New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Life Expectancy

Any normal human would be embarrassed at the full-service you render your Democrat overlords. Good grief.
Were you unaware that our life expectancy has risen relative to wealthy nations in general, since Obamacare was enacted? Were you unaware that our life expectancy had been falling relative to wealthy nations in general, before Obamacare was enacted? If so, then you're welcome. It's always good to shed some of the burden of ignorance, and I'm happy to assist you with that process.
 
the negligible life expectancy differences between the USA and EU nations is explained by a single "statistical trick" which those nations use. They don't count a birth as "viable/live" unless the baby is still alive after 30 days.

America includes deaths of infants in its record keeping. And America attempts more heroics to keep premature infants breathing than socialized medicine in places like the UK allows.
We've discussed this lie of yours before, but for the benefit of those who are new to this, I'll give the Cliff Notes version.

Yes, among right-wingers, there's this fun talking point that the only reason US life expectancy sucks relative to other wealthy nations is because of a difference in how we define live births. This is just something right-wingers pulled out of their asses and it can be proven false very easily.

There are published stats showing mortality by age. What those stats show is that it isn't just that Americans have low life expectancy at birth (relative to other wealthy nations). We have low life expectancy at age 2, and 5, 10, and 20, and so on. In fact, our life expectancy doesn't start to get close to that of other wealthy nations until people get quite old (at a time when Medicare gives them proper socialized medicine in the US).

For example:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK62373/table/ch1.t1/?report=objectonly

In Table 1-1, you can see that US life expectancy for men at age 50 is 29.28 years -- worse than each of the listed nations other than Denmark. For women it's 33.06 years -- again, worse than anyone but Denmark. Obviously, life expectancy at age 50 isn't impacted by some hypothetical tendency for other countries not to count a baby as alive for 30 days (a hypothetical that never had any basis in reality, anyway).

Here's another way of disproving this utterly bullshit right-wing talking point:

https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.IMRT.IN?view=chart
https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.DYN.MORT

Those links will show you infant mortality and under-5 mortality by country. Obviously, subtract one from the other and you have the mortality rate for young children who survive infancy. In the US, for example, 6.5 of every 1000 live births die before age five, of which 5.6 die in infancy. So, 0.9 per 1000 die after infancy but by age five.

Now, just copy and paste the charts together (using 2016, which is the most recent data). What you'll find out is that the US ranks 49th-best for mortality rate of under-5/post-infancy. In other words, even after we control for your nonsense interpretation, by eliminating every single infant death from the calculation, we find that American toddlers are still dying at rates higher than in pretty much every other developed nation.

Or yet another way of disproving it:

http://www.worldlifeexpectancy.com/your-life-expectancy-by-age

Using that ranking, we're 31st for life expectancy at birth. We're an identical 31st in life expectancy at age 5, 10, 15, and 20... obviously, if our infant mortality were driven up artificially relative to other wealthy nations by differences in the way live births get counted, then what we'd see is that the US ranking would be poor at birth but then rise dramatically at age 5 and beyond. That's not what happens. Our shameful life expectancy at birth is exactly in line with our shameful life expectancy at age 5, 10, 15, and 20.

In fact, it actually gets worse after childhood (presumably because we have some half-assed socialized medicine for kids in this country, whereas people in young adulthood are basically on their own). We drop to 32nd-best life expectancy at age 25, 30, 35, 40, and 45. In that part of life when Americans are too old for CHIP and too young for Medicare, we do even worse relative to other wealthy nations than we do when we're infants. At higher ages (especially when Medicare kicks in, and we get access to socialized medicine the way people in other wealthy nations do), our ranking starts to rise (e.g., we rank 18th at age 80). It never gets up to the elite level, presumably because of the cumulative toll of a lifetime of sub-standard healthcare. But at least we rise from near-third-world levels to something respectable.

I don't expect this to make a dent for you. You've been shown these facts before and have chosen to repeat the lie, even though you know perfectly well, based on hard data from multiple independent sources, that what you're saying isn't true. You know that the US life expectancy is crap far beyond that hypothetical difference in how we define live births. But a politically convenient lie is too precious for you to abandon. No matter, this post isn't really for you. It's for others who might be taken in by your lie if not for links to the truth.
 
the negligible life expectancy differences between the USA and EU nations is explained by a single "statistical trick" which those nations use. They don't count a birth as "viable/live" unless the baby is still alive after 30 days.

America includes deaths of infants in its record keeping. And America attempts more heroics to keep premature infants breathing than socialized medicine in places like the UK allows.
Also, the difference here isn't "negligible." Yes, the difference between the US and EU has shrunk dramatically since Obamacare went into law -- the gap now barely over a third what it was back in 2009. But even now, it's 0.20 years, which is very significant factored over a population our size. That's not some random blip in the data. It represents a very real difference in how long people are living.
 
I'm guessing the infamous predilection for suicide in Sweden could be a factor.
I don't have up-to-date data on that, but it looks like at least until recently, suicide rates in Sweden were falling:
'
Suicide-deaths-per-100000-trend.jpg

So, that doesn't look like a good explanation for why Sweden fell in the rankings of life expectancy.
 
It hasn't, though. Basically, what happened is life expectancy went up for years, which the right-wing press mostly ignored, then fell for one year, which they trumpeted far and wide, leaving those who rely on the right-wing press with the false impression that it was a net decline rather than a net increase in life expectancy.

Obamacare passed in 2010, so you can compare life expectancy pre-Obamacare (78.5 in 2009) to the most recent reading (78.8 in 2015).

Of course that's not the really interesting thing. It's hard to tell whether life expectancy is rising due to a change in policy, or just due to underlying improvements in medicine, etc. So, the real test is how we're doing relative to other advanced nations. For many years before Obamacare, US life expectancy was rising more slowly than for most other advanced nations, causing us to slide down the international rankings, even as our healthcare spending rose much faster than in the other nations. Not only were we an international disgrace, but we were falling further and further behind our peers. Since Obamacare was enacted, that has changed:

https://web.archive.org/web/2010031...ns/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2102rank.html

As you can see, according to our own CIA's numbers, in 2009, we had the world's 49th-best life expectancy, behind the likes of Portugal and Denmark. Now look at today:

https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2102rank.html

Not only did we halt the long-slide, we actually reversed it, climbing back up to the 43rd spot. We passed by Denmark, Portugal, and Gibraltar, among others. We also closed the gap between ourselves and the average wealthy nation. For example, in 2009, we died 0.56 years before the average EU resident, whereas by 2017 that was down to just 0.20 years. And, keep in mind, that improvement relative to our peers not only reversed years of sliding the other way, but it happened even as we lowered healthcare spending growth to much lower rates than before Obamacare.
that's a lie you ignored the thread I started a while back
 
that's a lie you ignored the thread I started a while back
I provided the links to confirm what I'm saying using our own CIA's data on the subject. I don't think I saw your post but let me guess: you were fixating on a one-year drop in life expectancy, right? Did you compare the net change in life expectancy from before Obamacare to today, or did you just go with the one-year snapshot your right-wing propaganda source ordered you to notice?
 
I provided the links to confirm what I'm saying using our own CIA's data on the subject. I don't think I saw your post but let me guess: you were fixating on a one-year drop in life expectancy, right? Did you compare the net change in life expectancy from before Obamacare to today, or did you just go with the one-year snapshot your right-wing propaganda source ordered you to notice?
YOU ARE DEAD WRONG
https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/death-rate-rises-under-obamacare.100837/#post-1833824
 
Face it you got owned.
You've spotted your error, I see. Fair enough. Next time, react with skepticism when you're at one of those "News for Imbeciles" sites like CNS News. Remember: they're not your friend. Their whole MO is to turn low-IQ people like you into their brainless foot soldiers, by telling you cherry-picked factlets, that you'll spread far and wide for them, while remaining ignorant of the big picture. Now you know the big picture: despite that one-year decline in life expectancy that CNS News trumpeted, life expectancy is up since Obamacare became law... and up more rapidly than in the average wealthy nation, such that we've started rising back up the international rankings for life expectancy. Now that you see how the news-for-imbeciles sites work to make fools out of people like you, you can guard yourself against this kind of humiliation in the future. Good luck.
 
You've spotted your error, I see. Fair enough. Next time, react with skepticism when you're at one of those "News for Imbeciles" sites like CNS News. Remember: they're not your friend. Their whole MO is to turn low-IQ people like you into their brainless foot soldiers, by telling you cherry-picked factlets, that you'll spread far and wide for them, while remaining ignorant of the big picture. Now you know the big picture: despite that one-year decline in life expectancy that CNS News trumpeted, life expectancy is up since Obamacare became law... and up more rapidly than in the average wealthy nation, such that we've started rising back up the international rankings for life expectancy. Now that you see how the news-for-imbeciles sites work to make fools out of people like you, you can guard yourself against this kind of humiliation in the future. Good luck.
I spotted yours.you did read the link
 
Back
Top