Arkady
President
Right-wing politicians continue to cite "moral decay" as the reason for tragedies like Newtown:
http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.co...-moral-decay-after-school-shooting/?hpt=hp_t2
I suspect some of them are just trying to distract from substantive policy suggestions (like restricting guns, or spending more money on treating mental illness). They figure if they can get us navel gazing for a while, reform efforts will lose steam. But, whatever their motivations, I think there's something there. Even if I take my maximum estimate of the role that guns and poor healthcare in the US play in our violent crime problems, I still wind up with a big chunk of the problem unexplained. In other words, even if we could fix those two problems to the maximum extent practical, I think we'd still be left with a violent crime rate that's considerably elevated above what other wealthy nations have.
So, there's something else at work, and if a person wants to call it "moral decay," that's fine, as long as that's followed by a serious discussion about how to fix that decay. What do people here suggest? What specific policy changes can we try to work on the cultural side of our national violent crime problem?
Before you answer, think about a couple things:
First, our violent crime problem has already decreased by almost half in the last two decades. So if you focus on something that has supposedly gone wrong in that time, you're probably barking up the wrong tree. Whatever went wrong, predates that, and, if anything, we appear to be on the right track in recent decades. So, for example, if you want to ban violent video games (which took off in the early 90s, even as the violent crime rate went into free-fall), that won't make much sense.
Second, our violent crime problem is much worse than the problem in Western Europe, Canada, Australia, and Japan. So, if your prescription is something that would take the US even farther away from what's going on in those peer countries, it's unlikely to help, and could make things worse. So, for example, the US is already considerably more religious than those countries, so if your prescription is a policy that encourages a religious revival, not only is that unlikely to help, it could actually make the problem worse.
Having said that, I'm open to other ideas. I just hope they're specific policy suggestions, rather than vague ranting. I also hope that they have some rational connection with global and historical trends, and what those trends tell us about the nature of the problem.
http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.co...-moral-decay-after-school-shooting/?hpt=hp_t2
I suspect some of them are just trying to distract from substantive policy suggestions (like restricting guns, or spending more money on treating mental illness). They figure if they can get us navel gazing for a while, reform efforts will lose steam. But, whatever their motivations, I think there's something there. Even if I take my maximum estimate of the role that guns and poor healthcare in the US play in our violent crime problems, I still wind up with a big chunk of the problem unexplained. In other words, even if we could fix those two problems to the maximum extent practical, I think we'd still be left with a violent crime rate that's considerably elevated above what other wealthy nations have.
So, there's something else at work, and if a person wants to call it "moral decay," that's fine, as long as that's followed by a serious discussion about how to fix that decay. What do people here suggest? What specific policy changes can we try to work on the cultural side of our national violent crime problem?
Before you answer, think about a couple things:
First, our violent crime problem has already decreased by almost half in the last two decades. So if you focus on something that has supposedly gone wrong in that time, you're probably barking up the wrong tree. Whatever went wrong, predates that, and, if anything, we appear to be on the right track in recent decades. So, for example, if you want to ban violent video games (which took off in the early 90s, even as the violent crime rate went into free-fall), that won't make much sense.
Second, our violent crime problem is much worse than the problem in Western Europe, Canada, Australia, and Japan. So, if your prescription is something that would take the US even farther away from what's going on in those peer countries, it's unlikely to help, and could make things worse. So, for example, the US is already considerably more religious than those countries, so if your prescription is a policy that encourages a religious revival, not only is that unlikely to help, it could actually make the problem worse.
Having said that, I'm open to other ideas. I just hope they're specific policy suggestions, rather than vague ranting. I also hope that they have some rational connection with global and historical trends, and what those trends tell us about the nature of the problem.
