New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Jindal and Walker Make Educational Statements...

Craig

Senator
Supporting Member
Two stories hit me this morning. Two men who have their sights set on the Oval Office are in the news regarding their stances, and actions, on higher education. Neither man impresses me.

The first one I encountered told of Bobby Jindal, who, while making a speech stating higher education was key, he submitted a budget slashing education. I see education for educational purposes valuable in itself. Growing the flexible, thinking mind, not one dedicated to a certain "job", but a mind able to adapt to changing circumstances.

So...the stories...


“Why is it important to fund and support public education?” he asked the attendees of the American Principles Project’s conference. “Because if we want to keep the republic we have, our republic can only be as good as our citizens. So we need an educated population with critical thinking skills. We need to train citizens to be responsible, functioning adults. I always hear from parents, from the Chamber of Commerce, from business groups that we’ve got to fund education.”

But Jindal, whose mother studied at Louisiana State University after immigrating from India, is currently trying to cut the budget of the state colleges by as much as $300 million — nearly a third of the system’s current budget.

Officials in Louisiana on both sides of the aisle are blasting Jindal’s proposed budget cuts, saying they would cripple the state’s public higher education.



http://thinkprogress.org/election/2015/02/05/3619958/bobby-jindal-education-speech/

The Jindal reality is far different...

Louisiana’s higher education budget, one of the few discretionary targets, has been slashed by more than just about any other state since 2008; there are a thousand fewer full-time college faculty members on the state payroll, and next year Louisiana State University, the state’s flagship institution, is facing a potential 40 percent cut in its operating budget. Possible cuts to health care for next year, when compounded by the loss of matching federal dollars, could approach $1 billion.

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/07/u...t-center-of-louisiana-budget-vortex.html?_r=0



The next one comes from Wisconsin, where the Governor seemingly quietly altered the mission of the State University.


Stunned educators accused Gov. Scott Walker on Wednesday of trying to kill the Wisconsin Idea, which has guided the mission of the state's public higher education system for more than a century.

And although the governor backed away from his early position, both university officials and his own words seemed to contradict how the issue unfolded...

...First articulated in 1904, the Wisconsin Idea states that the mission of the UW System is to solve problems and improve people's lives beyond the classroom. The core principle is that "the boundaries of the university are the boundaries of the state."

Walker hadn't alluded to changing the UW System's mission during his budget speech Tuesday night; it does not appear he had ever mentioned it publicly.


But in the proposed budget he released Tuesday, the governor made the UW System's mission to "meet the state's workforce needs." He also proposed striking language about public service and improving the human condition, and deleting the phrase: "Basic to every purpose of the system is the search for truth."...


http://www.jsonline.com/news/educat...the-wisconsin-idea-b99439020z1-290797681.html
 
Two stories hit me this morning. Two men who have their sights set on the Oval Office are in the news regarding their stances, and actions, on higher education. Neither man impresses me.

The first one I encountered told of Bobby Jindal, who, while making a speech stating higher education was key, he submitted a budget slashing education. I see education for educational purposes valuable in itself. Growing the flexible, thinking mind, not one dedicated to a certain "job", but a mind able to adapt to changing circumstances.

So...the stories...


“Why is it important to fund and support public education?” he asked the attendees of the American Principles Project’s conference. “Because if we want to keep the republic we have, our republic can only be as good as our citizens. So we need an educated population with critical thinking skills. We need to train citizens to be responsible, functioning adults. I always hear from parents, from the Chamber of Commerce, from business groups that we’ve got to fund education.”

But Jindal, whose mother studied at Louisiana State University after immigrating from India, is currently trying to cut the budget of the state colleges by as much as $300 million — nearly a third of the system’s current budget.

Officials in Louisiana on both sides of the aisle are blasting Jindal’s proposed budget cuts, saying they would cripple the state’s public higher education.



http://thinkprogress.org/election/2015/02/05/3619958/bobby-jindal-education-speech/

The Jindal reality is far different...

Louisiana’s higher education budget, one of the few discretionary targets, has been slashed by more than just about any other state since 2008; there are a thousand fewer full-time college faculty members on the state payroll, and next year Louisiana State University, the state’s flagship institution, is facing a potential 40 percent cut in its operating budget. Possible cuts to health care for next year, when compounded by the loss of matching federal dollars, could approach $1 billion.

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/07/u...t-center-of-louisiana-budget-vortex.html?_r=0



The next one comes from Wisconsin, where the Governor seemingly quietly altered the mission of the State University.


Stunned educators accused Gov. Scott Walker on Wednesday of trying to kill the Wisconsin Idea, which has guided the mission of the state's public higher education system for more than a century.

And although the governor backed away from his early position, both university officials and his own words seemed to contradict how the issue unfolded...

...First articulated in 1904, the Wisconsin Idea states that the mission of the UW System is to solve problems and improve people's lives beyond the classroom. The core principle is that "the boundaries of the university are the boundaries of the state."

Walker hadn't alluded to changing the UW System's mission during his budget speech Tuesday night; it does not appear he had ever mentioned it publicly.


But in the proposed budget he released Tuesday, the governor made the UW System's mission to "meet the state's workforce needs." He also proposed striking language about public service and improving the human condition, and deleting the phrase: "Basic to every purpose of the system is the search for truth."...


http://www.jsonline.com/news/educat...the-wisconsin-idea-b99439020z1-290797681.html

Just to be clear... money ALONE doesn't mean much, apparently. Although in Louisiana's case, cutting the budget probably isn't the best idea...

Utah spends its education dollars most efficiently, scoring 86 points on the Nation’s Report Card for every $1,000 spent on education. Despite spending only $6,441 per pupil, less than any other state, Utah’s combined reading and math score on the Nation’s Report Card beats 20 other states.


Nationwide, math and reading points per every $1,000 spent on education range from 28 in New York to 86 in Utah. The District of Columbia performs even worse than New York, earning only 26 points per $1,000 spent. The District of Columbia spends $19,847 per pupil, more than any state, and gets the lowest combined math and reading score, 513 points, on the Nation’s Report Card. Meanwhile, New York spends $19,396 per pupil, the most of any state.


Massachusetts has the best combined score on the Nation’s Report Card, with math and reading results combining for 578 points on average. Despite that, it receives just 39 points for every $1,000 spent per pupil, 15th worst in the nation.

Mississippi is the state with the lowest combined math and reading scores in the nation, with just 524 points on the Nation’s Report Card. However, it gets 65 points per every $1,000 spent per pupil, 10th best in the nation.


The Nation’s Report Card, which gets results from the National Assessment of Educational Progress, is widely-considered to be the gold standard measure of educational success. Given semi-annually, NAEP results from this article are from 2013.


New state fiscal data for the 2011 to 2012 school year was released in January by the National Center for Education Statistics.


States in the Northeast get relatively little for the dollars they spend on education, with every state getting fewer than 50 points for every $1,000 spent. States in the West and South perform better. Louisiana is the only Southern state to get fewer than 50 points for $1,000 spent.


http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/w...ng-for-their-educational-buck/article/2559887
 
Just to be clear... money ALONE doesn't mean much, apparently. Although in Louisiana's case, cutting the budget probably isn't the best idea...

Utah spends its education dollars most efficiently, scoring 86 points on the Nation’s Report Card for every $1,000 spent on education. Despite spending only $6,441 per pupil, less than any other state, Utah’s combined reading and math score on the Nation’s Report Card beats 20 other states.


Nationwide, math and reading points per every $1,000 spent on education range from 28 in New York to 86 in Utah. The District of Columbia performs even worse than New York, earning only 26 points per $1,000 spent. The District of Columbia spends $19,847 per pupil, more than any state, and gets the lowest combined math and reading score, 513 points, on the Nation’s Report Card. Meanwhile, New York spends $19,396 per pupil, the most of any state.


Massachusetts has the best combined score on the Nation’s Report Card, with math and reading results combining for 578 points on average. Despite that, it receives just 39 points for every $1,000 spent per pupil, 15th worst in the nation.

Mississippi is the state with the lowest combined math and reading scores in the nation, with just 524 points on the Nation’s Report Card. However, it gets 65 points per every $1,000 spent per pupil, 10th best in the nation.


The Nation’s Report Card, which gets results from the National Assessment of Educational Progress, is widely-considered to be the gold standard measure of educational success. Given semi-annually, NAEP results from this article are from 2013.


New state fiscal data for the 2011 to 2012 school year was released in January by the National Center for Education Statistics.


States in the Northeast get relatively little for the dollars they spend on education, with every state getting fewer than 50 points for every $1,000 spent. States in the West and South perform better. Louisiana is the only Southern state to get fewer than 50 points for $1,000 spent.


http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/w...ng-for-their-educational-buck/article/2559887

Yes...not the "best" idea...:rolleyes: Much like the idea of a Jindal presidency...not the "best".

Regardless, I do appreciate your attempt to move the discussion away from Jindal and Walker by clouding the discussion with your money "alone" comments and page of statistics.

.
 
Yes...not the "best" idea...:rolleyes: Much like the idea of a Jindal presidency...not the "best".

Regardless, I do appreciate your attempt to move the discussion away from Jindal and Walker by clouding the discussion with your money "alone" comments and page of statistics.

.

I'm not trying to move anything. I'm simply trying to open your mind (an impossible task, I know) to the possibility that simply throwing more and more money at something isn't always the answer.

As shown in my post.
 
I'm not trying to move anything. I'm simply trying to open your mind (an impossible task, I know) to the possibility that simply throwing more and more money at something isn't always the answer.

As shown in my post.

Why do you make such an assumption? I certainly made no mention of the efficiency with which education funds are spent. Nor did I say a word about spending more money.

I was trying to focus on the words and actions of two men...Two men running for the Oval Office. You didn't like that, so you tried a different tact.
 
Two stories hit me this morning. Two men who have their sights set on the Oval Office are in the news regarding their stances, and actions, on higher education. Neither man impresses me.

The first one I encountered told of Bobby Jindal, who, while making a speech stating higher education was key, he submitted a budget slashing education. I see education for educational purposes valuable in itself. Growing the flexible, thinking mind, not one dedicated to a certain "job", but a mind able to adapt to changing circumstances.

So...the stories...


“Why is it important to fund and support public education?” he asked the attendees of the American Principles Project’s conference. “Because if we want to keep the republic we have, our republic can only be as good as our citizens. So we need an educated population with critical thinking skills. We need to train citizens to be responsible, functioning adults. I always hear from parents, from the Chamber of Commerce, from business groups that we’ve got to fund education.”

But Jindal, whose mother studied at Louisiana State University after immigrating from India, is currently trying to cut the budget of the state colleges by as much as $300 million — nearly a third of the system’s current budget.

Officials in Louisiana on both sides of the aisle are blasting Jindal’s proposed budget cuts, saying they would cripple the state’s public higher education.



http://thinkprogress.org/election/2015/02/05/3619958/bobby-jindal-education-speech/

The Jindal reality is far different...

Louisiana’s higher education budget, one of the few discretionary targets, has been slashed by more than just about any other state since 2008; there are a thousand fewer full-time college faculty members on the state payroll, and next year Louisiana State University, the state’s flagship institution, is facing a potential 40 percent cut in its operating budget. Possible cuts to health care for next year, when compounded by the loss of matching federal dollars, could approach $1 billion.

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/07/u...t-center-of-louisiana-budget-vortex.html?_r=0



The next one comes from Wisconsin, where the Governor seemingly quietly altered the mission of the State University.


Stunned educators accused Gov. Scott Walker on Wednesday of trying to kill the Wisconsin Idea, which has guided the mission of the state's public higher education system for more than a century.

And although the governor backed away from his early position, both university officials and his own words seemed to contradict how the issue unfolded...

...First articulated in 1904, the Wisconsin Idea states that the mission of the UW System is to solve problems and improve people's lives beyond the classroom. The core principle is that "the boundaries of the university are the boundaries of the state."

Walker hadn't alluded to changing the UW System's mission during his budget speech Tuesday night; it does not appear he had ever mentioned it publicly.


But in the proposed budget he released Tuesday, the governor made the UW System's mission to "meet the state's workforce needs." He also proposed striking language about public service and improving the human condition, and deleting the phrase: "Basic to every purpose of the system is the search for truth."...


http://www.jsonline.com/news/educat...the-wisconsin-idea-b99439020z1-290797681.html
Let's be clear. Republicans want to privatize education. They are not pro-labor. They want to bust up teachers' unions. It is also a way to get religious indoctrination and ideological indoctrination into schools.
 
Wow...300 million dollars...what would be left? I guess state aide, faculty, and equipment would just be desecrated.

Not defending Jindal, but just throwing another thought out. SU's spend an awful lot of money on things that are non essential to education and the cost is reflected in their need for funding and in tuition. Certainly you don't correct that by cutting 300 million from a budget and I don't think that was Jindal's reason anyway. Just saying....colleges spend a lot of money on useless stuff.
 
Let's be clear. Republicans want to privatize education. They are not pro-labor. They want to bust up teachers' unions. It is also a way to get religious indoctrination and ideological indoctrination into schools.

Can't find much to argue with there.

This part about Walker really bothers me...the quiet alterations of mission statements.


But in the proposed budget he released Tuesday, the governor made the UW System's mission to "meet the state's workforce needs." He also proposed striking language about public service and improving the human condition, and deleting the phrase: "Basic to every purpose of the system is the search for truth."...
 
Wow...300 million dollars...what would be left? I guess state aide, faculty, and equipment would just be desecrated.

Not defending Jindal, but just throwing another thought out. SU's spend an awful lot of money on things that are non essential to education and the cost is reflected in their need for funding and in tuition. Certainly you don't correct that by cutting 300 million from a budget and I don't think that was Jindal's reason anyway. Just saying....colleges spend a lot of money on useless stuff.

It's 300 million on top of already slashed cuts over the past six years...That's why I bother to post such things as this:

Louisiana’s higher education budget, one of the few discretionary targets, has been slashed by more than just about any other state since 2008; there are a thousand fewer full-time college faculty members on the state payroll...


Useless stuff those faculty members...
 
It's 300 million on top of already slashed cuts over the past six years...That's why I bother to post such things as this:

Louisiana’s higher education budget, one of the few discretionary targets, has been slashed by more than just about any other state since 2008; there are a thousand fewer full-time college faculty members on the state payroll...


Useless stuff those faculty members...

I was reading that Jindal came up with a 4o million dollar fund for universities aimed to further education in certain disciplines. But many universities spent the money on the campuses. Anyway it's moot now because that's part of the cut he's talking about.

I didn't say faculty members. You did. If you want to have a conversation with yourself, just let me know and I'll stop answering you.
 
I was reading that Jindal came up with a 4o million dollar fund for universities aimed to further education in certain disciplines. But many universities spent the money on the campuses. Anyway it's moot now because that's part of the cut he's talking about.

I didn't say faculty members. You did. If you want to have a conversation with yourself, just let me know and I'll stop answering you.

Right...I posted an article about cuts on top of cuts...and posted article that stated that there are 1000 fewer faculty members. You're the one who inserted useless spending into the discussion...yet gave not one single example.
 
Back
Top