degsme
Council Member
We have had one poster asserted that Sandra Fluke dare not sue Limbaugh for defamation lest Limbaugh's lawyers "tear her a new [Unwelcome language removed] in discovery".
Except that this would not happen. For a couple of reasons.
1) Limbaugh's "discovery" of Fluke would be restricted to determining if in fact she was or was not a "public figure" and whether or not she had been harmed by his claims
He would NOT be able to seek in discovery to find out whether or not she in fact had slept with a lot of people or not. Because the standard as to whether or not Limbaugh's statement was true or false WRT Libel has to do NOT with the absolute truth of the issue but rather whether or not Limbaugh had a "reasonable person" basis for believing what he was saying was true at the time of publication.
This is to prevent me from saying things like "Lippy Facks 7yo Boys" and then trying to get Lippy to settle out of court by engaging in discovery of all of Lippy's private sex life - and to prevent someone with no assets from using a shotgun approach of accusations against political or public figure enemies and then use discovery to find the one or two cases where the accusation turns out true.
2) Discovery in this case would also be about Limbaugh's "intent to defame"
and that means that the technician that was fired when Limbaugh called Chelsea Clinton "the White House Dog"
His claiming that Michael J. Fox was "faking" his symptoms
and a host of other cases would all be brought out in Discovery AGAINST Limbaugh... and that would be very very very bad for Limbaugh.
Either way, this is a suit Limbaugh would try to settle in a BIG Hurry. And if Fluke is smart, she settles for a moderate amount of money and a public allocution by Limbaugh as to his being guilty of lying about her.
Except that this would not happen. For a couple of reasons.
1) Limbaugh's "discovery" of Fluke would be restricted to determining if in fact she was or was not a "public figure" and whether or not she had been harmed by his claims
He would NOT be able to seek in discovery to find out whether or not she in fact had slept with a lot of people or not. Because the standard as to whether or not Limbaugh's statement was true or false WRT Libel has to do NOT with the absolute truth of the issue but rather whether or not Limbaugh had a "reasonable person" basis for believing what he was saying was true at the time of publication.
This is to prevent me from saying things like "Lippy Facks 7yo Boys" and then trying to get Lippy to settle out of court by engaging in discovery of all of Lippy's private sex life - and to prevent someone with no assets from using a shotgun approach of accusations against political or public figure enemies and then use discovery to find the one or two cases where the accusation turns out true.
2) Discovery in this case would also be about Limbaugh's "intent to defame"
and that means that the technician that was fired when Limbaugh called Chelsea Clinton "the White House Dog"
His claiming that Michael J. Fox was "faking" his symptoms
and a host of other cases would all be brought out in Discovery AGAINST Limbaugh... and that would be very very very bad for Limbaugh.
Either way, this is a suit Limbaugh would try to settle in a BIG Hurry. And if Fluke is smart, she settles for a moderate amount of money and a public allocution by Limbaugh as to his being guilty of lying about her.