New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Getting specific on trade.

Arkady

President
We've all heard Trump whining repeatedly about how bad NAFTA is for the US, or how much the EU takes advantage of us when it comes to trade. But aside from generic mewling about how "very, very unfair" things are, I have yet to hear him explain in what way we're being taken advantage of. He seems to believe that if he whimpers pathetically enough, other countries will take pity on America and offer concessions.

So, does anyone here know exactly what Trump is sniveling about? In what ways, specifically, are our trade deals with the EU, Canada, Mexico, etc., asymmetrical? Certainly it's not about "currency manipulation" -- the old charge that once applied to China. In fact, to the extent the EU manipulates the Euro, it's in the opposite direction -- artificially bolstering it, which would be expected to make their products more expensive here, while making our exports more affordable to them. If Germany eased off their strong-Euro policy and devalued the Euro, as the poorer EU countries want, our trade deficit would get even worse.

I've tried digging into the specifics, but the general understanding of why we run trade deficits with most other major economies (notably, not Canada), is that we don't save much. Nations of savers will tend to acquire US debt in exchange for exported goods and services, giving them a trade surplus against us. As long as we're eager to spend beyond our means, we're going to be exporting IOUs, and that means a trade deficit. And we're not just talking about government debt (though, obviously, that's set to get much worse with the orgy of military spending and upper-class tax giveaways). It's also private debt. In the Obama years, household debt plummeted as a share of GDP, from 98.5% to 80.1%. But lately household debt is rising again, and in 2017 it passed the prior peak reached in 2008.

But maybe I'm missing something. Which specific trade terms are unfair and how should we improve them?
 
There is no economic reason for starting a trade war. It's purely political. It plays well politically in the rust belt. Trump has zero shot at winning if he can't hold the rust belt.
 
There is no economic reason for starting a trade war. It's purely political. It plays well politically in the rust belt. Trump has zero shot at winning if he can't hold the rust belt.
I certainly agree with you on those points. But what I find fascinating is how willing the marching morons are to join in lock step on this without even asking for an explanation. I have heard Trump speak on international trade literally dozens of times, and heard him repeat these same themes about America being taken advantage of, and how bad the trade deals previous leaders negotiated are, etc. In all that time, I have yet to hear him cite a single specific. It's amazing that so few are asking about that.

Think about it. If he has real gripes, rather than just channeling a vague sense of nationalism, xenophobia, and grievance, how hard would it be to raise some specific issues showing trade unfairness. For example, just to make up some fictional gripes "NAFTA allows Mexican tequila to come into the US with no tariff, while applying a 5% tariff to US bourbon that goes to Mexico." Or "the European Union allows European-built cars on the road with less stringent pollution controls than they require from US-built cars." Or "China applies a six-month waiting period for any Americans seeking business visas to travel to China, while the US is required to review visa requests from China within 30 days."

The fact he isn't citing any examples suggests he lacks any examples to cite.
 
Free trade has been a net positive for the US, but not everyone benefits from it. Trump does deserve credit for making that point. His proposed remedies for that problem are absolutely moronic. Tariffs are going to shrink the economy vastly more than if he just taxed the winners of free trade and gave it directly the losers of free trade in the form of welfare or jobs retraining.
 
Free trade has been a net positive for the US, but not everyone benefits from it. Trump does deserve credit for making that point. His proposed remedies for that problem are absolutely moronic. Tariffs are going to shrink the economy vastly more than if he just taxed the winners of free trade and gave it directly the losers of free trade in the form of welfare or jobs retraining.

always first plan of dem/libs

WELFARE
 
The tariff is just Trump's attempt at wealth redistribution. It will go from farmers and auto workers to steel workers.

You seriously should see if community college would refund what your parents paid for your education, they got ripped off........
 
I find it endlessly hilarious that the forum's biggest whiner, when it comes to supposed "thread jacking," is also the forum's most shameless thread-jacker. If liberals so much as offer disagreement about the premise of a thread, you'll howl like a wounded dog that they're jacking the thread, yet you see no problem with out-of-left-field references to school shootings in a thread about trade policy. The utter lack of self-awareness is funny as hell.
 
I find it endlessly hilarious that the forum's biggest whiner, when it comes to supposed "thread jacking," is also the forum's most shameless thread-jacker. If liberals so much as offer disagreement about the premise of a thread, you'll howl like a wounded dog that they're jacking the thread, yet you see no problem with out-of-left-field references to school shootings in a thread about trade policy. The utter lack of self-awareness is funny as hell.

No wonder you have NO clients
Mop need in Office 102, hop to it boy.
 
The tariff is just Trump's attempt at wealth redistribution. It will go from farmers and auto workers to steel workers.
Yep. It amounts to a political payoff. The American people will be expected to pay higher-than-market rates for steel, aluminum, and products containing those materials, and that'll be a windfall for a few workers in politically important states, which Trump hopes will help him get reelected.
 
Back
Top