Arkady
President
CBS's neoconservative talking head Lara Logan has been put on leave in the wake of her error-strewn reporting about the Benghazi attack. By nearly all accounts, the piece was scandalously bad, in ways that any good reporter and producer should have been able to detect and avoid with a little care, so it makes sense that she should be disciplined. If anything, I worry that the punishment will end up being too lenient. However, I do take issue with one count being used against her. Logan is being faulted for having taken hard-right stances on US policy regarding Benghazi, in public appearances, even as she continued to report on the subject, which CBS News has now indicated is in conflict with their standards. I disagree with that criticism. If she has hard-right views on the topic, better that those be openly aired, so people understand the perspective from which her reporting comes, than that she be encouraged by her channel's standards to masquerade as impartial.
Unless we want our "reporters" to be empty-headed, pretty-faced transcriptionists for political press releases ("the administration said this; the Republicans responded with that"), it's inevitable that they'll have strong opinions about many stories on which they report. You don't get to be a good reporter without thinking the subjects you're reporting are important, and if you're a smart person immersed in the facts of a topic you think is important, then of course you'll become opinionated about it. So there's no shame in that (putting aside whatever you think about Logan's Obama-bashing stance on Benghazi). What benefit is there in driving those sentiments underground? Let reporters be open and honest about their prejudices and the public can consider that context when evaluating the material. I'd rather see a Lara Logan report on Benghazi and know where her politics lie than to see it and think she's some neutral party following the facts wherever they happen to lead.
Unless we want our "reporters" to be empty-headed, pretty-faced transcriptionists for political press releases ("the administration said this; the Republicans responded with that"), it's inevitable that they'll have strong opinions about many stories on which they report. You don't get to be a good reporter without thinking the subjects you're reporting are important, and if you're a smart person immersed in the facts of a topic you think is important, then of course you'll become opinionated about it. So there's no shame in that (putting aside whatever you think about Logan's Obama-bashing stance on Benghazi). What benefit is there in driving those sentiments underground? Let reporters be open and honest about their prejudices and the public can consider that context when evaluating the material. I'd rather see a Lara Logan report on Benghazi and know where her politics lie than to see it and think she's some neutral party following the facts wherever they happen to lead.
