New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Global Warming Illustrated

This is the best graphic I've yet seen to give you a sense for the instrument record for global warming:

http://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2014-hottest-year-on-record/embed/?v=1

It's an animation that shows you the month-by-month global temperatures for each year in sequence, along with the rise of the annual records.

Yep..

since 1880, it's the hottest year.

Things honest people keep in mind.
  • This a monumentally short time for gathering data about the climate considering the lifespan of our planet.
  • Our planet has been much hotter than this, that's a fact.
  • All changes in temperature that we observe today are relatively small variations within a much larger trend on a geological time scale.
  • There are rarely to never any actual numbers reported in the media, thus, making it a non-scientific claim.
Inconvenient facts that Arkady can't explain:
  • About half of the warming that occurs in that time happens prior to 1940, before it could have been caused by human activity. This warming was probably a natural rebound from the Little Ice Age, a cool period that ended in the middle of the 19th century.
  • Using proxies, there were warmer temperatures during Roman times and the Middle Ages, when “recorded history” describes wine grapes growing in Northern England and Newfoundland.
  • We know that the earth is going through a series of freezing and warming cycles on a scale of tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of years. And it has mostly been freezing. We’re fortunate enough to live in a cozy, warm “interglacial” period between ice ages. So we’re all staring down the barrel of the next ice age, yet we’re spending our time worrying about global warming.
  • The margin of error for the study is 5 times as large as the claimed increase:
    • The alleged ‘record’ amounted to an increase over 2010, the previous ‘warmest year’, of just two-hundredths of a degree—or 0.02C. The margin of error is said by scientists to be approximately 0.1C—several times as much.
And the kicker:
  • GISS’s director Gavin Schmidt has now admitted NASA thinks the likelihood that 2014 was the warmest year since 1880 is just 38 per cent. However, when asked by this newspaper whether he regretted that the news release did not mention this, he did not respond.
http://thefederalist.com/2015/01/19/global-warming-most-dishonest-year-on-record/

Keep spinning Ark!
 
Last edited:
may-snow_wide-0bd8548805fa832764cf91491230bbd6634fcb5c.jpg


"freak may 2015 snowstorms destroy crops, gardens"

"NASA 'pristine site' temperature monitor shows 10 year cooling trend"

http://dailycaller.com/2015/06/15/a...ion-data-shows-us-in-a-10-year-cooling-trend/

don't you get tired of being wrong ALL the time ?
 
Yep..

since 1880, it's the hottest year.

Things honest people keep in mind.
  • This a monumentally short time for gathering data about the climate considering the lifespan of our planet.
True. But that's just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to evidence of warming. There are a vast array of paleoclimate reconstructions based on all different methods (e.g., tree ring data, ice core sampling, geological evidence of glacier extents, sediment sampling, and so on). And it all builds a picture that tells us things have been heating up more rapidly than at any point in the last several thousand years, and this is despite an unusually dim solar cycle. All that points to anthropogenic causes, and given the huge increase in CO2 from known human fossil fuel burning, it's no surprise.
  • Our planet has been much hotter than this, that's a fact.
True, but I fail to see the relevance. Our planet once was a ball of molten rock in a newly forming solar system, but that doesn't mean we'll be just fine unless temperatures get even hotter than that.

  • All changes in temperature that we observe today are relatively small variations within a much larger trend on a geological time scale.
The point, though is that this isn't along a "geological time scale." We're not talking about a few degrees warming for every few thousand years, where ecosystems could be expected to shift and species to evolve to cope with it. We're talking about the kind of very rapid shift that causes mass extinctions.

  • There are rarely to never any actual numbers reported in the media, thus, making it a non-scientific claim.
It is a scientific claim. If you favor media outlets that don't report actual numbers, that's a personal choice on your part. The numbers are widely available and regularly reported.
  • About half of the warming that occurs in that time happens prior to 1940, before it could have been caused by human activity. This warming was probably a natural rebound from the Little Ice Age, a cool period that ended in the middle of the 19th century.
Incorrect. The warming is being attributed by scientists to greenhouse gas emissions by humans. That would be expected to ramp up with the industrial revolution, which happened long before 1940. What makes you think that warming before 1940 couldn't have been caused by human activity?
  • Using proxies, there were warmer temperatures during Roman times and the Middle Ages, when “recorded history” describes wine grapes growing in Northern England and Newfoundland.
Which proxies, in particular, are you referring to?
  • We know that the earth is going through a series of freezing and warming cycles on a scale of tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of years. And it has mostly been freezing. We’re fortunate enough to live in a cozy, warm “interglacial” period between ice ages. So we’re all staring down the barrel of the next ice age, yet we’re spending our time worrying about global warming.
The vast majority of scientists, and nearly all leading climate scientists are telling us that global warming is happening and that it's mostly the result of human activities. Where do you get the notion that they're wrong, specifically?
  • The margin of error for the study is 5 times as large as the claimed increase:
    • The alleged ‘record’ amounted to an increase over 2010, the previous ‘warmest year’, of just two-hundredths of a degree—or 0.02C. The margin of error is said by scientists to be approximately 0.1C—several times as much.
The warming has been VASTLY greater than the margin of error. It's just the claim that one particular year has been the warmest that is within the margin of error. Maybe 2014 wasn't the warmest year. Maybe 2010 was. Maybe 2013 was. We can't say for sure, because of the margin of error. But we can say that temperatures have been getting much warmer in recent decades.

  • GISS’s director Gavin Schmidt has now admitted NASA thinks the likelihood that 2014 was the warmest year since 1880 is just 38 per cent. However, when asked by this newspaper whether he regretted that the news release did not mention this, he did not respond.
Why would he regret the news release? 2014 was the hottest year in the temperature record. That's simply a fact. The temperature record, itself, is subject to a margin of error, but NASA has never pretended otherwise.

Denialists are a funny lot. When there is a cooler year, they seize on it, even though the cooling is within the margin of error and that year could well be the hottest since instrument records began. Yet when there's a warmer year, they insist that the same data set is meaningless because of that margin of error. There's a reason than nearly all denialism is confined to people with no scientific training. Ignorance really helps a person swallow that tripe.
 
may-snow_wide-0bd8548805fa832764cf91491230bbd6634fcb5c.jpg


"freak may 2015 snowstorms destroy crops, gardens"

"NASA 'pristine site' temperature monitor shows 10 year cooling trend"

http://dailycaller.com/2015/06/15/a...ion-data-shows-us-in-a-10-year-cooling-trend/

don't you get tired of being wrong ALL the time ?
What I get tired of is having to explain the same stuff over and over to deeply stupid people like you, knowing all the while that your IQ is simply too low to grasp it. No matter how many times I tell you that the "10 year cooling trend" is just for the US, and that this is an extremely tiny portion of the globe, and that the data in no way changes the trend of global warming, you'll still post the same irrelevance in a thread about GLOBAL warming again and again and again. Honestly, it's amazing you ever even learned to tie your shoes.
 
What I get tired of is having to explain the same stuff over and over to deeply stupid people like you, knowing all the while that your IQ is simply too low to grasp it. No matter how many times I tell you that the "10 year cooling trend" is just for the US, and that this is an extremely tiny portion of the globe, and that the data in no way changes the trend of global warming, you'll still post the same irrelevance in a thread about GLOBAL warming again and again and again. Honestly, it's amazing you ever even learned to tie your shoes.

no wonder you have no clients
I can see you melting as above while in courtroom........

"you stupid people" don't know how smart I think I am, STFU ☻
 
no wonder you have no clients
I can see you melting as above while in courtroom........

"you stupid people" don't know how smart I think I am, STFU ☻
I have never had a problem getting clients. But, of course, I wouldn't tell a client he was an idiot, even if he was as stupid as you or "as seen on TV". Here, where I'm not being paid and it doesn't matter what people think of me, I can be more honest.
 
True. But that's just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to evidence of warming. There are a vast array of paleoclimate reconstructions based on all different methods (e.g., tree ring data, ice core sampling, geological evidence of glacier extents, sediment sampling, and so on). And it all builds a picture that tells us things have been heating up more rapidly than at any point in the last several thousand years, and this is despite an unusually dim solar cycle. All that points to anthropogenic causes, and given the huge increase in CO2 from known human fossil fuel burning, it's no surprise.
  • Our planet has been much hotter than this, that's a fact.
True, but I fail to see the relevance. Our planet once was a ball of molten rock in a newly forming solar system, but that doesn't mean we'll be just fine unless temperatures get even hotter than that.

  • All changes in temperature that we observe today are relatively small variations within a much larger trend on a geological time scale.
The point, though is that this isn't along a "geological time scale." We're not talking about a few degrees warming for every few thousand years, where ecosystems could be expected to shift and species to evolve to cope with it. We're talking about the kind of very rapid shift that causes mass extinctions.

  • There are rarely to never any actual numbers reported in the media, thus, making it a non-scientific claim.
It is a scientific claim. If you favor media outlets that don't report actual numbers, that's a personal choice on your part. The numbers are widely available and regularly reported.
  • About half of the warming that occurs in that time happens prior to 1940, before it could have been caused by human activity. This warming was probably a natural rebound from the Little Ice Age, a cool period that ended in the middle of the 19th century.
Incorrect. The warming is being attributed by scientists to greenhouse gas emissions by humans. That would be expected to ramp up with the industrial revolution, which happened long before 1940. What makes you think that warming before 1940 couldn't have been caused by human activity?
  • Using proxies, there were warmer temperatures during Roman times and the Middle Ages, when “recorded history” describes wine grapes growing in Northern England and Newfoundland.
Which proxies, in particular, are you referring to?
  • We know that the earth is going through a series of freezing and warming cycles on a scale of tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of years. And it has mostly been freezing. We’re fortunate enough to live in a cozy, warm “interglacial” period between ice ages. So we’re all staring down the barrel of the next ice age, yet we’re spending our time worrying about global warming.
The vast majority of scientists, and nearly all leading climate scientists are telling us that global warming is happening and that it's mostly the result of human activities. Where do you get the notion that they're wrong, specifically?
  • The margin of error for the study is 5 times as large as the claimed increase:
    • The alleged ‘record’ amounted to an increase over 2010, the previous ‘warmest year’, of just two-hundredths of a degree—or 0.02C. The margin of error is said by scientists to be approximately 0.1C—several times as much.
The warming has been VASTLY greater than the margin of error. It's just the claim that one particular year has been the warmest that is within the margin of error. Maybe 2014 wasn't the warmest year. Maybe 2010 was. Maybe 2013 was. We can't say for sure, because of the margin of error. But we can say that temperatures have been getting much warmer in recent decades.

  • GISS’s director Gavin Schmidt has now admitted NASA thinks the likelihood that 2014 was the warmest year since 1880 is just 38 per cent. However, when asked by this newspaper whether he regretted that the news release did not mention this, he did not respond.
Why would he regret the news release? 2014 was the hottest year in the temperature record. That's simply a fact. The temperature record, itself, is subject to a margin of error, but NASA has never pretended otherwise.

Denialists are a funny lot. When there is a cooler year, they seize on it, even though the cooling is within the margin of error and that year could well be the hottest since instrument records began. Yet when there's a warmer year, they insist that the same data set is meaningless because of that margin of error. There's a reason than nearly all denialism is confined to people with no scientific training. Ignorance really helps a person swallow that tripe.

I would think that one who fancies himself to be so intellectually superior to all of the "merely mortals" who do not believe as he does would shy away from trying to use sh it like, "The vast majority of scientists, and nearly all leading climate scientists are telling us that global warming is happening and that it's mostly the result of human activities.", in his attempt to PROVE something to others.

Most of the really intelligent folk I ever spoke to knew that consensus does NOT a fact or truth make.

At one time in history you could have pointed out how the vast majority of scientists, and nearly all leading doctors were scoffing at the idea there were teny tiny little critters floating around out there that you couldn't see or tell were there making you sick and rotting wounds too but that didn't make it a fact or the truth, am I right?

At one time in history you could have honestly argued that the vast majority of scientists, and nearly all leading scholars and academia in general were all telling us that the earth was flat.

Didn't mean it was an actual fact or the truth now did it, hoss?

But today, right NOW, somehow a "consensus" does just that......Weird, right?
 
I would think that one who fancies himself to be so intellectually superior to all of the "merely mortals" who do not believe as he does would shy away from trying to use sh it like, "The vast majority of scientists, and nearly all leading climate scientists are telling us that global warming is happening and that it's mostly the result of human activities.", in his attempt to PROVE something to others.

Well, that's because you aren't very bright. If you were brighter, you'd understand the reasoning behind that approach to analyzing the question.

Climate change is a difficult topic. It's the kind of thing where those who really have a grasp on it have spent many years of full-time labor getting themselves up-to-speed. Most got doctorates in related fields, they keep up with the latest literature, and actively participate in peer review and in performing primary research. It would take a titanic ego for me --a person who hasn't done that kind of work needed to get myself up-to-speed-- to assume I know more about the topic than the clear majority of those who have put in that effort. My ego may be pretty big, but even I'm not that kind of psychotic egotist.

So, at the end of the day, I realize I'm stuck with a meta-analysis. Absent many thousands of hours of work to develop a meaningful independent understanding of the science, the best I can hope to do is to figure out where those who have put in those thousands of hours have come out on the issue, and base my views on that. If I look into that and find out that a large group of experts have spent a lot of time and effort looking into it, and that a large majority of those have come down in favor of a particular position, the reasonable course of action for me is to adopt the working assumption that they're more likely than not to be right. Although I haven't done enough homework for a meaningful independent appraisal of the science itself, I've done enough to have a solid sense of the consensus view.

Most of the really intelligent folk I ever spoke to knew that consensus does NOT a fact or truth make.

It's not a question of a consensus making a fact. It's a question of whether a reasonable person acts with the assumption that a strong expert consensus is correct, or goes with a blind hope that it isn't.

Take, for example, the theory that AIDS is caused by HIV. There is a strong expert consensus in favor of that. But there are a handful of doctors who insist it isn't. And there's always the possibility that some new evidence will come out that will overturn the consensus. The consensus doesn't make it a fact. But, that isn't the question at hand. The question is whether public policy should be set with the working assumption that the consensus is correct. Should, for example, public policy be set with the idea that reducing the transmission of HIV will reduce AIDS? Should public policy focus on developing treatments involving anti-virals to reduce HIV loads? Most advanced nations decided to address it that way, and the results for them have been very good. The rate of new AIDS cases has declined greatly and survival of those with HIV infections has increased greatly. But in some places denialism was strong, particularly in Africa. And results in those areas were horrible.

There are CONSTANTLY cases where public policy has to be set either with a working assumption that a scientific consensus is correct, or by ignoring the consensus. Should smoking be discouraged with the idea that the expert consensus that it causes cancer is probably correct? Should lead be removed from interior paints and gasoline with the assumption that the expert consensus that it causes developmental problems is correct? Should an investment be made into developing an atomic bomb, with the assumption that the expert consensus is correct that an explosive chain reaction is possible? Should an area be evacuated based on an expert consensus that a hurricane heading that way will cause seriously life-threatening conditions?

Time and again public policy is set based on those kinds of working assumptions that an expert consensus is correct. That doesn't mean the expert consensus necessarily is correct. It just means that reasonable people will favor setting public policy based on a working assumption that it is. In that same way, reasonable people favor setting public policy based on the working assumption that the climate is warming, that anthropogenic greenhouse gases are the majority of the reason, and that this will cause serious problems for humans if we don't limit that increase in greenhouse gases. Maybe the consensus position will some day fall apart. But, for now, the reasonable course of action is to assume it's correct.
 
I have never had a problem getting clients. But, of course, I wouldn't tell a client he was an idiot, even if he was as stupid as you or "as seen on TV". Here, where I'm not being paid and it doesn't matter what people think of me, I can be more honest.

sure
right
really
 
Well, that's because you aren't very bright. If you were brighter, you'd understand the reasoning behind that approach to analyzing the question.

Climate change is a difficult topic. It's the kind of thing where those who really have a grasp on it have spent many years of full-time labor getting themselves up-to-speed. Most got doctorates in related fields, they keep up with the latest literature, and actively participate in peer review and in performing primary research. It would take a titanic ego for me --a person who hasn't done that kind of work needed to get myself up-to-speed-- to assume I know more about the topic than the clear majority of those who have put in that effort. My ego may be pretty big, but even I'm not that kind of psychotic egotist.

So, at the end of the day, I realize I'm stuck with a meta-analysis. Absent many thousands of hours of work to develop a meaningful independent understanding of the science, the best I can hope to do is to figure out where those who have put in those thousands of hours have come out on the issue, and base my views on that. If I look into that and find out that a large group of experts have spent a lot of time and effort looking into it, and that a large majority of those have come down in favor of a particular position, the reasonable course of action for me is to adopt the working assumption that they're more likely than not to be right. Although I haven't done enough homework for a meaningful independent appraisal of the science itself, I've done enough to have a solid sense of the consensus view.



It's not a question of a consensus making a fact. It's a question of whether a reasonable person acts with the assumption that a strong expert consensus is correct, or goes with a blind hope that it isn't.

Take, for example, the theory that AIDS is caused by HIV. There is a strong expert consensus in favor of that. But there are a handful of doctors who insist it isn't. And there's always the possibility that some new evidence will come out that will overturn the consensus. The consensus doesn't make it a fact. But, that isn't the question at hand. The question is whether public policy should be set with the working assumption that the consensus is correct. Should, for example, public policy be set with the idea that reducing the transmission of HIV will reduce AIDS? Should public policy focus on developing treatments involving anti-virals to reduce HIV loads? Most advanced nations decided to address it that way, and the results for them have been very good. The rate of new AIDS cases has declined greatly and survival of those with HIV infections has increased greatly. But in some places denialism was strong, particularly in Africa. And results in those areas were horrible.

There are CONSTANTLY cases where public policy has to be set either with a working assumption that a scientific consensus is correct, or by ignoring the consensus. Should smoking be discouraged with the idea that the expert consensus that it causes cancer is probably correct? Should lead be removed from interior paints and gasoline with the assumption that the expert consensus that it causes developmental problems is correct? Should an investment be made into developing an atomic bomb, with the assumption that the expert consensus is correct that an explosive chain reaction is possible? Should an area be evacuated based on an expert consensus that a hurricane heading that way will cause seriously life-threatening conditions?

Time and again public policy is set based on those kinds of working assumptions that an expert consensus is correct. That doesn't mean the expert consensus necessarily is correct. It just means that reasonable people will favor setting public policy based on a working assumption that it is. In that same way, reasonable people favor setting public policy based on the working assumption that the climate is warming, that anthropogenic greenhouse gases are the majority of the reason, and that this will cause serious problems for humans if we don't limit that increase in greenhouse gases. Maybe the consensus position will some day fall apart. But, for now, the reasonable course of action is to assume it's correct.


Yeah, got it..........

To be safe public policy should be set based upon majority opinion.

Except when it shouldn't.

When that opinion is one YOU share, when it results in public policy which will allow those who feel as you do on the mater to dictate what needs to be done to everyone else, like how global warming would empower you to restrict the rights of others as far as energy goes, in THOSE instances public policy should be set based upon majority opinion.

When that opinion is one YOU do NOT share, if it would result in public policy which would NOT allow those who feel as you do on the mater to dictate what needs to be done to everyone else, like how a majority opinion on gay marriage would empower OTHERS to restrict the rights of YOU to force everyone to assist you in wedding the pool boy brucie or something, in THOSE instances public policy should not be set based upon majority opinion.

Clear as mud. Loony li bby "logic" at its finest.

As I said,......Got it...
 
True. But that's just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to evidence of warming. There are a vast array of paleoclimate reconstructions based on all different methods (e.g., tree ring data, ice core sampling, geological evidence of glacier extents, sediment sampling, and so on). And it all builds a picture that tells us things have been heating up more rapidly than at any point in the last several thousand years, and this is despite an unusually dim solar cycle. All that points to anthropogenic causes, and given the huge increase in CO2 from known human fossil fuel burning, it's no surprise.
  • Our planet has been much hotter than this, that's a fact.
True, but I fail to see the relevance. Our planet once was a ball of molten rock in a newly forming solar system, but that doesn't mean we'll be just fine unless temperatures get even hotter than that.

  • All changes in temperature that we observe today are relatively small variations within a much larger trend on a geological time scale.
The point, though is that this isn't along a "geological time scale." We're not talking about a few degrees warming for every few thousand years, where ecosystems could be expected to shift and species to evolve to cope with it. We're talking about the kind of very rapid shift that causes mass extinctions.

  • There are rarely to never any actual numbers reported in the media, thus, making it a non-scientific claim.
It is a scientific claim. If you favor media outlets that don't report actual numbers, that's a personal choice on your part. The numbers are widely available and regularly reported.
  • About half of the warming that occurs in that time happens prior to 1940, before it could have been caused by human activity. This warming was probably a natural rebound from the Little Ice Age, a cool period that ended in the middle of the 19th century.
Incorrect. The warming is being attributed by scientists to greenhouse gas emissions by humans. That would be expected to ramp up with the industrial revolution, which happened long before 1940. What makes you think that warming before 1940 couldn't have been caused by human activity?
  • Using proxies, there were warmer temperatures during Roman times and the Middle Ages, when “recorded history” describes wine grapes growing in Northern England and Newfoundland.
Which proxies, in particular, are you referring to?
  • We know that the earth is going through a series of freezing and warming cycles on a scale of tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of years. And it has mostly been freezing. We’re fortunate enough to live in a cozy, warm “interglacial” period between ice ages. So we’re all staring down the barrel of the next ice age, yet we’re spending our time worrying about global warming.
The vast majority of scientists, and nearly all leading climate scientists are telling us that global warming is happening and that it's mostly the result of human activities. Where do you get the notion that they're wrong, specifically?
  • The margin of error for the study is 5 times as large as the claimed increase:
    • The alleged ‘record’ amounted to an increase over 2010, the previous ‘warmest year’, of just two-hundredths of a degree—or 0.02C. The margin of error is said by scientists to be approximately 0.1C—several times as much.
The warming has been VASTLY greater than the margin of error. It's just the claim that one particular year has been the warmest that is within the margin of error. Maybe 2014 wasn't the warmest year. Maybe 2010 was. Maybe 2013 was. We can't say for sure, because of the margin of error. But we can say that temperatures have been getting much warmer in recent decades.

  • GISS’s director Gavin Schmidt has now admitted NASA thinks the likelihood that 2014 was the warmest year since 1880 is just 38 per cent. However, when asked by this newspaper whether he regretted that the news release did not mention this, he did not respond.
Why would he regret the news release? 2014 was the hottest year in the temperature record. That's simply a fact. The temperature record, itself, is subject to a margin of error, but NASA has never pretended otherwise.

Denialists are a funny lot. When there is a cooler year, they seize on it, even though the cooling is within the margin of error and that year could well be the hottest since instrument records began. Yet when there's a warmer year, they insist that the same data set is meaningless because of that margin of error. There's a reason than nearly all denialism is confined to people with no scientific training. Ignorance really helps a person swallow that tripe.


''Denialists are a funny lot.''

Well until globalwarmalists begin to call Oil and Coal what they really are which is mineral, abiotics which rise from the center of the Earth and are self replenishing, and stop calling them by the ridiculous title of 'fossil fuels' --- we can't take any of it seriously, can we?
 
What's your point?
My point is that it does a great job visualizing the process. It allows people to see the way there is a great deal of variability from month to month and from year to year, but that new records keep getting set on a regular basis, and averages just keep rising over any extended period. I think some people get confused by the "noise." That think that if we haven't set a new all-time high in a few years, that means that global warming must have reversed. But the visualization makes it clear how it's not uncommon to go a few years without a new record, and for their to be unusually cold months or seasons or even years, amidst a clear upward trend.
 
''Denialists are a funny lot.''

Well until globalwarmalists begin to call Oil and Coal what they really are which is mineral, abiotics which rise from the center of the Earth and are self replenishing, and stop calling them by the ridiculous title of 'fossil fuels' --- we can't take any of it seriously, can we?
Let me guess -- no actual science training, eh? There is near-total unity among geologists on the question of these things being fossil fuels. And those who have to put their money where their mouths are -- searching for these fuels -- do so on the basis of methods that only make sense in light of the fossil fuel understanding (e.g., looking for oil in places of ancient seas).
 
Let me guess -- no actual science training, eh? There is near-total unity among geologists on the question of these things being fossil fuels. And those who have to put their money where their mouths are -- searching for these fuels -- do so on the basis of methods that only make sense in light of the fossil fuel understanding (e.g., looking for oil in places of ancient seas).

It depends on how deep one is prepared to dig.

Until more of them start telling the truth what difference does it make what they say when it is all about saying the right thing to keep your job?
 
It depends on how deep one is prepared to dig.

Until more of them start telling the truth what difference does it make what they say when it is all about saying the right thing to keep your job?
The coal and oil we actually produce is of biological origin. It doesn't show the equal distribution of left-handed and right-handed molecules that we see with non-biological synthesis. Instead, the molecules are left-handed, the way we see biological organisms building them. So, for the fuels we're actually using, they're all or nearly all fossil fuels. Could there be other non-biological oil or coal somewhere deep down where we haven't found it in any significant quantities? Conceivably. Maybe we just haven't dug deep enough or we've dug the wrong places. But there's no particular reason to believe it. And there's reason to be skeptical, since even in areas of high volcanic activity (where the deeper earth layers bulge up towards the surface) we aren't finding wellsprings of non-biological coal and oil. And in Russia, where the deepest holes ever were drilled, there's no oil extraction from those sites -- Russian oil comes from the same kind of ancient sea beds that oil from other parts of the world comes from, and shows the same left-handedness.
 
Back
Top