New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Managing Gridlock and Getting Things Done

imreallyperplexed

Council Member
One point that has not been much talked about but which will be very important in 2013-14 is the probable makeup of the House and the Senate and how Romney or Obama - whichever one is elected - will be able to deal with Congress.

I think that it is a safe bet that neither of these two will enjoy the kind of "friendly" Congress that GWB enjoyed from 2001-2007 and Obama enjoyed from 2009-2011. They are going to be stuck with a evenly split and highly polarized and potentially dysfunctional Congress like the current Congress. The most likely scenario is that the Republicans will keep control of the House but with a slimmer majority and fewer blue dog/conservative Democrats. The Senate is more of a toss-up. Whichever party holds the majority, it will be narrow (and far from the 60 votes needed to make it easy to avoid bi-partisanship.) I happen to think that the Democrats will hold onto the Senate narrowly. But the general picture will be the same no matter who has control of the Senate.

With this kind of Congress, the potential for continued gridlock is VERY high. To be effective, Romney will almost surely need some cooperation from Democrats. Similarly, to be effective, Obama will almost surely need some cooperation from Republicans. So the question really is who will be more effective at getting cooperation from the other side.

My personal opinion is that Obama has a much better chance of getting cooperation from Republicans than Romney has of getting cooperation from Democrats despite Romney's tenure as governor of Massachusetts. I have several reasons for thinking this. First, Obama has four years of experience (and several years in the Senate) dealing with Republicans. If anything, Obama was overconfident about getting any cooperation from Republicans when he first took office. I think that he has a more realistic viewpoint now. Second, I think that the challenges are big enough now that there has to be some compromise on both sides. I think that Republicans are going to be forced to abandon the Grover Norquist pledge in talking about tax reform. When the Republicans are willing to talk taxes, the Democrats will agree to talk about entitlement reform. In this climate, even Paul Ryan would have voted for a Simpson-Bowles type solution. Romney, on the other hand, has no experience in Washington, no ties to the Democratic leadership, and weak ties to the Republican leadership, has poor personal skills apparently (outside a corporate boardroom environment) and will be in great debt to the Tea Party and limited in what he can do. Another advantage that Obama has is that everyone knows that he won't be running for reelection and can afford to ignore political gamesmanship to some degree. Romney on the other hand is going to have - at best - a very, very weak mandate and will be worried to death about his political future - including possible primary challenges in 2016.

Both Obama and Romney will claim that they seek bipartisanship. And tempermentally both seem to be "compromisers." But I think that Obama's experiences over the past four years are much more relevant to the challenges that either man will face over the next four years than Romney's limited experience in Massachusetts. I think that Obama will be more successful.
 
IRP~

I don't anticipate the GOP to be any more co-operative next year so long as they are in the grasp of right wing power brokers. I don't think they will budge until or unless GOP rank and file demand more responsibility from their leaders; that will probably require that many vote Democratic in enough red states to change the make-up of the House. You expect them to be as reasonable as you are.
 
You could be right David. The one thing that gives me some hope are bipartisan "aberrations" like the Gang of Six or the Simpson-Bowles Committee. In addition, Grover Norquist has changed his tune and now says that tax reform is not necessarily a tax increase. (Norquist also indicated that he was willing to cut defense to cut spending.) And there have been rumblings that Republicans are ready to revolt. (For example, John Huntsman said last week that he would not be attending any more Republican conventions until the Tea Party environment changed.) Depending on the election results, you may a little more willingness to compromise (rather than jump off a cliff). The problem that a Romney Administration would face is that they are in no position to offer a compromise and Ron Wyden will show Paul Ryan the door.

But I have no illusions that either Obama or Romney would have an easy time. They won't.

IRP~

I don't anticipate the GOP to be any more co-operative next year so long as they are in the grasp of right wing power brokers. I don't think they will budge until or unless GOP rank and file demand more responsibility from their leaders; that will probably require that many vote Democratic in enough red states to change the make-up of the House. You expect them to be as reasonable as you are.
 
I don't think either one will get cooperation from the other side in the 1st 6 mos (unless we have the 1/5 shot that Obama takes the House with his CoatTails- possible but unlikely).

So that means that

  • If Obama Wins - the sequestration cuts go into effect and we lose about 3% of GDP by March
  • If Romney Wins - the sequestration cuts go into effect WITH an increase in DoD spend (whcih actually harms the economy) so we have about a 5% drop in GDP


Now in the case of an Obama Win - he's going to be campaigning from Nov - through the March Congressional Recess against the cuts and for more government spending. Which means that when Boehner and the other non-tea party GOPers go home in March, they will face extremely angry voters. And that means that from April onwards, we will see some cooperation.

In the case of a Romney Win - He will be championing the cuts (he can't but otherwise) and trying to push through more tax cuts, which will only make things worse. And the DoD spend increases will not get blocked by the Senate Dems for political reasons. So even though the economy crashes by 3% by March - the GOP is going to "hold strong" until the summer recess - at which point the 2014 Campaigning will start.

So then we will see some moves by Romney that will be a little bit too little-toolate. And 2014 the GOP will lose the Senate and the House.
 
  • If Obama Wins - the sequestration cuts go into effect and we lose about 3% of GDP by March
  • If Romney Wins - the sequestration cuts go into effect WITH an increase in DoD spend (whcih actually harms the economy) so we have about a 5% drop in GDP

Does both sequestrations include letting Bush's tax cuts that Obama extended for 2yrs, expire?
 
Back
Top