New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Is Herd Immunity the Answer?

Mr. Friscus

Governor
There are two mindsets that can be applied to how we deal with this crisis moving forward

1. Treat all people of all ages in all areas the exact same, a big one-size-fits-all decree (Leftist preference).

2. Treat the different age ranges and areas according to the data (Conservative preference).

Take Wyoming for instance. They have 596 cases, and 7 deaths. New York has over 300,000 cases and almost 20,000 deaths. Not only would prominent Democrats and media advocate to treat the states equally in a feel-good "I care" decree, but would scorn those in Wyoming for opening their business, being in any sort of close contact with others, etc.

The problem becomes that the standard set means it has to be applied across the board. Now, anything that kills 7 people means we have to shut down Wyoming, and that would include a LOT of things. The risk is infinitely low, yet we have government forcing them to shut down and possibly lose their entire livelihood. I smell massive law suits.

I mean, maybe we can be smarter than a 5th grader and realize that different areas can be treated differently. Maybe upstate New York didn't need to be completely shut down, but New York city did. The Data certainly says that.

And this goes for age as well.

Let's be data driven. Instead of citizens of all ages, 12-year-olds to 87-year-olds, being locked away, maybe we allow the young and healthy, who statistically have almost 0 chance of dying from this, go out and be in public, work, etc. That way they develop herd immunity, becoming immune before a cure is found. Let's follow the data and keep those who have a high mortality rate (the elderly, and especially those with preexisting conditions) in heavy quarantine.

Let's stop ignoring data, and instead relying on theories and the worst-case-scenario, as we are currently doing. So many models have been thankfully wrong and on the low side. We can be careful in public, but this lockdown mentality could actually be harming more people in the long run. We don't have a cure yet, so the longer we have people getting sick (no herd immunity), the more danger the elderly are subjected to.

Hell, it might make more sense to completely quarantine seniors for a month, and intentionally encourage the healthy to get infected. After a few weeks, immunity.

Sweden looks to be ahead of the curve, as they've taken this type of road. We haven't, especially in places like New York, and the numbers are horrible (Of course, it's not Cuomo or Deblasio's fault, it's Trumps). LOL

My advice? Based on the data?
1. Uphold and possible sadly increase quarantine procedures for the elderly and sick
2. Open schools, children are at near 0 risk.
3. Open most businesses. Encourage masks and a distancing mentality if you want, but put the onus on the individual, and arm the young and healthy with data of their infinitely low mortality rate from this disease (a shockingly high amount of people think we are all in some sort of relevant danger, the data says that's completely incorrect).
4. Open outdoor areas and parks. Encourage the public to be healthy, get sun, exercise, and social to avoid depression and increased obesity.

With no cure, the only cure is herd immunity.
 
There are two mindsets that can be applied to how we deal with this crisis moving forward

1. Treat all people of all ages in all areas the exact same, a big one-size-fits-all decree (Leftist preference).

2. Treat the different age ranges and areas according to the data (Conservative preference).

Take Wyoming for instance. They have 596 cases, and 7 deaths. New York has over 300,000 cases and almost 20,000 deaths. Not only would prominent Democrats and media advocate to treat the states equally in a feel-good "I care" decree, but would scorn those in Wyoming for opening their business, being in any sort of close contact with others, etc.

The problem becomes that the standard set means it has to be applied across the board. Now, anything that kills 7 people means we have to shut down Wyoming, and that would include a LOT of things. The risk is infinitely low, yet we have government forcing them to shut down and possibly lose their entire livelihood. I smell massive law suits.

I mean, maybe we can be smarter than a 5th grader and realize that different areas can be treated differently. Maybe upstate New York didn't need to be completely shut down, but New York city did. The Data certainly says that.

And this goes for age as well.

Let's be data driven. Instead of citizens of all ages, 12-year-olds to 87-year-olds, being locked away, maybe we allow the young and healthy, who statistically have almost 0 chance of dying from this, go out and be in public, work, etc. That way they develop herd immunity, becoming immune before a cure is found. Let's follow the data and keep those who have a high mortality rate (the elderly, and especially those with preexisting conditions) in heavy quarantine.

Let's stop ignoring data, and instead relying on theories and the worst-case-scenario, as we are currently doing. So many models have been thankfully wrong and on the low side. We can be careful in public, but this lockdown mentality could actually be harming more people in the long run. We don't have a cure yet, so the longer we have people getting sick (no herd immunity), the more danger the elderly are subjected to.

Hell, it might make more sense to completely quarantine seniors for a month, and intentionally encourage the healthy to get infected. After a few weeks, immunity.

Sweden looks to be ahead of the curve, as they've taken this type of road. We haven't, especially in places like New York, and the numbers are horrible (Of course, it's not Cuomo or Deblasio's fault, it's Trumps). LOL

My advice? Based on the data?
1. Uphold and possible sadly increase quarantine procedures for the elderly and sick
2. Open schools, children are at near 0 risk.
3. Open most businesses. Encourage masks and a distancing mentality if you want, but put the onus on the individual, and arm the young and healthy with data of their infinitely low mortality rate from this disease (a shockingly high amount of people think we are all in some sort of relevant danger, the data says that's completely incorrect).
4. Open outdoor areas and parks. Encourage the public to be healthy, get sun, exercise, and social to avoid depression and increased obesity.

With no cure, the only cure is herd immunity.

It’s not even clear yet that survivors of the virus have immunity and, if so, how long it lasts or how strong it is.
 
De Santis is 18 to 20x less popular.

Popular as in school-yard teenaged image concerns?

Or popular as in population?

Florida: 21,000,000 people, 1,400 deaths
New York: 20,000,000 people, 20,000 deaths.

I think there's different factors at play that could cause a mild difference, but nothing that would account for all. What do you think Cuomo and DeBlasio are doing that is wrong? Why is their state so deadly?
 
There are two mindsets that can be applied to how we deal with this crisis moving forward

1. Treat all people of all ages in all areas the exact same, a big one-size-fits-all decree (Leftist preference).

2. Treat the different age ranges and areas according to the data (Conservative preference).

Take Wyoming for instance. They have 596 cases, and 7 deaths. New York has over 300,000 cases and almost 20,000 deaths. Not only would prominent Democrats and media advocate to treat the states equally in a feel-good "I care" decree, but would scorn those in Wyoming for opening their business, being in any sort of close contact with others, etc.

The problem becomes that the standard set means it has to be applied across the board. Now, anything that kills 7 people means we have to shut down Wyoming, and that would include a LOT of things. The risk is infinitely low, yet we have government forcing them to shut down and possibly lose their entire livelihood. I smell massive law suits.

I mean, maybe we can be smarter than a 5th grader and realize that different areas can be treated differently. Maybe upstate New York didn't need to be completely shut down, but New York city did. The Data certainly says that.

And this goes for age as well.

Let's be data driven. Instead of citizens of all ages, 12-year-olds to 87-year-olds, being locked away, maybe we allow the young and healthy, who statistically have almost 0 chance of dying from this, go out and be in public, work, etc. That way they develop herd immunity, becoming immune before a cure is found. Let's follow the data and keep those who have a high mortality rate (the elderly, and especially those with preexisting conditions) in heavy quarantine.

Let's stop ignoring data, and instead relying on theories and the worst-case-scenario, as we are currently doing. So many models have been thankfully wrong and on the low side. We can be careful in public, but this lockdown mentality could actually be harming more people in the long run. We don't have a cure yet, so the longer we have people getting sick (no herd immunity), the more danger the elderly are subjected to.

Hell, it might make more sense to completely quarantine seniors for a month, and intentionally encourage the healthy to get infected. After a few weeks, immunity.

Sweden looks to be ahead of the curve, as they've taken this type of road. We haven't, especially in places like New York, and the numbers are horrible (Of course, it's not Cuomo or Deblasio's fault, it's Trumps). LOL

My advice? Based on the data?
1. Uphold and possible sadly increase quarantine procedures for the elderly and sick
2. Open schools, children are at near 0 risk.
3. Open most businesses. Encourage masks and a distancing mentality if you want, but put the onus on the individual, and arm the young and healthy with data of their infinitely low mortality rate from this disease (a shockingly high amount of people think we are all in some sort of relevant danger, the data says that's completely incorrect).
4. Open outdoor areas and parks. Encourage the public to be healthy, get sun, exercise, and social to avoid depression and increased obesity.

With no cure, the only cure is herd immunity.
It is really quite simple> These draconian COVID measures play right into the "control freak" nature of statist lefties. It's like a kid home alone with a freezer full of ice cream. There's a reason you see over the top actions in this regard.
 
It is really quite simple> These draconian COVID measures play right into the "control freak" nature of statist lefties. It's like a kid home alone with a freezer full of ice cream. There's a reason you see over the top actions in this regard.
Reason being will use their freedom to endanger others.
 
Every time you get behind the wheel you endanger others. Every headcold or flu you ever had endangers others. It’s ok.

We should help those at risk by participating in the economy that sustains them.
Na, I think I will continue to save money and continue to socially distance. I am gonna do What's best for me.
 
1. Treat all people of all ages in all areas the exact same, a big one-size-fits-all decree (Leftist preference).

2. Treat the different age ranges and areas according to the data (Conservative preference).

Roughly -

When you have an Ebola epidemic you do number 1.

When you have a flu epidemic you do number 2.

when something is "novel" you do number 1 (if there is no containment) until you have data to do number 2 or stay with number 1 for a definite period of time.

You should have universal shutdowns for number 1 for 14 days and extend it to 21 total if the quarantine/isolation dike is breached. In that time you hopefully have re-built the quarantine dike so that you can go back to testing and contact tracing when dealing with number 1 types.

Your advice is what the Swedes did (an the UK started to do) and it worked for them (i.e. the Swedes). They played informed Russian roulette with Covid and seem to have come out the winners.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top