New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Let's start with the basics.

First of all, who thinks that there is an endless supply of money? In theory, it is true that we could make money out of thin air making it true that there is an endless supply of money. But in practice, we all know that if money was as easy to make, get or create as that, it would have no value. So, intrinsically we all know that there is not an infinite supply of money. We also know that there definitely is money because it's in use today and that's how we operate. On one side of the curve is infinity and the other side is zero. Somewhere in between is where we are at any one point in time. The total supply of money is knowable, it is a number made up of all the money in circulation, in banks, in mattresses, in loans, in value, in the total liquidation of anything of value that we have decided can be redeemed for money. That number is a national number and a global number because there are lots of different types of money out there. Our national number is a subset of the world's total supply of money.

Everyone with me here?

Let's start with our total supply of money in dollars. As of this instant, that number is a finite number. It has to be or it would be an infinite number. But it is growing fast because we need more money all the time to run the economy. You are shaking your head saying, no, its not growing. But every credit card you own represents new money that you are storing until the time you need it. When you spend it, it gets created. When you pay it back with money you have in pocket, the supply retracts again. But what if you spend more money than you have constantly and run up massive debts? How do you pay them back?

At a personal level, you have to find a way to earn more than you spend and pay it back, it's pretty easy. Or you default.

At a national level, your nation has to either drop its lifestyle dramatically so that the nation exists on the left over money after you have paid your debts or you print more money out of thin air or you get money from another country by exporting or conquest. There is no other way to service that debt unless you grow the supply of your own currency by some means to cover the debt. What is left after you cover the debt is what you survive on.

This is exactly what happened to Germany after WW1 and we now call it austerity. First you pay your debts and then you survive on the remains. No one on the right tells you what this really means because if they did, it would have to mean that for one entire year, the whole nations output would have to be confiscated by our debtors to pay off the soveriegn debt which is equal to our GNP. Are you so concerned about the immorality of owing debt that you would be willing to work for a full year and make nothing?

I didn't think so. This is exactly what the Germans are trying to do to Greece in essence. Work for nothing, peanuts, pay us first, your survival is your problem because you owe us a debt, its immoral not to pay your debts.

But what did Germany do when it was their moral imperative to pay off their debts? They elected a man who said "No, we will not pay those debts again, forget it. We will start making things in Germany, increase our spending, build roads, factories, war machines and so on using our own currency and the rest of the world can go [Unwelcome language removed] themselves". Guess what happened? Germany started to prosper again. What did they really do? They defaulted on the debts owed from WW1.

This morality tale has been played out over the eons by nations so many times that it is quite silly to ignore the lessons. As we speak today, the only way to pay down our debt is to take money out of our hands and give it to our creditors OR we increase our exports to the rest of the world so much that the new money they give us in return can pay down the debts. Anyone think that is going to happen?

There is another way out. We take the current supply of money which is far greater than the debt owed and tax it to get it back into circulation. Now, this will not pay it down over night but it will decrease the amount of money we have to borrow to slow down the rate of growth so that our interest payments are not increasing as a function of our budget. If we do this and increase our exports while increasing our money supply, sooner or later the numbers we now think are obscene can be manageable.

If we follow the austerity program, there is only one possible end game. Most of us will become very, very poor and quickly. And what happens when we become poorer and poorer? The debt gets bigger and bigger and harder and harder to pay back as a function of the overall GNP. GNP will shrink if you follow austerity just as it has done every time it was tried. At the core of this entire mess is a morality that says the debt you incurred must be paid back in full plus interest.

Do you now realize why many religions outlawed interest? It is a form of bondage, a promise of income to a borrower based upon your future earnings. It is much like slavery. Why do we have so much debt?

Because we have refused to tax ourselves at the same time we gave ourselves spending authority. We also decided that massive trade deficits somehow make us richer or more prosperous. Anyone feel richer because your old job got outsourced?

Now how did economists explain what was going on when the last huge experiment with austerity happened? Here is a quote from Lord Keynes which everyone should read:

"Ultimately, and probably soon, there must be a readjustment of the balance of exports and imports. America must buy more and sell less. This is the only alternative to her making to Europe an annual present. Either American prices must rise faster than European (which will be the case if the Federal Reserve Board allows the gold influx to produce its natural consequences), or, failing this, the same result must be brought about by a further depreciation of the European exchanges, until Europe, by inability to buy, has reduced her purchases to articles of necessity."

Do you see how a national economic debt problem is completely different than a personal debt problem? They are two different economic conditions. Inside of an economy, a personal balance sheet can be manipulated without having anything to do with the other 300 million people in the nation. Money comes and goes between all the players in this poker game with 300 million hands dealt out. At the national level, there is only one hand, the aggregate total of all the hands dealt to all 300 million of us. If the individual runs out of money, they can borrow but they cannot make money, that is forbidden. If the nation needs money, they can borrow or they can print money or they can take money from another nation to make up the difference. If they borrow money, they owe interest plus principal depending upon how reliable they are as a debtor. The more risk, the higher the interest. Anyone follow the down rating of our national credit score? It's because the Tea Party decided to threaten not to pay our debts. That is risk and it costs you to play that game. Now, we could have taken money from another country. The old way to do this is to go to war and take everything they have, that is how we got so rich. We took everything the native Americans had and it was a very cheap way to make a ton of money. Or, we could destroy you and then loan you money that we created out of thin air to rebuild you. That is what we did with the Marshall Plan.

Anyone interested in following those lines? Didn't think so. There is another way to go. We could just print money and inflate ourselves until we get back on our feet. But can you stop inflation? No one knows the answer to this question and it scares the shit out of the Fed. But is there a way to add just enough money to the supply to increase output, legitimate output, so that we increase exports, increase the velocity of money between ourselves and grow the economy to a point where it starts to function without massive borrowing every year?

No one knows the answer to that one either. What we do know is that the nation continues to believe that concentrations of wealth somehow makes our economy tick. If we keep the incentives high for folks to make tons of money by taxing them favorably, magically they will enable wealth creation for the rest of us.

This has never happened in the history of economics once you get to this point.
 
Back
Top