New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

MAGA 101

PhilFish

Administrator
Staff member
Should schools be a place for indoctrinating kids by way of educators espousing one political view or another? Be it left leaning or right... do teachers have a right to express a particular politic...do students?

take this maga story for example, and the reaction.. http://www.newsweek.com/school-apol...dents-wearing-trump-t-shirts-maga-make-659370

conversely, if the child's expression is deemed not permissible, then should not the teachers views as well?

My position, a school is a place for teaching, apolitically.
 
I see no reason why students cannot express their views as much as any teacher.
 
Should schools be a place for indoctrinating kids by way of educators espousing one political view or another? Be it left leaning or right... do teachers have a right to express a particular politic...do students?

take this maga story for example, and the reaction.. http://www.newsweek.com/school-apol...dents-wearing-trump-t-shirts-maga-make-659370

conversely, if the child's expression is deemed not permissible, then should not the teachers views as well?

My position, a school is a place for teaching, apolitically.

Teacher's can't. Kids can.

Kids are impressionable, undeveloped. Adults can manipulate them easily.

However, it's common for teachers to throw jabs at Trump in their assignments. I've seen many stories of teachers getting in trouble, and those are just the ones where there's action. Most probably just go under the radar.

What would you say the percentage of teachers who voted for Clinton is... 80%?
 
Should schools be a place for indoctrinating kids by way of educators espousing one political view or another? Be it left leaning or right... do teachers have a right to express a particular politic...do students?

take this maga story for example, and the reaction.. http://www.newsweek.com/school-apol...dents-wearing-trump-t-shirts-maga-make-659370

conversely, if the child's expression is deemed not permissible, then should not the teachers views as well?

My position, a school is a place for teaching, apolitically.

No, teaching should be apolitical.

Science should be science and religious opinions shouldn't be part of it. History should be as neutral as possible which is hard to do though. Same for sex education. Remove "Under God" from the pledge. etc.
 
No, teaching should be apolitical.

Science should be science and religious opinions shouldn't be part of it. History should be as neutral as possible which is hard to do though. Same for sex education. Remove "Under God" from the pledge. etc.

religious opinions should be part of a religion class, for example..
 
No, teaching should be apolitical.

Science should be science and religious opinions shouldn't be part of it. History should be as neutral as possible which is hard to do though. Same for sex education. Remove "Under God" from the pledge. etc.

So burn all the money in your wallet or prove to be a hypocrite..........'IN GOD WE TRUST' and you will not burn all your cash!
 
right. though me personally, i wouldnt change the pledge..
Why. It violates the position of your top post. It is indoctrination to imply, one way or the other, that a God exists and he has anything to do with this country.
 
Why. It violates the position of your top post. It is indoctrination to imply, one way or the other, that a God exists and he has anything to do with this country.
my position was expressed as a question regarding educators and students. i believe in many places students have the option to recite it or not.
 
my position was expressed as a question regarding educators and students. i believe in many places students have the option to recite it or not.

They can say it if they are taught at home or church to insert it. If it is published and shown in school, it involves educators, and then it is indoctrination. They wouldn't know to insert it unless it was taught and it shouldn't be taught at school.
 
Last edited:
They can say it if they are taught at home or church to insert it. If it is published and shown in school, it involves educators, and then it is indoctrination. They wouldn't know to insert it unless it was taught and it shouldn't be taught at school.

when it was taught back in the 50/60/70's we didn't have school shooting or need Cops walking the halls of education in the South...............when liberal education came around look what we have now.

Again, when will you burn the cash in your pocket with 'IN GGOD WE TRUST' or are you a liberal hypocrite?
 
Should schools be a place for indoctrinating kids by way of educators espousing one political view or another? Be it left leaning or right... do teachers have a right to express a particular politic...do students?

take this maga story for example, and the reaction.. http://www.newsweek.com/school-apol...dents-wearing-trump-t-shirts-maga-make-659370

conversely, if the child's expression is deemed not permissible, then should not the teachers views as well?

My position, a school is a place for teaching, apolitically.
I agree teaching should be done apolitically. However, what one considers "political" may not be the same for others. For example, in Sex Ed, should the fact of homosexual sex be taught? Should the fact of transgender be taught? Should the fact that abortion is available and legal be taught? In science, should the Christian view of the origin of humans be taught alongside evolution? In history, is the Civil War the "War between the states" or "the war of Northern aggression"? Should teaching assistants be available for non-English speakers as it was in the 70's in California because of the influx of Vietnamese refugees, or should no accommodation be made to non-English (or, really, "not-yet-English") speakers? Can schools choose to use the original Pledge of Allegiance or are they required to use the one modified (to distinguish us from "the Godless commies") in 1954? When my mom was a teacher in the 50's, she was required to quit her job when she became pregnant with my sister (though my dad, also a teacher, got to keep his). The decision to allow women to teach even though they were pregnant was a political one for many people -- goodness, all those boys seeing that their teacher had HAD SEX.

So while in principle I agree, I think the implementation of an apolitical teaching environment would be fraught. I think the teaching environment should be as non-political as possible (e.g., teachers not badmouthing the president).
 
In science, should the Christian view of the origin of humans be taught alongside evolution?

Christian view of the origin of humans isn't science and should never be taught in a science class. Only science should be taught in a science class. It is a religious opinion and should be taught in a class on religions with more than Christianity taught, otherwise, it is political.
 
Christian view of the origin of humans isn't science and should never be taught in a science class. Only science should be taught in a science class. It is a religious opinion and should be taught in a class on religions with more than Christianity taught, otherwise, it is political.
I don't disagree. In my college Anthropology classes, the professors had to begin the first day of class with a disclaimer: "this class will discuss evolution by natural selection as the basis for human evolution. It will not discuss the Christian, or any other religion's, view of the origin of humans." It seemed stupid to me at the time that the disclaimer had to be made, but to make the snowflakes aware, so they could disenroll to avoid actual science in a science class, it had to be made.
 
They can say it if they are taught at home or church to insert it. If it is published and shown in school, it involves educators, and then it is indoctrination. They wouldn't know to insert it unless it was taught and it shouldn't be taught at school.


well, it is our national pledge, and we're a predominately christian nation.. I think it's ok and shuld stay.
 
Should schools be a place for indoctrinating kids by way of educators espousing one political view or another? Be it left leaning or right... do teachers have a right to express a particular politic...do students?

take this maga story for example, and the reaction.. http://www.newsweek.com/school-apol...dents-wearing-trump-t-shirts-maga-make-659370

conversely, if the child's expression is deemed not permissible, then should not the teachers views as well?

My position, a school is a place for teaching, apolitically.
during the bush administration, there were quite a number of news stories about public schools removing, or refusing to display, pictures of president bush.

membership in antifa by public education employees should be a prohibited/dismissible action, since their goal is prevention of free speech and peaceful airing off opposing political viewpoints. they are fascist, not anti-fascist.
 
during the bush administration, there were quite a number of news stories about public schools removing, or refusing to display, pictures of president bush.

membership in antifa by public education employees should be a prohibited/dismissible action, since their goal is prevention of free speech and peaceful airing off opposing political viewpoints. they are fascist, not anti-fascist.


I think any overt political discourse intended to persuade, or dissuade a child from one political view, or toward another.. should be prohibited.
 
They can say it if they are taught at home or church to insert it. If it is published and shown in school, it involves educators, and then it is indoctrination. They wouldn't know to insert it unless it was taught and it shouldn't be taught at school.

Yes because I'm sure you draw a very hard line when it comes to teachers indoctrinating children in any way. :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top