior.” What we learned Tuesday, however, was that zombie economic ideas have eaten his brain.
In case you’re wondering, a zombie idea is a proposition that has been thoroughly refuted by analysis and evidence, and should be dead — but won’t stay dead because it serves a political purpose, appeals to prejudices, or both. The classic zombie idea in U.S. political discourse is the notion that tax cuts for the wealthy pay for themselves, but there are many more. And, as I said, when it comes to economics it appears that Mr. Rubio’s mind is zombie-infested.
Start with the big question: How did we get into the mess we’re in?
The financial crisis of 2008 and its painful aftermath, which we’re still dealing with, were a huge slap in the face for free-market fundamentalists. Circa 2005, the usual suspects — conservative publications, analysts at right-wing think tanks like the American Enterprise Institute and the Cato Institute, and so on — insisted that deregulated financial markets were doing just fine, and dismissed warnings about a housing bubble as liberal whining. Then the nonexistent bubble burst, and the financial system proved dangerously fragile; only huge government bailouts prevented a total collapse.







Instead of learning from this experience, however, many on the right have chosen to rewrite history. Back then, they thought things were great, and their only complaint was that the government was getting in the way of even more mortgage lending; now they claim that government policies, somehow dictated by liberals even though the G.O.P. controlled both Congress and the White House, were promoting excessive borrowing and causing all the problems.
Every piece of this revisionist history has been refuted in detail. No, the government didn’t force banks to lend to Those People; no, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac didn’t cause the housing bubble (they were doing relatively little lending during the peak bubble years); no, government-sponsored lenders weren’t responsible for the surge in risky mortgages (private mortgage issuers accounted for the vast majority of the riskiest loans).
But the zombie keeps shambling on — and here’s Mr. Rubio Tuesday night: “This idea — that our problems were caused by a government that was too small — it’s just not true. In fact, a major cause of our recent downturn was a housing crisis created by reckless government policies.” Yep, it’s the full zombie.
What about responding to the crisis? Four years ago, right-wing economic analysts insisted that deficit spending would destroy jobs, because government borrowing would divert funds that would otherwise have gone into business investment, and also insisted that this borrowing would send interest rates soaring. The right thing, they claimed, was to balance the budget, even in a depressed economy.
Now, this argument was obviously fallacious from the beginning. As people like me tried to point out, the whole reason our economy was depressed was that businesses weren’t willing to invest as much as consumers were trying to save. So government borrowing would not, in fact, drive up interest rates — and trying to balance the budget would simply deepen the depression.
Sure enough, interest rates, far from soaring, are at historic lows — and countries that slashed spending have also seen sharp job losses. You rarely get this clear a test of competing economic ideas, and the right’s ideas failed.
But the zombie still shambles on. And here’s Mr. Rubio: “Every dollar our government borrows is money that isn’t being invested to create jobs. And the uncertainty created by the debt is one reason why many businesses aren’t hiring.” Zombies 2, Reality 0.
In fairness to Mr. Rubio, what he’s saying isn’t any different from what everyone else in his party is saying. But that, of course, is what’s so scary.
For here we are, more than five years into the worst economic slump since the Great Depression, and one of our two great political parties has seen its economic doctrine crash and burn twice: first in the run-up to crisis, then again in the aftermath. Yet that party has learned nothing; it apparently believes that all will be well if it just keeps repeating the old slogans, but louder.
It’s a disturbing picture, and one that bodes ill for our nation’s future.
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/15/opinion/krugman-rubio-and-the-zombies.html?ref=opinion&_r=1&
 
*****

Good one, Yuri. Anticipate crickets from the right....or zombies. I'm betting on the crickets, though. I don't think there's a zombie here with the attention span to even read the article, let alone venture to dispute it. More likely, one of them will start a new thread titled, "Lefty is a zombie" with some inane, Peewee Herman dissertation that dull-normal people will find entertaining.
 
has anybody used a calculator to total up what the cost will be for all of Obama's SOTU wish list?

I bet even if you taxed the 1% at 100% of their income, you couldn't make a dent in it.

This is the consensus of both democrat and republican analysts. Which is why the SOTU speech was "full zombie" - not a recalcitrating house of reprsentatives.

if you want recalcitrant, why not focus on the senate, which has refused to even bring a federal budget to the floor for a vote, in over 4 years. those lazy bums in the house, however, have passed one every year.
 
has anybody used a calculator to total up what the cost will be for all of Obama's SOTU wish list?

I bet even if you taxed the 1% at 100% of their income, you couldn't make a dent in it.

This is the consensus of both democrat and republican analysts. Which is why the SOTU speech was "full zombie" - not a recalcitrating house of reprsentatives.

if you want recalcitrant, why not focus on the senate, which has refused to even bring a federal budget to the floor for a vote, in over 4 years. those lazy bums in the house, however, have passed one every year.

here is your first most zombiest of all zombies, zigg
 
has anybody used a calculator to total up what the cost will be for all of Obama's SOTU wish list?

Yes. Karl Rove. Five minutes after the speech, with a list as a prop. He was holding one of those things as "proof" when he promised a Romney landslide, too.

I bet even if you taxed the 1% at 100% of their income, you couldn't make a dent in it.

You know neither figure, so you'll "bet". Really compelling info.

This is the consensus of both democrat and republican analysts.

Got a link to that whopper?

those lazy bums in the house, however, have passed one every year.


It's easy when you don't employ arithmetic, specifics, or acknowledge the existence of half our citizens.
 
Supplementary point....


Challenge to any Rightwinger....name something NEW in what Mitt...I mean Marco spoke about in his SOTU response?
 
Crickets are still winning by a landslide. Facts are like pesticide around here. Crickets are the ones barely smart enough not to step in it. They applaud your post with their silence.
 
BTW, on another of Yuri's points....love the new "historical revisionism" that the housing crises and recession are "Clinton's and the CRA's fault"....

and we're supposed to pretend that Dubya and the GOP Congress were "helpless" to "fix" it.
 
When I was issuing dire warnings about the housing bubble, I was called a 'Chicken Little', and a 'girlie-man economist'.

Ah, the memories.
 
has anybody used a calculator to total up what the cost will be for all of Obama's SOTU wish list?

I bet even if you taxed the 1% at 100% of their income, you couldn't make a dent in it.

This is the consensus of both democrat and republican analysts. Which is why the SOTU speech was "full zombie" - not a recalcitrating house of reprsentatives.

if you want recalcitrant, why not focus on the senate, which has refused to even bring a federal budget to the floor for a vote, in over 4 years. those lazy bums in the house, however, have passed one every year.

Our overall rate of taxation remains absurdly low, both relative to our own modern historical norms and relative to what is typical in other wealthy nations. So we have plenty of room to boost revenues without too much heartache. I'll grant that this will mean increasing taxes on more than just the top 1%. However, a huge amount of revenue can be gained by going after them -- especially if we removed the privileged treatment their UNEARNED income gets (bizarrely, you pay a higher rate on income you earn by the sweat of your brow than income you earn passively by collecting dividends or capital gains.... and income you get as inheritance is mostly sheltered from ANY tax, given the ridiculously high exemption.) As you're probably aware, for most of this country's "Golden Age" of very strong GDP growth and general prosperity improvements, the top bracket paid between 70% and 92%, so we know that taxes on the rich can go up a great deal without killing the economy.

Of course, it'll take more than just tax increases for us to be able to pay for first-world-style social services (like universal pre-school). We'll need to cut some of the waste out of our budget, too, to find the savings. But the good news is that some areas of the budget are so extravogantly wasteful, that finding hundreds of billions in savings isn't difficult, other than in the sense of getting by the pork-protecting politicians. For example, if we cut military spending to the point where we were "only" spending twice as much as the next-closest country --a level of relative spending (relative to contemporary countries) that few, if any, other countries in the whole history of the world were ever at-- we'd save $425 billion per year. That's more than enough, even without tax hikes, to cover Obama's wish list.

By the way, it's tough to calculate what the impact would be of increasing taxes on just the top 1%, since the Census doesn't report that way. But, I can calculate the impact on hiking taxes on households earning $250,000 or more (roughly the top 2%). There are 2.808 million such households, with a mean income of $426,271. So, they collectively earn 1,196,968,968,000. Thus every 1-point increase in effective tax rate for them brings in $11,969,689,680. Pre-school would cost the government about $10,000 per child per year. So, for a one-point increase in taxes on the top 2%, you could put over a million kids in pre-school. For a four-point hike in taxes, just on those richest Americans, you could provide fully-paid pre-school for all four-year-olds, with money to spare.
 
I don't blame Dumbya for anything but accepting the nomination when he knew he wasn't even close to being up to the job. He didn't really call any shots after that. Least engaged President since the Alzheimers guy. Yes man. Nothing more. That's the RNC's wet dream. Stupid guys who drift in and out of consciousness throughout their Presidency and do what they're told.
 
Great post Yuri, concise and to the point, of course the righties on here will say you're crazy, but don't they always.
 
Supplementary point....


Challenge to any Rightwinger....name something NEW in what Mitt...I mean Marco spoke about in his SOTU response?

It's not just the Rubio/Romney harmony, either. The leading Republicans have stuck as closely to traditional dogma as the Catholic Church over the past decade and a half.... which makes sense, since it's effectively a religion, where heretics get punished and ideological purity is the only test of virtue.

During both 2008 and 2012, I pointed out how the Republicans were losing in part because they refused to distinguish themselves in any meaningful way from the Bush administration, which was a COLOSSAL FAILURE of historical proportions, in the eyes of all but the most nutty partisans. McCain ran as Bush 2.0, then Romney ran as Bush 3.0. Now it sound like Rubio wants to run as Bush 4.0. There was even a moment in one of the debates where Romney was asked, directly, to distinguish himself from Bush, and even then he couldn't come up with anything meaningful (he instead spoke about how the times are different, not how his policies or attitudes were different).

I guess the Republicans figure if they keep running as George W. Bush, sooner or later political memories will have faded enough that voters will have forgotten that he led this nation to across-the-board catastrophe.

This is quite different from Democrats. Carter was branded as a failed president, in the conventional wisdom. I think that's unfair (we had fantastic job creation on his watch, kept deficits down, started on the path that would break the back of inflation, and avoided any major wars). But fair or not, that was the conventional wisdom. Democrats responded by expressly situating themselves as "new Democrats," including the triangulating DLC movement that Clinton was involved with. They broke with Carter-administration policies and attitudes. And, as a result, the Republicans have been unsuccessful at using Carter against them. Again and again Republicans try to pretend they're running against Carter when they run against a Democrat, but it hasn't really worked since it worked against Mondale, because the public just doesn't see modern Democrats as an extension of the Carter legacy. Republicans haven't yet made that step. It's five years since the Bush presidency melted down this country in a way that made the Carter years look enviable by comparison, but every major Republican is still reading the Bush-era liturgy without any meaningful variation, as if it were Holy Writ.
 
I don't blame Dumbya for anything but accepting the nomination when he knew he wasn't even close to being up to the job. He didn't really call any shots after that. Least engaged President since the Alzheimers guy. Yes man. Nothing more. That's the RNC's wet dream. Stupid guys who drift in and out of consciousness throughout their Presidency and do what they're told.

You've got to wonder how ANYONE is arrogant enough to think he's up for the job of the presidency. I mean, I'm an ATROCIOUSLY arrogant guy, when it comes to intellect. I think I'm the smartest person I've ever known. Yet I wouldn't even begin to think I was up to the job of governing a nation like the US. To feel ready for that challenge, I'd have to be a Rhodes-scholar-level genius with many years of roaring success a step down on the political ladder, world-class interpersonal skills, supreme public speaking abilities, and an almost pathological tendency towards workaholism. I know that other than my intellect, I lack any of that, and so I'd never think I was up to the challenge of leading this nation well.

Even someone who had all that going for him would have to be overconfident to the point of narcissism to want to step up to that plate. But you'd have to be insanely deluded to think you were up for the job if you were a lazy dim bulb like Bush (or maybe just so immoral that you didn't care how many lives you ruined, as long as you got to sit in the big chair for a while).
 
He just saw it as a rich kid's trophy. Same as Mittwit. Ridin' daddy's coattails. How hard could it be? You just tell people to do things and they do them.

I honestly think both of them thought that is how it works....judging by their own statements. Bush even said in a debate that he'd lower gas prices simply by "telling the Saudis to open the spigot". Maybe that's what his daddy was talking about with the Bin Ladens when the planes hit the towers.

BTW, I'm the smartest guy in the world. That's why I'd never want to be President. I'm smart enough to know that no one pays any attention to me. If it were like Mittwit and Dumbya saw it....same as being President of a company....I'd make a great President. If everyone just had to do what I told them, I'd be the most benign dictator ever. Or we could just elect Michael Scott.
 
He just saw it as a rich kid's trophy. Same as Mittwit. Ridin' daddy's coattails. How hard could it be? You just tell people to do things and they do them.

I honestly think both of them thought that is how it works....judging by their own statements. Bush even said in a debate that he'd lower gas prices simply by "telling the Saudis to open the spigot". Maybe that's what his daddy was talking about with the Bin Ladens when the planes hit the towers.

BTW, I'm the smartest guy in the world. That's why I'd never want to be President. I'm smart enough to know that no one pays any attention to me. If it were like Mittwit and Dumbya saw it....same as being President of a company....I'd make a great President. If everyone just had to do what I told them, I'd be the most benign dictator ever. Or we could just elect Michael Scott.

Hehe. Just to be clear, I'm not claiming I'm the smartest guy in the world. Even I'm not quite that arrogant. I'm just the smartest of the roughly 1000 people I've gotten to know so far in my life. Even with a 1 in 1000 intellect, there'd still be millions of people smarter than me.
 
in other words, zombie = insanity, going by the bolded part, given they wanna repeat the failed policies the slogans cover
 
Savants are the smartest people in the world by some measure. It's a pretty ambiguous designation. I've known a chess master who never takes his finger out of his nose.

Genius seems to be targeted to certain proclivities in most cases. If you're lucky enough to have communicative skills as one of them, it's easier to project yourself as the smartest guy around. (And simultaneously know that you're full of shit.)

I've never been intellectually intimidated by anyone in my 64 years. That's all I have to go on. So yeah....I walk around thinking I'm God's gift to humanity. (Yuk yuk)
 
Back
Top