Arkady
President
Greatly boosting the rate of legal immigration would have a number of benefits:
(1) It would reduce the number of people here illegally. The major driver for people to come here illegally, or to overstay visas, is the availability of jobs for them. Even if it were practical to build a good enough wall to prevent southern border crossings, people would find other ways in, including coming in on temporary visas. As long as those job opening are there, the draw will remain. There are other ways to eliminate the job openings (e.g., sting operations against illegal employers, with draconian penalties), but filling those openings up with legal immigrants will help. Boosting legal immigration will also mean making it easier for people to come here legally, which will make that a more inviting option relative to the hardships and dangers of coming here illegally.
(2) It would help deal with one of our biggest economic challenges: a dependency ratio that keeps getting worse as the Baby Boomers age. The reason that Medicare and Social Security have long-term funding problems is that there just won't be enough young workers relative to the number of retirees. We can fix that easily enough, simply by inviting in a bunch of young workers -- evening out our demographic distribution.
(3) It would help with national debt. The proven formula for working your way out of high national debt is economic growth. That's the formula that took us from debt being over 120% of GDP at the end of WWII, to being only about 30% of GDP, prior to Reagan's fiscally catastrophic upper-class tax cuts. When the economy is growing fast enough, you don't even have to run budget surpluses for debt to become a smaller and smaller issue over time. But achieving 3% or higher GDP growth for extended periods is pretty much impossible without robust population growth. As recently as the 1990s, population grew by up to 1.4% in a year, and during the Baby Boom it peaked at over 2%. Now it's just 0.69%. The bigger our country gets, the smaller past debt is in proportion to the size of the country. Boosting legal immigration by about 2.3 million immigrants per year would bring us back to something more like 1990s-era growth rates, helping us to grow out of debt without the need for potentially counter-productive austerity.
(4) It would mean less overpopulation, globally, long term. There's a strong negative correlation between wealth and birth rates. A poor country can have birth rates five to seven times higher than a rich country (e.g., Niger at 46.12, versus Japan at 8.07). As migrants move from poorer countries to richer countries, they tend to have smaller families than were average in their countries of origin. That means fewer overall people. To the extent the exodus lowers resource competition in the source country, it can also theoretically lower population growth there, as well, by helping the source country to grow richer per capita.
(5) It would help to fight outsourcing. A well-stocked supply of low-skill labor in the US will keep the costs of such labor lower, helping us to be competitive with countries to which businesses may be considering outsourcing.
(6) It would cause upward pressure on the economic "ladder" in this country, provided we're mostly bringing in low-skill workers -- as new immigrants come in to take the bottom rungs of the economy, existing Americans will tend to move up into managerial roles, the same as happened in prior eras of mass immigration (e.g., when the Irish and Italians were arriving).
(7) It would keep American culture vibrant by continually stirring in new influences from around the world.
(8) It would make it easier for the US to keep its de facto role as the globe's economic hub, since we would have more personal connections with more foreign countries (including lots of bilingualism).
(9) It would drive down crime rates. Immigrants commit crimes at lower rates than US-born residents.
(10) It would improve average national health. Immigrants tend not to have developed the sedentary lifestyles and bad diets of native-born Americans, and so they live longer. Their good habits may influence the native-born population, too, by presenting us with healthier authentic cuisine options, as well as more active ways of living.
(11) It will reduce resource competition in poorer countries that can lead to wars, famines, and refugee crises.
(12) It will improve the US image abroad, especially in poorer countries, where more people will have personal relationships with people in the US, making it harder to demonize us.
(13) It will allow US values, such as democracy, pluralism, and a respect for individual rights to filter back into the countries that need them, by way of ex-pat influence.
(14) It would improve quality of life of existing Americans by way of making some upper-class luxuries more affordable to the middle-class (e.g., landscapers, housekeepers, etc.)
That's not to say that such mass migration would be without any problems. For example, it would almost certainly make us more religious. And all those "scary" brown people would probably only worsen the reactionary extremism on our political right. But given all the benefits, I think those would be prices worth paying.
(1) It would reduce the number of people here illegally. The major driver for people to come here illegally, or to overstay visas, is the availability of jobs for them. Even if it were practical to build a good enough wall to prevent southern border crossings, people would find other ways in, including coming in on temporary visas. As long as those job opening are there, the draw will remain. There are other ways to eliminate the job openings (e.g., sting operations against illegal employers, with draconian penalties), but filling those openings up with legal immigrants will help. Boosting legal immigration will also mean making it easier for people to come here legally, which will make that a more inviting option relative to the hardships and dangers of coming here illegally.
(2) It would help deal with one of our biggest economic challenges: a dependency ratio that keeps getting worse as the Baby Boomers age. The reason that Medicare and Social Security have long-term funding problems is that there just won't be enough young workers relative to the number of retirees. We can fix that easily enough, simply by inviting in a bunch of young workers -- evening out our demographic distribution.
(3) It would help with national debt. The proven formula for working your way out of high national debt is economic growth. That's the formula that took us from debt being over 120% of GDP at the end of WWII, to being only about 30% of GDP, prior to Reagan's fiscally catastrophic upper-class tax cuts. When the economy is growing fast enough, you don't even have to run budget surpluses for debt to become a smaller and smaller issue over time. But achieving 3% or higher GDP growth for extended periods is pretty much impossible without robust population growth. As recently as the 1990s, population grew by up to 1.4% in a year, and during the Baby Boom it peaked at over 2%. Now it's just 0.69%. The bigger our country gets, the smaller past debt is in proportion to the size of the country. Boosting legal immigration by about 2.3 million immigrants per year would bring us back to something more like 1990s-era growth rates, helping us to grow out of debt without the need for potentially counter-productive austerity.
(4) It would mean less overpopulation, globally, long term. There's a strong negative correlation between wealth and birth rates. A poor country can have birth rates five to seven times higher than a rich country (e.g., Niger at 46.12, versus Japan at 8.07). As migrants move from poorer countries to richer countries, they tend to have smaller families than were average in their countries of origin. That means fewer overall people. To the extent the exodus lowers resource competition in the source country, it can also theoretically lower population growth there, as well, by helping the source country to grow richer per capita.
(5) It would help to fight outsourcing. A well-stocked supply of low-skill labor in the US will keep the costs of such labor lower, helping us to be competitive with countries to which businesses may be considering outsourcing.
(6) It would cause upward pressure on the economic "ladder" in this country, provided we're mostly bringing in low-skill workers -- as new immigrants come in to take the bottom rungs of the economy, existing Americans will tend to move up into managerial roles, the same as happened in prior eras of mass immigration (e.g., when the Irish and Italians were arriving).
(7) It would keep American culture vibrant by continually stirring in new influences from around the world.
(8) It would make it easier for the US to keep its de facto role as the globe's economic hub, since we would have more personal connections with more foreign countries (including lots of bilingualism).
(9) It would drive down crime rates. Immigrants commit crimes at lower rates than US-born residents.
(10) It would improve average national health. Immigrants tend not to have developed the sedentary lifestyles and bad diets of native-born Americans, and so they live longer. Their good habits may influence the native-born population, too, by presenting us with healthier authentic cuisine options, as well as more active ways of living.
(11) It will reduce resource competition in poorer countries that can lead to wars, famines, and refugee crises.
(12) It will improve the US image abroad, especially in poorer countries, where more people will have personal relationships with people in the US, making it harder to demonize us.
(13) It will allow US values, such as democracy, pluralism, and a respect for individual rights to filter back into the countries that need them, by way of ex-pat influence.
(14) It would improve quality of life of existing Americans by way of making some upper-class luxuries more affordable to the middle-class (e.g., landscapers, housekeepers, etc.)
That's not to say that such mass migration would be without any problems. For example, it would almost certainly make us more religious. And all those "scary" brown people would probably only worsen the reactionary extremism on our political right. But given all the benefits, I think those would be prices worth paying.