New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Judge Gladys Keller

I posted this at the time -

http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/jul/09/guantanamo-bay-videotapes-force-feeding

''A federal judge appears ready to defy the Obama administration and accelerate the release of potentially inflammatory videotapes depicting the force-feeding of detainees at Guantánamo Bay.

Judge Gladys Kessler has accused the administration of launching baseless legal challenges to delay or minimize the impact of a court-ordered release of videotapes showing what lawyers who have viewed them say is brutal and shocking treatment.

A Justice Department challenge to Kessler’s order last year to disclose the classified footage is among “the most frivolous I’d ever seen,” Kessler said at a Thursday hearing at the US district court in Washington DC. The delays, which have lasted the better part of a year, have served to diminish the “cause for concern” by the public about the Guantánamo force-feedings, Kessler said.

Kessler said she would soon order a timetable for release of the tapes, despite Justice Department lawyer Andrew Warden’s objections that removing the faces and names of US personnel at Guantánamo remains a laborious process.

“We’re going to move as fast as we can,” Kessler said.''

That was in July

The full order - http://apps.washingtonpost.com/g/documents/local/dhiab-vs-obama-opinion/1780/

http://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1308951/dhiab-vs-bush.pdf


The Obama admin are still dragging their feet and I saw somewhere yesterday they are mounting another appeal against showing the footage. If we have Human Rights laws, right or wrong - shouldn't there be transparency and shouldn't everyone be accountable. especially those who write the laws?
 
I don't think force feeding someone is an inflammatory as waterboarding them.

or as outrageous as sending overseas assassins to knock of putin's rivals with radioactive polonium.

perhaps the Gitmo detainees were protesting against Michelle Obama's healthy menu makeover?
 
I don't think force feeding someone is an inflammatory as waterboarding them.

or as outrageous as sending overseas assassins to knock of putin's rivals with radioactive polonium.

perhaps the Gitmo detainees were protesting against Michelle Obama's healthy menu makeover?

They are tied down, their mouths forced open, a tube rammed down their throats, it is excruciatingly painful ( watch the video in the Guardian link) and lasts hours on end. every single day --- until they cannot eat naturally, their insides are so damaged.

Why shouldn't the pubic be able to judge for themselves though?

There is something like ten hours of this footage which everyone who has seen it says has haunted them ever since.

He wasn't Putin's rival at all, not in any way was he even a whisper of a threat to Putin- his rivals were of the underworld Oligarchs in London.
 
I posted this at the time -

http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/jul/09/guantanamo-bay-videotapes-force-feeding

''A federal judge appears ready to defy the Obama administration and accelerate the release of potentially inflammatory videotapes depicting the force-feeding of detainees at Guantánamo Bay.

Judge Gladys Kessler has accused the administration of launching baseless legal challenges to delay or minimize the impact of a court-ordered release of videotapes showing what lawyers who have viewed them say is brutal and shocking treatment.

A Justice Department challenge to Kessler’s order last year to disclose the classified footage is among “the most frivolous I’d ever seen,” Kessler said at a Thursday hearing at the US district court in Washington DC. The delays, which have lasted the better part of a year, have served to diminish the “cause for concern” by the public about the Guantánamo force-feedings, Kessler said.

Kessler said she would soon order a timetable for release of the tapes, despite Justice Department lawyer Andrew Warden’s objections that removing the faces and names of US personnel at Guantánamo remains a laborious process.

“We’re going to move as fast as we can,” Kessler said.''

That was in July

The full order - http://apps.washingtonpost.com/g/documents/local/dhiab-vs-obama-opinion/1780/

http://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1308951/dhiab-vs-bush.pdf


The Obama admin are still dragging their feet and I saw somewhere yesterday they are mounting another appeal against showing the footage. If we have Human Rights laws, right or wrong - shouldn't there be transparency and shouldn't everyone be accountable. especially those who write the laws?
Interesting story, I wonder how much coverage it would be receiving if the President's name was Bush, and not Obama.
Funny how you don't hear the left squawking about "torture" and this is causing "more terrorism to occur".
Dead silence really.
 
They are tied down, their mouths forced open, a tube rammed down their throats, it is excruciatingly painful ( watch the video in the Guardian link) and lasts hours on end. every single day --- until they cannot eat naturally, their insides are so damaged.

Why shouldn't the pubic be able to judge for themselves though?

There is something like ten hours of this footage which everyone who has seen it says has haunted them ever since.

He wasn't Putin's rival at all, not in any way was he even a whisper of a threat to Putin- his rivals were of the underworld Oligarchs in London.
yeah - I think they use the same procedure for mental patients.

which begs the question - are jihadists who behead unbelievers and sell their kids as sex slaves "sane", or not?
 
yeah - I think they use the same procedure for mental patients.

which begs the question - are jihadists who behead unbelievers and sell their kids as sex slaves "sane", or not?

Which begs another question.

Whatever our opinions, for they can only be opinions, informed or otherwise, of the 'Prisoners of Gitmo'.

One, they have been denied a fair trial or any trial at all, even our unquestioned 'habeas corpus' was ditched for a very long time, no-one even knew who was there - this goes against every Treaty or Convention ever signed by the US. The US has got around this by imprisoning them outside US territory so they are not covered by your constitutional rights. They are not classed as POWs so those rights are fucked. But even so they have legal and moral Rights within international Conventions and Treaties and Charters.

And two - read what those who have seen the footage say about it, if it is as horrendous as they say, then we must also ask if it is appropriate to treat prisoners and the mentally damaged or sick in such an inhumane manner rather than dismissing it by sayin 'Oh pooh, they do that to the mentally disturbed all the time, so what'?

Terrorism is a criminal act --- Declaring that we are in a War against Terrorism was political rhetoric and bull shit in the first place, nonsense which has run away with its self. An act of terrorism is a criminal act as any charges bought should be criminal charges.

But where were the 'Prisoners of Gitmo' detained? In countries the US took War too - there again if a country occupies another they may legally detain partisans who fight against but they also are protected by Conventions.

This is no different to any Inquisition of the past --- we need question it, no matter who is in the WH because it crosses all political lines, and my own country was obviously in cahoots so this crosses borders too. And no matter who the prisoners are or are not. Equality under the law.
 
Interesting story, I wonder how much coverage it would be receiving if the President's name was Bush, and not Obama.
Funny how you don't hear the left squawking about "torture" and this is causing "more terrorism to occur".
Dead silence really.

Yes, I agree but it crosses admins - Repub and Dems did done do it. Both are involved.
 
Back
Top