New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Intrade Divergence

Arkady

President
Earlier, when I was urging people to buy Romney's stock on Intrade, any time it dipped under $4, a few of us speculated that one thing that might cause it to rise, late in the election, would be manipulation by the Romney campaign. If it was ever seen as worthwhile to create an artificial bounce (which would only happen if Intrade got a lot of press coverage, as a kind of quasi-poll), manipulation could be done relatively cheaply, given the low volume on the exchange... a single wealthy person could do it without great expense.

I'm not sure if that's what's happening, but I wouldn't be surprised. Romney's stock has suddenly surged upwards, following what was, according to all of the polls, a big win for Obama in the last debate. Right now, it's selling at $4.45, representing a 44.5% chance of victory. Sophisticated state-by-state election modeling puts Romney's chances between about 30% and 40%. The 538 blog, associated with the NYT, is the most commonly cited analysis, and it has Romney's chances at 31.9%. To win, Romney almost certainly needs Ohio, which is currently tilting towards Obama by an average of about 3 points in recent polls, AND Virginia, which is tilting towards Obama by about one point. If I were a betting man, I'd bet on Romney taking Virginia, but Ohio is going to be tough for him.... about as tough as for Obama to win Florida, which would also throw the election to Obama. So, right now, 44.5% chance for Romney feels pretty high to me.
 
Maybe Romney's alledged tidal wave of momentum has convinced the party faithfull that he really is gonna pull it off, and have finally put their money where their mouth is?
 
Maybe Romney's alledged tidal wave of momentum has convinced the party faithfull that he really is gonna pull it off, and have finally put their money where their mouth is?

That's possible. The Republican base is certainly delusional by nature. Still, this looks more like market manipulation. Probably a smart move, as I would expect a better ROI from such behavior than from more negative ad buys. People are sick of political ads by now.
 
Could be. I've got a feeling it's manipulation, though. Either way, it looks like an opportunity to make money... the cost of gaming Intrade is paying an inflated purchase price for those shares, and thus likely losing money. Whatever money the manipulators (or credulous party faithful) are losing is money that others are gaining. If I weren't concerned about Intrade's legal gray area, I'd be betting on Obama until Romney falls back below $4.
 
It's funny....when he was at $2.00 a share....you couldn't get a Righty (especially those who claim good insight into "investments") to buy a single share....

now he's in the $4.50 range and it's too late. :D
 
Doubtful than any person who understand investing would listen to lefty after four years of Obama...was there any actual green energy company that did not go bankrupt after getting money from Obama...and did any of those CEO's give back there money they got in Salary? Making money is Buy low sell high....it's called profit ...so when Romney becomes President in November do you sell? or do you wait and see if it goes higher after the inaguration...and what about lefty stock iin Obama will there ever be any value in Obama stock?
 
Doubtful than any person who understand investing would listen to lefty after four years of Obama...was there any actual green energy company that did not go bankrupt after getting money from Obama...and did any of those CEO's give back there money they got in Salary? Making money is Buy low sell high....it's called profit ...so when Romney becomes President in November do you sell? or do you wait and see if it goes higher after the inaguration...and what about lefty stock iin Obama will there ever be any value in Obama stock?

Drum, why didn't YOU buy stock in Romney when he was at $2.00 a share on InTrade.....you'd have made a fortune by now, much less Election Day???

:D
 
Doubtful than any person who understand investing would listen to lefty after four years of Obama

Actually DC theopposite is true. Market investments under Obama have done much better than under GWB. And market investments under Democratic administrations in GENERAL do abotu 33% better in the long run than under GOP.

That's just the historic data

FACTS MATTER
 
Turn on Bollinger Bands Ark.

Combined with the weighted moving averages and "price momentum" they tell a story of convergence to stability. I don't think the Romney campaign is spending to influence InTrade this late in the game. Instead I think that what's going on is that InTrade is moving from a predictive market mode, to a "representative" market mode. IE you are seeing a significant chunk of folks "voting their wallets" rather than their predictions. And that means that in a tight election you will see the numbers converge towards roughly 53:47 with some noise variance.

And that's exactly what they are doing.
 
D_O, you were were predicting a Romney win even in the "Dark Days" of late September when he was at $2.00-2.50 a share.....

yet never placed a bet on Mitt.

You could have been rich. :D
 
Intrade is a game, not an investment vehicle. I didn't have the guts to play it this time around. But, having observed it for the last year around, if it's back 4 years from now, I think I'll play it.
 
The Hill and WA Examiner? please.

Pull your head out of the Echo Chamber DO

I notice you do't address the actual topic which is INTRADE


BTW they aslo build ships in WA and CA.. but those ain't gonna go for Romney either.
 
I'm not sure there's much difference between a game and an investment vehicle, when money's on the line. Even betting on sports can be an investment, if you think of it the right way.
 
Turn on Bollinger Bands Ark.

Combined with the weighted moving averages and "price momentum" they tell a story of convergence to stability. I don't think the Romney campaign is spending to influence InTrade this late in the game. Instead I think that what's going on is that InTrade is moving from a predictive market mode, to a "representative" market mode. IE you are seeing a significant chunk of folks "voting their wallets" rather than their predictions. And that means that in a tight election you will see the numbers converge towards roughly 53:47 with some noise variance.

And that's exactly what they are doing.

Why 53:47?
 
I'm not sure there's much difference between a game and an investment vehicle, when money's on the line. Even betting on sports can be an investment, if you think of it the right way.

No doubt. I think maybe what I meant to suggest was that the average lay person should consider it in the vein of a "game", rather than an investment. The problem I have with the Intrade model, is that the share value is capped at $10. That enables the manipulators who would "invest" in Mitt, by buying up shares for "appearences", rather than on the expectation that he might win the election. By capping the share price, the manipulators can "fix" their cost. If the share price weren't capped, they couldn't.
 
They do build ships in Virginia.

But then, you guys are always saying that "government cannot create jobs".

Given that, they certainly can't create jobs in Virginia building ships, can they?

Aren't you folks suffering from massive cognitive dissonance by this point?

Because if not, it must mean you are utterly lacking in cognition.
 
Why 53:47?

Because the base election is trending roughly towards 51:48, and there still is a complement in the InTrade Market that is buying/selling based on "predictiveness" rather than "representation/selfidentification". And that tends to pull slightly in the direction of likely winner/likely loser.

I suspect that we will see Intrade's numbers diverge again in the last fiew days before the election
 
I suspect much of it has to do with a) the outlier national Gallup poll b) the low price just prior to that and c) a sudden run on Willard stock from people looking to make a quick buck.

You think Adelson didn't buy a few million shares?

Trust me, they will all dump when they see the next round of polls and it'll be back in the mid $3 range by Friday of next week.
 
Back
Top