New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

How we can measure the difference between...

Raoul_Luke

"Wait, it's all Marxism?" "Always has been."
The Trump economy and Obama's:

https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2018-02-08/inflation-alert-velocity-money-has-finally-bottomed

As I maintained all along, the Obama "recovery" was tepid despite trillions in Fed quantitative easing, due to his decidedly anti-business & anti-wealth agenda. And the way we knew that was the case was the steady decline in the velocity of money in the face of all that Fed "easing." Once the Obama agenda ended, just the fact that he was out of office led to the animal spirits of capitalism to reawaken. And the result is this nascent reversal in the trend line of money velocity. Of course, the problem with this is that the Fed went way over board in "easing" and now all that liquidity is leaking out of speculative financial assets, real estate and high end collectables, and making its way into the real economy. That means inflation folks:

http://money.cnn.com/2018/02/02/news/economy/january-jobs-report-2018/index.html

And that means higher interest rates. And so that is why the stock market is crashing - the air is coming out of that bubble. I keep telling you this isn't rocket science...
 
Looks like the GOP held a contest in which GOP sycophants had to cook up half-assed fairy tales blaming the Trump stock market plunge on Obama.

;-)
 
Looks like the GOP held a contest in which GOP sycophants had to cook up half-assed fairy tales blaming the Trump stock market plunge on Obama.

;-)

LOL! I hadn't even thought of that angle. Thanks for pointing it out...
 
The Trump economy and Obama's:

https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2018-02-08/inflation-alert-velocity-money-has-finally-bottomed

As I maintained all along, the Obama "recovery" was tepid despite trillions in Fed quantitative easing, due to his decidedly anti-business & anti-wealth agenda. And the way we knew that was the case was the steady decline in the velocity of money in the face of all that Fed "easing." Once the Obama agenda ended, just the fact that he was out of office led to the animal spirits of capitalism to reawaken. And the result is this nascent reversal in the trend line of money velocity. Of course, the problem with this is that the Fed went way over board in "easing" and now all that liquidity is leaking out of speculative financial assets, real estate and high end collectables, and making its way into the real economy. That means inflation folks:

http://money.cnn.com/2018/02/02/news/economy/january-jobs-report-2018/index.html

And that means higher interest rates. And so that is why the stock market is crashing - the air is coming out of that bubble. I keep telling you this isn't rocket science...

If manufacturing is not profitable, because there is a glut of manufactured goods on a market unable to afford them, capital won't be invested in manufacturing no matter how business-friendly the political climate is. The sharp rise in private - sector jobs since 2014 suggests that the decline in velocity of money had less to do with Obama's purported anti-capitalist agenda (lol) and more to do with the deep international crisis of the capitalist market.
 
The Trump economy and Obama's:

https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2018-02-08/inflation-alert-velocity-money-has-finally-bottomed

As I maintained all along, the Obama "recovery" was tepid despite trillions in Fed quantitative easing, due to his decidedly anti-business & anti-wealth agenda. And the way we knew that was the case was the steady decline in the velocity of money in the face of all that Fed "easing." Once the Obama agenda ended, just the fact that he was out of office led to the animal spirits of capitalism to reawaken. And the result is this nascent reversal in the trend line of money velocity. Of course, the problem with this is that the Fed went way over board in "easing" and now all that liquidity is leaking out of speculative financial assets, real estate and high end collectables, and making its way into the real economy. That means inflation folks:

http://money.cnn.com/2018/02/02/news/economy/january-jobs-report-2018/index.html

And that means higher interest rates. And so that is why the stock market is crashing - the air is coming out of that bubble. I keep telling you this isn't rocket science...
So I guess you can go back through last year and highlight all the times you posted that the fast rising stock market was Obama doing ?

So, let's see em !
 
The Trump economy and Obama's:

https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2018-02-08/inflation-alert-velocity-money-has-finally-bottomed

As I maintained all along, the Obama "recovery" was tepid despite trillions in Fed quantitative easing, due to his decidedly anti-business & anti-wealth agenda. And the way we knew that was the case was the steady decline in the velocity of money in the face of all that Fed "easing." Once the Obama agenda ended, just the fact that he was out of office led to the animal spirits of capitalism to reawaken. And the result is this nascent reversal in the trend line of money velocity. Of course, the problem with this is that the Fed went way over board in "easing" and now all that liquidity is leaking out of speculative financial assets, real estate and high end collectables, and making its way into the real economy. That means inflation folks:

http://money.cnn.com/2018/02/02/news/economy/january-jobs-report-2018/index.html

And that means higher interest rates. And so that is why the stock market is crashing - the air is coming out of that bubble. I keep telling you this isn't rocket science...
I know the stock market is in bubble because you cite "animal spirits" as a reason for the economic growth. "Animal Spirits" tells me a good portion of people have abandoned fundamental analysis, and they have been trading irrationally.
 
As I maintained all along, the Obama "recovery" was tepid despite trillions in Fed quantitative easing, due to his decidedly anti-business & anti-wealth agenda. And the way we knew that was the case was the steady decline in the velocity of money in the face of all that Fed "easing." Once the Obama agenda ended, just the fact that he was out of office led to the animal spirits of capitalism to reawaken
Are you including Trump among those "animal spirits"?
rising%20rates.jpg

Geopolitical risk seems to worry investors more than inflationo_O
https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2018-02-08/inflation-alert-velocity-money-has-finally-bottomed
 
If manufacturing is not profitable, because there is a glut of manufactured goods on a market unable to afford them, capital won't be invested in manufacturing no matter how business-friendly the political climate is.
Personal-Consumption-Expenditures-as-a-Percent-of-US-GDP-by-Decade.jpg

https://jobenomicsblog.com/consumption-based-economy/

"2 September 2013

"The USA is a consumption-based economy and America is a consumption-driven society.

"Neither fact is necessarily good or bad.

"It is the way America has operated for a century.

"The issues at hand are (1) whether America can sustain high rates of consumption in an ever changing geo-political/economic environment, and (2) what are the consequences of a reduced consumption-based economy?"

Another issue at hand is what happens when robots and AI replace millions of additional US workers.

Will displaced employees demand government nationalize the means of production?
 
I know the stock market is in bubble because you cite "animal spirits" as a reason for the economic growth. "Animal Spirits" tells me a good portion of people have abandoned fundamental analysis, and they have been trading irrationally.

Precisely wrong. Animal spirits ARE "the people," as opposed to the institutions (Wall Street banks, the government, large mega-corporations). THEY all did exceptionally well throughout the Obama non-recovery. Now the people are finally starting to gain:

http://money.cnn.com/2018/02/02/news/economy/january-jobs-report-2018/index.html

And the government industrial complex is having a shit fit:

http://money.cnn.com/2018/02/06/investing/stock-market-turmoil-global/index.html
 
Precisely wrong. Animal spirits ARE "the people," as opposed to the institutions (Wall Street banks, the government, large mega-corporations). THEY all did exceptionally well throughout the Obama non-recovery. Now the people are finally starting to gain:

http://money.cnn.com/2018/02/02/news/economy/january-jobs-report-2018/index.html

And the government industrial complex is having a shit fit:

http://money.cnn.com/2018/02/06/investing/stock-market-turmoil-global/index.html
"animal spirits" is just made up term for some peoples feelings, some people feel the economy is stronger than it was under Obama when very little has changed about the fundamentals. When emotions are involved in the market, it's a clear sign of bubble territory.

The whole dergegulatory movement conflates additional risk with additional growth. Deregulating industry is increasing the risk in the industry. Sure, there is a possibility that industry doesn't take their new found freedoms as a way to cut corners. And there is a possibility that even when they do cut corners the outcome won't be so bad. But now there is risk that they will cut corners leading to additional safety, environmental, and fraud risk, which can and will spill over into financial risk.
 
"animal spirits" is just made up term for some peoples feelings, some people feel the economy is stronger than it was under Obama when very little has changed about the fundamentals. When emotions are involved in the market, it's a clear sign of bubble territory.

The whole dergegulatory movement conflates additional risk with additional growth. Deregulating industry is increasing the risk in the industry. Sure, there is a possibility that industry doesn't take their new found freedoms as a way to cut corners. And there is a possibility that even when they do cut corners the outcome won't be so bad. But now there is risk that they will cut corners leading to additional safety, environmental, and fraud risk, which can and will spill over into financial risk.

No, it's a descriptive term for the economy's (the "markets'") natural tendency toward growth, as a result of people working in their own best interests to improve their lot in life (i.e. capitalism). Seriously, the two clearest indicators of the economy's "fundamentals" are the velocity of money and wage growth (and their evil twins, inflation and interest rates). The reason you lefties were (rightly) ridiculed for touting the Obama "recovery" is simply because there was no evidence of wage growth and/or any discussion about the need for "normalizing" interest rates.

As for "risk," you don't get reward without it. And the definition of a "bubble" is when investors decide that there is no risk. And with respect to taking "emotions" out of markets, nothing does that like communism. It puts emotions out in the street, like in Venezuela:

venezuela chaos

Personally, I'd rather have it put to good use in the (free) markets...
 
No, it's a descriptive term for the economy's (the "markets'") natural tendency toward growth, as a result of people working in their own best interests to improve their lot in life (i.e. capitalism). Seriously, the two clearest indicators of the economy's "fundamentals" are the velocity of money and wage growth (and their evil twins, inflation and interest rates). The reason you lefties were (rightly) ridiculed for touting the Obama "recovery" is simply because there was no evidence of wage growth and/or any discussion about the need for "normalizing" interest rates.

As for "risk," you don't get reward without it. And the definition of a "bubble" is when investors decide that there is no risk. And with respect to taking "emotions" out of markets, nothing does that like communism. It puts emotions out in the street, like in Venezuela:

venezuela chaos

Personally, I'd rather have it put to good use in the (free) markets...
Who determines what "normal" interest rates are anyway?
There was no inflation expectation so the interest rates were low. That's sound policy.
It will be interesting to see if Powell does his job and raises interest rates when the inflation expectation is clearly rising or if he bows to political pressure and doesn't raise interest rates which will lead to uncontrolled inflation. If I were a betting man, I would bet the Trump appointee caves to political pressure.
 
Who determines what "normal" interest rates are anyway?
There was no inflation expectation so the interest rates were low. That's sound policy.
It will be interesting to see if Powell does his job and raises interest rates when the inflation expectation is clearly rising or if he bows to political pressure and doesn't raise interest rates which will lead to uncontrolled inflation. If I were a betting man, I would bet the Trump appointee caves to political pressure.

There was no inflation expectation because the velocity of money was on a protracted decline. I would say a "normal" interest rate is one that exceeds zero percent, which it was for the entirety of the Obama administration. Which is not "sound" policy, it's an extraordinary effort to overcome an anti-capitalist agenda.

You may well be right about Powell - I know nothing about him. But regardless, his actions have zero consequence to this discussion. That is a moot point...
 
There was no inflation expectation because the velocity of money was on a protracted decline. I would say a "normal" interest rate is one that exceeds zero percent, which it was for the entirety of the Obama administration. Which is not "sound" policy, it's an extraordinary effort to overcome an anti-capitalist agenda.

You may well be right about Powell - I know nothing about him. But regardless, his actions have zero consequence to this discussion. That is a moot point...
The zero to negative interest rates were due to deflation which at the time was more of an economic threat that inflation.
 
Back
Top