Arkady
President
One of the dumber lines of "reasoning" I've heard from abortion opponents involves looking at the products of the decision not to have an abortion, and arguing that shows that abortion is bad. In its bumper sticker form, it goes like this "Choose Life -- Your Mother Did."
It should be clear how inane that "logic" is, simply by considering all the other stuff your mother chose that resulted in you. Your mother chose to have sex with your father, for starters. Does this mean it would be good for you to do so, too? More seriously, your mother probably chose not to use birth control on the night of your conception -- does that mean choosing birth control (even abstinence) is necessarily bad?
Or, if you prefer, flip it around and consider all the people who are only around because their mothers chose to have an abortion. Before you reject that as impossible, remember that lots of women choose to terminate a pregnancy and then later choose to keep one. For example, a woman could get pregnant in college, choose not to have a child at that point, and then choose to have one later, when she's in a better position to raise a family. Lots of those women would not have had the children later in life if they'd kept the pregnancy they had earlier. And so lots of people alive today are only alive because their mothers chose to have abortions. That doesn't make the choice of abortion any better or worse.
It should be clear how inane that "logic" is, simply by considering all the other stuff your mother chose that resulted in you. Your mother chose to have sex with your father, for starters. Does this mean it would be good for you to do so, too? More seriously, your mother probably chose not to use birth control on the night of your conception -- does that mean choosing birth control (even abstinence) is necessarily bad?
Or, if you prefer, flip it around and consider all the people who are only around because their mothers chose to have an abortion. Before you reject that as impossible, remember that lots of women choose to terminate a pregnancy and then later choose to keep one. For example, a woman could get pregnant in college, choose not to have a child at that point, and then choose to have one later, when she's in a better position to raise a family. Lots of those women would not have had the children later in life if they'd kept the pregnancy they had earlier. And so lots of people alive today are only alive because their mothers chose to have abortions. That doesn't make the choice of abortion any better or worse.