New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Getting my son baptised.

afella

Mayor
Yes I am an agnostic, though I despise organized religion to it's core. My wife is catholic, I was raised catholic, and wanted to get our son baptised. I didn't, and don't, have a problem with that. So we arranged a meeting with the priest to organize a date and technicalities of the matter.

During the conversation he asked us both if we were catholic, my wife said yes and I said not practicing. I do still identify with some of the teachings I learned growing up. They could be attributed to human nature and common decency or the religion, that's up for debate.

He then asked typical questions of why I wasn't practicing, and he pushed and pushed. I didn't want to get into it, I wanted to support my wife and go through with our sons baptism. He finally said, "your a nonbeliever.". I said correct. He then said that he probably wouldn't be able to go through with the baptism, as my son's future in the Catholic Church could be mislead by myself.

I tried to explain that I supported my son going through with this, and I would support him along the way as much as I could. He asked, "and when your son asks you what you believe what will you say?". I told him I would tell him how I feel, and that I would ensure that my son sees it through confirmation before he makes a choice on what he wants to believe.

Ok ok long story I know. Here's the winner. He told me I was not allowed to tell my son my beliefs as it could put objectionable opinion into my son's beliefs. So first he can go F himself for telling me what I can and cannot do. Second, is the so called objectionable opinion so detrimental to to their belief and faith and what should be. Then how strong is the conviction of the faith they follow? If what they say is true then how is anyone opinion even remotely correct? The list goes on and on.

Either way I will teach my kids to be as objectionable as possible, always be open minded (which is why it is important for him and the new one to go through confirmation), and always be respectful of others opinions when it comes to faith.

I thought it was an interesting exchange, so just wanted to share.
 
Yes I am an agnostic, though I despise organized religion to it's core. My wife is catholic, I was raised catholic, and wanted to get our son baptised. I didn't, and don't, have a problem with that. So we arranged a meeting with the priest to organize a date and technicalities of the matter.

During the conversation he asked us both if we were catholic, my wife said yes and I said not practicing. I do still identify with some of the teachings I learned growing up. They could be attributed to human nature and common decency or the religion, that's up for debate.

He then asked typical questions of why I wasn't practicing, and he pushed and pushed. I didn't want to get into it, I wanted to support my wife and go through with our sons baptism. He finally said, "your a nonbeliever.". I said correct. He then said that he probably wouldn't be able to go through with the baptism, as my son's future in the Catholic Church could be mislead by myself.

I tried to explain that I supported my son going through with this, and I would support him along the way as much as I could. He asked, "and when your son asks you what you believe what will you say?". I told him I would tell him how I feel, and that I would ensure that my son sees it through confirmation before he makes a choice on what he wants to believe.

Ok ok long story I know. Here's the winner. He told me I was not allowed to tell my son my beliefs as it could put objectionable opinion into my son's beliefs. So first he can go F himself for telling me what I can and cannot do. Second, is the so called objectionable opinion so detrimental to to their belief and faith and what should be. Then how strong is the conviction of the faith they follow? If what they say is true then how is anyone opinion even remotely correct? The list goes on and on.

Either way I will teach my kids to be as objectionable as possible, always be open minded (which is why it is important for him and the new one to go through confirmation), and always be respectful of others opinions when it comes to faith.

I thought it was an interesting exchange, so just wanted to share.

I don't like saying negative things about other denominations.....but I've always had a problem with Catholics that do things like this. I have problems with ANY that tell you what you can and cannot do in your family and I have the biggest problem with Catholic "laws". Nobody should be able to tell you that you can't teach your kids your beliefs. They should know ALL about the beliefs or non-beliefs there are. This gives them the option to make a choice (what God wants us to do!). I can't believe you would have had this problem with a good Protestant Church. Problem is, there's not a lot of "good" ones around....Catholic OR Protestant.

The Protestant Churchs (I think all do) have the option to "dedicate" your child to the church. They aren't baptised. When the child gets old enough to decide for themselves & are at the age of responsibility, THEN they may chose to be baptised. You didn't say how old your son is.
 
I don't like saying negative things about other denominations.....but I've always had a problem with Catholics that do things like this. I have problems with ANY that tell you what you can and cannot do in your family and I have the biggest problem with Catholic "laws". Nobody should be able to tell you that you can't teach your kids your beliefs. They should know ALL about the beliefs or non-beliefs there are. This gives them the option to make a choice (what God wants us to do!). I can't believe you would have had this problem with a good Protestant Church. Problem is, there's not a lot of "good" ones around....Catholic OR Protestant.

The Protestant Churchs (I think all do) have the option to "dedicate" your child to the church. They aren't baptised. When the child gets old enough to decide for themselves & are at the age of responsibility, THEN they may chose to be baptised. You didn't say how old your son is.

He was baptised at a year and a couple months.

My wife's family recently found out about a long list sister they have as well. My wife's mother was forced, by her father and the local priest, to give up the child at birth to the church. The Catholic Church has a poor history, though they have come a long way. This new Pope seems to be the most Christian's out of any I've studied, perhaps there is some hope.
 
I watch the program on OWN called "Long Lost Family" and love it! Did your wife get to meet her sister? I love to hear of reunions like this.
 
Yes I am an agnostic, though I despise organized religion to it's core. My wife is catholic, I was raised catholic, and wanted to get our son baptised. I didn't, and don't, have a problem with that. So we arranged a meeting with the priest to organize a date and technicalities of the matter.

During the conversation he asked us both if we were catholic, my wife said yes and I said not practicing. I do still identify with some of the teachings I learned growing up. They could be attributed to human nature and common decency or the religion, that's up for debate.

He then asked typical questions of why I wasn't practicing, and he pushed and pushed. I didn't want to get into it, I wanted to support my wife and go through with our sons baptism. He finally said, "your a nonbeliever.". I said correct. He then said that he probably wouldn't be able to go through with the baptism, as my son's future in the Catholic Church could be mislead by myself.

I tried to explain that I supported my son going through with this, and I would support him along the way as much as I could. He asked, "and when your son asks you what you believe what will you say?". I told him I would tell him how I feel, and that I would ensure that my son sees it through confirmation before he makes a choice on what he wants to believe.

Ok ok long story I know. Here's the winner. He told me I was not allowed to tell my son my beliefs as it could put objectionable opinion into my son's beliefs. So first he can go F himself for telling me what I can and cannot do. Second, is the so called objectionable opinion so detrimental to to their belief and faith and what should be. Then how strong is the conviction of the faith they follow? If what they say is true then how is anyone opinion even remotely correct? The list goes on and on.

Either way I will teach my kids to be as objectionable as possible, always be open minded (which is why it is important for him and the new one to go through confirmation), and always be respectful of others opinions when it comes to faith.

I thought it was an interesting exchange, so just wanted to share.

Thanks for sharing this. I'm an Orthodox Christian, and we share with the Catholics the practice of infant baptism. However, in Orthodoxy, it is the Godparents who hold the baby and participate in the service of the baptismal sacrament . The parents stand behind the Godparents and only after the baby is baptized and churched is he/she handed to the mother by the priest. The father honestly doesn't do anything during the service. I'm wondering if there's something similar in the Catholic service?
 
I watch the program on OWN called "Long Lost Family" and love it! Did your wife get to meet her sister? I love to hear of reunions like this.

They will be meeting next month, her and two of her other sisters will be meeting for a dinner and drinks. She turned out quite successful, she's an RN at a well known hospital has two little ones of her own and has been married for 30 years. My wife's mother will be meeting her, again, this weekend for the first time since she was born. My wife's mother is very apprehensive about it all, she wants to get the church's approval and guidance through this. It seems like a crutch to me, given they're the reason for the separation to begin with. I'm very curious to hear the priests opinion on the matter.
 
Thanks for sharing this. I'm an Orthodox Christian, and we share with the Catholics the practice of infant baptism. However, in Orthodoxy, it is the Godparents who hold the baby and participate in the service of the baptismal sacrament . The parents stand behind the Godparents and only after the baby is baptized and churched is he/she handed to the mother by the priest. The father honestly doesn't do anything during the service. I'm wondering if there's something similar in the Catholic service?

I didn't have to do to much, we both held him up as the priest baptized him, then the god parents did the same. I hadn't been to a baptism before, atleast not that I could recall. It was interesting. I don't know if it's the same across the whole church but I would assume so.
 
They will be meeting next month, her and two of her other sisters will be meeting for a dinner and drinks. She turned out quite successful, she's an RN at a well known hospital has two little ones of her own and has been married for 30 years. My wife's mother will be meeting her, again, this weekend for the first time since she was born. My wife's mother is very apprehensive about it all, she wants to get the church's approval and guidance through this. It seems like a crutch to me, given they're the reason for the separation to begin with. I'm very curious to hear the priests opinion on the matter.

That's exciting! I agree though....I shouldn't matter to the church if she wants to meet with her daughter. Nobody needs to approve that! What happens if they recommend that she doesn't do it? She'll always wish she had. Good luck!!
 
Back
Top